Shadows Over Camelot Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairmen of the board today I'm talking about shadows over Camelot which is a cooperative game set in the kind of Arthurian legend world it plays in about an hour and a half and plays up to seven players this game is pretty famous because it's kind of the the game that really made the whole traitor element of the game really famous so basically the idea of the game is you're a bunch of Knights you are trying to complete a number of different kind of missions to gain white swords and the one or maybe two of the traitor players are trying to make the team lose without blowing their cover yeah it's a it's a game that's been out for quite a while now and it's pretty simple from a mechanical standpoint because all you got to do on your turn is you do something bad and you do something good the bad thing can take a number of different forms it can be such as them play a trebuchet and once there's a certain number of trevor shades outside the castle then you will lose all the good guys will lose at least or you can take damage on your character or your knight sir and basically what you run out of health you will die and obviously if everybody dies you'll lose and lastly you can draw a card from the kind of fake deck or the kind of a shadow deck where something bad is going to happen regarding one of the missions now in
terms of doing good things or you're trying to do is you're basically trying to move around to these different missions and play cards to form basically poker hands and these poker hands are going to vary in difficulties such as having just like a I don't know like two pair or three pair or something like that and if you do that before the bad guy or before those cards come out to trigger the losing effect of a mission then you will pass the mission and if you pass the mission as I said you get white swords and you might get like a little health bonus so you can even get like a permanent bonus in the forms of like the Holy Grail or Excalibur which let you kind of bring payers back to life or increase your kind of fighting prowess and yeah so you're basically trying to basically take turns and trying to complete as many missions as you can successively before the one of the negative effects takes place so on your turn is pretty simple we I said it we do is take that one bad action than that one good action and this is where some of the good and bad of the game really shines through because it can really seem like you know when especially if you're playing at the higher play accounts when it comes back round to you that you are not doing enough on your turn because it takes a whole action to move from one place to another so if you know if it comes back to you and all you want to do is move there to there then it's like oh that's my turn done and you got to wait everyone to go around again so in that aspect it could be quite frustrating at times I feel like you're not guessing anywhere also in the fact that say as I said you want to play all these these poker hands in a row all
these kind of lines of cards in a row and you can only do that one at a time because that counts as a heroic action so you know if you've got a play hole five cards by yourself then that takes a whole five turns now naturally obviously you want to work together to try and get those done quicker but you know sometimes if you left somewhere on your own it really does fill it you're just going through the motions for a good four or five turns in a row at which again it can seem a bit plodding and almost a bit dated this game has pretty much stood stood up you know to the test of time quite well I think it's still relatively popular but for me it is starting to show is kind of cracks bit and just the way it flows just isn't quite there for me anymore now that being said the whole idea of it the different kind of as I said the different medieval legends such as beating the arm you know defeating the back knight or you know being I don't know fighting the Holy Grail and finding Excalibur and fighting the Picts and fighting off the Saxons now they're really thumb attic and it really does in the board itself looks like it's really thumb attic in the trebuchet is building up it's just a point it paints a picture of the whole medieval world really really well but yeah it's it's kind of gameplay I think it's a little bit too simplistic and there's also some kind of Vega T to it which really doesn't quite sit well with me because the game states that you cannot actually tell other players what is in your hand no the cards wise because everyone had their cards they've got you know the different numbers they
need to form the poker hands they've got kind of special Merlin cars that can cancel were like really horrible effects or and stuff like that or even like positive classify kill your partners and stuff at that but um yeah as I said the game says that you can't actually tell people exactly what you have but you can kind of suggest like them ethically what you might have so you might say oh I think I do really well down I don't know to find the Holy Grail so you're pretty much saying that you've got loads of Holy Grail cards but the kind of Vega T of what you can and can't say as I said it just doesn't sit well for me and I like kind of cut and clean rules I mean when you've got a rule like that people are just gonna say what they've got anyway and I think it's really kind of open to you know that rule is open to being abused by players so something that I just it kind of bugs me a bit but I guess more kind of thematic players it probably wouldn't bother them as much the game also I don't think it really plays in the hands of alpha gamers too much which is a positive because I like these cooperative games really do you know you know pandemic is your kind of classic where you're almost play more efficiently when when someone is really dictating the play or someone who's more experienced it takes the play and this one because you have got your secret dick you know hand of cards it does play it differently and obviously you've got the traitors as well which are trying to mess things up by such as you go to the certain spot that lets you get off cards and you know it's been used to ditching a few bad cards but if you're a traitor
