Skip to main content
Loading video...

Mansions of Madness 2nd Ed. Review - I'm Not Mad, I'm Just Disappointed

Transcript 6:31

Mansions of Madness second edition is a Cooperative horror game your investigators sent to creepy places to explore find Clues uncover Mysteries and fight Monsters the game revolves around a mobile app which reflects the board you have in front of you and takes care of all the admin usually involved in a Cooperative game it's a joy to use and makes what would normally be quite a complicated game incredibly easy to learn it enhances the exploratory nature of the game on your turn you can just move your character and click an icon on the screen which will reveal a new new room or encounter the app brings with it some creepy music and we've had a great time casting the visuals to our TV helping us get fully immersed and this is where Mansions of Madness really shines it does a brilliant job of providing atmosphere the artwork in the game is stunning The Room tiles bring to life the feeling of this creepy Mansion you start the game with only one TI on the table and as you explore you reveal more rooms and it's fun to see what's around the corner and mimics the feel of what it would be like to investigate a place like this Plus it means you can set up and get into the game instantly just pick some characters a scenario and you've started it makes me dream of more games coming with apps to avoid the usual head in a rulebook problem after I played the first scenario for this game I was in love it felt like a transformative experience a sign of the future of board games it felt so immersive such a pure sense of exploration we were cracking the case and saving the world unfortunately that feeling hasn't lasted after playing more

scenarios I've come to realize how lazy and formulaic this game is one of its biggest appeals was the idea of solving Mysteries I love games like Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective or time stories where you're given pieces of a puzzle and it's up to you to put it together to win the game there some of the most rewarding game experiences I've had Mansions of Madness gives the impression that this is something you'll be doing it opens each scenario with a well-written introduction the opening of a mystery story and the reason your characters are in these places is to uncover secrets you encounter some papers you have to roll an observation check to search for something useful you succeed and what does the game give you a card called circumstantial evidence are you kidding me I can't believe that the designers think this is a satisfactory way to tell a story you don't uncover Clues you just collect meaningless evidence points there is no mystery to be solved by the players you just have to roll the right number of symbols on the dice the game is scenario based with four coming with the game and with more being released as paid for DLC I quite like this system to pay £4 for a new story driven experience that takes you on a new adventure that's okay by me except it doesn't every scenario in this game follows the exact same formula you explore some locations meet some characters and find loads of items spells and weapons then some monsters turn up and you have to kill them before escaping the story is just set dressing at first when you interact with characters it's exciting because you

have to pick what you're going to say to them the decision feels so important you don't want to say the wrong thing the more you play this game the more you realize those conversations have no bearing on anything sometimes you might get a clue token a soulless resource for changing dice results the scenarios are supposed to be replayable if you lose you're supposed to want to try again but it plays out the same there's no way I'm spending 3 hours to read the same flavor text find the same locations just in the hope that this time my dice rolling goes better and I defeat the monsters at the end we played the longest scenario expecting it to deliver a proper mystery instead it's just 5 hours of exploring locations having uneventful conversations hoarding items with a paper thin storyline only to fight some monsters at the end let me make this 100% clear it is 5 hours of buildup within that 5 hours there are no meaningful decisions the biggest Jeopardy is whether get an item from somewhere or not every action we took we became increasingly more desperate for the game to advance the story to keep us immersed and every time the outcome was an item or a clue token when we got to the final section when we had to kill the monsters my girlfriend walked out the room she was done this 6-hour slug was the most unsatisfying experience I've ever had with board games it's tantric gaming I could have forgiven the lack of story if the challenge of the game was interesting and I could have forgiven the lack of challenge if the story was engaging manchest a Madness

second edition has neither this game feels rushed one of the game's selling points is that it has puzzles to solve to unlock doors or find Clues the puzzles are literally the most basic puzzle a mobile app could provide and they're the same format in every game that would be forgivable in cardboard form it would cost to much to give Alternatives this is digital they have Limitless scope to create unique Innovative puzzles and they've simply chosen not to they've settled for the most basic unimaginative option available to them for such an expensive game the Miniatures are disappointing you have to fix them into these stupidly large bases they fall out constantly it's such a weird production choice and as ever there's no way to store them in the box you'll be refix in them every time you play the difference here compared to co Min or not standard is night and day Fantasy Flight need to up their game this game is one of my big disappointments it has so much promise it gets so many things right that it's all the more frustrating for the things it gets wrong but this doesn't have to be the end of the story the framework is solid the designers could completely turn this game around by using the app to deliver a game that offers a real mystery to solve or a proper story I so desperately want to hold on to this game to wait for that day but the game is selling well people are enticed by the glossiness the atmosphere it delivers why would fantasy flight bother improving a hit game there are some clever ideas in the game when a character goes insane their wing

condition can change that may pit them against the other players I like the switch of dynamic but it's not enough to save this game for me I would recommend playing this game once for the brilliant app I only wish they hadn't used it to distract us from the less than brilliant game if you like this video please check out the rest of my channel for more videos like this I'm actual all on Facebook and Twitter I'm John perkus thanks for watching

Progress saved