Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 15:23

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Clank Catacombs. Now, I cannot remember if I've already done a discussion over this game. Um, if I have, well, here's an updated one. Uh, so Clank is an extremely popular deck building game, one that I have gone on record many, many times, basically saying that I don't really enjoy. Um, like it's a it's a perfectly serviceable deck builder, but for me, there was always just a little bit too much randomness in the game. So, whenever they came out and announced Clank Catacombs, I was like, "Okay, this is feels like it's just going to be the exact same game." And for the most part, it is. Like, I I do enjoy Clank Catagums more than regular Clank. Like, cuz to me, regular Clank was just almost stale. Like, it felt like you kind of did the same thing because the board was pretty much the exact same. Now, they've completely rectified that issue by having a modular map. Like uh the game is uh broken up into different tiles that you just shuffle together and then as you're moving around, you're exploring the map and it's going to be kind of different every single time you play. Um that does kind of improve. Well, it's funny because it improves on the game for the fact that you have more variety,

but it also increases more and more randomness. So, if you're going into Clank from a deck building perspective, it's perfectly fine. Like, you make a deck, it's standard deck builder, nothing unique like Aon's End or Lost Ruins of Arnac or anything. It's everything you buy goes into your discard pile. when you have to draw and you can't, you shuffle your discard pile into a deck and you draw and then you just play everything in your hand and that's your turn moving around the the dungeon and picking up items and artifacts along the way. Uh what I mean in in the formula of Clank, I don't think it really improved upon it. You have you still have the randomness of the the the Clank bag. So whenever the dragon is attacking, then it's entirely possible that you and all the other players could have an equal amount of cubes. You might have less than less cubes than the other players and only your cubes get drawn.

Like that's still entirely possible. There's not really enough ways also for you to heal to mitigate that. So, it could be very frustrating when you're playing a game that just allows you to die super quickly with no real way to offset it. And there are ways though. I mean, there's there's spots you can go to that heal you. You can go to the market and get money, or not the market, you could go to the market with money and buy a potion that will one heal you twice and be seven points. Um, and it's been a hot minute since I've played original Clank, so I don't remember if there were many ways to heal in that, but there are more here. Uh, there are cards that you can buy that have ways to heal you. So, it's a little it's like [snorts] it works a little bit, but it is kind of possible for you to just get completely steamrolled. And especially if you're playing a larger player count game because when the dragon attacks, it's when an icon shows up in the market like this blink spell has an icon on it.

So, whenever that happens, you draw from the bag. Now, the way to go about this to where not everyone is being attacked all the time is you just don't buy from the market. As far as I'm aware, the dragon only attacks if you buy cards from the market when that icon shows up. So, it's it's possible you just quit buying stuff from there and it's like, okay, now we'll just get in and out. But obviously, the best cards are there. Um, and there comes a point in the game where I feel that people are doing that where you kind of have the deck that you want. This is a a game where your deck gets pretty large. Um, so everyone quits playing or quits playing. Everyone quits buying so that they just have the deck that they want. They're moving around. It's efficient and then everyone gets out. Now, the issue that I kind of have, funny enough, with the everyone gets out problem is it is it's almost a wash because if everyone leaves, then everyone gets their 20 points. Therefore, nobody got 20 points. I think it would have been a little bit better if those were kind of like some of the other icons. Like the artifacts grow in point value the longer you stay in the crowns that you can buy are valued less if you are the ones to buy them last. Like the first one you buy is 10 10 points, second one is nine, third is uh eight.

And it would have been nice if like the first person to leave got let's see would it be better it like if it was I don't know if it would be better if it was less points because you got out quicker or I think that would probably make the most sense if you were the first to leave you got less points. So it's another riskreward element. You stay longer in the dungeon to get a higher value artifact but if everyone has left then they're attack you're getting attacked even more. So, if you can also still manage to escape, you're rewarded even more again by escaping last. So, the only reason I feel like that those points even matter is if you happen to escape and no one else does, but they're still getting rescued. Uh that that would give you a significant boost. Um, and some people might be saying, okay, well, like because the technical rules are if you don't escape, if you don't have an artifact or if you are in the depths, so the blue tiles, then your score is zero. It doesn't matter. You you went too far, people can't come rescue you. Now, you could just easily be like, well, [ __ ] that and we'll just play and we'll just score it up and see who won. Um, but technic tech technically the rules are your score is zero, so it doesn't even matter. Uh, and that's always just kind of been an issue for me. Like the cube bag is pretty random. The the the cards that are coming out on the market are obviously

random. Um, and then now the tiles for clank catacombs are random. Now, some people could easily just be like, well, that's part of the fun is you see is what you get. And this last time cuz I've played Clank Catacombs before and I was like didn't really fix the issue. Um, and there was kind of a mindset change whenever I bought this again. And I actually have the two expansions for it as well because I want to give those a shot. So, look for my discussion on those. Um, but there was a mindset change coming in here where I kind of knew what to expect and uh did it with that new mindset, did it actually enhance my like or did it do I still not like Clank Catacombs? Um, and I think it's I think it's fine. Like I don't really uh like hate it, but it's still not necessarily a game that I'm going to be like clamoring to um to get to the table. Maybe those expansions kind of enhance it. But there was a moment though cuz I was playing this with uh my girlfriend and every time we drew from the bag, she was like stressed out when we were draw. And that was that was exciting because that those types of interactions with games like this are always um a positive. Those are the experiences that you want whenever you're gaming. So that was kind of exciting. And I was it's like, ooh, yeah. So, maybe that's the headsp space

