Skip to main content
Loading video...

Catan vs. Catan New Energies: 6 Major Differences

Transcript 19:02

in this video we are going to talk about the six additions or differences in the new version of Katan Katan new energies compared to the Bas Katan so we all already familiar with I think most people are familiar with the Bas Katan and the new one came out the new artwork and everything so we're going to share you this differences and we are going to share you what we think of the new one compared to the old Katan but first hello everyone I'm Stella and that's Taran and I'm friend Derek here thank you for coming again yeah always a pleasure Derek has been playing a lot of Katan as well and been are they starting off with Katan yeah I got into the hobby through Katan there that would have been like 20 2011 wow that's such an Ever grin game isn't it I know and Katan was my Gateway in as well and I there's a lot of Katan products out there there so many out there the ocean one is the only one that I have played on top of the base game so yeah interested to see this uh this new variation there you go and I myself have I have a love hate relationship with Katan I love it when the dice is on my favor on my side but I hate it when it don't get resources of all the th just like stealing my resources anyways let's get to the differences shall we so the biggest change you'll see is the artwork

so I'm a huge fan of IO tools redesign I love all the soda games and I you know katan's a really nice looking game as it was but this is I I love the style I love the aesthetic and the theme is based off Katan if it was in today time so you're you're dealing yeah you're dealing you're still doing the things you're trying to do in Katan You're Building structures to get resources to then build more things but in that process you're making Island just a little bit more polluted and so the theme is all about doing what you normally want to do but balancing the amount of negative that you put in versus the positive M which actually reflected throughout this game yeah we'll get to that but this is also cool so this is the Box Derek really loves this like Play Boxes it tells you what compartment houses what resources and then also it's cute that it's from what I understand no plastic yeah which fits the them very well I do have a little tip uh this is the P punch board and I keep them because just to keep keep things in when you actually put it sideways and so on so when you put it when you close the Box it'll actually hold things together better um so yeah keep keep the punch boards if you haven't try it out yet if you haven't caught it yet I assume you don't yep even the dice are wooden they got these old wooden style Dice and then yeah it's coming to the Modern Age so all the resources are a little bit more mod here we have bread here the what

appears to be Stone and what you'll constantly call Stone is of course the ibeam gers and of course these aren't sheep but they came from sheep so yeah just The Next Step Up basically yeah processed yes and then the one other thing that fits with that theme may maybe this one's a little dier we've got the uh environmental inspector here instead of the thief who goes around imposing fines I think cuz it works exactly the same way as the robber moves from place to place lets you steal stuff so yeah I think he's imposing fines so this is uh the theme and the basic mechanics of Katan new energies is still the same with Katan so that's why we kind of like okay what's the differences is more like additions than differences there's only one change to the original game which is what cities produce but other than that it's pretty much exact same game yeah so the second thing that's new and this is really where the mechanisms get new is that we've got two I've pointed at these there's two new types of resources basic resources on top of the five you're familiar with so we've got science science is this light bulb here and science goes into building power plants and then we've got energy energy comes out of power plants and so science cards they will go in your hand they'll form part of your hand the way they always do they're a little bit

better to trade you can see it says 3 to one on there so instead of going 4: one when you're trading with the bank you're going 3 to1 mhm and then the energy you hold that on your player board we hardly even pointed at the player board but you hold that on your player board you've got space for five and there are various things you can do with uh with energy but what's particularly helpful is that that will exchange at a 2 to one with the bank for any resources it reminds me of an old smaller expansion that they used to give out where anytime you there was a role and you don't get anything you get a coin you get to trade those coins in for a resour so that used to be a nice catch-up mechanic it's a mini expansion but I don't see it anymore it's a good way for it to come back in a different way this time exactly so uh it's kind of like oh I don't get resources I just need that one thing to build something else and then you exchange the energies so you don't get the energy for free your power plants still have to produce it still it's not a it's not a catchup it's just a different way of stuff so number three is really what is the new mechanism for the game what is what does the energy and the power plants bring to the game how does that work because that is really the not just the major thing it is the core thing that is different from basatan so you can now you can still build cities and towns and a town has space for one power plant and a city has space for two and

you can build dirty power plants or clean power plants a dirty power plant is going to cost you one science so very cheap a clean power plant is going to cost you three science so much more expensive you are a better hand model than me he's like you're pointing at the right one I was like here and so as you get your power plants out when the hex that the power plant is sitting on producers so there we go I've rolled a 10 the town is going to produce the cotton and the power plant is going to produce the energy and so as you get your energy that's when you can spend it on the stuff that we were talking about before now if you look at the player board under all of the towns and cities you'll see some brown clouds to represent the pollution that's being generated by that city or town and and as you pull the brown power plants off they're going to give you even more Brown clouds and as you pull the green ones off they're going to give you green clouds essentially Brown clouds minus green clouds is your local environmental footprint and so that will determine how polluting or non-polluting you are individually then up here at the top of the board is a global track and that is everyone's combined environmental footprint so that's one part of the energy side of the game the other part is that we have this bag of event tokens

and it begins the game with a whole lot of essentially uh these brown colored pollution events and they they're mostly kind of negative things underneath all of the green power plants there are some green tokens and when one of these gets built the green token is going to go into the bag so the bag will get diluted with these good event tokens at the start of every single turn one or more tokens is going to be drawn depending on how far we here yep so if everyone is more polluting more of these are going to be drawn uh and they'll go into its relevant spot and once that island is full it will resolve the event and Loosely speaking these events are going to be bad for the player with the worst pollution these are going to be good for the player with the most pollution now there are some the least pollution yes so there are some that affect everybody it's it's Loosely speaking but that is the the core of what's new so you can go in you can build a lot of cheap power plants with the science and get the benefit of getting extra energy remember energy swaps that two for one so if you're generating a lot of energy you're getting a lot of free flexible resources out of that without having to negotiate with people but these events are going to start punching you yeah that's really bad like in one of our games uh the person who's

the best like oh you know it's just every time it's got flooding or something's not working was that you wasn't it oh yeah so I I've played it twice so the first time I played it I I tried to be the person who was the most green and it you know it played out differently and the second time I played it I I was just as aggressive as I could and it really bit me in the butt yeah okay but I was that far off though it was just another way we we'll talk about you're usually that guy that guy that's like the worst and I don't have to worry because it's Derek you the we pollution so the fourth new thing is there is and it's related to the environmental side of things there is a new end game condition in fact you've got two kind of competing end game conditions so you can still win the game with 10 points the way you always could if you get to 10 points game ends immediately and you win and the points come from all the same ways they're in the de development deck they come from having the longest trade route and the uh the most environmental nights and so forth yes and just within these events uh you may have noticed these here they're called Hazard tokens they either get placed on the hex's or on the towns or cities they essentially stop them from producing once so once you know if it were here and I roll the eight I would just remove this instead of getting anything uh you can also get rid of them with energy yeah which is here in the in the playboard M the other way the game can end is if this bag gets

empty so if the environmental footprint is very high collectively and there's not a lot of green plants this bag is going to run out it could run out very quickly you might get eight or nine turns if everyone is just going the opposite of green yes or it will last longer than that cuz you'll you'll hit a good half of your medium but eventually this will run out and if this Runs Out victory points are relegated to being the tiebreaker now all you do is you look across everybody you count up their green power plants minus the brown power plants and whoever difference is higher is the winner if it's tied then you go to victory points so it's a little bit different to the environmental footprint because your environmental footprint goes up as you build towns and cities for the purposes of this second end Condition it's solely based on your power plants for that for that condition so you end up in this uh with these potential Divergent ways of going you could Rush towards the victory points and the best way to rush towards the victory points is to get lots of dirty power plants and get the energy and all the benefits that come with that but tried to but that's going to empty this bag more quickly if everyone's doing it or if enough people are doing it and you may run out of time and if you run out of time then having all those dirty power plants is going to you'll you'll

