Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 25:33

this video is sponsored by skillshare hey all you cool cats and kittens today we'll be reviewing a board game about a zoo and as we know all zoos are great because nothing bad ever happens in them let's get the cat right out of the bag arc nova is just elephant time a huge box filled to the brim with bits boards rules and yes over 200 cards and if you're used to games that are shorter on the time and easier on the noggin then you might be going thanks but i'm gonna go watch paint dry instead which fair but the first thing i want you to know about arc nova is how straightforward and thoroughly enjoyable it is in spite of the stodgy genre it caters to which brings us straight to the rules explanation you're gonna teach all of this on camera why do you do this to yourself it's not as if we get any money for it yes we do people donate to us on patreon.com included

where are you going i just have to buy a lot of stuff here's the thing i don't need to teach you as elaine put it all of that because grasping what happens in arc nova is fairly intuitive just by understanding the general concert as we mentioned in arc nova you'll be building a zoo which naturally leads to the question the whole world's been asking how do you win at zoo the objective in arc nova like in many games is to have the most victory points but here there are two different types of victory points called appeal and conservation collected on two tracks wrapped around the board both of these start on opposite sides of the board and advance in opposite directions so for example if i got some conservation i'd advance this marker that way and if i got some appeal i would advance this marker that way all the way back around to this way you get it when one player reaches a point where both of the markers intersect that triggers the end of the game folks get an extra turn and then whoever has the biggest gap between their surpassing markers wins which then begs the question how do you get conservation points and appeal that's right just like in real life it's the animals that give you victory points and in return we give the animals treats

talking of treats what a delight this deck is positively rammed with every fauna conceivable and some that i'm pretty sure are fictional because there's no way that this thing exists in the real world from donkeys to monkeys from stoats to goats there's the nile crocodile there's the australian pelican and a kawaiti that's american that's a moose and that thing looks like a goose a pack of kangaroos and a lonely marabou of course there are lizards birds that have gizzards and full on animal wizards and i have run out of rhyme porcupine and each comes furnished with at least some appeal and some of the complex animals might even have conservation points right so all we need is animals then well not so fast if you get an ostrich you can't just put in a kiosk and tell it to sell bro shows you need enclosures and for that we turn to boardgamer's favorite russian invention tetris although in this case it's hexagonal tetris each player gets a zoo board upon which they'll place enclosures of varying sizes when they play an animal card to their tableau they'll need to make sure that they have an empty enclosure that at least meets or even exceeds the size requirement for it and in some cases is adjacent to nice scenic views like rocks or bodies of water or as we call them in england quarries or rubbish ponds and yet for some animals

that isn't enough which is where we entered the mode i like to call zoo tinder listed on the left are additional requirements you'll need to meet to ensure your desired critter swipes right for example if you wanted to woo this alpine ibex you wouldn't have to work very hard all it wants is an enclosure of size two adjacent to two lots of rocks and if we really torture this analogy dating can get expensive so you need to spend some money if you meet those requirements you get to put it into your zoo in return it will provide you with some appeal points a potential unique ability and some tags in this case herbivore and europe which you can then use to fulfill further requirements in the future whereas this king vulture has an additional requirement of you having at least three other different bird tanks in your zoo already present why does it need other birds honestly i don't think we'll ever know but this fella looks a bit theatrical so i like to imagine that it puts on plays and needs an audience you know like shakespeare but from stratford upon avian other animals want things like partnerships research tags and even upgraded cards which all sounds like a list of tangly nebulous things and they absolutely are but they all interconnect via this final big

mechanism what do we want more cards how many do we want exactly five more dug in the trenches at the bottom of your suit board are card slots numbered one through five and each one of them houses exactly one of these these action cards do just that let you perform actions whether it's building a new enclosure drawing more cards playing animals playing sponsors which is a card type we haven't yet mentioned or doing one or more hodgepodge ancillary things that have been arbitrarily grouped into a single card because they didn't have any other way to make them all seem cohesive these cards will let you do that each turn you will simply choose a card and execute the action or actions on it but the strength of that action depends entirely on which slot the card is in so let's say for example i want to do build well my build card isn't slot free which means it's strength free which means i can only build an enclosure of size free or fewer but after i have performed that action the build card will move into slot number one nudging all the other ones forward this was a clever mechanism in civilization a new dawn and is equally or perhaps even more clever here not least because it made every single board game review in the world go why aren't more games using this mechanism good question but we only answer questions after the rules

explanation is done which is now there's a few things i missed out like the break track income conservation projects strength tokens assistance kiosks pavilions petting zoos conservation bonuses snapping end-game scoring cards research reputation and the fact that art nova is obviously a pun on mark nova the romanian dj who is also the founder of the funky nation project which is something i found out when i googled the words mark nova but instead of teaching you the rules i'd rather teach you about life and the thing you need to know about it is that it's a continuous race for survival when you want in it is appeal so that people like you and conservation so that you pickle yourself better and when those two finally meet well that's the end naturally we all want to get there first arc nova is undeniably a race many games are but what makes it fun is that you get to dabble along the way it's full of wonderful little distractions and goals that you sort of fudge into existence you might start the game with a northern giraffe in your hand which itself is nice because it provides you with a lot of appeal but you also have a sponsorship which gives you money every time you play a herbivore card which is good because you

never have enough money anyway comically the sponsorship is for elephants but since all it checks is whether your animals have the herbivore tag you get a lovely mental image of painting your giraffe grey giving it some floppy ears and voila you're swimming in sponsor money that means we want more herbivores and look we drew the koala but to play the koala we first need a card with the australia tag thankfully we have the australian sea lion in her hand and we could play that but first we would need a partnership with an australian university now to get that we would need to bump our association card all the way to slot 3 which means we would have to spend two turns doing something else but then eventually we get there and we play the association card and then we realize that actually we don't need the australian sea lion because if we get the australian partnership with the zoo then we automatically have the australia tag and can just play the koala but we want to play the sea lion because it has the sunbathing ability which lets us sell cars that we have in our hand that we don't want but to play the sunbathing ability we need to have more cards in our hand that we do not want so we need to take the cards action and when we take the cards action we draw some cards and we could just sell those but then we realized that actually it has the common agama which you would like to play as well because on and on your brain drifts

on endless tangents and diversions which arc nova was designed specifically to evoke each action has clauses ifs and busts to pull in different directions and at all times you feel like you could be just a little bit more efficient and since this is a race towards the finish line just a little bit more efficient could be the difference between winning and losing which accommodates this card strength mechanism perfectly in an ideal world you would always take whichever action is in slot 5 because it's the strongest and be maximum efficient thankfully it's exactly those diversions that make you want to pivot and squeeze the right opportunity in between the cards and yet arc nova never runs away with itself everything feels interesting and tantalizing but there's never so much of it that it ever becomes too wonky or too loose for example each of the action cards can be upgraded making their effects even more powerful but unlike civilization a new dawn each card can only be upgraded once and you can never upgrade all of these cards so choosing what you want to empower becomes even more meaningful because certain animals or sponsors might have an upgraded action card as a prerequisite to be played you get this ah i want that but also that and uh and that and that and that feeling and you know you can't have everything but you want to which makes arc nova feel generous with

possibilities yet tight enough to contain it in a shell that feels logical and fair games that achieve that are a rare treat mostly i'm just glad because once every couple of years there's one of these games that everyone loses their mind about and i feel most of the time like they're fine but don't really have the design rigidity i'm looking for in games and then i make a review and then everyone starts saying that i hate board games so finally finally there's one of these games that really captured the zeitgeist that i can finally proclaim that

i is i'm sorry i really just can't listen i'm not gonna tell you that art nova isn't a great game because i think it's so plainly obvious why people like it and i also like it i think it's very good but there's just too many cards i'm sorry there's too many cards first of all no game needs this second i think the size of that deck actively hurts it in fact i'd argue that ank nova is great in spite of the size of this deck not because of it and kudos to first time designer i'm gonna go with matthias wiggy making something like this feel cohesive is an enormous achievement i hope i don't sound condescending here because i do sincerely think that most established designers would not have the chops to pull this off so in terms of the game outside of that deck i think it's lovely but within it things start to get weird and it isn't even the number that's the problem it's what's done with that number let me tell you an example so this was our first game of arc nova imagine you just thrust a bunch of cards and you want to make something coherent out of it well thankfully there's always these public conservation projects that ask you to collect a bunch of stuff like have an x number of herbivores or animals from the americas if you do

you'll get a lot of conservation points which is great it gives you goals and something to aim for so in that first game i had a bear card in my starting hand and one of the conservation projects was predators and that aligned perfectly with my goals because bears are also classed as predators problem is to play this bear i already had to have had another bear in play and i thought nay bother i'll probably find another bear and that will once again empower my predator collection guess if i found another bear card in that entire first game that we played trick question i did i found two bear cards one of them also having the requirement of having another bear in play and the other needing a partner zoo for a continent i could no longer get because by then it was too long in the game and i already filled my quota of four partner zoos and none of these were the ones that i needed that's not game design that's a hostage situation okay i'm obviously hyperbolizing and looking back on it now it does sound quite funny and also ludicrous here's a line of bears waiting diligently to get into my park and me like peter at the gates of heaven telling them you must gather your

party before venturing forth all right i get it it's not the game's fault it was just trying to teach me that bears are a strategy but one that i shouldn't focus on unless i find papa bear first it's a particularly excruciating two hour long lesson but whatever except all of my subsequent plays left an equally unpleasant impression it's just hard to find the cards you want in this game i do want to highlight that this dilution in no way inhibits your ability to play the game well if all you want to get out of arc nova is victory at the end just reframe how you play this game react to what you draw and find ways to make it work after all each animal card does provide you with more viewer points so all you have to do is just keep playing them i'd argue it makes the game less fun overall you're running a zoo for heaven's sake the whole point is having fun collecting animals it's like pokemon but for boomers if i'm gonna sit here for two hours wrangling the grooves in my brain i want to feel like i achieved something cohesive at the end rather than reacting to whatever was thrown at me consider finally the action selection mechanism the almost only way you get new cards is by choosing the current action yet if you want to be efficient about it you will want it in the number five slot so

turn after tan you will inch it forward and forward until finally and then you draw four cards and look at them and they're all bank that's miserable i don't particularly like the effects on these cards either i think they're very cleverly designed and they accommodate the game well but i found myself very rarely to be excited by them i mentioned sunbathing earlier and it's a really cool ability because it works within the constriction of the game see what i did that was i said constriction when talking about effects when constriction is also an effect which is only funny if you already played this game anywho so to utilize sunbathing as an ability you should already have cards in your hand and you'd rather they were cards you wouldn't mind getting rid of which on one hand seems neat the game knows you're going to draw a bunch of junk so it leverages itself to offer you a clever outlet of translating that junk into money which is hard to get so you can play cards you actually want but what ends up happening more often is you drawing a card with sunbathing when you have no cards in your hand well you could draw some more but uh oh your opponent is about to trigger a break and then all your cards are gonna get wiped

anyway because that's when hand size is checked or alternatively you might just never draw a card with sunbathing and then you're just stuck with all of that junk in your hand i like that all these abilities interact within the rigidity outside of the deck it's hard to do things so all these effects push levers and make the gears turn and on paper get it because it's cards that sounds good in play however they are too unpredictable to matter because once again the difficulty and concern of the game is outside of that deck so all this feels too circumstantial the whole thing reminds me of a feast for odin a game with over 60 action spaces yet it turned out you at most wanted to do 20 of them with the other 40 being predestined strategic mistakes yet when a few years later the norwegians expansion came out instead of just chucking more things that you you could do it changed what the 60 plus actions were and how they worked and the game was better for it you could play enjoy and be good at a feast for odin without that expansion but making all options strategic possibilities made that game so much more fun this isn't a perfect analogy but i hope you can see what i'm getting at it's not that some cards aren't as good or as bad it's just that they're

too diluted and whilst the game is functional the way it is and in many regards fun i just feel like it would be a lot more fun if you didn't have to spend half your time digging through a never-ending mountain of cards arc nova is already a very popular game and it's inevitable that it's going to end up with a bunch of expansions seeing how genre's obvious influence and predecessor terraforming mars has gone i'm a bit wary that those expansions are going to be more cards or more mechanisms so here's my challenge to the designer developers and publishers maybe adding more isn't what this game needs maybe retool this deck instead this by now is being played by tens of thousands of people across the world many of whom are very enthusiastic and i know i'm not the only person that feels this way and designing a deck with over 200 cards balanced to feel fun was always going to be impossible but with so much feedback i feel like this is one good expansion away from being a game we will remember for a very long time this video is sponsored by skillshare the best community on the web to go and learn something skillshare is your gateway to discovering something new in your life it's great for brushing up a particular skill like photography or cooking or interior design and it's also a great place to just browse and

maybe find something that inspires you here's a hypothetical situation let's say you're designing or maybe even publishing a board game with over 200 cards in it well that sort of thing would need a lot of artwork because otherwise you would have to use stock footage and that would look tacky and nobody would want that on skillshare i found a class called mastering illustration sketching inking and color essentials by josiah brooks that took me step by step from doodle to better doodle to colorful illustration it also explained what kind of tools i need and how i prepare myself and most importantly i found it approachable despite my previous artistic ability which can be summed up by this i think there's at least one person watching this video who would find that sort of class very useful if you'd like to try a skillshare i have some great news for you you can do it for free the first 1000 of you to click the link in the description will get a one month free trial of skillshare that's just a great deal because i think skillshare is great and you can find that out for yourself without any cost and that's it we don't really have a credit sequence this video i'm very sorry we had to cut the credit sequence because we had this whole sketch that we had to cut and i don't really want to get into it to explain it uh but because of that the

credit sequence didn't work so we also had to cut that so there's just no credits and i'm really sorry i don't know what to do about that basically i think to ensure that this never happens in the future i have to make some sort of solemn promise right now that we will always be diligent and if we have a sketch that involves a credit sequence we will never cut that sketch no matter how bad that sketch is let's say hypothetically that sketch was about me designing a board game that involved fingers and we bought props for it such as actual plastic fingers and there was this whole joke about me in the credit sequence where i sit down and like prototype a board and move those fingers about and then have various cards like for example the middle finger and then somewhere through the development process of the video i would realize that maybe this isn't the best thing to include in the video and it isn't actually as funny as i think it is that then at that point i i would not cut that joke because i made a promise to you right now that in fact it would stay in even though i think it would be a really really really really bad idea so in instead of that

this time maybe you could do us a favor by uh watching all our other videos that would be good if you don't want to do that you can just subscribe we really really really could do with you subscribing i know everyone says that but it just really helps we know our big channel we we could do some growth so by clicking a button you genuinely help us out so that would be really good and if you really like us you can always donate to us on patreon.com included your financial support is what keeps this channel going and also you would be in the credit sequence but not this time because we had to cut it and that's it that's the end of the video there are no more surprises or surprise animals

Progress saved