going to be trying to ditch after good cards yeah so I like the I almost like the subtle ways that the traitor can kind of manipulate play in this it's really not glaringly obvious who the traitor is and you've got to be a bit more careful about when you do chip in to help to not you know to try and make yourself not look so suspicious but also try know when to hold back to help the team as well and the kind of balance between when the good people good guys win and when the good and bad guys win is pretty seems pretty good I'm I think I've had about a 50/50 you know 50/50 ratio of good and bad winning so that's that's quite nice yeah I think the they're kind of the real decisions in the game lie in which negative effects are going to take that time because every kind of all those negative effects do feel very very potent and very strong you know any any time when you draw those cards some of them are very very nasty and could just hurt people really badly you know some of them just obviously you draw cards that you really don't want to draw and sometimes you might want to push you luck and you know take more health with yourself but then you might someone else might draw a card which might kill you off so you know all those effects do feel very very punishing which is nice you don't you do what your a cooperative games to be quite difficult and you want the game to battle against you and this game does that very well I said mechanism wise very simple but a bit dated in a bit too a bit too slow a bit too plodding for me in terms of the gate the kind of time frame of the game it takes as I said about an hour and a
half to play which i think is a little bit on the long side for it and and I say that not only because of the way that game flows but I know it a lot of it does feel like you're through the motions and so yeah I think the it's just on the upper end of that kind of tolerable amount of time that it takes it doesn't have States welcomed by a longshot that's for sure but it would have been nicer if you can condense it down it's like 45 minutes or so this game wants to just have a very cool rule where people can drop in and out of the play as well because all you got to do is draw a role card draw a character and just get going which is quite nice thing just slot right into play which is a nice feature and also all the characters have different abilities as well so you've got a bit of replayability there you can do you're trying to use your character's ability most efficiently which again is a nice touch yeah so it probably sounds like I'm kind of ragging a bit on it but I assure you I'm not I do actually enjoy this game I think it's a a good solid game and I said it may be a little bit dated but I still do enjoy it and I certainly would play it again the replayability of it isn't tremendously I think once you've played it a few times you know the game's kind of feel very similar every time after that but as I said sporadically I will play it every once in a while I think the game looks really really nice it's a Days of Wonder so aesthetically very pleasing really nice you know layout of the board every kind of different minigame if you will is set up very clearly very precisely the place where you keep the cards is
nice and clear so yeah I do like the look of the board it looks very medieval and as you would expect with days in wonder it's a really nice production and quality miniatures as well and it's an affordable price yeah so production and looks wise you know I'm impressed it's excellent in fact yeah no complaints whatsoever and for a game that is pretty up strike you're just playing on poker hands the theme does shine through really well which again is a nice touch so yeah overall I like this game it's a really it always has a classic feel to it and as I said I would happily play it again it did leave my collection because I just wasn't really having the urge to get it back to the table um as I said it's slightly on the longer side of things and I didn't like some of the Vega tea and some of the rules and also felt a little bit slow for me but that being said it's a it's a solid cooperative game well it's fun the traitor aspect is used very well in it and yeah I certainly would recommend it if you do like cooperative games if you like your traitor II games this is one that is definitely worth checking out one of the real kind of pioneers I thought your honor of games and you know despite some of the negative things I said about it it does get a good verdict for me which puts it around a 7 out of 10 so you know it's that's I dig about those kind of ratings quite lightly you know I'm quite almost I'm a bit apprehensive to give out high rating as a games and this one I certainly do think it gets that that good verdict from me so yeah that's a shutters over Camelot definitely want to check out if you like your coops so that
concludes this review of shadows over Camelot if you have enjoyed it please hit like and subscribe to our channel and check out my other videos too for ever and I'll say see you next time on chairman of the board bye