lose and just for context I was on 8 or n and I was so close to finishing the game but the bag emptied before I could so I was I became last cuz I was the dirtiest player hilarious on the other side if you spend your whole game focusing on the power plants and focus fusing on trying to build power plants up it's expensive and getting all of that science is expensive getting science only really comes from cities so you have to build some cities and you have to manage all of that and you may end up having a much slower game so if the game does end on victory points you're going to be nowhere near it yeah um but if it ends because the bag is empty then you're in a good position so finding the the medium point between those or pivoting during the game because you can build dirty early on and then spend energy to clean it up later on that can often be the pace that you want to be nimble to do great strategy there from Teran although it's kind of like easier to say than done like know like there's so many things like roll the right dice please yeah so the fifth main difference here and Teran alluded to it earlier is how cities produce in the original cities would produce when the numers rolled two of that resource type but in this version you get one of that type and science so this is the pretty much the only way you can get science outside of a few development cards and what's going to be different this time is basically now you can't rush a certain

strategy you can't just collect lots of wood and bricks and build lots of Roads because you actually get the same output but what you do want to do is use the science to build the power plants that we spoke of earlier yes I mean you can still trade science that's the other way but like the usual way but that's the main thing that you do and towns can fit only one plant in the hex that you choose but cities you could see there slots three of them yeah this is like really cool I mean I can use that like that yeah one two three so there was a functional change it wasn't just an aesthetic Choice here there's a functional reason why they're shaped the way they are now yes the sixth edition is upgradable power in your player board I mean it's all symmetrical but remember how I complained about the dice roll Ian why am I Katana is all about dice roll so the teeth whenever the rolls is seven MH always go around and stealing play resources now this is the one that you can upgrade by spending two energy and you flip it and the thief will only come and steal your hand if it's over 10 rather than seven so yeah it gives you that little bit of extra f F ability to hold more cards especially cuz there's more types of cards now as well yes like I really like oh I really need to collect this amount to build the cities I'm like oh no it comes and steal my cards at least you know this is an option to keep your cards more yeah in

the game that we played because there were four players we were generating so many cards that when it was on my turn I rolled a seven I lost half my card that happened to me three times I should have just upgraded but I was like surely I'm not going to happen times are you rubbing it on me because I I don't get resources I don't get stales well it's all lost anyway so fine I just want to trye in though I know we said six differences but one thing that I really hated in the original with the Monopoly card I hated the feeling of getting six wood between my turns and it's all gone especially when someone asks you what do you have and then it's all gone so depending on how you feel yeah that card is gone it's not in development deck everything else is still the same then nights are called clean C they're called cleanups but they work exactly the same way with the addition to either kicking the environmental inspector out or clearing all hazards so yeah celebration now to take that guard is gone yes like celebration thank you thank you very much those are the top six well PL a direct bonus of what new energies bring to Katan so if you what do you think let us know in the comments Maybe maybe you have played this what you think compared to the old Katan maybe now you want to try new energies go for it and let us know what you think in the comments so what do we think what all of us three think of this new Katan compared to the original Katan um well what's so I've

played a lot of Katan variants when I used to play a lot of it I tried all of them I tried the pick up and deliver one that was a train game but what's interesting about this is it it's still the same experience but with almost like a change to the meta like you can't just rush blindly you really have to be aware of whether or not you can actually get to the Finish Line cuz you don't like you don't want to you want to see if like you're the dirty player then oh I can get away with yeah you don't want to stumble a step before the Finish Line I think that's a really cool thing that if you don't see your path to winning by 10 points you could just focus on building up the green plant so I thought it was a cool sort of shift in The Meta so to speak yeah yeah that's true for me it felt like uh it felt like a reasonable addition it did let you play in some different ways and try to respond to what was going on but it was a bit of an unnecessary bolt-on for me I think the original was elegant enough and even if there were strategies that you could really work and bolt towards was always a quick enough game that you know all power to someone who got to that point so for me I would stick with original yeah well I'll probably do the new one because there other ways to gain Resources by exchanging two energies for example although it's not that easy but it is possible and the 10 cuts limit is just a bit of a relief for me cuz like I just like really really try to avoid the thief sorry what is it called the

environmental environmental inspector environmental inspector okay so yeah I think this is a good one to have different endgame conditions as well because it's not just 10 points because okay you really have to look around okay what's what's everyone doing like as you say it as well or how empty is the event bag yeah that's it yeah cuz it's like it's end game trigger as well so those are the top additions or differences of the new Katan what do you think let us know in the comments if you enjoy this video please help us like the video subscribe for more videos like this thank you so much again for coming Derek and hopefully you have a great day see you next time okay

Progress saved