Is this a better Trajan? - Ostia Board Game Review
Transcript
Hello everyone, this is Johannes.
is Sierra.
And you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings.
And today we are taking a look at Ostia.
We are. This is a board game and you might say this is not even a new board game and we usually review newer board games but sometimes there is a game that we play and we feel like we want to review this. So spoiler alert at least me, I like this game quite a lot. So we want to tell you No, that's true. We're going to tell you why. Uh just to be clear, this is a a review of the base game with the pirates expansion. I'm going to say already that I feel like the game needs that. So just like you know, this is that. The setup I'm going to show you things from both the base game and the expansion. We're going to try to make clear what is what when we speak about it. There are also a couple of smaller expansions. We will probably talk about them but there's no components. There might be some of the setup things that are from those with like variability but just so you know, that is what we're taking a look at today.
I'm going to do a brief overview.
Yes. Because that's what I do. Yes, please. In this game you are doing things. I don't know what the theme is. You're traveling from Ostia out in the world to see the world and trade things and get resources and trade them for better things like victory points because that's what you want to do. This is a Mancala game. So what I'm going to do on my turn is that I'm going to choose a spot and I'm going to move my pieces one at a time from that spot and where I land I'm going to do the action. But before I move anything where I choose to start I'm going to produce the resources of that spot. So resources are cubes. I'm going to put them there and then I'm going to place and then I'll do that action. So you're basically both choosing what resources you want to produce and also then what action you want to do. And the resources you produce in this location is then usually the resource you use in that location. So you want to produce the resources there before you land there to do the action. And there is different things you can do. You can build new boats. When you build the small boats, they go out here and you have a new more boats basically to move around. When you big build the big boats, you will have to gotten your movement out across this line. Then you will get this one and you will move a new ship out there which can then move on the map. And this is going to count as two when you get your resources. You can buy cards. There's going to be some cards you can buy for the grain. They will give you resources.
They will give you these vases that will be worth points and also some symbols that will also possibly be worth points. There's a lot of points in this game. You can build buildings and then you will see how far your ships have gotten. You can then build buildings out in where your ship has gotten past. You will take the building and you can place it in the base game. You can place it here on your player board. In the Pirates expansion, you can also place it here on the Ostia city board which will give you a bonus, either an instant bonus or a victory point bonus at the end of the game plus like some resources. Then you can trade. You will be trading depending on the different trading places you have built. You can also buy weapons which you then will need to fight the pirates in the Pirates expansion. You have the administration action where you can do like a little bit of everything. You'll be able to do like two actions in that spot. And I'm not going to explain exactly how because it can be a mystery. And over here you'll be able to move your ship. Then you have to pay resources to move. You will then get resources if you land on resources. If you move past one of these, you will take the token and get some stuff from that. What you're trying to do is to choose like the path you want to go because at the end of the path there is a final scoring. And then of course there are different buildings that you can build to try to get better at different scorings throughout the game. You're going to continue doing that and it's kind of like a game. It's not kind of like a game. It is a game where it has like a lot of different ways that it can end. It will end if somebody has built all of their buildings. It will end if somebody has
built all of their ships. It will end if somebody is at the top here. I don't know how that will happen. Uh it will also end if you remove all of the treasures from the treasure map. And there's one more way I we have but somebody has like two or three three ships I think on the end here. So, the pirates is basically super quickly. When you enter in a space with a pirate you have to be able to fight it and depending on where you are in the game and also if it's a small or a big pirate ship you need more weapons. Or you can also have legionnaires which makes the treasure chest that you get worth more points and also makes you lose useless weapons. You will gain treasure chests and you will get some bonuses whenever a empty a area of treasure chests there's an event that's going on that's going to score and you have some like negative cubes that's going to be worth negative seven points. Negative cubes. Uh in if the end of the game and all the special powers and stuff like that. But we're not going to go into detail in everything. That is not a very brief but it is a overview of the game. Well, let's start talking about the Mancala mechanism.
Yes.
Because that is heavily influenced by Trajan.
Yes. If you haven't played Trajan that also has a Mancala mechanism but I like the changes they've done to this Mancala yeah. Because here it matters more where you take stuff from. In Trajan it was just like where pieces landed.
Yeah. But here you also want to see where you can actually produce and I like that if you have like a lot of ships collected in one space Mhm. you will produce that many resources.
