Skip to main content
Loading video...

Blackout: Hong Kong Review

Transcript 17:11

imagine loving eurogames very very dearly and imagine my excitement when I've learned that one of her favorite designers Alexander Pfister was paired with a great Chris Williams did the artwork for his big new game imagine my surprise when I've learned that the theme for this new game wasn't going to be trains of farming or exploitation imagine my delight when I've actually played blackout Hong Kong for the first time and I discovered that it is indeed very fairy

typical not the game the game is no typical the situation is typical you know what I mean roll the intro welcome to Hong Kong in 2020 a world suddenly plunged into darkness there is no power no smartphones no shops no banks no hope for survival thankfully you're not surviving you are here to re-establish order and whoever is best at re-establishing order wins which is very weird like most euro games the winner at the end of the game is the person with the most points and what ahh these points aside from prizes and more importantly why are we competing are we heartless corporations pursuing government contracts to set up ramshackle excuses for hospitals leeching on the power of free labor provided by brave volunteers who risk their lives because there are dear lists yes in this face of a whopping free hours you will send volunteers to gather resources rescue survivors and we establish amenities set up new outposts secure district Scout locations and what's your own face melt has your flashes consumed by the fires of the bureaucratic nightmare you have just created nonsense this game only sounds complicated whereas in reality

all you have to do is follow 8 simple phases each with their own individual unique rules that they interact with each other in very subtle ways and it will only take you about three or four games to begin to get a handle on fine hi other f Cohutta take a rest on account of his nervous breakdown which I don't get because as we mentioned black out Hong Kong it's just split into eight simple phases the first thing you do in black art Hong Kong is roll three dice these will determine the resources that your volunteers can collect then each player will play three cards one to each of your free card columns if evict a blue cube that means you get one resource that's depicted of the blue dye yellow for yellow and red for red simple each card is then revealed and activated in any order we already explained what the red blue and yellow cards do but we also have purple cards that sometimes use resources to perform special actions like this fun card that gets you a lot of resources as you get so many resources dug the resources you collected can be spent to complete objectives these even become new cards in your hand letting you gather more resources or special abilities that can be activated at the end of each round equally importantly each completed objective will let you put down an outpost letting you reach new scouting tiles and potentially scoring new points

the cards that you haven't played to one of the rows can then be sent to scout new tiles these will reward you with more resources but one of the cancers you send will get injured meaning that you can no longer use it until you get it back with the doctor and it won't score you any points at the end of the game each player will then spend money for new objectives that they can complete in future rounds some resources like food or water are perishable but thankfully they turn into money just before they do if every stage a Blair has surrounded a district with outposts they will score that in district removing the scouting tiles from it and deploying a base other players with outposts in their district will also potentially score points finally players can select the largest pile of cards they've played and returned it to the hands but only if they have four or fewer cards in their own hand if they do they will get to activate any checkmark abilities they've received from completing objectives that's it except it really isn't because drawing the line here would be like saying that black holes are just big space holes and that's astrophysics in a nutshell each volunteer you play is now effectively trapped and you will only maybe get to pick up one of these piles at the end of the round naturally you want your best volunteer in the largest pile because not only will they

bring you back three balls of rice but because they live in the largest pile you will get to return them and deploy them again next round to maybe bring you back some petrol jus to go with the rice but that's not where this puzzle ends after resources have been collected you'll move on to completing objectives like a set of awful interview candidates up to three counts we'll be waiting for you here to bring them stuff for example this objective actually wants your weird petrol / rice mashup and will come and work for you if you bring it to them now comes the kicker some objectives are a little bit more esoteric and require you to have a special set of certain color cards in one of your discount piles so yes you could send the rice man to do the rice job and then immediately bring them back for next round but then you'd be neglecting objectives that are easy to complete especially since every player has special objectives this one is asking you to have two purple cards and two yellow cards in one discard pile and spend 10 Hong Kong dollars which is a big dent in your Hong Kong wallet but then you'd be able to unlock a fourth card slot playing four cards every round so good and if you're watching this right now in your cozy pajamas and scratching your head and wondering okay bearded man on the computer who tells me about board games I get the getting

resources and spending them on objectives I get the hard to manage hand management but aside from this little rundell that you actually put the resources on why the map each objective you complete won't just join your repertoire but it will also extend your network of outposts now just to be clear here it's just me who calls them outposts the rulebook calls them cubes if you surround an entire area with outposts you'll score points and the larger the area the bigger the reward but as soon as you score it any opponent cubes will score points for them as well but unlike the strange man that sometimes comes around my house the game won't let you put wooden cubes just anywhere completing objectives means extending your network onto specific colored spots and you'll be racing against other players to get there first each new objective you acquire stops being oh I like this one I think I'll just get it and becomes oh I really want this thug but thud stoned extend support networks they mostly just break them or break arms or I could get myself a bank which never becomes a volunteer but will let you put an AAPIs any way you like and will score your additional points decisions decisions and that is just one part of the intertwining web of causality that will make you think and then rethink and then rethink your plan step one of roll three dice and play

free cards becomes step one of own oh I have just spent the last five minutes in silence and I am nowhere near playing one card much less free and it's become so quiet that I can literally hear the clock tick alright this turn should be pretty simple here with the two blue hoops goes then I still haven't got any purple so dye definitely got hardly forgot about the money I just if I had two more coin playing this two column two and checkmark just won't my Fred card no that won't work this is that exact feeling we are looking for in a good hero game like the answer is just on the tip of our tongue and we could just but reach out and grab it we would seize the day but there of course realized that we're holding on to a wet tongue and it slips away black out Hong Kong execute that card masterfully part of that is because of how this game handles uncertainty we've already learned that having just the right resources at just the right time is crucial but what if the dice don't

tumble onto the face that you need that's okay you can spend transportation tokens to effectively travel along this rondelle to get something else and of course they're a little orange truck so he can go beep beep beep as you go along having gone in transportation tokens that's not a problem you can get as many as you like at any point at a cost of one victory point per Transportation token beep beep indeed which means any plan you have you can make it work but what are the repercussions one of the key decisions comes in the very first round each player starts with two objectives and at a push if you wanted to you could complete both of them and it would make you feel very smart first because every single volunteer that you've sent away on the mission has brought you resources you are left without money and money is what you need to acquire new objectives leaving you a floundering mess four rounds two and three until you restart your economy second because you just had these objectives slash volunteers join your ranks the ones you send out don't actually want to come back and work for you restricting your choices making your piles harder to manage I just heard it one of the main criticisms that black out gets it's that it's the game that

just doesn't feel formatic which they totally get but I also disagree with what we have here is a game that leaves you to discover the theme for yourself the rule book that teaches you the game very well I might add never tells you that the reason you rescore a card when you bring it back with a medic from the hospital is because everyone's morale is boosted as they rejoice the turn of the brave volunteer you have to imagine that for yourself every little role in this game has a reason to exist not just because it makes the game systems work but because it makes sense to this world a world where batteries are a universal resource and serve as a substitute for food but the game does nothing to bring these elements to the surface and if I had to blame one thing here I would have to blame the artwork which doesn't feel great because if we compare it to most games produced in Germany it is still a stunner but if we compare it to other works of Chris Williams frankly it's a disappointment you can still recognize his style especially in the character artwork but one look at the card borders and you realize that publisher a gorilla had all this wonderful character artwork and had no idea what to do with it and at no point do we actually feel like we are in

Hong Kong check out this board yes it's a map of the city but would it have killed to at least name the districts would it have killed to fill these empty black spaces with illustrations of a population in distress of iconic locales my guess is that the artwork was rushed to meet the deadline of releasing an essence peel further evidenced by the surprise announcement of the game just two weeks before the massive Convention and the two-player version of the game closing up just before you feel like your engine stops going in fact after consulting with mr. Pfister we have added six cards to the objectives deck which works as an endgame timer and suddenly it started to feel much more like a four player game every time I teach this game to someone they have the exact same reaction that we did when we first play it about 30 minutes in they look up from the player board and with a glint of epiphany in their eyes they utter this game is a maze but if you were going to ask me well this is going to be your favorite Alexander Pfister game then I'd have to admit that the outlook isn't great let's set the record straight this game is pretty good but if we can criticize Chris Williams for artwork that is below his standard then mr. Pfister we accept nothing less than perfection with black out I am six games in and I still feel

like I'm learning how some of the strategies relate to each other I have no trouble with the rules but I am yet to crack the real subtle parts of the gameplay and that's very rewarding if you want to play the game over and over again but here's the funny thing with each game I felt like I've learned more understood more had to work harder and each game my scores have gotten worse which isn't the criticism but bear with me surely if I've played the game more and it felt like I understood it more my scores should get better right and I mean they weren't that terrible apart from that one time when I had an ear infection and Gwynn's beat me but that time totally doesn't count okay I started noticing two things it was really hard to string together a cohesive strategy and just because I understood those strategies more I started going for them more and realized that the more I went for them the wishy-washy my game became and the second thing no matter what strategy I went for it all felt a bit samey which is perfectly fine except that if you played the game four times the novelty starts to wear off and the things that you do start feeling wrote there aren't many new things to explore and the things that are left to explore feel a lot like the things you've already been exploring most folks tend

to compare black out to Aleksander fists this previous game Mombasa because they share a similar card playing mechanism but I think it's much more useful to compare it to Great Western trail arguably his most popular complex game and one that is immediately more accessible you can go either the train route or the qaol route or building route and even though they mix an overlap you have a direction and a purpose and most importantly you have a different experience the recommendation pretty much writes itself here if you are a die-hard Alexander Pfister fan sure there is enough game here to keep you dazzle but let's be honest you probably already own it but if you haven't played either of these then this is the one to buy especially now since there's an expansion to it adding even more replayability to this wonderful game if you enjoyed this video you should click some buttons that will let you to know that you like us and that way oh great I guess we'll just sit here in silence because of the blackout thing mmm Matic do we have a battery it could suck on

Progress saved