Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 30:25

hi I'm Adam in Wales and this is my board gaming vlog and today we're talking about monopoly which might be a little bit of a dirty word in communities which play these sort of games so the question really is does monopoly have any relevance in a world where you could be playing this or this or this or this or this or this instead and I'm gonna look a little bit at different variations of Monopoly how the game has evolved now back 10 years ago so ago when I started playing all these modern type of board games the big sort of catch phrase for Hobby gamers was no not like monopoly because that was commonly the answer we had to give when people were saying to us so what are you doing you know we did free time where you say you're playing this board games what you mean like monopoly no not like monopoly and actually I'm finding more recently over the last few years I'm much more likely to be saying no not like cards against humanity' and actually answering the question well that's sort of like monopoly you know when people say just like monopoly yeah I suppose so we're going around a board often we're making decisions exchanging money negotiating there's a lot in monopoly which is in these modern games now frequently over recent years I've seen people absolutely slamming monopoly it's it's it's the thing to do if you're a modern strategy board gamer there's videos about it on YouTube why is monopoly so bad and the things that people hate about monopoly seem to be player elimination the fact that you

can you've got a long game you know that's another another downside this game could go on for 3-4 hours plus if you ever get to the end and for a lot of that time some players are going to be sat out because they'll have been knocked out in the early stages of the game there's very few decisions in the game so people don't like that the fact that the whole game is determined by rolls of dice now there's certainly ask some decisions largely around trading and deciding when to spend your money and when to hold a little bit of money back to protect you but those are minimal really considering the time scale that's involved people don't like the graphic design the the paper money there's there's all sorts of stuff lino there's lots of stuff about people creating these huge arguments it's quite a mean-spirited game you know it's all about trying to bankrupt your opponents there's nothing very constructive about it that's all true if we're talking about classic Monopoly now when I say classic Monopoly there was a precursor to monopoly so monopoly was first a game called the landlord's game which was invented in 1903 patented in 1904 by a woman called Elizabeth McGee in the in America and later a guy called Charles Darrow took the idea apparently without permission and sold it to Parker Brothers Parker Brothers then to be fair to them went back to the original pattern and licensed it from Elizabeth McKee now this game the landlord's game was all about teaching the evils of monopolies essentially that

business practice of monopolizing a marketplace and so there were two different versions of the rules there was this super competitive game about bankrupting people and then there was a cooperative version where the aim of the game was but all players to double their money at which point all players won and this was the idea that you could play one version or the other or ideally play both and then make your own decisions about which was the most sort of admirable economic environment for the world of course when Parker Brothers bought the game they only ever pushed the Monopoly version not the other version which is called prosperity and then later in 1991 Hasbro bought Parker Brothers and then in 1994 this slew of licensed versions of monopolies with changing rules and certainly with a myriad of themes and settings came in to the marketplace now I think a lot of the criticisms that are aimed at monopoly are aimed at that older style version of Monopoly the the Parker Brothers version where all we had was standard monopoly and Deluxe monopoly and now we have all sorts of different types so let's have a look at how monopoly has evolved over the last 20 or so years I guess and we're going to start by looking at monopoly millionaire in monopoly millionaire each space is primed with a fortune card the first time this space is landed upon the player takes the card and follows its

instructions this might give you free money free houses or even allow you to steal properties from your opponents often it simply allows you to purchase two properties instead of one and this significantly speeds up the early stages of the game as players amass sets of properties quicker players pass go more frequently in this Monopoly variant due to the shortened board and when they do so they collect income as normal but they may also pay to upgrade their player token for example from a rowing boat to a speed boat to a yacht the upgraded tokens payout bigger rewards when you take chance cards the major change in this version of the game is that the winner is the first player to make a million not the last person standing after all other players have bankrupted as in the standard game this is a much quicker goal to reach and what other feature to note in this version is the money tiles which replace the paper money from the original game these are a very welcome addition in 2006 hasbro brought out a version of monopoly called mega monopoly which have a much bigger board more properties to buy more to do more of the same really and I can only imagine that that game went on an extraordinary amount of time because the board was enormous so monopoly millionaire is kind of the opposite end of that this came out in 2012 and it has a smaller board and and very quickly you get to the whole load of properties because as you go around the board you're picking up those fortune cards and they often reward you with being able to buy to monopolies on

your very first to tus properties on the very first sort of stages of the game so very quickly everyone is as glottis selection of properties in front of them this harks back to the original landlord's game where properties were actually dealt out before the game started so everybody started with a selection of properties in front of them before you even started going round the board in this game the is quite cleverly designed so that actually you tend to end up with sets so if I buy one property then often I'll advance to the next property and I can possibly buy that well that's likely to be part of the same set so very quickly people have two properties of the same color and now they're just hoping to to vie for that third one which is kind of about the point where the game of Monopoly actually gets a little bit exciting so the whole thing is kind of ramped up and then the money escalates rapidly because as we go past that go then we start to get bigger awards every time we pass go we get more because we've upgraded our vehicle every time we land on chance we get bigger rewards the game actually is cut quite short and about an hour an hour and 10 an hour of 15 something like that the games going to come to an end because one player will hit a million now the great thing about that is that no one is well you can go bankrupt in this game but it's less likely than in standard monopoly because the game's over so quickly so it's a bit more constructive it's not quite as a mean-spirited albeit there are lots of cards in here which allow you to steal properties from other players swap properties with other players all helping you to build sets and and speed the game along but perhaps making the

game feel a little bit more unfair a little bit more swingy that sort of thing the other thing with the game ending so quickly is that sometimes you know when the game ends you're not gonna have that many houses on the board you're not gonna have that many hotels you can end with a bit of an anti-climax where well I was just getting going really and now the things come to a halt I understand that's the standard for tournament play of Monopoly is to have a time limit set on it and I've certainly seen that as official variance in rule books of Monopoly that you end the game after an hour or an hour and a half and then see who's got the most money but you're really missing out on the most interesting part of the game which is the late game where things are escalating if you do that the great thing about Monopoly millionaire is that brilliant tile money now that is a huge improvement over the cash the paper money and actually you've seen in over many years monopoly trying to deal with this issue often by using electronic banking little devices electronic devices a nice little gimmicks which will help to sell the game but probably make the game even clunkier than using paper money because you've got to go through that whole thing of transactions using electrical devices and all this which is probably a bit more fiddly than the paper money was in the first place this tile money is a good feature in the mega edition of Monopoly Hasbro introduced this little dice here the the speed die with the intention of speeding up the gameplay and actually it adds a couple of little neat decisions into the game as well gets those properties running more quickly it's a bit like the fortune cards in monopoly millionaire this was later incorporated

into many editions of monopoly and actually I've got the die on its own but you can use it in in pretty much any game of Monopoly to speed the game along let's have a little look at how that works when you play with them an operative speed die you roll the extra red die along with your standard two dice the red die doesn't count towards rolling doubles which give you an extra turn but if you roll a treble ie the same number on all three dice then you can move to any space on the board if you roll a one two or three on the speed die you simply add that number to your normal move so you advance around the track more quickly if you rolled the bus icon then you get a really interesting decision because you can choose to move the number of spaces showing on one of the regular dice or the other regular dice or you can combine the two which gives you a choice of three spaces that you could possibly move to if you roll the mistermonopoli icon which is on two sides of the die then you take another go after your current one in which you instantly move to the next unpurchased property and you may buy it or auction it immediately so this increases players getting sets more quickly now as with the fortune cards in Monopoly millionaire this has a double effect you know is it's in one sense it gets you around the board quicker which means that you're picking up more money for passing go quicker on the other hand you're buying up more properties more quickly which means you're running out of money and you're landing on properties which are owned by other players more frequently and you don't have the money to pay the rent so people are more likely to go bankrupt

more quickly which will end the game quicker but it feels quite brutal in those early stages that bus when that comes up that's a brilliant decision and do I go to this space or this space or this space I've got a choice of three spaces that is a significant decision to incorporate into a game of Monopoly you know if people don't like roll roll and move mechanisms in games you know one neat doing that is saying when you roll the dice but then you've got to choose one of those results and actually again if we hark back to the original landlord's game that game four significant portions of their board you could choose whether you moved left or right so your dice rolling you automatically have pretty much double the decisions that you have in a standard game of Monopoly and so we're harking back to that version of the game again with the speed dice in monopoly gamer everyone is competing for points rather than money each time a player passes go they fight a boss by rolling dice and they score points of their victorious and throughout the game each player will frequently be forced to drop coins on the spaces that they're currently occupying other players then collect these coins when they pass over those spaces landing on a pipe allows you to move great distances around the board collecting all the coins in your path purchasing properties is really only a very small feature of the game and you can't improve them at all with houses or hotels or anything like that a completed set of two properties still charges double rent and that's that's the simplicity of this set collecting in this version on your turn you roll a

numbered die to move around the shortened track and also a powerup die which allows you to shoot shells at other players forcing them to drop coins or you might steal coins or collect coins from the supply depending on what you roll each player also has two special abilities dependent on their character these are really powerful donkey kong for example specializes and stealing coins from the other players peach specializes in collecting massive rents from our properties Yoshi sucks up all the coins from the board when the final boss is defeated which is after a set numbers of laps of the board then the game ends and the player with the most points from fighting bosses from buying properties and from collecting coins wins the game 2017 s monopoly gamer is a real step in the right direction for monopoly here we've gone some way away you know some we're no longer building houses we're not building hotels in fact we don't even care that much about buying up properties what we're doing is going around the board exchanging money making deals and and the great thing here is that when I'm targeting somebody so when I roll that that red shell I choose who that shell hits and who's going to drop the coins which allows much more for this sort of negotiation part of the game where you can sort of say well look I'll give it I'll give you this property for you know you can buy off me four four five but in order to buy it from me four five I want you to promise you won't hit me with the shell next time that you roll it and

those sort of decisions there's nothing in the rulebook which says whether those are binding or not so we open up this whole other realm of negotiation and promises that doesn't feature in in the earlier versions of Monopoly of course in monopoly there's always been that thing of you know what do you do if somebody just fails to notice that they've landed on your spot and actually it's some recent version of Monopoly including Monopoly game err it clearly says if you land on someone's space and they don't notice then you don't have to pay them rent which again I mean the game is chaotic as Monopoly gamer there are lots of really funny moments where people are kind of you know just sort of they know you've landed on their that they landed on your space but they're not gonna tell you are the other players going to notice and you get those moments of sort of sitting around waiting they've kind of urging the next player to take their go so that we can move on without the player realizing that they've just missed out on some income that I mean in this strategy game that wouldn't be acceptable in a game of Monopoly mario world sort of edition then that that feels utterly rich and enjoyable the dropping coins that picking up toys those mega turns where you've got those mega powers and jumping from one one pipe to the next and picking up tons of coins brilliant moments and actually the game is ultimately decided based on the final boss battle really realistically the person who beats Bowser at the end of the game is very very likely to win and that's entirely dependent on a dice roll

so you get you know the game only takes about an hour but you get to the end of the hour and you realize that most of what you've been doing is fairly pointless because it's ultimately currently going to come down to who beats that final boss that's not to say it's not fun it really really is it's colourful the pieces are lovely those playing pieces fact in this game you can collect lots of little extra pieces that you buy in different packs I don't know how easily available they are now I've certainly not seen them anywhere but just just with the the game as it comes in the box there's a rich enjoyable experience here it's not a strategy game but it is funny monopoly tropical tycoon uses a DVD to guide much of the action player has a character with a special ability for example the police chief can manipulate jail and the developer pays less for buildings the mayor gets more money for passing go etc and when you've completed a set of properties you may purchase houses or resorts which function like hotels or you could buy casinos or parks or piers or restaurants and these all give random payouts they might be higher or lower than standard rents according to the weather or depending on whether there's a cruise ship in the dock and all of these things are randomly determined by the DVD casinos might even end up paying out money to the players

who land on them instead of collecting rent for the player who owns them the game is won by the player with the most victory points at the end of the game not money and when one player goes bankrupt we count up those victory points and see who's won some buildings will pay low rent but they give you high numbers of victory points and vice versa and so this second economy is a major feature of this particular variant I feel like monopoly tropical tycoon was probably a really important step forward for monopoly through Hasbro this introduced victory points as the ultimate goal rather than bankrupting your opponents in fact money wasn't even the deciding factor and often you had that decision that that sort of do I go for the money which is going to help me to generate victory points throughout the game or do I go directly for the victory points by buying the buildings that generate me that that double economy is something that features in many modern strategy euro games and it features here in this weird little DVD game that said many of the decisions in the game and there are decisions are a bit odd like I can choose to buy a house or ultimately a hotel which is going to give me a set amount of income or I can buy a restaurant appear a park casino which is

going to give me a variable amount of income dependent on nothing dependent on chance really on what the DVD decides to give me now there's some decision to be made there about that you know some of them are going to give you more victory points some of them are going to give you more money some of them you might even lose money when people land on them but the rule book doesn't really explain you know what which one is going to give you more of what its kind of down to you to go I think I'll try out a casino and then you know your first game really it's gonna be a learning game where you find out really what the pieces do and then it's only in your second game your third game and so on that you're actually gonna start to make those decisions right I think what I want here is a restaurant or I think what I want here is a casino as it happens I never actually managed to play this game because all my DVD players don't work well they don't work with this disc the high tech of monopoly DVD game has outdone any DVD player in this household the laptops won't play it my portable DVD player you can see in the video that it'll it'll sort of go for a bit and then it stalls completely so you end up playing it on your living room floor with the main DVD player getting it up on your TV which results in scenes like this inevitably so I haven't actually got a game of Monopoly tropical tycoon in and I can't honestly say that I'm itching to play it but the main reason for that is because I know of a version of Monopoly that's even better in you build monopoly players construct

the board before starting the game using modular pieces which clip together you don't have to use all the pieces and the rulebook has suggested setups for a 30-minute game as 60 minute game and a 90 minute game or you can use a custom setup that you come up with yourself in this version of the game you can place buildings onto properties that you own even if you don't have a full set and you can choose to either place residential buildings or industrial buildings residential buildings are cheaper but their rent can be affected by placement of Hazard tiles by other players industrial buildings are protected against the hazards but they cost more - by owning complete sets is still desirable though because I play with the complete set can build a skyscraper which doubles all the rent in that group there are also buildings that you can construct and with all sorts of other different abilities for example the stadium gives you a bigger payout every time you pass go the wind farm the school and the park protect you against hazards placed by other players and then there's the super-powerful monopoly tower which gives you massive payouts the game ends when a single player goes bankrupt and the player with the most money wins so you build monopoly is the first version which I can genuinely say to you I think this is a really good game and that idea of being able to set how long I want the game to be to build the board before I start the decisions about placing hazards next to other

players or moving hazards or protecting yourself about hazards those are real decisions yes the game is hugely random and hugely swingy but it's also very very short and and those decisions are a genuine and meaningful and impact on the outcome of the game the pieces are tactile they're not hugely high quality but then it's not an expensive game certainly not now when you can buy on eBay or in a charity shop for you know pence really and I mean this you build series of games was made in response to Lego bringing out their own board games and we're certainly not talking about the same quality of construction here but the game does look good it's it's sort of fascinating laying this out and feeling like you're building a Monopoly board each time and you can make it as weird and there's mixed up as you like really I think you build monopoly is a real step forward and it's it's it's quite older when this hue bill I've got it written down here 2010 so this is some eight years ago I'd like to see house bro going more in this direction what we've actually got coming out from Hasbro next year is cheetahs edition of Monopoly how Pro clearly does little surveys and finds out what do people think of when they think of Monopoly and one other things obviously is people think oh yeah my friend used to cheat they still steal money from the bank so cheaters monopoly encourages that steal some money from the bank you win some extra points slip an extra house on to you on tour hotel onto your property you're going to get some extra points that I'd be interested to try it and but

that's the way monopoly is evolving rather than towards this this sort of euro gain crossover hybrid version of Monopoly that came out some eight years ago and you build monopoly I forgot to mention the best thing about you build monopoly is the fact that you don't have to have a set of properties in order to build houses or industrial buildings or these other sorts of buildings and actually when you sell those properties when you give them to other players as part of a deal the buildings the residential buildings the industrial buildings all of that go with it it takes a whole layer of complexity out of monopoly it takes at hours off the game I think it's a brilliant rule and you don't see that in many other versions of Monopoly but you really really should in the monopoly deal card game each player has a hand of cards and on your turn you draw two cards and then you play up to three cards money cards are played by placing them into your bank pile property cards are just placed simply in front of you to have to pay for them action cards have all manner of special effects usually nasty ones like stealing from other players you might even take their properties or take their money but often they simply collect rent on the properties that you have on the table in front of you the more properties you have in a matching set then the greater the rent you charge to the other players and if they can't afford to pay you from their bank they have to give you properties instead the first player to collect three full property sets wins the game

