Skip to main content
Loading video...

Excalibur Review - Seek And You Shall Find!!

Transcript 11:15

Hey, I'm Alex from Board Game Co. And today, I'm reviewing Excalibur from Roxley. Excalibur is a two to eight player game in which you are trying to be the player left holding Excalibur when the game comes to a close. Before we dive into the game, this channel is sponsored by All Play. More about them at the end of the video. In Excalibur, you're basically going to start off with one player holding Excalibur. It's going to be one of these chips over here. I definitely put it over here. Excalibur. You have Excalibur over here. One player is going to be holding Excalibur and one player is going to be holding, if I can find it, the cursed blade. Every other player is going to have a hand of four chips. Now, to be clear, these players also have a hand of four chips. They just have Excalibur and the cursed blade in their starting hands. And the goal of the game is ideally to be the player left holding Excalibur at the end of the game. But if you have the cursed blade, then you lose. So, kind of the cursed blade is the ultimate loser. Excalibur is the ultimate winner. And if Excalibur has the cursed blade, everyone else wins and that player loses. That's the general arc of the game. In the game, what you're going to do is every single round, you're going to look at your hand of chips. You're going to select one chip. They all have abilities in them.

You're going to place it face down on the table in front of you. Then everyone is going to go ahead and reveal their chips simultaneously. That's the step. You take a chip, you place it down, you reveal simultaneously, and then starting with the player with the crown, which will be passing every single round, players will resolve their chips. Chips have a ton of effects. The most common ones are going to be things like drawing chips from the center, stealing chips from other players' hand, returning chips. Basically, a lot of chip shuffling in the game. If a player has Excalibur, it's only interesting if other players can get a hold of Excalibur one way or another. Hence, a whole lot of stealing, trading, putting chips back in the middle, and a lot of fun abilities. The fun abilities are going to be a big part of it because the special more powerful chips, of which there are often only one of, often have a wide variety of incredibly powerful abilities. Players who are holding swords stick out their hands. You can go ahead and steal one. People players going to go ahead and discard their swords. Protect the chips. Discard the chips drawn and place them again.

They're going to have a ton of effects that are going to be stronger, powerful effects that make you feel super cool when you play them. And so, the question you have is do you play that chip right away because it's super cool and powerful, or do you save it for late game where it's going to have more of an impact, but along the way it may well be stolen from you? The general arc of the game is players are playing a chip, resolving the chip, then at the end of the beginning of the next round they're going to draw back up to four chips if they have less than few chips. You might have more than that, in which case great, but if you have fewer than four chips, draw back up to four. And then when any one of these sectors of Avalon over here is emptied, if a single sector is emptied, that's going to trigger the end of the game, at which point players are going to finish the round, and whoever is left holding Excalibur wins the game. See all the previous notes and asterisks around how they can possibly lose the game as well. That's the game. That's all you're doing in here.

Everything comes down to the abilities. The rule set over here is this. These are the rules, this little double-sided pamphlet. The player aids are these. These give you a little bit more information about what the chips do. They do say on each chip what that chip does. Well, that's Excalibur, that's not interesting. They do have over here Uther. All swords are passed in one direction. If you're a little lacking clarity on exactly what that means, this will give you a bigger breakdown of exactly how that works. Point left or right, anyone with swords must pass the pass in that direction. Pretty intuitive, but in case you needed that extra clarity, that's what the player aid is for. Do that until the game is over and see who wins, loses, or wins, really loses, everyone in the middle, or however it all plays out. With that, let's go ahead and dive into my review of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking about Excalibur. And this is a weird one for me. This is a This is This entire game could be a conversation as to what makes a good game. And I'll get into all of that. But let's start off with the things I like about the game. The production is great.

And I'll note, this is the retail version of the game. This isn't even the super deluxe version with either the wooden swords or the metal swords or the plastic bits. These are just chunky chunky cardboard tokens over here. I will note, the game does include extra copies of Excalibur and the cursed blade in case these find too much wear and tear over time. They don't replace every token, but at least those two that are super important to be distinct, there are extra copies in case they are standing out as they will be the ones handed the most in the game. So, that's a nice little quality of life bonus over there if you're playing this that much or just that heavy on your game. But again, general production, the artwork is fantastic, which I expect from my Roxy at this point. The production of these are very, very thick tokens. The swords are nice. Again, these are This is the basic version of the game. There are various versions. I think there's three different versions, if I'm not mistaken, of this. The others are even more over the top, but this the basic version is already a very solid production. The theme is great. It works well with the game is doing. And the biggest thing I can say in the game's favor is it's just fun. It is one of those games where you go ahead and do things. I will have a bunch of critiques shortly, but the experience I have is fun. The experience I have is a lot of playing chips, activating their abilities, passing the sword around. You have those moments of I just stole the sword from you. Someone just stole the sword from me. Look at this really cool ability that I just played. Look at this cool ability I was holding on to. Or sometimes there's those clever moments of those mind games. I remember one of my favorite games of Excalibur I've played, had me had the Excalibur in my hand, and it had me return a chip to the center, and so I buried Excalibur in the center, simply keeping my eye on it, because players are so involved of having the swords in their hand, then no one thought that happened. And so the entire game, players were hunting for the swords before finally, right close

to the end of the game, I managed to snatch it back up from the center, which was amazing. Then someone stole it from me, which was a little less amazing. But story-wise, it was great. I just hoped no one would take that exact chip, and I kept an eye on it in case someone did. You can do fun things like that as you play, but ultimately, every single time I have played this game, I have been surprised by how much I enjoyed it given the game play mechanics. Which is where I get into the things I don't like about the game, which is aside from the fun of playing, which ultimately is what makes a good game, I think. But aside from the experience I'm having, I don't think this is mechanically speaking a good game. Which is why I mentioned this could be an entire conversation as to what makes a good game or not a good game. I think objectively speaking, this is not a great game. It's a game which you basically do a bunch of abilities with minimal control over those abilities. If you play an ability too early because it's a great ability and it's really powerful, it has no impact because swords are changing hands throughout the entire game. If you hold onto that ability, you might lose the ability anyway, so what was the point of holding onto it? But only the last few turns of the game really matter, and arguably only the very last turn of the game matters. As much as I have had fun every single time I play this game, it's also a game where even as I had fun, very often the last turn is kind of the thing that decided everything as someone made everyone discard their swords to the middle, as someone stole a chip that someone else had. It very rarely feels like the first 75% of the game matters.

