Tiny Towns Review - Give Me That Hammer!!
Transcript
hi everybody i'm luke hector from the broken meeple if you like what you see please consider thumbing up the video subscribing to the channel maybe check out the patreon if you can lend a hand but also mainly just leave a comment on the video talk about the gaming question any of older acts of the games anything about the video itself or my thoughts on it let me know your comments i want to read them we'll get on with the video in just a second but first a quick word from a sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.cod.uk kiender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kianda and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get done with it and thank you to older act games for actually sending me a copy of tiny towns to review i think it's the first review copy i've had from all direct so moving up in the world but yep definitely keen to try this one out again because little history lesson i tried this about three or four years ago at the uk games expo and it was you know it was a proper demo played it four players it might be more actually and my initial thoughts were what the hell was that since then i kind of ignored the game and just thought yeah whatever flash in the pan so since then i've not really looked at it again but then i learned that there was a
certain way we played it and there was another way to play the game i thought ah okay i'd like to try that other way but it's taken me a while to actually get around to doing it and i thought okay let's reserve judgment on tiny towns until i get to play again with what is deemed a spoiler alert to be the proper way to play this game but a little overview first tiny towns is a stupidly simple game rule wise anyway where you essentially have well let me tell you the two ways you can play it right one way you can play it is that you have a deck of cards and these cards are shuffled up and on the turn top card is flipped and it tells you one of five resources on it in this case brick every player then takes a brick cube there's cubes for all the different resources and plunks in somewhere on their 4x4 grid board this will rinse repeat every turn with a new card flipping and a new resource being called out and play players are going to place cubes on their board so what exactly are they mean to do they're aiming to build the patterns that correspond to various building cards that will be in the game you can have a monument which is your own personal building but they'll typically be one of various different types before the game starts so we got farm and well and factory and chapel and tavern and theater and cottage i mean that's just like the basic game one but then you have quite a few more in this game yeah there's your monuments there's all the other buildings there's like three of each different other type it's a decent amount of variety in there but we'll get on to that a later but let's say that we take the cottage for example it requires an l shape and it
needs yellow blue and red in that format you can mirror rotate it as much as you like but you need to try and create that on your board so okay let's see i've got the yellow there fine right i need a glass i'll put that one there and that red let's say i've moved it there once you have put the pattern down you essentially take off all the resources relating to that specific pattern take the building in question and plop it on one of the spaces the cubes took up and then you just carry on as normal keep flipping the car choosing a different resource putting the resources on taking them off when you need another building put down and you essentially keep going until everybody is stuck like they choose not to or they can't physically put any more cubes on their map or put any buildings down and as you put the buildings down you can only have one per space and only one resource cube per space that you can't move around you'll quickly find that space gets very tiny very tight i mean it is a tiny town after all so it's an idea of trying to leave yourself like some escape routes in case the resources come up that you don't want but also building the buildings you want to build in the corresponding light formation that you want them in order to score the most points so for example cottages score you three points each but they need to be fed so at some point you need to build a farm the tavern scores you more points the more taverns you build the chapel scores your point for each fed cottage the well wants adjacent cottages and you know the the theater wants you to have unique buildings on the same row in color they've all got various different conditions to meet in order to score points and of course once you get to the end the most points is the winner of course so first things first wow this
game is simple rules wise i mean this rule book is oversized frankly for what it needs to be but yeah there's not a lot of rules in this game i mean the two back pages are literally just explaining every single building in the game but you have i kid you not right there's your setup diagram huge really nice setup diagram publishers take note two pages to explain pretty much every single rule in the game including the faq additional rules bit and a scoring example and one page for the alternative variant a little solo variant which is okay it's not but you wouldn't play this one for a solo mode it's basically just a beat your high score thing and you know and building clarifications that's it this rule book is super simple to learn i guarantee you you can be up and running in five minutes with this thing it really is gateway level rule set now how to do well in this game is another question though it is um tricky more tricky than it gives you credit for because you constantly are in the space where you regret every decision you made how could i have been so careless because you're thinking ah this is good yeah i'm gonna put the resources there there and there this will go according to black women i don't need the wood i'll put that over there then all right i don't need to i don't need a stone either i'll put that there right i've got my glass right now let's build this building and now i can't fit that building and what am i going to do with those two resources there don't match a building ah ruined everything that happens a lot and that's a good thing i mean this one definitely requires you to forward plan how you're going to build but then there is that somewhat chaos factor of the resources