clearly this is not really monopoly in the form that we're talking about here a big board game type this is a card game that uses the same graphic design and the same sort of branding as monopoly but the gameplay is very very different that said it's got the spirit of Monopoly the exchanging of money the exchanging of properties and actually that sort of mean-spirited play of attacking each other all in a game that lasts about 15 to 20 minutes it's very easy to teach very fun to play it's I mean modern card games in this sort of genre you know your munchkin killer bunnies flocks this is better than those games this has more decisions just as much chaos just as many funny moments it's over quicker it doesn't outstay it's welcome I believe there are some nice prettier versions of Disney version at some point a Transformers version I think if I don't know how easy that is to get hold of and but actually monopoly deal is a neat little card game by any standards yeah it's unfair yeah its swingy yeah it's a bit tacky but so are many of those games and and and and in such a short game that can actually be really quite fun we had a good time with it monopoly free parking is a very simple dexterity game where players roll a die and it tells them where they must place a taxi token onto a rocking platform if all the taxis tumble off the platform then the player whose turn it is collects all the fill and tokens the

first player to place all their taxis wins the game when you combine this minigame with monopoly it functions there's a little minigame which you play when you land on the free parking space which normally does nothing in regular monopoly in this version the player must roll the dice five times and successfully place five taxis on to the rocking platform if they do that then they're allowed to move to any space on the playing board so now of course we're on to the real nonsense they're basically branded pieces of merchandise that have that Monopoly logo stuck on them so that people will buy it never play a game of Monopoly with free parking in court operated on the free parking space and you have to play that top aboard pointless okay adds length to the game is actually a really easy challenge anyway to put five of those on there there's a kind of fun sort of little dexterity game here you know this was a stocking filler or something that you just saw pulled out after a bit is a minute to play I don't know who would actually play it or I don't know I think it's sort of fun but there's so many good dexterity games are there you don't really need to be playing this and it has none of the spirit of monopoly in it it just has the similar sort of graphic design and similar sort of look but what it does do is remind us that monopoly really is a brand ok monopoly is is it has been around for so long it's kind of a tradition a part of our culture and and

it's not going anywhere okay so monopoly has to be hurt seen in in a different light to all these other sort of games you have to take it on its own merits now I know that people will often talk about monopoly you know on monopoly ruing board games for people or you know there are people who don't play board games now because they hate them because they play Monopoly as a kid and I just think if you hated monopoly as a kid you're probably not going to enjoy these games very much I either because I played Monopoly loads as a kid and I really enjoyed it and and it certainly that's the thing that carried through into my adulthood and and led to me enjoying all these other games for me it was a a sort of gateway to gaming it certainly wasn't a huge turnoff to gaming I seen many many people who are terrified of these sort of games I mentioned them to friends of mine who have never played anything like that they didn't want it they don't really want to get involved I see people struggle with the the simplest rules in the simplest little games but those people aren't intimidated by a game of Monopoly because they were taught to play it by their granddad their their mother their father and it was passed down to them probably with the rules all wrong but because I think scary about it even though the game is actually fairly complex so monopoly has a place it's a strange place it's if it was designed now I don't believe anybody ever publish it but it's it's here to stay and you know love it or hate it

it's part of our sort of ancestry as board gamers as board game designers and if you give it the chance with these modern sort of versions I think you'll find there's actually quite a lot to love about monopoly in 2018 anyway thank you very much for watching this video I hope this has done something to redress the balance with so much hatred towards monopoly I'm sure I'm gonna get a lot of people completely disagreeing with me and particularly what I've done previous videos talking about how awful roller move is as a mechanism and so on and so forth I still believe if you're a game designer designing games today monopoly is probably not your template for making a brilliant board game but if somebody wants you to have a game I'd say yeah get stuck in a Virgo if you want a gift for a kid somebody who likes to play board games hasn't played but you could do worse I think I wouldn't maybe wouldn't go for the for our versions go for something lighter monopoly gamer that's it that's a really good game you build monopoly brilliant if you can get a nice pristine copier like that's a brilliant gift for anybody anyway I'm having Wales this is my board gaming flog on board game geek I'm Adam 78 if you want to follow me on youtube please subscribe to my channel Adams board game Wales or follow me on Twitter act board game Wales and thank you very much for watching all the best

Progress saved