It's the last 25% if that. And again, the last turn of the game has frequently changed who the winner is through sheer luck of the draw of who stole the sword or tracked the sword as you play through the game. And so mechanically speaking, I object to Objectively is the wrong terminology. I subjectively objectively think that this is a bad game as far as the mechanics go, which is a weird element to be in because again, I have fun playing this every single time. We'll come more into it in final thoughts, but I want to I want to do both things. We'll talk about the experience I'm having as a player, but also I I don't I I want you to know that when I look at this objectively subjectively objectively, I don't think it's very good. I just think it's very fun. Also, I'll say as a more other note, too many of the chips are not meaningfully different enough to justify having so many different chips. Meaning this game kind of has two tiers of chips. There are the basic chips of which there are multiple copies of each, and there are things that are fairly repetitive, you know, steal one from multiple players, steal two from one player, steal one draw from the center. A lot of these chips aren't meaningfully different enough to justify having so many iterations of them. Just condense the amount of chips you have and don't have little small tweaks in each ability. I don't think it matters a ton. I think they wanted to have the sense of variety. The problem with variety is variety is has you more likely to be checking the player A to constantly see what's going on, and I think they could have condensed down at least three or four rows if not more without meaningfully changing the experience players are having. The cool chips are super cool. The one offs, those are super cool. And And I guess the problem is you're mostly going to be looking at those anyway, so it doesn't super change how many there are. But again, I think

that there were extra levels of nitpickiness on differences that didn't mean anything to matter. As far as I can see others not liking, first of all, I'll say this game really does need a higher player count in my opinion. It's rated as a two to eight player game. I haven't played two, so I don't know about that one, but I played it at three, four, five. I played it at I I don't know if I I think I've done a full eight player game. I'm not sure. I played this both during the prototype phase as well as the final production. But I played I've definitely I've definitely played at the higher player counts and lower player counts. I'll say that. And I can tell you that at least in my experience, it works much better at higher player counts. I think that four is arguably the lowest player count I would suggest as that. And realistically, I think five plus is really where I would suggest it. I think it's a better experience when the game has more players in it, more elements of what's going on at the table as far as the swords go, as well as the game just moves faster. Because you don't really adjust the number of chips around the number of players, I think the game just moves faster when you have multiple people playing chips and cycling them out of the game as you go, as opposed to a three player game can really drag when you're going through that experience.

And for a game where only the final turns matter, I I I just think higher player counts are better all around. Don't get me wrong, you could probably house rule just getting rid of a chunk of chips if you are playing at lower player counts. I probably do suggest that. I still think higher player counts are better. Also, I'll say these swords over here, cool as they are, don't really do much. They divide up Avalon into three regions. If you've got those fancy metal swords, if you've got those fancy wooden swords, they're just sitting on the table as as little set pieces, which is I guess if you I mean if you knew that, then great. Honestly, I still want them despite me saying that. But in case you were hoping for a super cool meaningful components to your game, they're just cool metal swords, which are I mean these aren't these are the wooden swords, but whatever swords you got, they're just uh glorified set pieces. As far as final thoughts on Excalibur, this is a weird one for me. I'm going to be giving it a 3.5 out of five. Ultimately, I do enjoy this game and every single time I play. Like Like for context, I have this retail version.

So I have I'm debating picking up a copy of the deluxe version. I'm not going to right now because it's $300 on eBay when I checked, but I I honestly want the deluxe version of the game, which feels weird because mechanically I just don't think it's a very good game, but it is a game that multiple people have continuously asked to play and I'm always fine playing. My kids have asked to play it. A lot of gateway gamers or people in my kind of circle aren't heavy gamers have asked to play it. And it's one of those ones where every single time someone does, I'm like, "Yeah, sure. Let's play Excalibur." It's fun to watch it all play out. I have more fun than I should. Should is a relative terminology. I don't know how you express that, but I have more fun than I should when I think about what this game is actually doing versus the experience I'm having. Because again, I cannot separate the fact that I'm enjoying myself when I play the game, but also when I look at it from the mechanics, I think only the last turn or two really matters. So that's a weird abstract position to be in. Just know that I am both critical of it and also want a deluxe copy of the game. So uh take that for whatever you will. It's 3.5 out of 5. As far as other game recommendations, definitely check out Coup if you're looking for a game that gives you a similar experience with I think more player agency and control.

And check out The Resistance: Avalon if you're looking for something with this exact theme, but a hidden role game again with much more player agency and control. And if you I mentioned at the beginning that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games both from All Play themselves as well as their partner publishers. And you can get anything for $4 flat rate shipping if you're in the US. And check out Alibis if you're looking for a different kind of hidden game, a cooperative experience in which you're kind of trying to figure out who the odd man standing is, but through the nature of connecting words. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. I hope you enjoyed this video. And as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved