Skip to main content
Loading video...

SETI | Solo Board Game First Impressions

Transcript 10:31

Hello everybody. Welcome to Totally Tabled. My name is Shaggy and today I'm running down my initial first impressions of STI: Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence. I made a full solo playthrough of STI, so go check that out if you haven't already. In this video, I'm going to assume that you've either watched that video or you at least know how STI plays. I had pretty much stopped making these first impression videos, but a couple of people in the comments convinced me that I should start doing them again. But I want to make it clear, this is not a review, and I am not a board game reviewer. That's an entirely different discipline. All I'm doing is letting you know my random first impressions of a game that I've only played four times and only solo. These are just some casual thoughts. Please don't mistake this for a review.

Okay, with that out of the way, let's start talking about the the solo game of SETI. Right off the bat, I can say I love the game. It's a fantastic, you know, medium to mediumheavy weight Euro game. I actually think the theme really comes through and the thematic integration here is really good. There's a few main gimmicks and I think uh both of them work really well. We have a map of our solar system and everything is orbiting the sun. And the way you have those three rings and how they spin around just works really well. It's a cool simple simulation of the orbits. And I like the way you have to sort of time your your movement through space, moving your probe, possibly changing up your plans because, you know, an opportunity presented itself or the planet you wanted to go to is now suddenly completely out of the way. I'm glad that the movement is tied to the action of the players and so you can predict it a little bit, but you can't exactly be certain when it's going to move and that adds a lot of tension.

The other gimmick that I think really works is the discovery of the two different alien species. That's a really fun and satisfying reveal when it happens. It's such a cool idea that you don't see in a lot of other games and it's the perfect fulfillment of the theme. We're not just trying to find extraterrestrial intelligence. We will find it, but we don't exactly know what it's going to be from game to game. And that's fantastic. Now, there are five aliens that come in the base game. I have not played with all of them. I also don't want to ruin any of them because I think that first time surprise is actually kind of fun. So, I'll only talk about the two that were revealed in my playthrough. But basically, the aliens don't seem to change the game on any sort of fundamental level. They're more just adding new opportunities for scoring points and for taking actions.

there sort of new avenues, new kind of strategies that you can pursue, but they're not like taking the game and like turning it on its head or, you know, doing anything that extreme, which for me, I think is a little bit of a lost opportunity. We know there's an expansion coming and I don't think it's going to be the last. I think we're going to see many expansions for this. And what I'm hoping for in those expansions is a little bit more extreme alien activity and and powers. I'd like to see the aliens really dramatically change the game. And that goes against the sort of strategic you euroey aspect of the game, but I think having the choice at the beginning to be like, okay, do we want sort of more of a a calm game or do we want something that could go off the rails? And I would like to have that option because I think sometimes it would be fun to have maybe like an aggressive alien species that, you know, we need to do something about or everyone loses the game. Like like it changes the game dramatically. I think that'd be really fun. The design space for these aliens is so massive. They could do so many different things with it. And I find that to be a really exciting part of the game. Now, even just with the aliens that we have in the base box, it still opens up these opportunities for new actions, for new things you can pursue. If you watch the playthrough, I focused on one of the aliens like really hard and and got a lot of points for doing that. So, it's great the way it is, but I can just see

the possibilities of so much more. Now, in a similar vein, when you land on these different planets, the planets are different and you know, some of them have moons that you can go to if you get the right tech, which give you a bunch of points. The different planets will give you different special abilities, different rewards. Again, none of it is dramatically different, right? Feels like a little bit of a missed opportunity. It would have been cool to have each planet be a little bit different, like you could get something truly unique and interesting depending on which planet you landed on. Maybe like certain texts are are tied to different planets or, you know, certain cards you there's a different decks that you could draw from something something that felt a little bit more exciting because the difference between, you know, Venus and Mars, it's not that much of a difference. And if the planets were a little bit more distinct, you know, as that solar system moves around and now suddenly Venus is out of range and you have to go to Saturn instead, that would be a bigger deal. I don't know. I'd like to just see a little bit more there, but again, overall, everything works fantastic. I also have nothing but good things to say about the AI bot here.

It's extremely well done, easy to manage. It uses that same card system that, you know, we're so familiar with in so many games. It just works. It's really cool how once the aliens become revealed, the bot gets specialized cards, you know, just based on that alien, so they can exploit that alien specifically. That works really well. The way they get new cards into their system, so they get stronger and stronger as the game goes on, that works great. In general, their turns are super quick and easy to run. The only little a fiddly annoyance that I've had is that they do seem to, at least in my limited experience, do the scanning action a lot. Again, depends on how the cards come out. But that's the one that gets a little fiddly because you're constantly just putting out, you know, markers and they're taking the little data tokens and that can get a little a little much.

And just in general in, you know, this two-player game that we're simulating with the solo, the scanning action feels a little off to me. What's interesting to me is there's no changes to the scanning for lower player counts. So, you have just as much scanning out there for a fourplayer game as you do for a two. And I think that's a mistake. It feels like shortening those scanning tracks a little bit. So, you'd be completing them a little more often would do wonders to spice up that scanning action. There's a lot of scanning that takes place before any of these are are filled up and resolved. I might try a house rule where you just remove one of those data tokens from each of the different scanning locations. Not sure what that will do to the balance or how much more powerful that will make the AI since they're scanning so often. Not sure, but it's something I'd like to try. It's definitely a game I want to try with three. I'm not sure about four just because the game is so long. And that's maybe my other, you know, final criticism here. It's a long game even at two. Obviously, I don't mind long games.

Some of my favorite games are extremely long, but the game has to earn it. something like Civolution, which again I've done a full solo playthrough of that. Go watch that if you haven't. That's a game that earns it. SETI almost earns it. It comes very close, but towards the end, things do get a little bit repetitive. Don't get me wrong, the alien reveals do a lot to mitigate that, and if the aliens were more crazy, then it might earn its length completely. But as it is, I do think it's a little long for what it offers. Now, I want to end with two things that I think are extremely positive. First, it's the solo objectives. I love that they added something just for the solo game, and that's these objectives that you have to fulfill, or else you, you know, you're giving the solo opponent uh either points at the end of the game or movements on its progress track. That works great. I love having those extra objectives in the solo game as something that can, you know, direct your actions and give you just a little bit more to think about. The other thing I love, and it's probably my favorite thing in the whole game, and it's the multi-use cards. first. You know, you can spend them for the little resource that's on the top, either movement or publicity or a card or something, or you can tuck them for income each round. Or you can pay money in order to play it and do the special action that's on it. And what's really cool is some of these have special objectives on them. So after you

play it, you put it aside and now you have an another objective that you can complete for points or whatever. Some of them will give you points at the end of the game. Some of them are things that you can complete during the game. That's so much fun. And there's a huge stack of cards. I'm always a sucker for that in any game. And it works beautifully here. It's really the glue that's holding everything together, bringing out all of that theme. It really is just so well done. So, in the end, SETI for me at this point is definitely one of the best games to come out in 2024. I'd say it's a top 50 solo game of all time for me. Again, I need more plays. I need to see all those aliens. I'm really excited to see what expansions bring. A few of the problems that I mentioned keep it out of that sort of elite top 25 of all time. It's just one tier below that right now, but who knows what the future holds. And there you go. Those are my rambling thoughts on SETI, Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence. Thank you so much for watching and goodbye.

Progress saved