I need to get into of like what are the cubes going to be versus more of just the sheer randomness of it. Um, but yeah, like I like uh I like the the prisoner aspect. Those are different ways that you can get victory points. That's neat. I like I mean you feel like you're getting a lot more out of it versus just go in, grab an artifact, and leave. Um, this one definitely has you gathering a lot more stuff, a lot more items. The prisoners have different conditions on ways to get points. The minor secrets and major secrets. Uh, the market stuff, the coins are victory points. Um, the cards in your deck are victory points. So, you feel like you're accumulating a lot more wealth in this game, and that can make you feel really good. So yes, I I will say if you are going out and you've seen Clank a deck building game and you've seen Clank Catacombs, it's like which one should you get? Cuz I believe yeah, the original Clank has uh has expansions as well. I don't know how many. I don't know if they're, you know, equal in their expansions, but I would definitely recommend Clank Catacombs over base Clank. Uh, not and I'm not considering Clank Legacy or Clank Legacy 2 or anything like that. Um, but this is an improvement on the whole system if you do like Clank. Now, if you're like me and you're kind of, you

know, 50/50 on Clank from the from the original box, I I mean, this I don't think is going to completely shift you. It's not like this rectified a whole lot. One thing that I never really enjoyed about either system is people could be like, "Oh, well, if your issue is the fact that you're making noise, well, there are ways to remove Clank, like the the cubes that get thrown in the bag." There are, but from my understanding, it is only until they're in the bag, which I guess thematically is supposed to represent the current noise you are making. And once the dragon is attacking, then he's heard you and there's a chance he might get attacked. So I but still mechanically like I because I I've always said theme doesn't make good game mechanics. Um it would have been a little bit of a better system in my opinion if you had ways to remove Clank and you got to take them out of the bag. Um cuz I mean even thematically it's like well this is a massive cavern. You could just say that the noise is just noise in general. It doesn't matter when the dragon heard it. So like if I just bought this darkened al cove, like when I use this, I can remove two clank. Oh, but I don't have any in the thing uh like on the board. So I guess I can't remove any. No, [ __ ] that. Just remove it from the bag. But as the rules as

written, that's not what you can do. Has to be. So, I mean, it's like a mitigation kind of if you play cards that do give you clank where it's like, I'm going to play this riot card and then I'm going to play, you know, my stumble that's two clank. Well, I have enough skill to buy this darkened al cove, so that makes this a wash. Yeah, I mean, that's something, but I still would rather have something that allows you to remove noise from the bag. Um, there is something though that actually, again, I haven't played base Clink in a very long time, but at least in Clink Catacombs, the cards that come out on the market have a couple extra uses, which is cool. They have an arrive ability, so when they enter the market, they trigger something. Some of them might put black cubes back in the bag, so it it waters down the bag, so you might not get attacked. Uh, that's nice.

Uh, and then there's also acquire abilities. So, whenever you buy cards, you get a quick ability. I that I guess that's the uh twist on the deck building element. It's not just buy this, put it in your deck or put it in your um discard pile. You might get something for it real quick that could help you on that current turn. Uh which is very nice. Don't get me wrong, I still love consistent, you know, true blue deck builders like Dominion, but the quality of life improvements of stuff like that or stuff like Chemical Overload where things go straight to your hand or on top of your deck, that's always just been an improvement, but there's still um there's still something that's nice about standard deck builders. Um but yeah, like this is quick to get to the table, very simple to relatively set up. I mean, the the storage solution is ass, and they they don't even give you enough bags. They give you two large bags for a game with actually quite a bit of tokens. So, it lends itself for 3D uh inserts.

And yeah, like I mean, regular clink maneuvering around the map and stuff is pretty straightforward. It's pretty simple. One thing that is kind of annoying again from a production standpoint is since there are a lot of tokens, a lot of prisoner tokens, a lot of secret tokens, they only give you one player raid for that, which is extremely annoying. So, I guess I mean it's not that big of a deal if you just have one person hold it, you know, cuz a lot of the secrets are one time use. So, you flip them and it's like, "Oh, okay, cool. I don't know what this does." You look at it. Okay, cool. This gives you a lockpick or you get to keep this. It's an egg. It's worth uh some victory points, but it increases the the dragon attack track and so it's pretty quick, but still it's just like why only one?

So yeah. Um on a scale of 1 to 10 with Clank Catacombs, I think I'm going to give it a surprising seven. I think Clank Catacombs is it's a good game. Um, whereas I probably in the past might have given it. Actually, I might be able to tell you if I look up my um my sexy little BG uh because I keep this relatively up to date. Um, I gave it a six. So, last time I played, so I am going to bump it up by one point to a seven, which in my scale is good. And like if people wanted to play this then I wouldn't I I mean I wouldn't be like oh god get that away from me. So it I guess my my tastes have slightly increased on it and we'll see what those expansions bring uh to the table. So keep an eye out for my reviews on those. Other than that uh let me know what you think of Clint Catacombs in the comments below. Like comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved