Art Society Board Game Review - Biggest Surprise of 2023?
Transcript
hi everyone I'm Luke heor and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top T and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solu head down to my new sponsor Kender Kender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over £30 further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5% of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy enjoy the rest of the video get on with it right today I'm taking a look at Art Society this game again I kind of glossed over mainly because art society as a title doesn't exactly win me over and I think I just missed it in the anticipated games but this one for Mighty boards was definitely one of the bigger hits of the show it sold out within a couple of days to the point where when I got my review copy of this thank you mighty boards I was almost having to do it as a kind of Black Market deal like yeah quick give me the game give me the game you know I to kind of keep it hidden because I was afraid I was going to get mugged for it you know it was a definitely a popular title people were definitely asking as I was chatting with Mighty boards you know have you still got a copy of it left there were a lot of demos going so this felt like it was a a Hidden Gem of the show for many people so I was definitely
interested to get my hands on it especially when I realized that the designer is Mitch Wallace and not Martin Wallace as I almost thought it was at first which normally would be an offut for me not to mention the cover with this indented thing where where you know you can feel inside with the paintings is very weird but also somewhat addictive it's quite a weird cover I thought you know what let's get stuck in a light game with some auction elements that is showcasing about building an art gallery which I quite like as a theme as well let's give it a shop and see if it's any good art Society is a light game about building your own little Art Gallery you have different square and rectangle tiles that you will auction for each round and you will place this on your board so that they're touching each other but you are concerned with what types of paintings you get and where they go and what they're next to each round there is essentially an auction held where the person whose turn it is will choose a certain number of tiles based on player account and they can pick any one of the any like mix of tiles from this box it's pretty cool how it's all laid in here and the idea is is that they'll all be laid out so let's say I mean let's just say for Giggles I take these four in this game so I got one two three four these are the ones being auctioned everybody has a set of paddle bid cards numbered from 1 to 20 that are one use only for the game and it's one of the free-end game triggers all 20 of these being used so there's only 20 rounds Max although the game will never end by this because frankly it should end by other means by then the idea is is that you will basically look
at what's out there and think hm how much do I want that do I really want that painting are they going to want it and you simultaneously secretly choose one of your Bard cards put it face down on a stack the stack basically acts as a breaker as you go down and so you flip them over whoever's got the highest gets first pickings and then it goes in order of that once you've got your tile you figure out how you're going to place it on your board touching something else but there's certain things that you have to be aware of firstly what frame does it have in the art World matching frames makes it look good so if I've got a wooden frame here I want to place it next to other wooden frame paintings by doing so you get to pick up these Decor tokens which are basically little one two or three size tiles that can plug up spaces on your board but they're also worth victory points but then you also have to think about the type because there are four different types of paintings you know mainly like scenery and portraits and stuff like that but the idea is is that in the art World they don't like these types of paintings to be all next to each other so if you get a yellow for example when you put another yellow next to it it creates what's called a faux par and so this will mean that they won't score any points on top of that you've also got an eye level line on your board which means that if they're really popular paintings they'll score extra points for being in the ey line of a particular person but how do these paintings score in general well that comes from the prestige Bard because whichever painting doesn't get picked in the round you always have one more than a number of players it will increase the prestige value of that painting by as much as the size of the tile so a big tile left over could jump
The Prestige rating up quite a bit whereas a small one will barely move it at the end of the game you'll rank them on first second third and fourth and they'll score more points if they're more prestigious and the ey line is concerned with the most prestigious paintings you essentially carry on until somebody's completed the whole gallery or if they've had to drop paintings or put them aside because they didn't have room for them not something that happens very often but it's another consideration then the game ends you look at your gallery you total up all the points and of course whoever's got the most of course so from a spatial awareness point of view if you've played a polyomino game you've played this kind of thing the idea of getting tiles and getting them on your board and trying to fit them in spots and obviously get them to go in the little gaps and stuff if you've played any polyomino game at all you know that kind of element although at least this one doesn't bother with Tetris pieces like something like a of cats wood or you know what other games would there be that are P Alice's garden and Baron Park and stuff you know it's not concerned with weird t-shapes and stuff it's all easy to follow shapes it's just a case of spacing and what goes next to where but one element that did stick out was the whole idea of choosing what's getting auctioned each round and then seeing what other people are going to do that's come from games like Suburbia and I think I think also uh castles are maing lwi from bezier games those ones had you picking City tiles and you were essentially trying to see right well which city tile do I really want castles were mad lugwig especially had you picking out the room tiles and so you had to basically pay