Yeah. That also give you an incentive to like gather a lot of pieces in one space and then do like a big movement action. And it really wants you to have a plan of what you're doing because as you said, kind of want to do everything before you do the others thing and it kind of doesn't add up, but that's like the the the cool puzzle that you're picking your brain with. This is a game that worked very well in my brain. Oh, yeah, it does.
in Trajan as well, I would be like always planning like six, seven turns ahead and in this game it's like even more stuff to plan and my brain just like it works so well. I I feel like I would play this and people like, "Oh, I don't know what to do." I was like, "I know exactly what to do in the next four rounds." Doesn't happen in many board games, but here it does happen. Of course, I'm going to like it more because it works very like I do For me this is like the perfect level of of weight because I don't spend that much like energy on doing it. The thing I really like is that you are a planning ahead in many, many ways. Yeah. And it is like there's so many reasons for doing the things because you want to rush, but you don't want to rush too badly because you want to rush to get to the specific buildings and the first player to get to this will get more points. So, it is really a efficiency thing because you you're not out of the game if you're not doing it like perfectly, but you might be like a bit ahead because you are doing the thing in like an order which Oh, because when I place this here, sometimes you are in a position and this happened in Trajan as well, where you are like, "Oh, all of my things, let me do the same action."
Yeah. And I don't want to do that action because like there's one there, there's two there, there's three there, there's four there, there's five there and all of that. The thing I have to say is that this game, whereas I like Trajan quite a bit. Well, we have played Trajan a lot. I really like Trajan. The thing in this game, the last time we played Trajan, I felt that the this was the game. Yeah. And then the actions you're doing are kind of okay mini games. I I like for me it's upgraded here. I feel like everything I do here is more fun. Yes. And it's also more like interlinked in more ways. Because in Trajan, it feels like I'm doing this and then the different actions doesn't really have anything to do with each other. I agree. There is so many more things to think about here. So many small choices and the timing is super super crucial. You can be in a position where like we flip a card that we really want or multiple people reach a milestone they can take at the same turn, but I don't have the means to get to that action with my ship. Like and also I've been in a position where I can end the game. Yeah. The action that I am going to do, that I want to do, is ending the game and that's a bad thing for me because I wanted to last a little longer. And I feel like there's so many different strategies you can go for in this game and it really depends on like the setup of the board and the different powers that you use start with
some player powers if you're playing with the pirate's expansion and that's also adds like another layer of things to think about and also influences the way you play in that game. I also think that there is a It's not a lot, but there's a nice level of interaction. It's not that in your face kind of interaction, but it's like the same interaction you get in like a game with multiple races. Because as you said, there is these milestones. There's going to be a few of them where you want to rush for this because only the first player who gets it. But when you manage to have it, as you said, you also have to then be able to do the trade action and have enough money in the trade action to buy it. I really like that because sometimes it's kind of like in the same with the cards that comes up. It's not like you can just Oh, I need that. I'm going to take it. You need to be able to do that in the moment. So in many games where it's just like, oh, you randomly got the card you needed. That might happen here, but it's not instantly because you have to be in a position where you will be able to do it. The interaction like you had the race for those goals, you also have the race for these. Uh like these ones will be have room for for all players can build each building, but the first player who gets there gets like a quite a bigger bonus scoring. And also some of these uh this one that you move past is going to be good like the timing of those. And especially the timing of the uh the the events on the treasure chests.
absolutely. I feel like uh the Pirates expansion, and you said it also, it's kind of essential. Yes. I have to say we haven't played without it. That's true. But there's so many things you're taking away from playing without it. I feel like I would have a lot of fun with the just the base game as well, but I feel like the the Pirates add a lot of crunch and thinkingness. You're adding all the special powers. You're adding like a whole new element to think about that influences your what you're doing on this on this track. There is like I feel like half of the game is in the in the Pirates expansion. Like you have the system with uh the negative cubes. I don't remember name of them, so now they are the negative cubes. The negative cubes which you get
remember the name. and lose when like you when you win these events, you will lose one and the player who has the least of a thing will get one. So that is like a good kind of another part of interaction, this timing. Uh and also you you add this board which has more variability in the places that you can place your buildings.
also feels like a race. Like I want to place that building out so I get that power before you or that scoring or those resources. I like player powers, so you add player powers. Uh so there's like there's so many things added in the expansion that I feel like if you think you will like the game and you'd not only play lighter games because it adds it doesn't add too much. Like it we played it. I was reading the rules for Pirates expansion and thinking not to play with the first I was like all these things are very easy to implement. It is though an expansion that changes the game quite a bit.
