My City Review: GET THIS GAME! - By Board Of It
Transcript
hello hello ty ann farrell here from board of it and today we're going to be talking about my city a game by dr reiner kinicia it's a legacy tar lane game for between two to four players and just to be up front this is the quickest turnaround we've ever had between playing a game for the first time and reviewing it and that is because we have absolutely rinsed my city we've played all 24 episodes in like about a week or something and it's one of the most moorish board game experiences we've ever had now if you know my city and you've been on the fence that should tell you what you need to know but if you don't know about my city tawi is going to tell you more my city is a tower lane game in which you'll be building your own city using polyamino building tiles you'll be covering empty green land spaces whilst trying to avoid covering beautiful oxygen producing trees so unfortunately unlike new york zoo you can't just cover your entire board with a giant animal or a building
it's split into eight chapters and each chapter has three episodes the rules start off exceedingly simple and each episode will introduce about one to two new rules and each chapter new mechanisms it's impeccably designed terrifically relaxing and truly a joyful experience now like many games there are some elements we really like some elements we dislike we're going to be talking about them but if you want the short version it is this we completed it we played all 24 episodes then we realized that we could actually play quite easily a new campaign online with our friends who just got their own copy because we played two player so we have two untouched boards and this got us so excited by the fact that we could play again with other people and i think having just finished this and that's how we feel that should tell you all you need to know now this is a legacy games our review will contain minor spoilers or they will aim to warn you up front before we talk about them in any detail however the legacy is just introducing new rules to the gameplay to increase complexity it's quite an abstract game and the story is non-existent so it can't really be ruined so don't worry too much so after a brief overview of the game we'll jump right into the discussion
you begin my city with a green and luscious space of land represented by this board and let me just say how happy i am that this is an actual board rather than a thin sheet of plastic you will also have a bunch of polyumna tiles painted to look like buildings that come in three colors and you begin with 10 victory points you'll be drawing cards from this deck which will tell players which building they need to place there are a few rules to follow such as you have to start building next to the river the river cannot be covered by a tile and a tile has to be placed next to an already built building you can also skip placing a tile by losing a victory point the game will end when either the deck runs out or all players have passed and you will then score up with everyone getting one point for each visible tree in their city and losing one point for each visible empty green space of land and visible rock and that's it that's all you need to know to play the first game and my city at its most basic obviously it becomes more and more complex as each episode will add one or two new rules the game is split into eight chapters each with three episodes and at the beginning of a new chapter you'll open up an envelope full of new rules and goodies and the state of the board will be changing at the end of each episode because you'll be very likely altering it in ways that that chapter tells you
to now very very mild spoiler but as an example at the end of the very first game of my city you will be adding either stickers having trees or rocks depending if you lost or won and depending on how well you did you'll be filling in these progress points and the player with the most progress points at the end of the campaign will be the overall winner let's just get this out the way up front my city is a brilliant game by all rights it should feel kind of stale and boring particularly if you're usually playing big table hogging games like us it really doesn't sound like much you autonomously lay tiles until you personally decide to stop you're covering up rocks whilst trying to avoid trees whatever snooze but once again dr reiner kinicia shows his brilliance yeah so at its core my city it's relaxing it's soothing and it is charming and i actually think it's genius that you have a card that tells you what tile to lay because in polyumna games a lot of times you get a lot of ap because you first have to pick a shape of tile which one's best and then you have to decide where to put it here you're presented with a simple problem and you can calmly figure out the solution where should i put this specific tile and the thing is is that each of these colors of tiles
all have the same shapes so through repetition you become familiar with each shape in the game and this allows you to strategize because you then are able to visualize the board in terms of these shapes and know where to put them in the future what really flips the script is obviously the legacy elements each chapter adds new mechanisms and each episode adds just one or two new rules thus there is always a feeling of constant progression and there's always a new consideration in play which makes you think differently than you did in the previous episode what's amazing is that you hardly notice this increase in difficulty because it's done so masterfully chapter four feels different in terms of your goals versus chapter one but you'd be hard-pressed to pinpoint the exact moment the game flipped the script on you now there's really not much to criticize about this wonderful experience although we will cover some things that we think could have been better or that we disliked but just know that it's a total recommendation from us we love it it's just that the nature of this game makes it a little easier to dissect as you can take chapter one and chapter three and compare and contrast what worked and what didn't now we're going to talk about our least favorite part of my city so unfortunately there's going to be spoilers for chapter three and very minor abstract spoilers for chapter two so if you want to avoid those jump ahead the video is time stamped but the gimmick in chapter three is this you have half as much land to build on
now this is a legacy game each episode you only get to play once and it's gone the board has changed forever and when you've completed all the episodes the game's over you have to buy a new copy if you want to play it again this is why we were so disappointed that a mechanic major mechanic in the chapter is to play less of the game that you enjoy playing and have paid for because there's half as much land it plays in half as much time and this is already a lightning quick game and obviously you run into problems so you end up passing even sooner than you usually would and this is compounded by a mechanic introduced in chapter two which was essentially buildings you always have to place you can't skip them and one of these buildings is a total beast and if you've played my city you know the one i'm talking about it's horrible and so what happened is i got caught out very early in an episode of chapter three just because i couldn't place this building and it's a bit my fault a bit bad like i had plenty of green spaces couldn't put it and the fail state for that is the game ends for you so i was ending a game about i would say a minute or two into playing and that episode was then done for me and this episode was already half the time anyway right and then it made it not fun for tally because what's the point of her playing on she knows she's won so yeah all combined we just found these mechanics really disappointing this chapter really disappointing but the good news is like a lot in my city if you don't like it it's going to be