coming up at the time you don't want that you need to kind of budget for like allow for so everybody around the table is having a bad time in the sense of everything like sort of falling to pot and every now and again and i say bad time i'm talking about their decisions not enjoying the game enjoyment is pretty good actually it's a solid game but here's my little elephant in the room before this variant that i mentioned um i showed you a method which basically had you flipping a card and using the resources like that this was the method i was taught as a demo at the uk games expo three to four years ago i recommend you take this deck of cards and burn it wow that was pretty brutal even by my standards no backsies i'm not joking burn this little deck of cards because i will never use this deck of cards ever again this creates a very meh experience what you want is this little thing the master builder token because the proper way to play this game this is the variant this is the actual way you're supposed to play it is where on your turd whoever has this and it keeps going around you pass it around like a first player token in a sense dictates the resource to be used and that opens up so much more depth for this game because you can get this hammer and go right well i need a wood so i probably should go for wood but wait a minute you need wood as well and so do you so chances are you're gonna pick wood at some point so maybe i should pick something else i need well i
also need a stone you don't like stone you've got way too much stone on your thing as it is you're not a massive fan of stone ida so you know what i say stoned then you pass the token and hopefully they'll say the wood that you need but they might go for glass it's like where am i gonna put glass now but that idea that you can look at the other players and kind of gauge what resource they're likely to take is such an improvement for this game if you use the cards then every resource will appear three times each before this deck runs out but you don't know whether something's gonna appear a lot more often than not with this master builder rule now the game can go up to six players yes you can play this with six players and yes it is simultaneous the problem with the master builder rule and that though is it's easy to look at two to three other like like tiles to see oh yeah you probably don't like these resources trying to look at five other tiles is a little bit more tricky so five to six players is doable but it does make it a bit of a chaotic game so honestly i recommend capping this at four honestly but it's not like the game is bad at five or six it's just gonna be a bit more on a chaotic site component wise very good i mean the artwork on this car on these cards is really nice really colorful you know really evocative the you know cubes are big yes i know it's cubes but you gotta keep the cost down if they had custom resources for all five of these it'd be ridiculous and you've got different building sculpts for all the types of buildings this is just three of them here there's another three in the box and the monuments i haven't even got
those out and each one has its own unique wooden miniature there's a lot of wooden pieces in this box which is why it's this big frankly because you might think well why do i need a box that big for this it's mainly just to hold all these other pieces and the insert does it fine with the assistance of a few baggies it does look a little bit weird on your board though when you're putting resources down on like little cubes on little squares and then you take them off and you plunk this tiny little thing down in the middle of a square you've got a lot of dead space on your board even when you're putting all of these buildings down so it kind of looks like a weird little town really when you're said and done but that's a really minor blemish i mean that's just a personal me thing i don't think it's gonna bother other people but yeah with that master builder rule it's so much better the cards they just pale in comparison and this is what made me go on the game when i first played it because i thought it was just a random luck vest that i just i got no control over what's happening i can only predict maybe a card will come out and it's like well when's it gonna come out but this is the variant apparently like like the super simple variant if you're teaching it to kids but yeah i mean with this you've got more control you've got more reason to care about the other players around the table even though technically i can't influence your map i can certainly make life a bit harder for you and of course it's a giant hammer so who isn't picking this thing up and going bashing it around like some child well no i am i don't know about you but yeah it's a solid you know solid game overall
and you've even got the world's biggest score pad for actually writing down the individual scores and this is a low scoring game so every little bit helps and you lose points for empty spaces so again you gotta be pretty efficient which is tough when people are dictating the resources you put on your board it's definitely an interesting game now you've got a decent amount of variety with these cards because you've got all these different monuments that you can build and you only have one per player and they can influence your strategies a little bit more like uh you know obelisk of the present if i make that you may place all future buildings on any empty square in your town okay so i don't have to care where the resources are when i place a building do i build this early do i build it later do i just skip it because not all of them give you points this doesn't give you any points it just gives you a special ability but then for example managers palace two points for each unique adjacent building types it was a bit like the theater i had one the other day or was it cool let's have a look it was fort iron weed and for ironweed gives me seven points which sounds amazing and that is pretty amazing for a building but unless i'm the last player in the game i can no longer take turns as the master builder that hurt because i was forced to build it a little bit sooner than i wanted to and it meant that between three of us at the time because one person was already out i never got to use the master builder again that hurt my ability to do well in the rest of the game i think i was only one i know i did win the game in the end it's actually the scoresheet i've got here yeah i want it by tie breaker just but still really hurt not being able to use the
master builder pawn but there's a lot of cool ones that were in here i quite like what my friend had which was the grand mausoleum of the rodina your unfed cottages are worth three points each so you don't have to build a farm so you can just build cottages wherever and it means you won't build certain buildings that want fed cottages so that's gonna change your strategy a little bit and say these monuments are pretty cool you can take them out of the game they are a variance module at the end of the day but honestly i would just throw these in because you can actually ignore your monument and still do well particularly if it doesn't get you any points you may decide you know what is too much hassle i'm not gonna build it fine it's your choice but i like the fact that you've got a lot of these different buildings i mean you've got uh i mentioned three it's technically more if you include the intro set so yeah you're talking four buildings for each type so instead of say let's take the color the tavern which are green okay well let's have a look at the greens for those i could have a tavern i could have an arm's house i could have an inn i could have a feast hall i mean they're all based around the same kind of thing but they've got slightly different like color patterns for them it's the same shape but it's different colors but then it gives you completely different scoring conditions based on what it is you build i mean the arms house in particular is weird because the tavern gives you more points for more taverns this one gives you positive or negative points depending on how many you've built it goes minus one five minus three fifteen minus five twenty six it's a weird one say the least but again it's you know these create some good variety
and you can just mix and match the different types as long as you have one of each so overall tiny towns has you know it's impressed me actually because i feel kind of bad that i didn't give this one enough of a chance three to four years ago when it was like the hotness we're sorry now i never really see anybody play this game but it is still sold by other rack and i still see it on shelves and of course i like to try out more of these gateway level games and see if they're any good i think that when you use the cards you are going to probably find this a bit of a meh experience but i think it was uplifted greatly by the use of the hammer now the game does quote 45 minutes that is kind of semi-accurate uh this is not a filler by any means because i think the time it takes for people to consider what they're doing an ap person could slow this game down particularly there's six of you and the fact that it does take a while to do actually fill up your board does mean that this is outside the realm of filler territory but yeah it's still a pretty decent romp all around and i can recommend it as a good gateway game is it one that i'm gonna play crazy often possibly i mean it is actually it's a simple game the components are cool you know i can get used to the fact that i'm using cubes and the fact that i can teach the game in literally about two minutes is definitely a big plus point particularly when the rule book is really easy to read and reference it's got decent components it's got a decent uh like feel and it's got with the master builder a decent amount of depth and a
reasonable amount of variety do i care about getting the expansions not particularly i mean i've looked at the dice tower reviews for those expansions and one of them i just don't think looks any good at all the villagers i think it is and the other one fortune maybe i'll get it i don't know but really i'd only be getting the expansions to get more buildings i'm not really interested in the other mechanics that they throw in because i like the fact that this is simple so you're getting a decent enough package with just this one even if it is a bigger box than you would probably expect for a game called tiny towns but yeah overall i'm giving this one a decent eight out of ten it's a seal of endorsement not quite excellence level but i definitely think i was too harsh on it before when i first played it i think like i say a rule variant can change a lot about the game you know taki noko is a good example of that and so i think i recommend this as a good gateway game it's one that i'm going to hang on to actually i'm going to bring it out every now and again be interesting to see if my family could get used to it although i don't know spatial awareness is not my mum's forte so i reckon you would struggle with this one but other than that i can recommend this game and i definitely think you should give it a try so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see then please remember to thumb up the video like the video consider subscribing to the channel check out the patreon if you can to help me out with other review copies but also just leave a comment what are your thoughts on tiny towns are those two expansions worth getting do you like this variant or do you prefer the cards am i completely wrong about this and you have a different opinion by all means get it in the comments and let us all now until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the recent
review i did for the new acropolis game that came out at the uk games expo but you can also check out my recent retrospective top 10 of where i look at the 2021 year and consider whether it's an improvement from what i thought of it before take care and remember as always regardless of how crummy your little town looks at the end of the day it's still only a game bye for now