Skip to main content
Loading video...

Shadows Over Camelot - Boardgame Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 14:09

hello welcome back to the ball games 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings and we generally talk a load of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about 2005 bruno pathology or Lazio or whatever hidden trailer game shadows over Camelot and in this game you'll be assuming the roles of knights of the round table you'd be going on quests in order to win white swords you could place a camera and when you got a certain number of whites or send you go in the game but obviously there's a hidden traitor so you've got to be careful that you get those white swords on the board before they get the black sauce on the board and in this video we're gonna be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we will come back and we'll tell you whether or not shadows over camel still worth playing nearly 14 years after it was released I can't believe it and remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below just there and we'll see you after this

board games 4k sorry shadows over Camelot air to play this game so this game takes place over four phases but really there's only two phases really because so Atos phases are checking to see whether or not the game has ended or not so the first phase you will progress evil so what you'll do you'll have three choices you can either draw a black card from the deck you can add a siege engine to Camelot or you can lose a life point and when you take a black car to war look at it and you will play it and talk more often than not tell you to assign it to a quest right we'll get into that in a bit what a quest mean right so when you add a siege engine to Camelot you'll take your local siege engine you'll put on one of the available spots and when there's 12 siege engines on the board the game is over and if there's ever six siege engines on the board the heroes will then be able to make accusations on who the hidden traitor is right so the first thing you can do to progress evil is you can lose a lot of point and everyone's got a little die and all you do is you'll turn the die into the next lowest level and then you'll lose alive by falling on your sword right so once you have progressed evil then you will check to see whether the game has been won or lost and you win the game by having seven white swords at Camelot and you lose the game if there's ever 12 siege engines on the board all the loyal Knights have died or if you have 12 black swords a camera

right so once you've done that once you've check to see if the game has ended then you will then perform a heroic action and you can actually perform two heroic actions if you choose to lose a lot of point but you can never ever perform the same heroic action twice in one turn right so there are five heroic actions in this game the first action is you can move from Camelot to a quest or you can move from a quest back to Camelot the second action you can do is you can perform an action that is specific to the quest that you are currently on you could play one of the special white cards in the deck or you can heal yourself or you can if you're if there's six siege engines on the board then you can accuse somebody have been a traitor so the quests that you can't get involved in you first one you can do is the tournament for the Black Knight more you'll be done you'll be put in white cards down on the board when for heroic actions and there's a part of the progression of evil you might be able to put down black hearts and you can choose to play these facedown to get extra white cards out the deck that will inevitably allow people to start pointing their fingers and you thinking it you're that feel free traitor so what you'll do wants the area of that board is filled up with cars and you'll flip them all over and if White's got a majority then they will win the benefit which is usually swords and cards and Life Points or less or stuff all that second penalty which is the only black swords all yeah I haven't discard cards or whatever will lose a life or whatever the yeah so that's the first quest so the second quest is the quest for Lancelot's armor and what you'll be doing here you all be playing trying to

play cards that equate to a full house in Pokhara and then if you're successful if you massive duda you'll take lance on armor that will allow you to gain free going for life points and you will also get the benefit associated with that that's on the space and then if you failed a quest you'll have to endure the negative effects of that quest why so because this is a temporary thing once you've got the arm and you'll flip the board over and there the dragon's quest will be the permanent quest that's available and there's you could you could do this so many times you like the dragon's quest began it's a permanently implying this is the same sort of thing but you just get the benefit you don't get the lancers hama twice thea I mean what you've expected did you think it was gonna be like a jumble sale time so I had a next question you can go to it's the quest for Excalibur and this is the sort of thing where you they like you put a lady or leg power arm up with the sword thing and all that sort stuff so what you'll be doing you'll be trying to get across the lake to the other side so you can climb Excalibur for yourself and it'll be like a push-me pull-you sort of thing so if you get there you'll get the benefit you'll get the benefit of Excalibur and then you're if you don't do if you get pushback there be a negative effect so the positive effects of Excalibur means that you can choose to cancel one of these special blood cancers played and that's pretty powerful considering that there's never really enough opportunities to get actually what you need done done why it just hold a next one it's the quest for the Holy Grail when you'll be placing Holy Grail cards on the board in the appropriate spot trying to push towards the success and will try to negate the fact that you the black cards will push you to failure and the first one the first one who gets to either side will claim the Holy Grail you'll get the benefit so the Holy Grail you'll get some swords you'll get some cards you'll

get life back and there's also a penalty with black swords on so there's another one n ones which gives you a benefit and once it's done it's done so a permanent to permanent quest that seemed permanent scraps going on you've got a scrap of the pics and you've got a scrap of Saxons and what you'll be doing on this one you'll be trying to play straights a poker hand of straights and once you've done that you'll get a benefit and you if you lose you get the side a pedigree but these keep going to just reset these they just keep going and going on you could do these many times you like so if somebody accuses somebody of being a traitor what you do if they are a traitor then you will get a benefit without they're not a try you to place a black sword and sum up stuff on the board and what the trailer will do if they're successfully revealed that what they would do they'll flip over their planner and the instructions for what they need to do when they're a traitor will be followed and Nothingness to actions that's just the sorbets a slim line down version of the progression of evil and their progress evil every every stage and they won't take the ark actions yet so you'll keep doing this we'll keep doing this and doing this and doing this until like the endgame is met basically aside from a cut of fiddly rules with the Merlin cards when you can play three to cancel a special black card and play one to cancel its standard black art blah blah blah blah that's basically now you play shadows over Camelot so what do we like about shadows over Camelot first thing that we really like about this and it's akin to all of the earlier days of wonder games that sadly have slipped away a little bit their quality components that's why yeah the quality

components really do elevate this game up to stratospheric levels that the miniatures are absolute antastic the artwork is obviously fantastic the card quality is fantastic the insert is fantastic and it's just amazing that in 2005 the people bought this game and were like my god it looks astonishing and the fact that there was a hidden treasure in there there not many people had seen before really make this day special back in the day and it's just a shame that days of wonder haven't sort of carried on that's all innovative groundbreaking component quality you know so the second thing that we really like about this is the hidden tray is really easy to play up until a certain point in the game yeah so you don't really need any experience that he sort of games you just carrying on you're trying to undermine people without being caught you know so it's a new players can play this as the traitor up to a certain point right but yeah up to that's up to the point of the reveal this game it really does sort of accommodate new players into that sort of backstabbing wrong with this look is sort of a nice introduction to backstabbing I saw the third finger we really like about this it's the tension caused by not being able to do everything that you really really need to do and want to do in the game so because the games on the time of our siege engines they act as a timer if the game sort starts off ball and it gradually slims down your opportunities and that is really really good because you fit sort into kindness when you need to be doing more stuff but with hard so you can look back and said well she looked on that there should have done that there so fact that the game presents you with this or creeping death means that you can't get everything you want done

done at the time you want to do it so the final thing final thing that we like about shadows ever canalized the hidden trailer could be anybody because everybody has to take that question of evil action and it's not like say other hidden treasure games where you know you you may or may not have to sort of do the equivalent of progressive we just have to stay hidden and so undermine slightly but this one everybody has no choice you've got to progress evil and we really like the fact that that means that anybody could be the traitor in keeps the game tense and keeps the game fresh so what don't we like about shadows overcome a lot so the first thing and probably the main thing about this game is the fact that the game relies on his weird sort of poker hands I mean where did that come from I didn't play poker in Camelot did that I didn't play poker in enough in the times of our fury and legends you know I think this is more this would be better with a cowboy themed game right so it just seems a bit weird that you're sort of you know you were involved in this sort of it's constant battle by playing these weird and meaningless poker hands on the board and it's something that doesn't compute really for me it sort of detaches itself from the fame and that's a real shame so this second thing that we don't like about shadows over camera noise towards the end of the game your choices become much much more limited than at the beginning of the game in a sense or

contradict ourselves aren't we because we said that that was a good thing but the fact that when you get to the end in the game seems to sort of slow down and you're like well there's nothing else I can do I just have to perceive changing on the board or I just have to lose a life and that's basically what the end game comes down to so it would have been nice had there been extra a couple of little bits and bobs that you could do at the end it might be the expansion fixes that but we haven't got it because it's sadly been out of print for so long because the Merlin's expansion or some another so that's a real shame so the third thing that we don't like about shadows over Camelot it's the fact that some of these rules are quite fiddly and there's to let the same to rule books one of them is a quest book even though the rule books are aesthetically they're wonderful yes but they saw thee the way they go about with all the rules are a bit feeble and we recommend going down onto that Universal hit page and download in the cheat sheet the broad summary so you've got you can just go through for it with a highlighter and then the rules that you think you're going to forget our bang there there so there the rulebook boss there it's pretty and it's lovely it is pretty poor trying to pull the rules like the Merlin cards and work stuff out here when you really need it so a final thing that we are gonna mark about about shadows over Camelot was a factor once the trailer is revealed if you've got somebody who's not played the game before or it's not familiar with hidden trail or just not familiar with games in general then they might feel because they're on their own there they're pushed outside the group they might feel a bit intimidated by that and not know

how to play the game properly and that's not really the game's fault is it as such but that is more to do with who you choose to play the game with so I wouldn't recommend playing this game first of all whether trailer with new players yeah so play it without a trailer get them get the mechanics into you into your mind into the other place and then put hidden trailer in after that so to summarize is shadows over camera still worth playing today and in the future I'm gonna say yes course it is yes of course it is oh my god it comes down to this what we got this and then we got Battlestar Galactica and we threw away Battlestar Galactica because a it's too long it's too complicated and it is we thought the theme was on this goes this we like the like hard frame we like the light hide mechanics we like the fact that Sony lasts for about an hour and half and you've got that hinge right thing in there this game is an all-time classic it was a pivotal moment in gaming come 2005 you at this novel mechanic the hidden traitor thing and it's spawned all of these other games like her the resistance and all that sort stuff all these other hidden try games like secret lair and where they wouldn't have been here if it wasn't for Bruno kefalas masterpiece here and the fact this game is still in print is testament to the fact that it is timeless it is the original intro game in my mind and you really need to play it you really need to get older this one and yet it goes so that is shadows over cannot is a five star game yes it is yes

it is that's it so if you'll nowhere please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below that will help this channel grow that will stimulate the YouTube algorithm and it will help this channel grow so we'll see you next time

Progress saved