Skip to main content
Loading video...

Fresh Fish (revisited) - 4p Teaching, Play-through & Roundtable Discussion by Heavy Cardboard

Transcript 1:33:37

Hey, hey, hey.

One one.

What's up y'all? Welcome to Game Night here at Heavy Cardboard. I'm your host Edward

John Shay Ken.

All right. Tonight we are playing Fresh Fish designed by Freedom and Freeze published by 2F Spila. Uh this is the 2014 edition. We have the who who is it? Plen plenary

plenary.

Plenery. We'll show it in a minute. Uh we have that addition here. We're not playing with it though. However, we are going to play

Kyle's rules. It's going to require a little bit of explanation and why. So, there's going to be some front ending on this, but I'm going to teach like super quick how the game works. And then we are playing with the expropriation which is the more difficult original rules but not okay. So I'm going to show stuff then we're going to talk about the rules and everything. All right. Um there are some very very strong feelings in both directions about the rules.

We're going to talk about that as I'm going through all this. Okay. So here we go. All right. So we are set. This is the 2014 edition, but we are not playing with the uh the this sides of the board. We are playing for all intents and purposes the original rules with the 2014 edition. Now, the plenary or whatever you call it, go and bring all that over. Bring the box. So, this is what you would get if you got the first edition, but it's not. It's anyways the plenary edition is the older one here. Okay, we're playing with the the the the power grid size box. Yeah. Fresh fish. Okay. All right.

So, the original rules as they're written in here are terribly translated there. It's really bad. So, we played the last time we streamed this in 2021, we played with that side of the boards. Okay.

Uh, we are not we are playing with the original rules, but the original rules now have since been adapted with one major rule change. It's a minor, but it's a major and a secondary rule that is also changed because of the first rule change. It'll make sense, I promise. So, first things first, you make it roughly square using five boards. Four players, five boards. So, we did that. That's that's pretty roughly rectangulary. Okay. Then, uh, based on the number, uh, that's in the corner of all these, that comes out to 17. There are 17 tiles, uh, flea market tiles, and then there are 12 of the market tiles mixed in between those. Mhm.

That is also the timer of the game. Okay. We also have an unlimited number of road tiles. Hopefully, I got enough out. You can play with this side up cuz the roads it's all everything in this game is orthogonal. However, we're trying that side to make it a little bit clearer for everybody at home. We'll see how that looks. We'll we'll go from there. Okay.

Yep.

Uh also, uh the game comes with tiddlywinks. We have Reuben's. We're using those. All right. So, the rules say basically break the board up into rough quadrants and the fish goes into the corner in one of those quadrants and then the RNG is for the other three in the other quadrants and that's where we ended up with it. Okay, so be it. Okay. Uh, everybody starts with 15 bucks, six discs, and there four market stalls. All right. The goal of the game is you want the shortest route from wherever these things are. The shortest route to that's a bad example. Like something along the lines of this to where your market stall has a distance as short as possible to the people that are selling the thing, the delivery truck. Not Yeah, we're selling.

They're delivering it. So, this would have a distance of one. One is the minimum in this game. Okay. You could not do something like this to where that's a zero. That mean you can put it there.

You can put it there, but then it might be a two if you're lucky. It's going to be at least two. Okay. Uh [snorts] also, this is a game where you check your feelings at the door. This is really, really mean. Okay. So, just know that on your turn, you have two options on your turn. You can either place one of your reservation discs out on the board. I'll talk about that more in detail in a minute. Or you draw a tile. Now, technically, this is all one big stack, but just to make it easier to reach, there's two stack. Pick one up. And we're going to either have an auction or not.

So, the placing a reservation disc, the first one you place can go anywhere on the board that you want, any open space. So, anywhere there's a circle.

Sure. Subsequent ones, you must place reservation disc orthogonally adjacent to an existing disc, yours or another color, a market stall or a delivery truck. So, in other words, something wooden

or road

or or a road. Okay. Orthogonally adjacent to something that like that.

Okay. Uh when you draw a tile, there are two types of tiles that you may draw. You may draw a tile that looks like this. That is a flea market tile or it is a market stall tile. If it is a flea market tile, wherever you have a disc out here, you must place a little flea market thing just for a visual cue out there. take your disc back back into your supply and it goes onto that spot.

Easy enough. There's no other decision to be made. That's it.

The if it is a market stall, we are going to have an auction starting with the player to the left of the I'm sorry, starting with uh sorry. Yeah, it's a blind bid. So, okay. Boom. Done. Zero is a common and invalid bid in this game. Uh, and then the winner of the bid again puts that down on wherever they have a disc out there. And ideally, you want it as close as possible to that, right? Because you want the shortest step possible.

Maybe six away.

That might be, but

might be all right.

Might also not be. So, all right. So, those are the two types of draws. Okay. Yeah, just whatever. You can shuffle them up. Okay. All right. Anytime we put down a piece of wood, a piece of wood being a flea market, a market stall,

I think that's it, right? Uh

so not these, correct? All the other pieces.

Correct. Or a delivery truck during setup.

Sure. We are going to check for what's called expropriation and that is what expropriation is from the original game of fresh fish. They removed that to some degree in the 2014 version i.e. the other side of that because it's really it's one of those things you got to wrap your head around and it takes a little while and I guarantee you even tonight we are going to screw this up. Okay? But just know that it is a thing that we are checking anytime we put these out or these out or even at the beginning of the game put those out. Expropriation. Uh we're going to put down roads if forced to by the expropriation rules. There are two rules that if either of these rules would be violated, a road goes down somewhere on the board. Mhm.

The two rules are each market stall in each delivery truck must have an excess must have access to at least one path. Okay. There is no perceived road around the outside of this. The second one is each empty space, reservation disc or path can be connected to all other empty spa spaces or paths. Let me rephrase that second one. All roads must be connected to roads.

So how many roads will there be at the end?

One.

Yeah.

Every road space must be connected via the grid that we have built to a road.

Mhm.

So now with that said, I still haven't talked about Kyle's rules, what separates the rules we're playing in the original. I want to draw your attention to the map as it's laid out. These four market uh delivery trucks were randomish put out there. Okay. There is one spot on our board that must start with a road because of the rules that I just those two rules, but basically all roads must be connected to roads.

Mhm.

And for anyone watching at home, you may or may not already know what that is, but if you don't, take a second. There is a spot on the board that must have a road to begin with. All right, I gave you all long enough. And the reason is this is the spot that must be a road. And let me explain this and this will kind of explain the expropriation a little bit hopefully. Okay. So, let's say we didn't notice that at the beginning and I instead put a disc down. whatever people are putting discs and eventually maybe I'm able to put that down cuz an auction. Awesome. Well, this must be a road theoretically cuz it cuz it has to have a connection out there. But here's the problem.

Everything in this game is orthogonally connected. This road is not connected to the rest of the roads. So therefore, that is not a legal thing to happen. So therefore, this spot must start

with a road.

And that corner one, it it can't be something like a flea market or another stall because that would be isolated from all roads, which is also not

it has access to a road.

Well, I'm saying if if this weren't here.

Oh, correct.

Right.

So that starts with the road, which means this theoretically is a legal placement. should be fine.

And it might connect this way. It might connect out this way. Like how? We don't know. Possibilities. Yes.

Okay. But what we do know is that must be a road at the beginning of our game because of setup.

If you have that there and then a building goes there and there, then that has to be a road.

That must be a road because it must have connection to a road. And if those two are blocked, then go that must be okay. All right. So now let me go ahead and explain Kyle's rules. There are there is one rule change which then forces a second rule change. Okay. In Kyle's rules check that I'm I'm going to do this both ways. In the original rules, when we blind bid, if the auctioneer is the one that is tied for the lead for the for the for the highest bid, whether that's zero or some number up to 15,

they win the tie.

Yep.

That is the original rules. We are not playing with that tonight. In Kyle's rules, it is the player to the left of the auctioneer.

Uh uh

the first player

first person who's involved in

the first player involved in the tie clockwise from the auctioneer. So the auctioneer actually has last privilege.

Correct. They do.

Yeah.

Now, why does that matter? Because the player to the left of the auctioneer doesn't have full control over when auctions are called. So if I call it on my turn, he might be John might be forced to place a market stall depending on what tile I draw. So therefore, he might just get screwed.

That is a valid thing that happens in this game.

Mhm.

So therefore, the second rule change is forced in Kyle's rules, which is on your uh turn, you have two choices. You may place a disc or you can draw a tile. Well, in Kyle's rules, the first [snorts] three turns, everybody must put down a disc.

After that, you're on your own.

The gloves are off.

Sure.

If you run lean on number of discs out here, you are you are risk you're attempting fate. You are attempting the table to collude to screw you. What does that mean? If you win the auction voluntarily or involuntarily and you do not have a disc out here on the board, your marker is just going to come out here like that and that is a max pathing score. High score is bad in this. The perfect score that you could get for your four market stalls to delivery trucks is four with distance of one. One road between where it is road boop done. And you do that for all four. The max score for any one delivery is 12. So if you get kind of screwed, it's just going to kind of sit out there and that is a 12 score. That is not good.

In a four-player game is 12.

Yeah, in a four player game. Correct. Okay.

Is it lower or higher in higher player game?

It is higher in five player it's 14. It's it it goes by it's two or it's 8 to 14 depending on player count. Okay,

that's it. That's That's the game. So, every time we put down one of these or one of these, we're going to have to expropriate and show our work check

or check and see and we'll do the best we can

early on. Not so much. Okay.

And one other thing is uh if you start an auction and you lose the auction, you go again.

Yeah. It's your turn until you win an auction or you draw

or you place a disc. No, if you draw uh I believe

No, you you can always place a disc.

You You're right. You could pivot, I guess. And you are correct.

It's just your turn again.

Yeah, basically. That's a better way to put it. All right. Um last thing I want to point out is these are the plenary games uh rule book. There was a big discussion about this on BGG. I want to point out

it is right here. the player to the left of the auctioneer shows up in the rules. That's not how Freedom and Free is intended. And in fact, it says this is a change from the original German rules. In testing, we found this to be an interesting strategic twist. Henning, who is Freedom and Freez's right-hand man, developer, the whole nine yards, uh has pointed out this is the way we are playing tonight is not Freedomman's intent. Okay. If you don't like that, you just make it the auctioneer.

Yeah.

Wins the auction. That's it. That's the only difference that we are playing. Okay. Some people call it broken. No, it's just sharper elbows. You understand the risk that you're taking if you only have, you know, a disc or two out there. It probably won't come up, but it's possible. Uh that said, here we will uh I mean in honor of that, might as well here. We'll break out the uh elephant deck.

The fancy ones.

Yeah. My only the only fancy deck.

Fancy deck. Yeah.

Yeah. That I own. Yes.

I feel honored

in honor of uh you know, Martin not being here tonight. Here.

Go for it.

Okay. I guess that that was the one that was forced on to me.

Yeah.

Okay. Well, well, all right. So, Shay, you're starting.

These are so basic compared to what Martin gets. It's so funny, but they're elephants. So,

Oh, okay. So, I'm going first. Um, it's I've played I haven't played this version much at all and not in a long time. So,

do you want advice or no?

Sure.

Put it diagonal to something,

right? I mean, I figured this was a reasonable place to get

100%. Yes, that's it.

Yeah.

Because this is the only chance you can do that. Yeah.

Yeah.

Now, yours can go anywhere. To be clear, your first one can go anywhere.

I I guess I'll have to trust you guys to be to play sheriff down there and make sure doesn't take too much real estate near to this guy. [sighs]

Wow. I know. So, my original thought was one of these two because you're relatively close to both of them.

Yep.

However, if If I The other option is that Yeah, I'm scared of getting Hold on. [snorts] No, you know what? We're going to stick with my original thought.

All right.

It's going to be one of those.

That's one. You must put down three discs.

Yeah. Now it has to be

now it has to be adjacent orth

orthogonally adjacent

to another piece of wood right now. Okay. So, hey, look at that. It worked out. Uh, [groaning] yeah, I'm happy with that.

Pretty good.

Okay. Okay. Going to be like that. I see. All right. [sighs and snorts] Can't do that right. Um probably Oh boy. Ah, this spot sucks. That spot sucks.

Those both spots are both potentially great.

Yeah, I know.

I know. Oh,

I have a lot to say about that after this. Yeah, there. Done. Final answer. Okay. So, pause. That is three turns.

We are now allowed to start auctioning if you wish.

Yeah.

All right. Go for it.

That's okay. I'm not going to

I always put out six first.

Yeah.

Yeah. It's

It's way too risky not to. Unless you feel like you're in a good position to Yeah. Uh, I don't want to do that. You know, I'll hedge. I thought about doing that. Okay. Okay.

Oh, before you go astray. Okay. Well,

I want that to happen. I don't know about that. All right. I'm not going to overthink it. Y'all did not go where I wanted you to go.

I gave you a pretty good cheese spot.

Yeah. I mean, diagonals are always nice off of the jump.

Mhm. Um I'm running a risk by doing it, but I think I will.

Yeah, because you're not near the soda.

Yeah, that's that's the

Yeah.

So be it. All right. Well, we know what we're doing now, Shay. And you don't have to take top. Follow your heart. Take whatever one you want.

Come on, dude.

It's good thing you're not left of

I That is a fact. Um, okay. So, everybody's got 15 bucks to start.

Wait, so we're doing hidden money?

Yeah. Okay. Well, blind bid.

Well, well, are we doing hidden money and blind bid?

No. I I just blind bid like here. Here. Whatever.

Let me see.

It is early for this.

Ready?

Yeah. How about that?

All right.

That means I win. You do.

Very lucky for me.

Yeah, that that actually is pretty great. So

I just assume Oh, wait. No, wait. You're blue.

Sorry. I'm used to you being red. I apologize.

Yeah, which is weird,

right? Well, I

never cuz I never normally play red.

I know. Well, I know. And that's why I've stopped doing that. So, but anyway, that is your honor. He must place it. Uh, he's blue. There, there, there, there, there, or there. I'm going to go out on a limb and say it's going to be one of those two.

That's a good guess. Okay,

that seems like a reasonable spot.

Yep, that 100%. So now the very best score that that could have

is two.

Is two. Either that, that, or that.

All of that is valid.

Now we check for expropriation,

right? So

another way to put it too is if a building went here, would it violate the rules?

Right?

And if that the answer is yes, it must be a roof,

right? The answer is no. Mhm.

If this were a building, everything could still connect around the outside. So, we can just skip it and move on.

Stuff that's far away from the edge early is very unlikely to violate,

right? Is usually edge stuff like edge edge of the board stuff. So, Shay did not win that auction. He takes another turn, which could be placing a disc or an auction, but he doesn't have a disc. So, therefore,

and if a soda comes up, Ken doesn't participate.

Correct.

Fish.

Okay.

Who shuffled this?

Who shuffled this? I I I did all of that. I really did.

Not necessarily what I Okay, whatever.

Yeah. So, now Shrey is going to bid some money.

Am I?

Yeah. 100%. Cuz he wants this.

Do I?

Yes. 100. Stop. Just stop.

Maybe. I don't know. If he wins and puts it here, this will become a road.

Yes.

But that doesn't necessarily mean he can. The road can still come all the way around this way,

right?

So, what?

Yeah. Yeah. It's fine. Okay. Right.

Okay. So, the money goes out of the game.

I mean, I'll do the obvious thing.

Yeah. He's Yeah.

I get the disc. It's here.

Okay. So, now either of these, one of those must be a road 100%.

Exactly.

But because we don't know because the other is accessible, there is no expropriation that happens. Right. Okay. So, you won that auction.

Yep. And that's my turn.

Now, Ken, you have a disc. Follow your heart.

I do have a disc. It's true.

Um,

there is expropriation.

There is.

Yes.

Okay. Hit me.

Not these or something.

So, if this became a building, would it violate the rule?

Yes.

Okay. So, that must be a road.

Okay. I'll buy that. This became a building.

Yes,

you're right. You are 100% right. Yep.

Ah, interesting. Okay.

Yep. That is valid.

I took a dis back, didn't I?

Uh, there you go. Yeah.

Yep. See, and that that right there is a perfect example of why that this is tough to wrap your head around. So, and obviously once roads are built, once flea markets are built, once every once something's on the board, except for discs, it's permanent.

One of them is going to be a road for you. So, you're good.

As long as both of those are still there, one of them becomes a road, I'm in great shape.

True. True. I'll buy that. I'm I'm a little gunshy now. I'm not going to lie.

You don't like the top?

There you go. So, that's flea market.

You looking for a flea market? No, I really wasn't. Okay. Um I mean um

what if we just get it what if we just get all the auctions out of the way before they're ready flea markets? It'll be great.

Well, then we That's interesting, too, cuz then they're we really weapons.

Yeah, sure. Of course. I mean, they're they're weapons whenever they come out,

right? That's true. Yeah. Yep. They're always weapons.

They're just more dangerous.

Yeah, I think I go there.

Okay.

And so that that goes here. That's my turn.

Yeah. Onion mortgage. Is that what that says? Um, yeah. Onion. Quite of the stuff that we realized or John realized.

All right, John. Okay. Boy, go here for now. [snorts]

Sh. Yeah, I will take that one. Um,

and I don't like that option.

All right.

Hated it.

Giddy up. Ice cream.

Ice cream.

Okay. All right. Um I guess I did not explicitly uh explain uh victory points. These are points.

Yeah.

Uh so bidding them is bad. Like you want to not

uh so this is John's auction.

Yep. Yeah. Okay. Somebody overbid.

I couldn't tell if you guys were going in on that one or not.

So, I assume

Yeah, that's the right.

Okay, there you go.

This is the almost identical to what we just did.

Yep.

So, this has to be a road,

right? Because this can't be a building,

correct?

Yeah.

Yes.

Well, so in other words, this one not great right now cuz the best it could be 1, two, three, four, five, six.

Yep. And this one's looking a little better now,

right? So, not not great. Not not great.

Yeah. Okay.

Eight. Yeah. Mhm.

And you did not win that auction.

Oh, okay. Yep. All right. Let's keep going. Flea market. All right. See, now if I got the flea market the first time, it was going to go here,

but now this isn't looking as terrible.

No, it's not so bad.

Yeah. So, I think I'll just put it here. No, we're going to put it over here.

Okay.

Over there. Right next to the purple. And we check for expropriation. And I think we're still good. So, because this is all accessible

if this We're a building.

We're a building.

I can still Bro could still come around the other way.

Yeah. So,

but things are going to get funky over there without flea market.

Without

uh you won that. So,

Oh, I have no Where do Oh, I do have a disc. It's here.

Yeah.

Okay.

Uh let's keep going on this stack. Soda. That is everybody can

And that's why I put that down in case that happened.

Let me look at this for a second.

Okay. So, it is red and purple and yellow right through here. This is the delivery truck. You know what? C can you No. See, to me, and y'all seen this, so give me a second. I struggle with this. I get them confused.

You know what? The X's actually will pop better.

And it's not good. It's Yeah, they're they're they're hard to see because

So, here you can still see that's blue. That's pink.

These are all the trucks you're doing.

Yes.

These are what we're counting towards. Okay. Yeah, that that's way better.

You can't see the food, though. It It's

They're different enough shapes.

Would it Would this be helpful? Is that That's a good idea.

That's good. That That works.

But you can't really see. I mean, this the the

Oh, I I promise you they can see it. Um that's a more truckly shape.

Yeah, you can see the wheels at least.

Okay. And you know what? Still for me, indulge me. Just put the X next to it. Yeah. On that

tile. Makes sense.

Okay. Um, yeah, the the purple and the flea markets are a little close also, but I think there's you can you can sort of see them apart

there.

I stickered mine and I'm so bad at this stuff and I didn't put them all going the same direction and Jackie was like,

"You're a monster.

What are you doing?

It's already hard to see." And then you have them going in different directions.

Yeah. Like you're a monster.

I'm not participating.

So, getting to this these three colors.

Yes.

Okay. So, probably not that part of the board, just FYI.

Uh, do I care to win this?

Who drew it?

You're like, uh, who drew it?

I did.

Traded.

Well, you you care whether you know it or not because if everybody bid zero, you're placing

facts. Okay, fair enough. All right, Trey, that's you. So, purple where you want it. there, there, or there.

Um, sorry. Uh, uh, I'll take the one that's that side. Yeah.

Okay. I got to look at this now. [sighs]

Okay.

Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Before you do that, we'll just

I just want to make sure that I'm not missing anything cuz like there's there may be a road like out here somewhere, but I think it's still okay. Um,

if any of those were buildings, it still can reach around going however it wants.

Yeah, one of these is going to expropriate each other though because if a building goes here, then this has to be a road to get in and vice versa.

Right.

But I think we're okay for now. So,

which is why I'm placing right there,

right?

Cuz that's going to that's going to generate some expropriation, I think.

Yep.

Okay.

You didn't go right.

I have not. I mean, I'm drawing. I know. I just [snorts] Is that the right thing?

Unclear.

You better hope uh

It's probably safe because

better hope an ice cream doesn't come up between now and your next uh your next go is what I would say.

Why?

Well, he's that's a a terrible path. Yeah, this is a horrible path for me. That

actually if ice cream comes up and he wins it, that'll be good because then this will be expropriated.

Yes. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. So I think him and I are fighting right there.

Yes. 100%.

So if I win the auction, I

So he and I are going to go to war when an ice cream comes up if that were to happen.

And I'm rooting for John. So me, too. We're all rooting for John, right?

Welcome to my life. All right. [snorts]

All right. Let's see. Um, wow. I'm just going to go here just in case.

Here.

Yep.

Okay.

Cheese.

Cheese.

Cheese. Which is that one?

Okay. Everyone's in on this one.

Let's see. Uh, if that happens,

whose auction is this?

It's mine. Yeah, I'm trying to put it in front of whoever it is.

If that happens,

uh, relax for a second. Hold on.

We can talk them all through, too. We can say, "Hey, this goes here. This will expropriate. If that goes there."

Sure. Yeah, go for it.

Yeah.

Um, so starting with this one, it bicts this whole side

from this whole side,

which now means next appropriation way.

No, but it's something to be aware of.

If the red were to then it I don't think it I think it's still good.

If this is this becomes a building, there's going to be a time where like a road has to like go way out here.

Yes, exactly. That's what I'm alluding to with this. I don't think since all four of us are right here, I don't think there will be any expropriation that happens here.

I don't think Yeah, it's close. Like if purple goes here, there's going to be a road out here eventually to get into this section, but yeah. Yeah.

Not there yet.

I don't know. I have no idea. It's a hard hard game to sort of understand.

Okay. So to the left of the auctioneer for the tie, that's me.

Oh, right. left. So, I wanted this one for that to be able to take that and put that there for it.

I did.

Wanted it. Yeah.

Right there. Please. No. No.

That's funny when they're all on a row like that.

I know, right?

Oh, man.

It ain't easy being cheesy. I I It's you.

Market the flea.

All right. Now,

just a reminder, people make this mistake, too. These do not need to be connected. Correct.

Okay. So, I played that way once and it was a hard mode.

Okay. So,

that I think is going to generate some appropriate

100. This must be a road.

Must be a road. Y.

So, we start there.

Yep.

This does not need to be a road because it has a way out. The same goes with both of those.

Yeah. But if a building goes there, what happens?

Then it can't. So, therefore, that has to be a road, right?

So, and if a building goes there, what happens?

Then this has to be a road there. There you go. The other one right?

No. No. You're right. You're right. You're right. You're right.

That can be a building.

It can't.

Yeah. What if a building goes there?

Yeah. Well, this has to be a road.

Yep.

Huzah. Uh, purple.

Yep.

Red.

No, there just to protect

from someone else putting the disc there.

Yeah, that was the only reason it was there. So, it's fine. It's good.

I think that's it. I think everything else is copacetic.

I think so. If you say so.

I I said think.

Oh, I I mean from an expropriation front, maybe. Yes. In in every way.

Fair. Valid. Uh, okay.

Your turn.

All right. Uh, that was

that was me.

Uh, right. That was you here, right? Okay.

All right.

There we go. Okay. [sighs] Okay. So, cheese. That is done. I'm really wanting that to be a road. Me, too. Thumbs up.

Make it happen.

Oh, wait. That could be a road, too. So, I'm Yeah, either of those are fine.

Oh, yeah. You're okay.

Um,

I mean, also those could both not be roads,

you know.

Yeah. I'm sorry. It took me a second, but yes,

that's such a good spot.

It is. As long as that I don't put a flea market there, then that's guaranteed to be

cuz cuz you're now fighting with purple here. So that's you're that's awesome. Yeah, that'll never get exp.

Yeah. Yeah. I'm I'm already fine there. It's the cheese.

But you could expropriate him out is what I'm saying.

You can put a flea market there and

and now that becomes a road.

Yeah, that would have screwed Edward if he

if this if you put a house here, how does this road connect out here? It's got to come this way or this way, right? So that's what you want to be looking for is how can you expropriate

I

It's such a good game. But it's it's funny. Um there were one of our one of my patrons uh in Slack was like I don't get it. It's like a weight of like 2.5 on BG and like a 45minute game. Why is heavy cardboard? Hopefully now you

Is the Is that the Is that this edition or the original edition?

Uh

I think maybe they just never played it before. Like they were just like looking at the entry on BG because I would assume there were slightly there were different weights.

Well, this is weight 2.4.

Yeah. And the

Oh, and the original is 3.04.

Yeah.

Interesting.

It's just funny because like you'll understand the rules, but you'll still get them wrong.

Yes.

That that is a fact.

By the way, what's up, Lady Orca? Hi. Over on Twitch. Appreciate it. Uh, I'm happy with that. I'm happy with that. That side of the board is good. Um, I don't Do I want to mess any of that up? Oh. Oh, that could be fun. Oh, yeah. I don't mind drawing.

So sketchy right now.

Soda.

Uh, soda.

And you're the auctioneer. God.

Which means uh and you're done. So it's you and me.

Yeah. So I wonder what you're going to bid.

Well, I I'll leave it to you. You can figure it out.

You win ties, though.

I know.

So you're going to win this no matter what.

Yeah. I mean, there's literally no reason for you to pay to pay money for this.

Yeah. Well, yeah. I like we we

unless unless you want to do go stop him from placing. I don't see a reason why you would need to do that. So,

well, we're going to have an auction.

Yes.

You want to take the five also?

No, I think we're okay.

Okay, you win that.

Yep.

That's soda, right?

Yeah.

So, now this soda is locked for me.

Yes,

that is my soda. It is going there unless I screw it up somehow.

Yeah, you're good for soda. Yeah. So, we're just gonna kind of move.

You can't screw up. You're good.

Uh, flea markets.

Yeah. If you put a flea market there, but

if you if you if you somehow are drawing with one disc on the board.

Yeah. Right. It seems unlikely. Guess you do that. It's your job.

Yeah. So, now I think putting this here just in case seems like a good place to go.

So, now now I have to figure out how to expropriate yellow. That's like what I'm trying to figure out.

Why do you Why?

So I can get

So you can get a one.

Oh, right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Right. To help you. Not to hurt me, but to help you.

But next time if you draw a flea market, that is sort of the obvious spot for you to put it.

Oh, 100%.

Right. And I, you know, I keep drawing cheese.

Wow. Glorious cheese.

I have not a flea market, which is interesting. But

I am out of this. I'm the only one cuz cheese. Cheese. Cheese. So, uh, working our way through this. Um, if this wins, this be

Oh,

this must become a

This has to be a road. Missed it.

Why?

Because if this is a building and that's now

correct. Yep. This is a road. Yeah.

That should have happened when you put your uh Yep.

I think Wait, wait. Say it again.

If if that became a building.

Yeah. That can't be a room.

Violated the rule,

right? Or Right.

It could be a building, though.

That can be a building. But this can't

I'm I'm not following.

This has to have access to a road.

Yeah.

Can't Yeah. But couldn't it just be also be a road? I guess I'm

That could be a road. It's possible, but it doesn't have to be. This does.

Okay.

Did someone just put this flea market there? I can't remember.

No.

No. No. Okay, then whenever one of those happened, I should have

Yeah, so be it. Sure. Again, it's hard to Yeah.

Thank you, Smurf of Death. And I think uh uh I don't know who else mentioned it, Mark. So, thank you.

Good

and Onion. Glad you guys are liking the new

I mean, the question is, is is Ken bidding anything or should I be should I do I want to win this? Let me think about it. If Ken wins this, he's taking one of those two. Um, and that's fine for me. I don't necessarily care that much,

but it might be nice to get my thing on the

board.

Okay.

What does

this one

because if not,

if a building went there Oh, no. I'm sorry. You're right. No.

Okay, good. Because

that would make me sad that I drew it then.

You're good.

Okay. All right. That's what I picked up.

Yeah. If a building goes there, then I

auction. You're He's bidding nothing.

All right. To the left of the auctioneer.

So, I win.

Yep.

Which one's it going on? I suppose it's this one seems to give me the most options because either one of these is equally good for that.

Yeah.

But this one's better for this, right? I can't Does that make sense to you guys? I mean,

no, I that's the right answer. Okay.

This is the right between those two. This is the right answer. Yeah.

And there's an expropriation.

Okay.

Then do it.

Okay. I just

This has to be a road.

And the the blue one.

Well, here. This must be a road

cuz you got to be able to come through here.

Mhm. And the one that

Sure.

And then this one

This one here or this one here?

Uh, no. There.

Okay. Because that has to be able to connect out.

Sure.

This one has to be able to connect out.

So that's

So that's got to be a road.

Yep. And I would argue this has to be a road because this has to have access. Makes sense. Yep.

Okay.

And a building can still go in one of those spots.

Yep. Yep.

Yep. Yep. Yep. Yep.

And I still no discs.

Let's flee market. Flea market. There market.

Well, I got I got I just got the safe one. I'll just do this.

Okay. Fun. I feel confident Ken's going to

road.

Oh, where' you just put that? I wasn't watching.

Right here.

Yeah, it must be a road. Correct.

Sweet. I actually wanted the disc back. Thank god.

All right.

So, you you got a frame a framer can go right here. You just draw dry time.

I could. That's interesting. That's a great idea. I'm going to do that probably next time. Um, but this time I'm definitely placing a disc. Um, and I need to think about where I desperately want to play market. Just so you know.

I know you're

But the cool thing is though, if you do an auction and lose, you get to

I can't place it there. I cannot.

Must be adjacent to something on the board.

Yeah. But I would place it there if I could though.

But if I place it near there, then somebody else could potentially place there. So, I don't want to do that.

But you might be getting a disc back.

What?

Edward?

No, Edward's not getting disc back because Ken's not placing drawing tiles. So,

right. Edward has

Yeah.

prepared himself.

Um. All right. I'll put one here.

Okay.

So, is that legal? You can place next to flea market adjacent to something on the board

for my good friend John

which now means this is a road it must be

I can't see

because otherwise it wouldn't have

that has to get out

and if that's a road well this must be a road because these roads need to be able to connect which

that's right

there. And if a building, it could still come around. So we're good there. Yep.

I think

a bunch of access. So So if a building goes here, it can still come this way.

Yes.

Yep. I think that's it.

And that one would have access to a road because there Yep. Yep. Yep.

I think that's it. It is your honor, sir.

Yep.

Oh man. Well, okay. If I go here, I'm kind of competing with myself. So that's not terrible.

That's only four. That's not like you said, not terrible.

Not terrible. Here or here, though. If I Let's go there for now.

All right. Are you sure you want to do that?

Why wouldn't I?

One, two, three, four, five, six. I mean, I guess maybe I'm not. The flea market's never going there. The only reason it's there is to stop someone else from putting a disc there and making a flea market. Oh, because then a road maybe. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, I get it. I now

it's it's protection.

Yes. I defensive, not I I understand now. A little slow on the pickup sometimes, but

uh Ken, you went right?

I did. You went there.

Okay.

So, ideally this, but if not, let's see who has placed fish. Only purple. So that seems good.

Yeah, sure. Come on. Smurf says, "This game has so much jerk sauce. I love it." And and Mark says, "The expropriation is making my hair hurt and I'm just watching." Yeah, it's

it's it it really is hard. So, I guess I better defensively place there.

Oh, why do you need to defend there?

Somebody else placed there and then placed uh

market. Yeah, sorry. For your cheese. Yeah. Yeah. I forgot your cheese wasn't wasn't connected yet.

Well, speaking of cheese,

uh your two the ones in the auction

and me too.

You two.

Oh. Oh, yeah.

Procreation. So Shay and John are the only two in.

Okay, let's take a look here.

So it is to right here. Okay.

So it's if John takes it, he's got a couple of options.

Uh he doesn't want this one.

No, not that one. He really really doesn't want to get this one or that one. Right.

Yeah.

So if I win the red, I think purple gets expropriated.

If you win here, I mean I

Yes. Then that's a road and that's a road.

Is it? Is blue a road also? Because it has to get has to be able to get through.

Oh, sure.

It has to get this way. And if that then this is the bottleneck, which means these two are both

I don't think this becomes a road though because it can get it would get out through this road.

Yeah. Oh, cuz this could also be a road.

No, no.

If you flee market or if you put something here,

these will have to be roads.

Water has to flow out and out.

Yep.

And then if wins that blue,

I get expropriated out of there. Well, I have two options, right? I can go here or here.

Yeah, you may not want to be right next to it. So, yeah. Okay.

And uh you could go over here instead.

Yeah, he could go here that that becomes a road,

which it will be.

Well, again, similar to

he can he can make sure it's a road just by leaving it there.

Like everything's a road at the end of the game,

right?

Sure.

Everything that's Edward's auction, right?

It is. Okay.

All right. All right, Shrey, where's it going?

Uh, that's a good question. So, if I went here, what's going to happen? That's what I need to understand.

Uh, this becomes a road.

Yes.

Yeah. This does not necessarily

This This I think also has to be a road.

It would. Correct. Both of those.

This is not necessarily a road. Correct.

And if I went here,

um, does anything

Nothing changes because everything still has access around you all the way around.

Maybe this has to.

Yeah. Right. You are correct. I am wrong.

And this might also have to

if then yeah, it has to be able to get out.

These would both have to facts.

Yes.

Yep.

I don't know what the right call is here. [snorts]

I'm sort of surprised Alyssa's never played this before. It seems weird.

Oh, this feels like an Alyssa game.

But I also just feels like a game we would have played at one of our game.

Alyssa, it's on that website I told you about today. which is

poured together.

Okay.

It's when I hover over a disc, it shows the expropriation

these two.

Yep.

Because this has to flow out.

Sure.

So that means one of these two must be a road.

But we don't know which yet.

Yep. And that was your auction, right?

That was my auction. I did not win it. So I choose I have no discs. Market of the flea. Okay.

No,

that's an interesting idea though. Think about it a little bit.

I mean this is like safe. You could just do that because it's never going to be something you use.

That you know what that is? That is true. That is the likely one.

I mean that one is also not great but it is a backup I think.

Yeah.

Well that is the backup to this. So, no. Um, no. I think it's just here. Not overthink this. All right. So, that that means this gets expropriated.

Yes,

I think that's it.

I think you're right. But

I'm not willing to be at my turn. I wasn't even looking. Where did you put your thing?

Uh, right here. And so, that became a

move there. That has to be That has to be Yeah,

I we think that's it.

Yeah, that looks right.

Okay. Uh I won that auction. Go or not auction, but tile drill

shroom.

Oh boy. [sighs] All right. So, I do that.

You could do that one.

What do you think about that one just

I I like it.

I think I think we would all like it. I think conclusively everybody around this table would be fine with it, I think, is what I'm hearing.

So, if I put this here, this becomes a road.

Yeah. because it has to get to that. Oh, no. Those are still those will still be legit.

Yeah,

but I don't want to do that.

Okay, then don't

um my safest one is probably here for right now.

So, does anything happen?

I think road can get all the way around it.

It doesn't come this way, right? Right. Then there's two options. Yeah. So, even if this were a building, it could Yeah. Okay.

Yeah, I think so. I think we're okay.

Shray.

Um,

yeah. Okay. Uh, well, I got a disc.

I'm not saying I'm going to not read the comments on this, but if you're watching this after the fact, I would watch the whole damn thing before you say, "Hey, you forgot to expropriate." And then see if we actually ended up remembering it a couple minutes later.

Assuming it's perfect right now, we're actually doing really good. I I'm actually I assuming even if it's not perfect, I feel like we're doing a pretty good job of being vigilant at least. Even if we're not right,

vigilant.

The last game I played on the table, we did 100% and I was so proud of us.

It is. This is hard.

Do that,

sir. Huh?

Where did you just place that? Yeah. I hate you. Sorry. [snorts] Okay. Do I do I don't know. Oh, I need to draw.

Oh, you don't. You have a disc.

No, but if I can put if I can put one here.

Yeah.

I think that forces that to be a road.

It does. Glory to Rome. A boy.

All right.

So, this has to be a road. This has to be a road.

Keep going.

That's got to get be a road. And it could go out from there.

From there, I think we're good. And then this has to be a son of a

That has to be a road.

You expropriated yourself.

I sure did.

And now we're good cuz either one of those could be a road.

Well, that's good for me for that. This one's problematic still. It's my turn, though.

It's fine.

Four is not so bad.

Yeah, four is fine.

Three is better.

Sure. Three is better.

So, who still needs ice cream? Well, I was mad at you for doing this until he did that. Now,

I'm in the same situation as you. I'm good.

Yes.

Thank you, Ken. Um,

yeah.

Didn't know it was a team game.

Yeah, I got myself a one, so that's what I was shooting for.

My fish situation is not great right now.

No.

Um, [snorts]

yeah, that seems reasonable.

Mhm. And to be clear, the way we're playing this game is why the second edition came out is because this is hard,

right?

Um, so that is there. One of those for this and then one of I draw, baby, draw. Right. [snorts]

I'm sure nothing bad will happen.

Okay. Hold on. If one of these becomes a flea market, that means the other one becomes a road.

Correct. Mundo.

Yeah. Hold on. Uh, [gasps] okay. So, one of these. This one's closer to that, but this one's closer to that. I think we go there. this game like Yeah, you're right. I never thought of it this way, but it actually has some weird like go feels.

Yeah, someone I play with has also said that and chess.

Huh.

It's also like a big adult tic-tac-toe.

All right. Ice cream. That is me and Shay and Edward.

Ice cream is here.

Yeah. So, right there. So, you have that.

Yeah.

For free. You don't necessarily. So Shay and I both want this. We're both three away.

Mhm.

You both Yeah. Three away. Yep.

Mhm.

Oh, you can paid 15. Do you have 15 left? 14 left.

You paid one. You paid one, I think.

So, hold on one second. Let me let me just do some figuring here.

Okay. Four.

Four.

Come on. It was two. And then you were like hinging hard. I was like, let's add a third. Now, listen to four.

My thought was, "Oh, this screws me so hard."

Here.

Oh, yeah. Oh, glory to Rome again. I was like, h he's going to go three because Oh, I'll go four. Four is safe. Should I go five? Nah, four is safe. Five was the right. Yeah, don't I know it.

This one, too.

I think that might be it.

Oh, that's so bad. Because of a dollar.

That's it, right?

I think so. I'm looking.

Okay. Is this one a road? No, because this could go there.

This one's coming close, though, because for this is the middle of the map.

It's one of these two is a road.

Well, this one could be actually, too. Right.

You You're right. Yeah.

Yeah.

All right. Here we go.

Flea market.

Oh god, I hate this.

Do I just put it there?

Yeah, I think so. because this isn't really going anywhere yet. So,

that doesn't change anything.

Yeah,

put some stank on that one.

Um,

try

I'm trying to Oh, how do I make that? So, I need I don't think I

What's that you say?

Edward's cookie is not in a good spot here.

My cookie. There is no cookie.

Oh, cheese. I mean,

might be okay. Might be a three.

What?

Be this one.

No, his cheese is right here.

Oh, I I'm hoping that's a road. I'm It's going to be a road.

Is it? Yeah.

That helps Edward.

Oh, sure.

Yeah. Okay. Just pointing it out. That's all.

I mean, well, but Edward also, you know, has

he hasn't paid much. That maybe that's the uh that's the

Yeah.

Uh what just happened? What What did I miss there?

Okay, Ken.

Yeah, I should place one. I think it's probably somewhere like this. fixing. There we go. Okay. [sighs]

Hold on, hold on, hold on. Actually, wait. Road through one of those. It's still not a choke point here cuz either of those what you go ahead. What

I the disc I just placed cancer. Should that be a should that be a rose?

Tell me where it is. No, because it could

if that becomes a building

then yes that is a room.

Yeah, never mind. So that that that was

I could not have placed that there basically.

Correct. Correct.

So we place it somewhere else then.

Where did you place yours?

Placed here. Okay.

Um

you want Ken to just take his back then?

Yeah. Just here. Well, yeah. Nothing else has changed. I think this is the right thing.

Oh, right. I see.

Yeah, cuz this I knew that was happening soon because

Yeah. just I I was like it maybe there's a way to connect it that I'm not seeing. No, that Okay.

Um go here.

Okay.

And then Kenny, you can take the same spot if you want, but

I can. But now I think maybe it might make sense to take this spot instead. Do I want to draw

Are you finding it easier? I know you haven't played, but finding easier to see this road versus this road.

Six after the other.

I have a feeling it's probably easier on TV, though.

Yeah, that's valid. Yeah, looking at that,

it's clearly a road, right? Like

Wow. No, I think do I draw I draw? Yeah. Okay. Okay. I don't think that changes anything. Not true. It can get out. Uh,

no. This has to be a road now.

It does. You're right. Yes.

And then that could go either direction. That's legit. Okay, you're up.

Uh, Ken, could you put me at the end of that lane there? Uh, right at the bottom

there.

Uh, like towards Edward

there.

Uh, one more

there. Sure.

Thank you.

Oh, sure. I see.

Since Shay was so confident.

If Shay's so confident that's going to be a road, right?

Yeah.

Well, I'm not going to place a flame market there.

Uh, so do I draw?

I mean, if you did, you'd have a three instead of a two, but you'd hose Edward. Why would I How would I have a three?

Oh, you'd have a four instead of a two, but you'd hose Edward.

I guess I should check and I I could calculate. I don't know.

Right. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Um Wait, wait, wait.

Go ahead.

Hurry up, though.

Just going to go in this area.

Uh I'm trying to figure out how a way to

That's good to hear, Tuk. I was worried. Just saying it's easier to see it. Yep.

Good. All right. [sighs and gasps]

Boy, I think

only like eight tiles left.

I think that's six and one half dozen the other, but we'll go there. God, I would recommend there.

No,

this is also a good one for you.

Maybe here.

No. No,

it's got to be one of those two.

Oh, that's so

No, that was an emphatic no.

No, definitely not.

But if I do that, let me look at that for a second.

Whichever one of those you placed the other row. That seems wrong.

Yes,

100%. That is wrong.

Very good options here.

That's why I think I have to abandon.

Was your What about that one over there?

Well, that's my That's a soda.

No, you have your sodas already out.

Yeah, your soda's here. I know, but I want the road to go this way.

Sure,

it still probably will. I mean, maybe not. I guess

it may.

This is probably my

Trey has a little control over that.

Yeah.

All right, Shay, your honor.

That doesn't that doesn't that expropriates anything, right?

Um,

nothing in the

Can a building go here?

Yes, because this connects and then that would force this to be a road.

No, I think a road has to go there.

Why? Why? Because if a building goes here, oh, I guess that could No, not yet.

The options are tight. They're still available.

I have to draw. Let's draw this one.

Hey, it's Marcus. Okay, my choices are getting in way of of of the uh John

John over there. Or is if I do any of these, does anything happen. Clearly something happen. I just don't understand enough to

I mean, if you did this one, it would make a lot of stuff happen this way.

It would make this. But what what about that?

No, it wouldn't change that one. Yeah,

they're just easier to see.

I would have to control I would have to control myself and make sure I don't let it become a flea market,

right?

So I I really can't make I can't get this to be a flea market. Like I can't get the you there's no way for me to

force it. Yeah.

I think it would be very hard.

Yeah. So let's just get it there.

Uh that goes here.

Uh where did it go?

Yeah.

All right.

That's going to create quite a few rows.

It is. So, here we go. So, this could still come this way, but we know that's got that's got to be a road. I think

it it could come up either way.

Yeah, it could come up either way. I don't know if it adds any road.

Oh, wow. Why? That's wild. I think you're right cuz this multiple paths.

If you build a building here, it could still get around this way. If you build a building here, you can still get around.

That's that that thing has to be a road.

That's a road. If you build a building here, it blocks these off. Yeah, that is true. If you build a building here,

can go yellow,

right? And if you build a building here, you can go that. I think that's it. I think so.

Yeah, looks like it.

All right, that was my flea market.

Okay,

can Right. Flea market. Where are all those fish? My poor soda.

How bad do you want your soda? I want

it back.

One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine at best.

God.

So, I can't do this one because it'll make that one into a road, which I don't really want. I could do this one, though, which I don't think that does anything

because all of these still have a couple of paths to get through there.

That's right. The the thing it does do is ensure that one of those two is a road, which is a that's a happy outcome for me.

Oh, yeah. It must. You're right. Because this has to get out one of those or both, but at least one.

Yeah.

Oh, Lord. Okay. I'm in rough shape right now. Um, do I want to draw? I think the answer is yes.

Yeah.

Not a fish.

Okay.

Were these counted to the ones in there, too? So, there's three left. Uh, not necessarily. No, I just threw emptied them all in.

Okay.

Not options. Not options. So, it's those two.

Mhm.

If I were to go here.

Mhm.

Does that change anything?

Is that a road?

Not nec No, it could come either way.

Oh, good point. Okay. All right.

I don't think so.

If you did this one, then you know that way. Yes.

A road will come out.

And do you have a You don't have an ice cream yet. One of those will be ice cream. Yeah,

for sure. Whichever one,

right?

You know what? That actually makes that answer. Oops. Sorry. That's me done. Shray. Um, one, two, three. H. Where's your fish can? It's going to be one of these.

Fish is ugly right now.

Yeah. So, it's Well, no for can is fine. It's well, like a four. Five.

It's ugly for all of them.

Four. Five. Four.

Out of these five tiles, two of them are fish

and um one is ice cream

and one is ice cream. So, two fish and an ice cream, which means two of them are flea markets.

Yeah. Now, you may start to see remember these go out in order,

right?

Which can be very very important,

right? I'm just so I I'm So, if I draw a fle flea market, that's when it that's when it when it matters for me. The rest of the the other thing is uh none of these are yours. So,

right. Yeah.

Let's take let's take this one.

Flea market. Okay.

Market. So you have a your score is your score right now.

Well, no.

Oh, right. You're right.

I can I can affect my score. I can make my score higher.

Yes.

By making Edwards worse because Edward is actually beating me right now.

Well, Edward's in a very precarious position right now because I don't have ice cream and I don't have fish.

Right. But you're you're nine 10. If I leave this as a as a as a road, your score is 10. uh minus that which is negative is mine is like mine's worse because I spent a lot of money

and this is also incredibly good. So if me making this a road

is or me make putting flea market there makes this a road and that helps Ken right

however my score is one either way.

Yes. And that's the so I think I just have to do it. I have to

I have to do it. It's it like you you are beating me so I I need to uh [sighs]

All right. Any Does anything else have to go down?

Um I'm looking at here, but I don't think so because it can go that way.

Does this No, because the road can go this way.

Yeah, it can come up this way. can go there. Okay, I'll buy that.

Yeah. All right.

Yeah. Okay. That was

So, there's two There's two It's two fish and two flea markets in there. 50-50 chance.

There's one flea market. There's It's two fish and an ice cream.

Oh, and an ice cream, which I don't care about.

So, that's probably what I'll draw.

No, there's not an ice cream. There's three ice creams on the board already. No, this No,

there's there's there's two ice creams. I promise. Sorry. I promise you

these guys I I sort of think of those guys looking like ice cream. Okay, ice cream.

Those are soda.

That's an ice cream float over there. Um, it's entirely possible that we've missed stuff, but we're doing the best we the very best we can.

I don't see any. All right, I'm going to draw.

Well, that's it for flea markets.

Well, that's good. Actually,

I didn't I was tired of flea markets.

So, I'm going to put that there.

That doesn't change anything, I think.

I know.

Oh, no. It chang makes this one.

Yeah. This can't be a building now because that's the isolation.

Yeah. Road and road right here. These two are roads.

100.

Those two are roads and that has to be a road. I'll buy that.

Yep. All right. Well,

who's blue?

It's me.

Sorry. Let's make sure I don't have any fish. is me and Ken and Edward.

Oh, Fish is bad news. All right, I got to look at this for a second.

All right, I'm just going to think out loud.

Sure.

If Ken wins

Yep. It goes there. Which means this must be a road.

Why?

These would be roads.

Why?

Because if this goes here, this has to this system has

correct. Those two are roads. Okay.

But the not I don't think anything changes here.

Okay.

Right. I mean, don't don't go my my word. I have the hardest time with this.

So, if this is a building, those have to be roads to connect those two sides.

Okay. If this is a building, that means this has to be a road. Must be because this has to be able to connect to these.

Yes.

If this is a road, it could go either way then at that point. So if Ken wins and places it here, that's a road.

Ken is a die breaker right now.

If I win one of these,

the

the other one becomes a road. Yeah.

Which then means one of mine becomes a road. The other one does not. Correct.

Mhm.

That's right. There's no way both of yours are going to become roads on this play.

Correct.

Um

Okay. And so Okay. This is risky.

I was only willing to go a little bit. So,

so it doesn't make it doesn't make sense for me to try to win before you guys cuz then you can just seal my fate.

Yeah,

this one can actually be worse than this one potentially. Okay. So,

I think this the right move.

Oh, the the one that's further.

Well, because then it expropriates this way.

No, it doesn't.

It does not.

It does.

How? Show your work.

Because this is all disconnected.

Oh, you're right. This has to be a road. This has to be a road.

Yes.

This has to be This has to be a root. This has to be a root. That also has to be

Okay, I'll buy that.

Yeah,

I'll buy that.

Yep.

Yeah. Oops.

Yep.

And says this,

right?

Yeah.

Okay. And you drew that?

No,

you did.

No, I didn't draw it.

I drew it.

Yeah.

Oh, okay.

So, I could draw and I have a place. Oh, no. I because I have a place for to play. Uh, doesn't make sense for me to draw. Guess it's fish or cheese. Trying to figure out doesn't make sense. I don't know. I I don't know. I'll just draw.

So, the interesting. Okay. So, now thinking out loud. Um, and this is where this is the instance where Kyle's rules comes into play. Here, I biden Ken wins. Now, Ken's is going to go right there or right there.

Here.

Nice.

That's awesome.

At least it went out for free,

right? Yeah.

Um,

yeah. No, I I didn't realize I I I realized that after I drew it that Ken didn't have any uh

tokens on the board.

So,

thanks, Ollie.

I will do that.

Yeah, I need to

What is that just telling me?

Ice cream. It's like it it's your you or me.

So, it doesn't matter. So, I need to make sure I have a cookie or cheese path. And I'm putting cheese down first.

You You have a cheese pad. It's right here,

right? Good. Okay. I think we're good then.

Yeah. We'll just we'll just run this.

Yep. Ice cream bid.

Okay.

It's not you. I know. Not me. That's one of the good ones. Uh,

okay. So, we can go ahead and

uh hold actually wait.

Like there's no reason this is not going to be a road.

So, at the end, like after this, um

we'll start placing them one at a time.

The whole map becomes a road.

Yeah. Yeah.

Okay. Okay. So, this is going to go here. Y

which then will make

that a road.

That a road. Yeah. Exactly. Anything else? And the one below it, right?

Mhm.

That one.

Yep.

And either one of those can be.

All right. So now we start placing these one at a time for the people. There are four buildings left, so they get placed one at a time. So cheese is coming out.

Yep.

Good one.

Doesn't change anything. N.

Next one is ice cream. Yep.

Another good one.

Sod pop.

Nothing changes ones at the end.

And then fish.

Yep.

Now we will do this one at a time. So we'll start with uh start do it player by player.

The whole map becomes roads if you just want to make sure we did it right.

That is part of the rules.

You can take discs off.

Yep. I hope I brought enough tiles.

What have we done to this land? We've paved over it.

And where we haven't paved over, we've built flea markets, which might be even worse,

right? All right. So, I'll go first. So, uh I have negative that. But we'll do it or Yeah. Yeah. So, I have a distance of one.

Yep. 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10. Not great.

11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

Mhm. - 14 minus I have 14 here. Okay.

So, your score is neg five.

So, my score neg five. There we go. Okay. Go.

Go. Okay. Uh, one, two.

Yep.

Three, four, five, six, seven, eight, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17. Uh, 17

7 - 6.

Okay.

-6. So,

Edward ahead by one right now.

Uh, I'm purple. Okay. One, two, three, four, five, uh, five, six, seven, eight.

Yes.