Yes, it is. And as you said like it it's not that complicated to add. I agree. But it limits like how easy it is to get things done because I
It is good but you might I I I absolutely would recommend playing without it the first time if you're not very used to heavy games because if I want to go through this scoring right here, I need to have the weaponry or the the legions to pass two of these pirates. So it limits what you can do and that has to be taken into account to like your whole planning thing. There's been so many times where I'm just like I can sail a lot now. No, I can't because there's a pirate there and I don't have the means to defeat him. There's also two smaller expansions. I would not say those are needed. One of them is a thing I do they're very small. Like there's basically a module. The first one I don't remember actually that there's one that is just like variability. I'm pretty sure which is like adds more of these things. I don't remember if that has like a specific special thing. I think it's only variability. And the other one is where you will get a different kind of starting resources. Yeah.
So instead of just getting the the one of each or two of each something like that, you will get a some tiles and you will draw them.
that.
They will give you openings but they also might give you an extra ship or like a specific scoring for the end of the game. So you're like okay, I'm saying I'm going to start with less but I'm going to score this specific thing in the end. So I really enjoyed that one as well but I wouldn't say it is essential. But I think like if you're buying this I I'm don't think it's a widely available, which is sad part about this because I think it's a great game, spoiler alert. But I I think that if you order it, I think it's just easier to just order a whole package because if you play it and you like it, you are going to want to include those expansions and if you play it and don't like it, there's probably going to be people who want to buy it from you.
Let's talk about play time and player counts.
Yes. We played it with two and three players. I like the three player game a lot because it felt like it didn't Well, I'm taking taking like play time into account here. I felt like we spent around two hours and that was a very nice length for this game and also because it's like feeling of a race, you feel like those two hours go pretty fast by. Yes, because it's not like it's the first time I played it I was feeling like oh it was a bit longer than I thought, but you are doing things most of the time. But sometimes people will have a bit of AP because of this puzzle here.
Yeah. But most of the time the turns are pretty quick.
Yes, I agree. I felt like also sorry, I didn't mean to sorry I because I played two players. Yeah. And I felt like it wasn't losing anything. So you can I would recommend it with two, I recommend it with three. I think four might be a bit long, but you will get even more like in your face interactions if you don't mind that and if you play with the same group multiple times they're going to be shorter. Yeah, I think it would work really good with four if you don't mind taking a little bit longer which I feel like this this game will what you call it it will survive a little more time.
it will and now it's time for final thoughts. I almost said Final Fantasy. That's a video game. I'm it is not time for that. It's time for final thoughts. Do you want to begin? Yeah, I really like Austria. I think you won all the times we played it, yeah? So you're really good at this. Um, I I'm not the best planner ahead in games. So, I feel like this puzzles is a little challenging for my brain, though I really like it. I absolutely think that the whole package of things that you think about and like every um, thing you're planning with this to do the actions are more interesting than in Trajan. I haven't played Trajan in a while.
No, we played a few years back.
But, if I'm looking to play a Mancala game,
Yes. I'm choosing this one because it's really, really good and I'm looking forward to beating you someday in the future. I'm going to land on an 8.5. I think it's a great game. Ostia is a pure fun. I think that when you get into it, it's very smooth. Everything you do makes sense. Like it's very There's no rules versus like, I don't understand this because there's not that many rules. It's very Like you are taking this, getting resources, moving, and doing the actions. And the actions are pretty simple. As soon as you get into that, the rules is not the problem. Then you will have, of course, thinking of planning ahead, which I really enjoy, which I really enjoy in many games, but especially in like Trajan, Concordia, and this gives me the same kind of vibe where I can plan ahead for so far into the future. And of course, things will change if somebody goes away and goes away, goes and do the things I want to do. But, other than that, like it's one that just like it works very well my mind with my brain.
I feel like, as I said, if you are going to go and get it, I think you should add in the expansions. Um, I would say with a big caveat that we didn't play the base game, but I I played enough games to be able to look at, okay, if I take away this, this, this, this, and this, would I like the game as much? And the answer to that is no. But, all in all, I think that Ostia is a really good game. It's going to stay in the collection. I The only reason for me to keep Trajan now is because it's been there for so long and it's an old Stefan Feld title which is like a nostalgic thing because I would also choose to play this every time over Trajan. I'm going to land on 8.5 as well and that is going to be the end of the video. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes and you've been watching Board Gaming Bandits and bye-bye.