gone pretty soon because of how the progression works and the thing is this thing about the buildings and you know the failsafe that doesn't just be confined to that chapter it actually happened a few more times and it's just kind of disappointing that a fail state is to not play the game that you've paid for and you enjoy but looking back it's impressive how different each chapter felt with almost all of them being equally interesting almost all of the new mechanics were innovative and novel even if how much you like them will vary from person to person my city takes you on a really interesting journey and honestly we would buy another copy of this game so we can play with more players however one outlier to this is that at one stage the game takes away a mechanic just to bring it back two chapters later in a new hat masquerading as a new mechanic and that's a little bit of a shame given that most of them were very novel and innovative that being said it was different enough not to feel repetitive and it definitely provided a new puzzle what we would also say is that it maybe felt a little bit more fun earlier on in the campaign because you're excited to get the envelopes and open them up that being said my city does a great job at providing new surprises and there's always cool stuff and ideas in the envelopes one thing that maybe also lessened our enjoyment as the campaign went on was that early on in the early chapters
a lot of what's introduced changes how you score vp so you're always kind of on the back foot trying to figure out how now to best score and when whereas in the later chapters a lot of what was introduced it allows you to get little bonuses and rewards rather than change how you score and they just kind of felt a bit superfluous at times i'm the kind of person that when in a game like this a new mechanic is introduced i really lean hard into it i explore it especially because it's going to be gone very soon and it just felt like at times i was punished for that and taking chapter six as an example i went in really hard and tried my best to always max out mechanism i was introduced whereas tally kind of just played the base game and just gave it a passing glance and when the dust settled and this mechanism was taken out she had won almost every game and on the reward side of things i wasn't that much better off than her and what was worse and compounded this is that for losing the games and also some of the rewards i was getting from this mechanism i kept getting a little boost to an earlier mechanism that does allow you to score vp so i became very good at this one thing but what in what was really ironic is that if i did this mechanism it was at odds with the new mechanism the game was introducing so i was in a strange place
of the game basically saying look you can do really well and get a lot of vp and win but you're not allowed to engage in any way with the mechanism that we've just given you and as a totally made-up example it would be like if the mechanism had you make a chain of red buildings from the top of the map to the bottom of the map and you got some goodies but one of the rules in play was that you score if you have a group of red buildings in each corner of the map and as you can see you literally can't do both and that's what it was like for me these issues are only minor quibbles though as the game moves along quickly and the actual way these mechanisms change up the game is interesting it's just a shame that sometimes they are disparate from winning and this is just more disappointment with the implementation rather than any dislike however one thing we do dislike is the state of my city's rule book this is a game that'll have you pick up and drop rules faster than you would a hot tray with your bare hands and you're going to get rules whiplash from trying to remember what is and isn't in play and this is going from people that played each chapter with minimal time in between if you're meeting once a month with a gaming group you'd likely have to re-read every chapter sheet preceding the one you're on the first problem is that my city makes the rules so simple that it does leave space for ambiguity particularly if you're used to big books where everything is spelled out
because it has to be things sometimes just aren't specifically stated the game leaves you to infer then there's always an aspect of doubt secondly it seems like they've traded the clarity of having a big official rule book with everything in it for the fun of getting to pull these rules out of the envelopes every time you start a new chapter and these rule sheets they often say literally and i mean literally this all rules from episodes 13 to 19 apply and it's just not true because you've already been told that all these mechanics from episodes 13 to 15 are being taken out and you've already covered up spaces on your board that correspond to episodes 16 to 19 and although they do kind of cover it because in a previous episode it says that these rules are no longer in play so you could argue that it's covered i think we can all agree this is a horribly tedious and confusing way of stating this information we really think that my city deserves a pandemic legacy style rule book where the new rules are stickered in and then crossed out or stickered over when they are no longer needed so then you can just read through before each episode in order and find out what's in play so just before we end we just want to touch on the ending of my city whilst maybe not the giant culmination of everything you'd expect the theme is a very pleasant one so thematically after the journey you've been on it's a really lovely ending and
nice aspect to focus on even if episode 22 maybe introduces the toughest mechanism so far also unlike some other legacy games the game can be played after completion as the boards are double-sided and you'll play a game set about midway through the campaign this is a really nice touch even if it might get repetitive quite quickly final thoughts this is a game to get if you have a general love of board gaming obviously if you're a person that only plays one super specific genre then this won't be the thing to break you out of that but for everyone else the people who will play any game as long as it catches their eye this is for you in this very very reasonably priced box you'll get a wonderfully relaxing experience that is totally unique turning a tile laying game into a legacy experience is genius and even better if you don't like a chapter it'll be out of your life in about 45 minutes this game is super easy to get to the table it's quick to set up and it's quick to play that it will be over all too quickly if you enjoyed this video we really appreciate it if you give it a thumbs up and leave us a comment down below please feel free to ask us anything about the game and also if you haven't already please subscribe to our channel for regular board game reviews usually under 15 minutes always with a little hint of doggo bye-bye thanks for watching