money based on which ones were brought out to get those particular rooms in your Castle well this is similar except you don't have money you have these bid cards but they're one use only so they are effectively your money for the game but it's that thing you're thinking right well what do I want on my board and what do other players not want on their board I need a few of these shapes so okay so I'm going to take three of these two of these pop them on the board and see what goes and then obviously you're thinking well now that they're all on show how badly do I want one of those so those similarities are there in other games I don't think there's one game that's exactly like this but this is definitely borrowing from a few other little games to create its unique h you can if you like per the rule book bring all the tiles out onto the board and have them in Stacks that just sounds like slavery with extra steps why would you bother you the ru book says you could just leave them in here and this is where you would this insert is great it holds all the tiles with the number showing for each level in a nice slanted fashion so that literally the setup for this game is so stupidly fast it's unreal give everybody their 20 little bid cards and a board Prestige board middle of the table put these little things out for you know putting the tiles next to when you do your auction bag of Decor tokens nearby and box done that is a pretty Speedy setup but during the game this is also really convenient because if if we're playing on a small table then people can just reach over and grab what they need for the auction
phases but then even when I've been on a large table all you got to do is just pass them the box and they can just choose what they need because you can see see what the shapes are you can't look at the tiles before you auctioned them but you can at least go oh yeah that's probably a big enough shape that's fine and it's just very easy to pass this round I mean you can I mean yes I can only jiggle this so much before stuff goes flying but if you're just reasonably careful with it things will not fall out especially as the infold is kind of like this uh I don't know what it's called it's the it's felt it's it's kind of the same fabric like a snooker table would have as its top and it means that there's a decent amount of friction which means that things aren't going to slide out by just moving it across the table it's a neat idea and they could have easily just said you know what bunch of tiles in here bag them up and set them up into little PS remember um uh rebuilding Seattle when I did that review that one wanted you to lay out all these tiles of different shapes and sizes and colors before the game was set up and that was such a chore stupid it's stupid the fact that this publisher was intelligent enough to think you know what that could get annoying especially for a light game why don't we just build an insert that that works and it will make life a lot easier 10 out of 10 for this insert idear I am so glad that finally a publisher is taking note of such things we just make boxes here the rules of this game pretty straightforward it didn't take me long to do that overview did I there's not a lot of rules in the game I mean this is a pretty thin rule book most of the stuff you need is written on about four pages really Final scorings on the back
setup is one page this is a very easy game to teach does not take long to get through the rules Gateway level no I think maybe there's a little bit too much here for a Gateway level person but this is definitely light and maybe a Gateway level gamer could get into this you know but I think it's maybe one step higher than that but yeah you can be set up and rules taught in a pretty quick time yet this gives you a lot of really good turn angsty choices I particularly love two aspects in particular the whole bidding thing the idea that when you see what's out there you've got these one use cards and you're thinking well hang on a minute I could be 12 12 13 11 how much are you going to bid you've got a lot of that particular frame you're going to really want that you haven't played that many high cards are you going to play a high card and how high you're going to play it you know you don't know exactly what people are going to play but you're thinking about it you're concerned you're thinking well do I play it safe or do I go stick out my really high card knowing it's gone for the whole game or am I like you know what I don't care what I get I'll just put my one out and there are times when you can flip over a card and realize that you're first pick with barely a seven played and that's really cool but then I've had times where I'm third out of four players and I played an 18 you it's great reveals but it is a cool turn angst and a cool way to do like a currency in this game without having you have actual money in complicating stuff but what I particularly love and this is brilliant design I feel normally when you have something to pick from like say I got a bunch of tiles here and I'm saying right I'm going to pick from
these tiles normally there's one maybe two things you're thinking of when you're picking a tile here you have four what four different things to consider firstly will it fit on my board is the shape good enough to fit where I want it to go okay that's one secondly what type is it I can only put certain types next to certain types because of the creasing the faux par and I'm also looking at how much they're worth points wise potentially at the end of the game okay so that is a second thing third the frame the frame if I put frames next to different like sorry the same matching frame paintings I can get these Decor tokens they're worth points they plug up space they're a great thing to have but the fourth thing is what painting is likely to be left at the end of the term because the prestige markers are going to be moving on this point track at different rates one might get a big head start some might be really close together and you're thinking well if I pick that blue that means there's only yellows left yellow's going to go up and probably by three or nine points I reckon you're going to take the small so The Nine's going to be left which means that's going to Skyrocket maybe overtake the blue and I'm already focusing a bit on Blue maybe I don't want it to go that high do I take the other painting Instead This is like it's so many choices that aren't brain burning I mean it shouldn't cause too much AP but the fact that all of these are considerations simple considerations but a wealth of them every time you pick a tile and that is done anywhere between somewhere like usually the game will end in about 15 rounds top so you're talking
about maybe 12 to 15 rounds you're doing it that many times during the game it just feels so satisfying nothing about this is autopilot nothing about this should be guess work apart from like choosing what card you're going to do in compare to other opponents but there's just a lot of little things that wave together nicely to create meaningful choices that make you think and that deserves credit the whole spatial awareness thing is good fun as well I mean I like polyomino games where you're trying to put pieces together but I like the fact that this isn't Tetris pieces but it's starts off being fairly easy as to where to put stuff but then eventually you get to a point where it's like uhoh space is a little bit limited got to watch out and suddenly that spatial awareness comes in with more pra you know in in Greater emphasis you can exchange paintings that have been given to the museum the last one not picked and around but you know you might not have something that you can exchange it with and you have one assistant to hold something on a on a temporary basis but if you can't fit it anywhere and you're totally stuffed you've got to drop bit next to your board a bit like the tiles in Mosaic and it counts as negative points but if somebody does that twice it ends the game prematurely now that being said I've never played a game where the game has ended in that fashion but the risk is always there and you're obviously trying to avoid it the game bug says two to four players 30 to 60 minutes that's maybe a little optimistic I think there more accurate to say about 45 to 75 this game shouldn't take you 90 minutes but occasionally a four-player
game has if if you do have those players who do AP a little bit but for the most part this game should Fe you know end pretty quick fre player is a good sweet spot with a decent amount of interaction and not too much time length two player is pretty lightning fast but I think 30 minutes is pushing it unless you really know what you're doing and you're picking stuff nice and quick but this is not a long game and it scales well at those player counts yes you know there's not like oh I do something directly to your thing but with multiple players in the game you have got to consider all their different boards what are they collecting what frames are they likely to take it's not just ignore the other players yes you don't care what they do on their own board except for the fact that when you look at their board you're like hm you can't fit a lot of big shapes anymore cuz you filled up your board quite early well you know what 989 you know you can do that and certainly it is impossible to play this game without people making countdown jokes you know every game I do I pretty much write down someone's going to make countdown references on a piece of paper I put it face down on aable table and as soon as someone does it I flip it over because it's so easy to predict the amount of times I've been called Carol when I've been like fishing stuff out of the box you know it's like you're not picking consonants and vowels but you might as well be it feels like that you know I'll have I'll have two eights and a five please Carol and it's like shut it you know the joke gets old quite quick but yeah you know it does a job does a good job at scaling well for players being pretty quick and even though it's not a ton of direct interaction there's still interaction
I'm still interested in what the other players are doing and that's hard for a lot of games to do these days you know I don't regret playing this with two I don't regret playing this with four I think it scales nice and evenly there's not a lot of bad stuff to say about this game honestly but there are two niggles I have discovered firstly there is a little bit of a luck element here because yes you can pick which tiles you want to go from a shape perspective but you have no idea what frames they'll be what types they'll be you could be in a situation where you need certain types certain frames and you pick five tiles in a four player game and none of them are what you want but then somebody else happens to get a bunch of them and it's like oh yeah perfect there's one that I desperately want no one else is going to pick it I can pick a low one and I get off Scot free some of that does come into play and it is a little bit noticeable and you're going to have to get comfortable with that and it it did take me a little bit to get comfortable with it you know luck is definitely going to favor some people now and again but it's a light game it's not long this isn't like a vast strategic epic length game it's a short you know bidding spatial awareness game but yeah if you're not comfortable with luck maybe favoring the fortunate at times then you may want to stay away or perhaps you won't like this one as much but you do at least get to pick what shapes you want so you are mitigating that to an extent and of course if you try and get yourself into a point where you are just searching for one color with one frame frame or something then well you kind of brought
it on yourself you do need to leave yourself a little bit flexible I like your plan except it sucks the other part that I have noticed is that the scoring I'm not saying this game is unbalanced but there certainly is a couple of aspects that the rules kind of emphasize a bit more than they should really the stuff that is getting you points is two things the decor tokens because they can add up to a lot if you've managed to match the frames which makes matching frames really important in this game but also the prestige value that's really what's getting you your points if you've got more paintings that are first and second level Prestige compared to somebody else who's mostly got third and fourth you will beat them you know they're not going to catch up but there's a couple of elements to scoring which feel kind of arbitrary or I feel needed to be emphasized a bit more you have got minus two points on four corners of your board okay covering all four of these by the end of the game is pretty straightforward it's not difficult at all at most somebody has lost minus two because they haven't done one of the corners by the end and that's that's because they probably forgotten it was a thing but it's there in the scoring it's only minus8 if you were to miss all of them you know scores can be anywhere between something like you know the the 50s to the 70s by the time you've ended the game so a minus two is not a big deal and you're never going to lose minus8 cuz I can't imagine how you would build your board in such a way that you would deliberately omit to cover those spaces but then the other factor is that the whole dropping of painting because you can't fit anything rely happens somebody might drop one
painting and get a minus two but that's it it's not that impactful and the game has never ended as a result of someone dropping two paintings never never have I seen that so really despite the fact that you have fre endgame conditions you really only have one which is somebody fills up their board that will happen every single time before one of the other two now maybe a group of experienced Gamers with this are somehow able to really cleverly use that dropping two paintings rule but it's going to be rare that that's the thing and then lastly on this fact you get five points for filling out your entire board what that's it five points that seems pretty minor compared to the fact that one decent High Prestige painting is Five Points it really doesn't amount to much and a lot of the times the person who fills out their board first loses because they focus so much on trying to cover their board that they haven't got the right paintings for the prestige markers or the Decor tokens to do it with art Society could be one of the biggest hidden gems that I found this convention I mean I've talked praise about sweet mess and sweet mess definitely was a Hidden Gem but man I would have looked at this game this the way it looked the cover you know the Fe the title of it and just maybe gloss it on B just thought yeah whatever this has really surprised me about how good this was I can see exactly why this sold out in 2 days now maybe they just just didn't bring enough copies to essent I don't know how much Mighty boards
managed to get off the freight ship or whatever but I can see why this was popular I can see why it sold out and I can see why people were Keen to get a copy of this when it had sold out I saw Q's trying to grab it so it's not like it was spur a moment no the demos were always filled people were always playing it and I see why this is a fantastic game I think it gives you a lot of cool meaningful choices particularly with the choosing of a tow four different things to think about that's amazing the storage insert makes set up an absolute Breeze the the game itself is simple to teach it's not a hard one to play the turns are simultaneous which means that the downtime is mitigated as well because other than somebody freezing up us to what tows they want to pick you should be involved for the whole game there just a lot of stuff that does well it scales well with two to four players it doesn't outstay its welcome you know the Aesthetics could be a bit more enticing for an art game you know know but you know it does what it needs to do those two problems I mentioned in the bad thing are mainly small things but they are a factor but I don't think they trans I don't think they ruin what is a really great game I think this is one of my favorite games I've played this year I think it's welld designed I can't think of that many bad things to say I'm giving it I'm giving it a 10 out of 10 I think this is really really good if you want to give this a try I will happily teach it to you I I just think for the Simplicity of the game and how much it
meaningful like thinking and choices it gives you for the light rules the short play time the decent player scaling I wish it looked a bit nicer on the table okay it's a negative I wish the spatial element was more of a thing yeah it's a negative but remember a 10 out of 10 is not a perfect game perfect games like my arc NOA Spirit island senal of the merse can have flaws and certainly there are many games I've given a 10 so where this ranks some all them remains to be seen but it just does so many things right and as this type of game you know a spatial awareness simultaneous bidding game this is going to be a benchmark that I use this whole Prestige thing is definitely the focus of the game and I think it's a good amount of fun yeah I'm giving it a 10 out of 10 you want a light game that's potentially Gateway level but just you know is a bit of a departure from the usual polyomino thing but gives you some meaningful choices with a quick setup and take down then look no further than art Society you know I've poo pooed not poo pooed but you know I've not been blown away by some of Mighty board stuff recently you know I didn't really go much for Hamlet didn't go much for the Vengeance roll and fight and stuff but this one is a hit this one is going to be the one that I say oh have you heard of Mighty boards you might want to check out art Society it really is that good I don't think any of us expected him to say that so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please Thum it up on YouTube and Thum it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the site check out all the other rest
reviews I've been doing there is a ton of them I mean I've just recorded this is the fourth one I've recorded tonight there's a lot of them and by all means let me know your thoughts in the comments do you agree with me that this is fantastic or have I have I maybe overhyped it a bit you know have I missed something is there do those niggles bother you more or is there something else about this game that bothers you you know what I'd be interested to know because I've not heard a lot of people talk about this game and I kind of I want to know your thoughts hopefully I'll be one of the first channels to talk about it to a great extent that isn't a preview channel so you know maybe I should get this review up pretty sharpish we'll see it's not like I've got a strict order to these things let me know your thoughts I'll be glad to read them so take care and remember regardless of how much you're willing to bid for this lovely painting of a trumpet it's still only a game bye for now everyone