Nine minus six. So, I'm three. So,

leader in the clubhouse three. Yep.

Yep.

And then Ken.

All right. I've got one, two, three, four, 16.

Right. Minus 12 is -4.

Yep.

There you go. So, three, four, five, six,

five, six. There you go. So, Shay won that. There you go.

Good job, Shay.

Cool. All right.

Outsmarted myself on that one.

Maybe.

Maybe I should have tried to win that last that last

auction. Yeah,

but even if I'd won it, you guys could still have hosed me, I think,

pretty badly.

I'm not sure.

I over bid here. I would have tied Trey, probably,

right?

Yeah. You had three discs out here. It all got cleaned out and you had and you had nowhere else on the board. Yeah. So, yeah, I think I think you needed some safety somewhere else.

Yeah.

So, what did you you were the one that was hosed because of Kyle's rules, right? That

thoughts on the the SP Kyle's rule is the it's to the left of the auctioneer.

Um, and then the first three rounds have to be placed so that that doesn't happen off the jump. That part isn't I think the the real consequence of that rules change.

Okay.

The consequence of the rules change is that it deflates incentive for bidding.

It makes it easier to get away with bidding nothing.

Mhm.

Okay.

Yeah.

The um and and to I think to be just to check this

in that in that particular situation even if we weren't playing Kyle's rules, Ken would take it anyway because I all my all my markets were out there already. it would be the player to your left in that case. That's actually true.

That's right. Yeah. So, I think I think that I think that the the main change is that it just changes

bidding incentives. Now, some of that is board position stuff

like we didn't have any spaces where it really made sense to go to war by the time things played out the way they played out,

right? Um, and sometimes you will see more of that in a game of this, but like I think it also I think that rule also just depresses there's there's more circumstances where it makes makes sense to bid zero with that rule in

as opposed to going to war and bidding bigger numbers

without opposed to like the auctioneer winning ties, right? I think I think makes it slightly higher incentive for everybody else to bid a little bit.

Yeah. Like we had four was the highest winning bid, right?

Right. Yeah,

which is not I mean in the in the base rules, if you will, playing the same rules, just the auction being different. I feel like on occasion that that can be a a bigger number than four

for sure.

Um,

but I would also say like I spend a total of three money on my four spaces,

right?

That's just a low amount of money to have spent. Yeah, I I apparently spent

now Shay Shrey spent the most and he won.

I spent I spent so nine,

right?

Sometimes you really do have to bid big because otherwise you're going to you're going to be washed out,

right?

Yeah.

So,

y

thoughts?

This is a top 10 game for me easily. Uh it might be in the top 20 sometimes, but I love this game so much.

Why?

Um there's a lot of reasons. So, I've never played uh any other rules besides that. I played the plenary version for the first time I ever played was this, but I barely remember it. Um, it's Greg mentioned in the chat, but I this is what I talk about too, and this is going to sound so freaking weird, but it it is like a quantum positioning game because it it's like it's like Schroinger's cat, the board game. There there are no other games like this. So, the the game first of all acts on its own, right? Because the game will will decide based on what we did how the board appropriate expropriates and it's a probabilistic game in the sense that you have to like we said it a bunch of times out loud but either this or this is going to be a road and it doesn't become a road until you observe it which quantum physics

right so like

sure I'll buy that

that is just like such an interesting concept there are no other games like this that do that where the the the game automatically acts and there's like this quantum board state of probability Um, you have that then you like finding the expropriation is is enjoyable to me even though it's very difficult.

Um, the argument for the original bidding rules I I don't see why that's better, but I'm not arguing against it either. I just never played it. This

I'm not sure it is better or worse. I think it's just different.

It's just different. Yeah, it creates a different incentive and I think there [snorts]

I think you I said at the beginning we're probably not going to see the consequences of it in one play. It's something that like you see over a period of time.

Yeah. um because the the g the board state is completely different. And I [clears throat] do like playing it on this version because the board can be variable,

right? It's not a perfect 9 by9 grid or whatever it is. It can be a little bit

like kind of like L lost atlas. You could build a gap.

I've played maps where there's a giant gap right here and it's just cluster and it's just like, you know, just it's fun. So

yeah,

I don't know. This game is it blows my mind every time I play it and I really really enjoy it. Um

it is unique. There is no doubt. I just wish it was more intuitive for the expropriation. That's literally my only real complaint about this game is it's really hard to figure that out. And maybe it shouldn't be. Maybe there are a lot of smarter people than I am. Um but it it it I I know it. I understand it. It's hard to see it.

It's hard for me. And there are some people who just instantly can see it.

Yeah. So

I always have fun with it. It's never It's not a game I like crave playing, but I' i've never had a bad play. And I think John's right. I think the zippiness

is a huge contributor. Absolutely. If this game played in two and a half hours, I don't think I would want to play it very much.

Weird. Yeah.

Yeah.

Agreed.

This is in my top 50 also. I can't remember where in the top 50 it is, but it's it's pro I think in the 20s if I had to guess. Um I except um that is based off of the

these rules the the the 2014 version

2014 rules because that's what I've played the most. And

you prefer those rules.

And I'm not saying I prefer them. I'm saying that those are the ones I understand. Uh and I've played them a lot. Um and I've only played this the expos exploration rules like three times maybe over the span of like many many years. So, I've never been able to internalize how to interpret the board and um and and I still see a ton of value in or an ex an excellent game in the in the new

the 2014 version to to parse.

Yeah, I like that one, too. And I don't see and and I think and and I you know I'm sure people who have played this version a ton um uh would dismiss the the the new the easier version for for that that but I think it's kinder and gentler.

There's I don't know if it's kindler gentler.

Well, this can't happen.

No, it can't it can.

Don't don't you just have to like go outside? you go outside, but no, but you can also you can also get win one without um without having it's a good game. It's just it's very different.

It's it's not that it's worse.

It's hard to compare, I guess.

Right. And so for me, I I would, you know, I would love to be able to get to the point that I can understand the exprop expropriation well enough that I could

the expropriation is super clever and I love it

and it it kind of makes this version like really attractive, but it's also the thing that makes it

right

really difficult to gro, right?

It's funny, too. Like bidding over bidding by accident is hilarious and just like like nuking a whole row. I think is fun to do. Yeah,

I think if I was to play it again, I would probably prefer to to uh but again in a reasonable like soonish so I can remember. I would I would I absolutely want to play with the original auction for rules because I I'm just saying I think that's

we've been doing that so I I like doing this. That's something that we could do. We could revisit this again soon.

Sure.

Because I think the incentives are uh they're different and I I think I might enjoy that more. That's

And you wouldn't have the first three discs in that case. They would just

I think I I

think but I mean like be silly not to.

It's a smart thing to do.

Yeah, right.

Well, no, but someone could pull an auction right away.

That's fine.

Yeah,

they would win it and they would have a um you know

12,

right? It's fine.

Yeah, that didn't seem like a smart choice, right?

Yeah, unless again.

Yeah, I don't know.

All right. What happens if you pull a flea market and you can't place it?

You're not allowed to draw something if you don't have a disc on the board. Yes.

Oh, okay.

Well, so then you couldn't pull an auction right away. Well, I mean on your second turn.

On the second turn, you could.

Something that Yeah.

Okay, cool. That's a wrap. That's it. See you all next week. Like, subscribe, all that fun stuff. Patreon, all that. Certainly appreciate it. Uh thanks to these guys for doing this. Uh if you're in the Northeast, be careful. Hunker down this weekend.

Yeah.

Uh with the Nor Easter coming. Thanks everybody for the support. Thanks for watching. from patreon.com/hq. See you all next week. Go Ducks. I'm Edward,

John,

Trey, Ken.

Y'all have a good one. Take care y'all. Bye.

Progress saved