Skip to main content
Loading video...

Misfit Heroes Review - Are You A Cult Leader Scientist? Or A Famous Jester?

Transcript 12:34

Hey, I'm Alex Mackle from Board Gameco and today I'm reviewing Misfit Heroes by Phil Walker. Misfit Heroes is a two to four player game of combotastic card combos and the card overlays and the way the cards combine and how you can take advantage of those combinations in order to score the most points possible. Before we dive into the game, this channel is sponsored by All Play. More of them at the end of the video. In Misfit Heroes, the core premise of the game is you're going to have these cards. These cards have these overlays that come together such what that such that we have mayor monk as one example. Over here we have the cosmic mermaid as another example. Basically every single card in the something like 140ish cards are a combination of an overlay and a background that's going to define first of all the name. We have the uh the scared alchemist. Is it scared? Yeah, the scared alchemist and the hermit kaiju. We have all these fun little combinations. But then it also defines the cost of the card. As you can see in the corner, we have a five and a one, making the cost six, as well as the way the uh trigger and the overlays combine to give you a unique activation for each card, as well as which faction it's part of. For example, this is red, this is blue, and then you're going to have cards that are going to be purple when those card colors combine. So, basically, the combination of cards defines everything that's happening in the game. But none of that happens during the game. You see, when you first get this game, you're going to go ahead and combine all those cards and their backgrounds to create a unique deck. A a deck that is almost certainly unique to you, that no other player that ever plays this game will ever have that exact combination of cards again. I haven't done the math, but I assume that's true. And then when you're done

playing the game, you're going to go ahead and I think that box recommends like four cards, like swapping out four cards and then messing around a little bit. Honestly, when I've done this, I've swapped out 10 to 20 cards per game, but also that's cuz I want to see greater variety game to game. You can do whatever adjustments you want, but basically every time you play, you're diving in with a new combination of what cards are actually in your deck of Misfit heroes, but all that's intriguing on its own. Why are you doing all this? Well, in the game, you're trying to get the most points possible. The main way you're going to get them is by going on these quests. You have these quest tokens over here, which are going to require various elements. So, for example, or influence or whatnot. You're going to require various in this case, if you have six of these green tokens over here, you can cash them in to get this quest. And then other players can do the same, but they will get a decreasing amount of points. That's true for mountains and water. And then this one, which is a combination of two of each element, but it's the same basic idea. The first person to get those elements and trade them in, gets the most points possible. You trade in six elements, you get a a token worth 12 points. That's amazing because these on their own at the end of the game are worth one point each. So if you can trade them in for a 12-pointer, that's a six point bump, which is very helpful.

On the other hand, when you get to the ends of the stack, you're only getting seven points for those six points of the tokens. It's still worth doing, but not nearly as impactful as the earlier you get these tokens are. Now, how do you do all that? Well, on your turn, you do one of four things. You're going to start with handle cards, and you're gonna start with a whole bunch of money. I forgot to take my 35 money over here. You're going to start with money, and then you can choose what to do first because you're usually going to do, not usually, you're always going to do one of four abilities. The main ability is going to be playing cards. You pick a card from your hand, you play the card, you do the effects. That's the main ability. There are a bunch of other abilities, but we'll come back to those for those later. Let's talk about what the main thing is. So, on your turn, let's say you go ahead and you take a card and you place it down into the bottom. Good over here. This over here is not a bad one. Uh, it's it's probably actually a good one. This is a good starting play because this card is the Scared Alchemist. It costs me zero, so it's going to cost me nothing to place out. And it has a trigger ability. There are four kinds of abilities in play.

We'll go through one one at a time. This one is if I have fewer cards in hand than your left opponent, then I can do the effect. A trigger ability is green. It has a if this, then do the effect. In this case, the if is if I have fewer cards in hand. Since I'm going first, inherently as soon as I play this card, I will have fewer cards in hand. It's not a bad first card to play. But then you do the effect. Gain an element of your choice and then discard zero to five elements and gain 15 for each element you discard this way. So on this hand, I should have read the whole card. It's not the best card to play because I can go ahead and take an element and then I can discard it to take 15 money. So it's good to get a little bit of money, but honestly, this is a great late game card which going to allow you to get as much as 75 money really restocking your reserves. Now, the first card you play has to go in the bottom left corner. You'll also notice there's a point value. Usually, that's one, unless it's a point scoring card, in which case it's going to be variable, but most of the time it's going to be one point per card you play into your 4x4 grid. I should also note, by the way, this is the deluxe extra edition, which kind of comes with nicer tokens, a playmat, a custom back sleeves, a larger box. There's a bunch of things you get in this larger version. The base retail version is going to have more cardboard tokens, less premium sleeves over here, still sleeves. Uh, so just note the difference when you're picking out which version you want for yourself. But over here, you play a card, you do the effect. That's the basic idea. There's other kinds of effects. I mentioned there's going to be scoring cards. For example, this one, the cosmic mermaid, is score two points for each heart card in this row and column. So when you play your secondary cards after that first card, you just have to connect them to your previous card. I could play this here. I could play this here. The next card I could play here. Next card I could play there. They just have to touch other cards in the grid. But this

card, I'm gonna play it down here. At the end of the game, it's gonna cost me 17. and it's a red card. It's then the game is going to get me two points for each heart card in this row and column over here. And then right away it's going to get me two of those water tokens, which again is going to be very helpful. Then let's go ahead and show you one of those heart cards because we have one of each card type in our hand. We have Mayor Monk. Mayor Monk, which will cost me seven to put into play. It has a trigger ability. Those are the heart cards are basically an ability on the top part and an ability on the bottom part. When this when I play this card, we're going to draw two cards, then discard two cards. So I can draw two cards. I can go ahead and discard two cards, then discard any number of cards and gain 15 for each card discarded this turn. Again, it could be a great way to go ahead and ramp up your money when you're running low. The last ability is going to be a paid ability. This ability is Hermit Kaiju Kaiju and this one has the cost of discard a card of the same faction as this and then do the thing, activate one of your purple cards. Those are the four card types.

You have cards that have a if this then that ability. Those are those greens ones over here. If you meet a requirement, you can do the thing. You have a scoring card which will give you the trigger ability, the activation box, but also gives you a way to score points in the game. You have these double abilities which are basically going to give you the heart ability as well as the box. And then you have these abilities which have a cost. You do the thing and then you get the other thing. Those are the four card types. All of these cards are going to be primarily doing one of a few things. They're going to be helping you draw more cards. They're going to be helping you get more money or they're going to be helping you get various elements so that you can cash them in for quests. Because that brings us to the other abilities you can take on your turn. the other actions you can take because I mentioned there are four actions. You can play a card doing all the things I just showed you. You can alternatively take 10 money adding it to your reserve. Very helpful if you're in a pinch. You can take one element. You can add that to your tokens which can be again very helpful if you're trying to get one of those twelves and you're one element short. Or you can discard any number of cards from your hand and draw that many plus two cards into your hand. Basically, you have a bunch of cards that are designed to create an engine, but whenever that engine fails you, you have get out of jail free cards. Whether that's getting elements, money, or more cards, you always have a way to take an action to get something. They are usually less efficient than building a good set of combinations of cards that will get you to that end goal with those abilities instead. At the end of your turn, you have the opportunity to trade in various elements in order to take one of these tokens over here, which again is ultimately going to be how you're going to get a large chunk of your points. So, you're going to get points from these, points for every $10 left over, points for every element left over, and then points for the cards themselves, as well as primarily those scoring cards, which

can be worth a lot of points if you really lean into those strategies. That's the core idea. You have a completely unique, completely unique set of cards, unique to you, unique to you every time you play the game, assuming you're mixing it up. And then you have a goal, which is basically how to get as many elements as possible, trade them in for quests, and get in get as many points as possible, which makes the entire review of what I like about this game, what I like, don't like, and see others not liking all of that. Starting off with what I like in general. The art and card combinations are fantastic. Uh it's just the whimsicalness. Not just the art which gives off a great vibe. We have a clawed ghost, an ancient jester, a kind bard, a teenage halfling, a tentacle scientist, armored cobalt, a scared alchemist. We have all these card combinations over here, a hoarding pixie. And these are all fun and they not just give you a degree of whimsicalness to the game, not just a degree of again, your deck is going to be unique. No other player playing this game. Someone can do the math up there.

I haven't done it exactly, but if you have 140, I think it's 140. If you have 140 cards and 140 ways you can combine, it's got to be a near infinite set of not actually infinite, but practically speaking, I assume most people are never going to see the same set of cards. But it's not just the whimsicalness, it's also the abilities. These will create unique different combinations of abilities. That means your game is going to be strategically different than someone else's game. A lot of this game is about card hunting. You go ahead and discard five cards from your hand, then draw back seven cards because you're hunting for the right combinations of cards that are going to complement the cards you have on the table and the strategies you're going for. And a lot of strategies will develop. You're going to have strategies that want high cost cards, things that will help you activate cards that you already play down. It's helpful to have high cost cards, take the most advantage of those. Alternatively, you might have a whole bunch of cards that trigger lowc cost cards you played or trigger cards you played in column A or get you a bunch of elements or give a token to somebody else giving you a bunch back. There's going to be all these different kinds of ways you can combine the abilities to try to figure out what's best going to pop off on your board. what's best going to get you those elements, that money, and manage your entire resource engine so you spend as few dead turns as possible on those less efficient actions that can be helpful to get you out of a pinch. It's all about the opportunity of finding the right cards that combo well with your engine. Not really building those cards cuz that's going to happen pregame, but knowing how to most take advantage of what you need to get your hands on in order to win the game. As far as what I don't like in the game, outside of the fun of finding new combinations of cards or even again rebuilding your deck, so you have these new broken card combos, I think that the game engine is a little lacking in the core variety. The basic ideas are all

there. You get elements, you get money, you get cards. But the problem is because everything combines in ways that are meant to work well with each other, there is a limit to how interesting the game can actually get because it has to be designed to be cross-co compatible with a 140 different top cards and bottom cards combining perfectly. I keep saying 140. I don't know if that's the actual number. In my head, that's the number, but I'd have to check the rule book and see what the actual number is. But either way, the point is because of how modular the game is, there's also a limit to how interesting the game engine can be, if that makes sense. If you build a game that is designed so that everything combines with everything else, there have to be much harder degree of uh guard rails on that engine in order to actually make that engine work, which makes it for a lot of whimsicalness, a lot of fun finding the combos, but also kind of lacking in how broad the actual experience can be. As far as I can see others not liking the game, the lack of balance could be a thing. Again, I don't I can't speak for balance. This game is all about finding crazy card combinations. I can't imagine that it's actually properly balanced that these all cards are all worked well together perfectly despite the guardrails that keep it kind of within a set lane and despite the costs that are variable. There has to be a degree of chaoticness and craziness to this and players may not appre appreciate that.

There's also the factor that changing cards between games can feel like a homework assignment when you're not doing it in the game. It means that in between games you're shifting up a bunch of cards which just adds that extra area of work. If you just kind of mentally categorize it as setup time, this game is actually so quick on setup time that I think it's still a minimal amount of setup time, but you know, it could be a kind of experience that feels a bit more like busy work as opposed to the actual setting up of the game. As far as final thoughts on Misfit Heroes, the game is fun. The game's charming. I I give it a 3.5 out of five. I've enjoyed playing through this one. I've enjoyed trying to combine in different ways and seeing where things different things combine together. Again, the card art is phenomenal. the whimsicalness. It's a game that you constantly are calling out, "Oh, look, I have these two things together that make no sense, but they're funny, and look, the abilities actually work really well together. Look at the card combinations are going to place down." I've enjoyed the game.

Ultimately, the main problem seems to be that as that that guardrail aspect, which is there's a limit to how interesting the game is going to get. Despite the near infinite card combinations, it's mostly about trying to find broken card combos to make the game feel more interesting than the last time you played it. Still a fun time, a 3.5 out of five, but with limitations. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Custom Heroes by John Declair, who's actually usually the card crafting person with AEG. Uh, Phil Walker Harding is getting in on his game. And then check out Dead Reckoning, another John Declar title if you're looking for something a little bit heavier that's going to give you that card crafting. And I mentioned that AllPlay is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games both from AllPlay as well as their partner publishers. And definitely check out Pop Art from R2I. Pop art is another game that has you kind of crafting card combinations as you play, but instead of building a 4x4 grid, you're instead building a 3x3 grid of different cards and the way they all combine together to give you as many points as possible. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radical from Board Game Co. I hope you found this video helpful and as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved