TWO PLAYER SERIES: Libertalia Full Playthrough
Transcript
Hi everyone. I am Jamie. And I'm Molly. And welcome to the mill. Today we're starting our two-player playthrough series of all the Stonem games. Um we've decided to start with Libertalia. Mhm. One of our favorites to play two-player. Um we're going to be playing on the calm side of the board, which is our preferred method. Um we're willing to revisit games later in this series if it really takes off. So, we could in the future play the stormy side or the mixed, but today we're going to do the calm side. We've preset up for our first voyage. We've pre-drawn our six cards, which I will show off just so y'all can follow along. We have the first mate, the merchant, the bos, the mutineer, the bodyguard, and the stowaway. And yeah, we're going to get right into it. Yeah, and we're we're excited to do more than just the Libertalia. So, this is just the one we're starting with. Um, and we're excited we could run through the rest of the Stone Meer catalog from the two-player perspective. Um, see, kind of flush them out and see what we like about all the games from a two-player perspective. You know, obviously some games are going to play better with more people. Some games will actually probably hopefully will play better with two. Um, we'll we'll see how it goes.
Yeah, I'm excited. Me, too. Um I guess and with that we will get into liberalia. Yeah, let's dive right in. Pick our characters for day one. What do we got? Two maps and a
barrel. Okay, we'll go first spot. Best spot. You know what? I agree. I shouldn't look at your cards. That'd be cheating. Yeah. And my first thought, best thought for me, I'm on fourth or fifth thought already and made no decision. Well, I uh I didn't put a ton of thought into it. I just feel good about that choice. Um, I'm just going to wing it. This is a challenging first hand. I am ready. Ready? Yes. I like first mate. First thought, first mate. Mhm. I have the mutineer. So, we will follow along.
Starting with the day, we get to the first mate's ability. Lose one for each character in your ship. No one in my ship. Wrap around the desk. which we hit select choose your I'm going to take a map then you because I'm sharing the tile with the midshipman you choose a loop to the sky and I have to do it right you do that's what I do then I can choose I'm going to take the barrel barrel has a dustability of one reputation so I'm going to kick blue down a
notch bring her Then we activate knight abilities. My my mutineer goes rogue and mutineers themselves getting me two dons and we're right into day two where there's a saber, your other map on a relic. Oh, I need that map, don't I? You do.
Oh, I don't know what I want to do. Um, just follow your heart. Okay, I'm going to go with Okay, we'll do it right. Okay, bodyguard stow away. So, we will resolve. I don't want to mess with any of that. So, the stowway is going to draw me a random loot token. Oh, this is going to work out for me. Oh, it's a map. Oh, that's good. Nah, I have no way to get a second map, but we'll see from the bag. And then I discard the stairway. You have a desk. So, then I will discard all sabers um and hooks. Give me two bucks, please.
The balloons. Two deans, please. I'm pedantic like that. And then midshipman. I get to pick, right? No. So, the midshipman is if you share the tile with it, the other person picks. No, I believe so. Yeah. No. Place this towel to the second and third place on the island. Okay, that would make sense. So, if I wanted to be low, I'd go really low. We're simulating because we're both under it in this situation. Gotcha. Gotcha. So, I got to be a brat. Yeah, that was that was the right decision. You're a monster. It's a pirate game. One of the times I'm comfortable being a monster. It is a pirate game. But I still get you in my boat. Your boat's full. I am struggling though with one. It was a It was a big mistake.
I think it's a rough time for treasure maps. Yeah, that was probably a mistake. But you live, you learn. Say love. Mhm.
Okay. Ready? Still way first. Wait. Lay right next to. All right. So, I get a random. You know what? I hope you get a math token. There you go. It's not going to be bad. Of course. You're cursed. I I'm bad at drawing things out of a bag. We need that. Okay. So, I lose one for each character in my ship, which is nothing. Wrap around. I take this beautiful treasure chest. Mhm. Then I will discard the You've been getting one reputation with your barrel. That's when you take the barrel. The the recurring one is the big time.
I get rid of that for a reputation. Thank you. I appreciate that. You're welcome. And look, my first person who survived back to the ship. Your sto goes into your graveyard. Mhm. So is dead back into my hand. Right. I saw that. Okay. I know what I'm playing now. Um What color are you? I am
red. I don't Did you start with two reputation more than me? I started here. Moved one over and then you moved one over. We're bumping blue now. Okay, I have chosen. Okay. Three, two, one. Bam. No, you're here. Oh, yes. The 20.5 is smart cuz it's 20 characters on either side. It is a very good. All right. So, okay. Day abilities. Gain $2 character ship lower than nothing.
It's a high ranking ship. Discard one, two, or three. So, I'll discard two for four bucks. I'll give you a dollar. I'll give you a daboon for a five, please. Sure. Um, choose your treasure. Oh, that's going to hurt. What's the hook do again? You either get two balloons or you keep a character for the next voyage, which is good for the the powerful anchor power. that one. Mhm. So, you may want the hook if you can net more than two deloons with it. I will net more than two. I think that's smart. Okay. I'm going to take this beautiful anchor. Okay. No curses for me. Okay. And that's voyage one. It's only four days. Yeah. So, now we do our anchor abilities. Which deck is the random deck? Mine. Uh mine is, but we're going to do our anchor abilities first.
Yeah. Yeah. So, I get one for each character in my ship, which is one balloon. One for each character in your ship, which is two. Two back. And then we add up our balloons. Add the the balloons from the treasure cemented in our treasure chest. Oh, 18 plus map token is worth not by itself. 12. So, 18 19 and a hook and that's nothing. 19, right? Five, 16, 17, 18, 19. Nothing in a hook. I'll keep my first mate. Bodyguard, you did well. But you are now dead. I don't need the barrel anymore. Are these go back in the bag or stay out? Go back in the bag. I'm just trying to count mine and I kept hearing your numbers. So, I need one. Seven. Six. 79 102 17 18 21 for me. What'd you get? 19. You're never going to financially recover from this.
I'm devastated. I uh the balloons go back. But I do have my first mate. My trusty first mate. treasure goes in the uh it's this is like and and it's in androgynous osprey and a cut off. Mhm. I mean I got to appreciate that sort of a little bow gun, right? Little bow gun crossbow. Would you like to randomize six more characters at the top?
Oh, these would have that one didn't resolve too many to blooms for you, right? No. And then choose those from yours. I'm going to populate our five loop days. We got 11. If y'all hear any nonsense in the background, we have a puppy who we are distracting with a bone. And he's Roman. He is He's free, but he is named Billy Bones, which is fitting. Vampire themed. Yeah. All right. So, that should be 4 11 20. All right. So, we ready to walk through the cards.
15 13 12 11 20 11 12 13 15 20 40 All right. So, what do we have? We have the governor, the freed prisoner, the witch, the smuggler, the officer, and the carpenter. added to our crew. Whoa. Lot of maps. Lots of maps. Lot of maps. I have a straight. Got to refrain from making a joke. Um. Oh. So, we need our starting deloons, which is based on a reputation.
Oh, yeah. So, I get eight. Oh, yeah. Drop these off. You get nine. Okay, perfect. We got our cards. We got our cards. We got our We're ready to go.
Okay, I'm ready. Yeah, I'm ready. Ready. Mhm. Governor. Governor, you're going to hurt me, aren't you? It feels like I should go hard for this set of three Matt tokens, but well, we'll see how this shakes out. Lose half your dloons rounded down. Um, discard all characters from my ship. Then then I'm going to take this and I'm going to get rid of this for you. E, what? I'll take that. I didn't get anything for it the last round. Mhm. I just Yellow is my favorite color. I'll try the chests. All right. No nights.
No. No dusks. No nights. I guess that was a dusk. Here we go again. Okay, I've got mine. Baked. It's easy peasy lemon squeezy. I do too. I hope this mic picks us up both good. Ready? Me too. Yeah. No, I am ready. Are you ready? Yeah, I see yours there. Officer, bodyguard. E, you might not be happy with me. What's the body? What's the Oh, actually, if you have 12 or more deloons, I do not gain two reputation until otherwise.
gain the balloons until you are 12. So, give me seven deloons. Oh, wow. Great job. Well, thank you. What a good combo. Discard all saber and hook tokens and I get four deloons. This is where I didn't Yeah, but we're not going to get anything. Think this through cuz now neither of us Well, I guess I'll let you make I'll discard that. Yeah. Well, well then. Um I'll take it. No nighttime abilities for you. Nope. Here we go. Map time. It's nap time. It's nap time.
What should I do this? Ready? All right. Bam. Smuggler. Day powers. Do you have enough to give the 12? Nope. Two reputation one and then a bump up. Nice. I'm going to take my map and then go to my ship. Mhm. Um, let me think this through. If a character is directly to the right of the midshipman, that character's opponent removes a token. I guess we could still do that, but What this is telling me is I get to pick which one I want. Oh, if a character is directly to the left of the midshipman, that character's opponent removes a little.
But there's not one and it allows me to have my choice anyway. So, I'm going to take this. I feel like I should get to pick. There's not one to the left. So, then the midshipman. No, cuz not you would normally be punished in this circumstance for being right beside it. Yeah, but like if I was here and it was coming back in a game of four, if there was somebody here and somebody here and then we wouldn't have mid shimmer. We're simulating the randomness of what the midshipman wants. Well, it's fine. I Yeah, we're not going to max the automa in a game, are we? If we play something wrong, just feel free to rip us apart in the comments. Yeah, that's good. We'll be We both handle constructive criticism very well. Um I'm actually the most humble person in the world, so I'll be fine. It's true.
Um, I'm in awe of of how humble you remain. Take my officer back. What? Crap. Ready? 31. Ew. That works out for Jamie. Not going to work out for Molly. I could take the nap. Oh, I'd cry. I'm not going to. You could. You could. You could. It'd be no points, but it's just screwing me out of five. Um, day powers. Gain $2 for Oh, yeah. in your back. And then gain $2 for each character in your ship with rank lower than 21. So, six bucks, please. Six Dooms, please. I think you're getting me good this time. We, Fun fact, this is our second time filming this, and I handily won the first. Oh, she kicked my butt. I've got a little potty.
I've got a sailor's mouth, which was fitting for the pirate game, but apparently we need to clean it up. Um, remember to take your map. Oh, yeah. There was the whole point of this. Mhm. That's the whole point of the game, really. All right. Yeah, you got a good good thing going.
chosen poorly. Okay, choices haven't been made. I always like that like the powers are are a viable path. The tiles are viable. There's a lot of viability here. Actually, I'm really funny. What was I thinking? What was I thinking, Jamie? I don't know. I think you were not expecting me to play as well as I am, but I'm focused. I'm hell in on winning. I'm determined to win. I'm going to take this. I'm taking this player. This player series very seriously.
I am I'm determined to go undefeated and if I don't go undefeated, I intend to be a baby about it. Yeah. Smart. If you picked it, no, I have four bad choices I'm picking from. Should I like look over your shoulder like that or is that against the spirit of the game? Very much so. Okay. The spirit of remembering what cards people have. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. That's smart. I mean, I'm not registering it's all a wash. Um, we've got um I think that Yeah. Okay, I'm just going to do this. Ready? Bam. You didn't see that coming? Nope. I played the witch. You did? Which witch is which? Okay. So, my dilemma is I have to discard some. So, if I discard these two, I'm not less two less than I would have. This one, that's me one less.
I got a lot of money. Discard these two for four. And I did all of this to choose Um, no. I guess I want everyone counts. Hold on. I'm bumping up against anybody with the power. No, I'm bumping up against the top. So, both of them would be two. And then I'm going to discard this. Yeah, I got to take the stupid thing. The relic, but night abilities. There's no night abilities in my boat, so we're good. Mhm. Okay. So, I got nothing and you're going to be making lots here. So, I'll go first. White 10.
So, first one. Gain one for each character in your vote. One, two, three, four, five, six, please. Plus 10. So, 16. And then this one, I don't have any night abilities, so this one comes back to my hand. 16. Pretty good. That's pretty solid. I'm not going to lie. Plus, you got three maps. Three maps. But, um, I'll get wiped out by a thingy relic, right? Well, it's three. Yeah. So, throw that away. Discard the three. 24. Grab me a 12. All this. That was from the maths. That's a big money hand. That was a big money hand for me. Yeah. Yesesh.
That's gonna I just want to look at it as a big money and big stacks of fives. Enjoy it. Yeah, it feels good, right? What we got? 10 20 30 43. Everything else gets wiped. My total score is 45. 43 + 19. That is going to take us up 262. Fun fact, if Jamie wins this game, we've played hundreds of board games together. It'll be the first time she's ever won one. Yeah, I it's you would think that somebody's luck couldn't be that bad that it's just like a figment of their imagination. No, I am in fact cursed. I've never won. Really would like to though. I I can't stress how much frustrating it is to play for thousands of these and never have a single win.
Well, maybe some will. Will you do the six cards? I'll do our six days of loot. Four, five, six. This is final voyage. Yes. Mhm. I like this one. It's quick. I love the the symmetry and the cards that you're getting, right? It's all about you making better better choices than your opponent. And I mean, historically making better choices. Not something I'm great at, but tonight anyway, I'm doing pretty well. I would like to draw your attention to the relic on every single day I've drawn. We We tend to like to play less uh cutthroat, competitive, however you want to say it. Take that. Take that.
There we go. True. But for this game, I'm not able to be a brat. It's built into the theme. You know it going in. Yeah. And especially in higher player counts, it's just chaos. So, what do we got? We got the barkeep, the explorer, the thief, the arisa rat. Almost arrested cat that movie. Uh wind nymph, and the captain. Strong cars for the last round. Let's see what we got. Oh boy. Shoot. I caught it. We're good. You almost got cancelled. I I I think legally you could say that on TV now, so I don't think I get in trouble for that one. Could be wrong, though.
Oh, starting the balloons. Seven for me. Nine for you.
Agree. Okay. Let's change this around.
But if I kill you with the saber, then that means you don't get the relic. Yeah, correct. Yeah. No one's alive to take the loot. I mean, it's less kind of not so horrible, but it would suck to be getting yourself killed. play the captain. Your wrist are cracked. Bam. So I gain two reputation which is two balloons. Then you advance one two spots. So $2 give me back a buck. But you choose first. Oh man. I go for the maps. Wait. My girl loves map.
Okay, here we go. I'm ready. I'm intending to be ready.
Okay, I am ready. Three, two, one. Oh, it was bound to happen. Oh, no. What a whiff. We got We got Okay, so choose your leaf. First thing is first. Um, well, I got to take this. Yeah, because if I don't, you take it, then you kill me and I don't get any loot. Well, you would have grabbed your loot and run away first. So, Oh, yeah. But I mean, this one is net zero. But now killing you means that your wooden nymph doesn't go to the island. Oh, no. It's only on your island, so it's got to be there. No, that's a good point. If my wooden nymph is going to die, it's on the island. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Um, yeah. So, yeah. No, that was a good move.
Cruel. Cruel, but it worked. It was efficient. Okay. Knight abilities. Yeah. Right. If you're the only player with I'll take $2, please. I think you got me on this one. I I'm feeling good. I think you got me. Oh, wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a
minute. Yeah. Okay. Three, two, one. Sneaky. Yeah, but this is the sneaky. I forgot you had the 40. I got to take this. Hold on. Hold on. Yeah. Yeah. Sorry. Sorry. Sorry. Okay. Discard all the characters from my ship, dude. Oh, yeah. Sucks. That was I was hoping you'd kill them before. Um but those two are dead. Yeah. Mhm. Um but I get $2 or $1. Yeah. Like on the edge of the thing. The balloon. Wonder. Sorry. Then I get to pick. Mhm.
Is it better for me to take the map or kill you? I think the map. Yeah. I think killing me. I think killing me is silly. And then you'll like you'll kill me and No, no, no. You take it and you run away. Oh yeah. So then you can't even kill me. I'm going to kill the pesky midshipman. We never have to play out of the game for again. This has been a rough one. I Yeah, usually, but I usually this one plays well. I really like the I like the midshipman mechanic in this. I think for for a game that's not meant to or I guess I was built to be with more people, the uh the midshipman makes it play really well. Yeah, it simulates it being three player, which I really appreciate. Right, so we've got to make a choice here.
What do you have on here? Ready? Three, two, one. Okay, so no day times. We go to dusk. So, you choose something to remove. Smart. I'll take a barrel, which gives me a reputation. Nice. Which gives you a reputation. And we have dodged Bilbo. No down.
Sorry. Sorry, Bilbo. Be good. Almost there. Puppy going on the counter. Almost there. Two days left. He's been holding out so good. Right. All right. Okay. Oh, sorry. I have a night ability now. I get two balloons. Okay. Getting them ready. Risk, which you should be nice to me. Yeah, it's not gonna happen.
You know, day abilities gain two rep. Oh, I just dead. I'll take my green and then you choose to discard one. Sorry. Rude. I'm sorry. But you get to copy a night ability. So, I get four to balloons. Have you been doing this every time? I did it for two last time when I got it. Now I did it four because I'm copying the two the last
day. Um, no, no, no. This is interesting. choices. I just now realized the move that I should have made and let you have that map token. You ready? Mhm. We knew it was happening. You know, but you're going to hurt me. Um No, but I'm still going to get a map. It's fine. It doesn't matter. All right. So, I steal first. to take a loot for me.
This is interesting because if you don't take anything, there is a chance that I just don't take anything either. If I take the barrel, then you can take that and then I don't need one map. If I take the map, if you take the map, then I'm taking the map probably back. Yeah. So, I think it's If you take it, what happens? Maybe I'll take the relic. Maybe I'll take the relic. Okay. All right. I'll take the map back and then I'll take this map. Okay. Was that done? No. That was a smart decision.
Okay. And then Oh, lose two reputation. Oh, we both did. You would have went I would have lost. Oh, sorry. No, you would have lost first. It I think it's in your wash cuz it's not going to affect there's no more tie breakers. You've lost me one to many, but it doesn't go that either way. My rotation's lower. Yeah, you little they'll yell at us in the video. All right. Um and you put your thief down. So, now that it's done, I believe you netted yourself one last point because now your maps are going to exchange as two sets. One of your map tokens count. That was two. Never mind. Should have read that. So, now I've got five. So, a three and a three and a a two. You're set. I feel like we didn't even have the same cards this game. So, sorry. I get my abilities. Six. One sec, bud. We're almost done. Almost there. I get six. And then technically this is discarded. And then technically this is discarded.
But and then we both have the aristocrat which means we both lose three. All right. Night ability. So that's two. So that's five. Okay. So this is worth 12 and this is worth seven for 19. You three four 20. one back for 19. Um, I didn't don't think I gave myself a reputation for that barrel, but they dollar. Um, swords aren't anything. No money's at the bottom. Another one. Four. What do we got? 25 29.
takes me to 91. Drum roll on who won. Final scores of the night. Is that's your final score, my love. It is. Well, you heard it here first. Jamie with her first ever board game win. I am feeling good. First ever of all time. Um, no. I I really like Liberty every time we play it. I I I really like the midshipman. This plays really well from a two player. Um I know we we want to bust this out for a group of six and you know have a lot of pirate fun. Um but I really like it. I think it plays well with two. I like the I like the games that do the simulate a third person.
Sometimes they work, sometimes they don't. I think this really really works for that mechanic. I think and I'm not super thinking hard about this. This is the most elegant simulating of a third person. There's a reason we picked this first. We both love it at two players. We think it does really well at two. I love this game because I think this one showcased it well. We had all the same cards and your game went totally different. Uhhuh. And I did have a plan, but relics all coming out on day three really ruined that plan and I switched to trying to play high cards to stay above the mid shipment. Mhm. abandoning my plan. And I feel like a couple of relics might have just been less bad. Yeah, I that's what's always my favorite in this game is that um they're same cards. It's the parody is in your choices, not in the uh randomness of the game itself. So, you know, theoretically, you could just copy someone and have the exact more or less same game. And the only differences would be like the order for your reputation and stuff and and even that will have a little effect, but making different choices than your opponents will have a huge effect on your score.
I uh I really really like it. I don't know if we're going to have a criteria score sheet or something will fly out on this. Uh, yeah. Are you We We had a few ideas, but I think we'll formulate them in the next video when we have something to compare this to. Yeah. But yeah, thumbs up. We love Pirates. We love Libertalia. I love We I guess we should mention this is a a remake by Stonemire with new art, 10 new characters, the reputation track. Um, I'm not sure if you ever played the old one, but lots of elegant upgrades that I love. The old tiebreaker was random little numbers on the cards you play and each deck had different numbers. You could in theory memorize them though and if you're green you could know that you're like 20 your necromancer would always win ties so you could memorize it. I love the reputation system.
Uh yeah. So yeah, I think so. I think that's a wrap. We're going to go take care of Billy Bones. Um I think that's a wrap on the mill. Yeah. Thanks for watching everyone and we will see you next time. Bye.