Skip to main content
Loading video...

Eleven: A beautiful game about the beautiful game

Transcript 31:22

this episode of brains on games will talk about 11. a board game about managing a professional soccer team welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode I'm super excited to talk about 11 from Portal Games which is a game that's still delivering to backers I think but it should be hitting retail before too long so I'm going to review the final version the deluxe version of the game that I received we'll talk about the the first impressions of that one because this is a very complex game that I'm just kind of starting to scratch the surface of I feel like even after multiple plays now 11 here's the box for this thing 11 is a game for one to four players there's solo rules and there's different scenarios when you play on your own but you can play with up to four people it works with kids age 14 and up and like I said it is a complicated game and you can play a game in one to two hours though when you're first starting it will probably take longer than that let's take a deeper look at 11 11 is a complex heavy game where you are trying to win by earning the most victory points at the end of a six-week season now there are variations in the rules there are different ways that you can play you could play a longer season with the winter break there's lots of ways to play this game but primarily with the base rules you're going to play

a six-week season you're trying to have the most victory points at the end of that you earn those points through your position uh in the on the leaderboard among all the other teams in the league you'll earn points by upgrading your Stadium by uh training youngsters and having them play in your game by collecting staff there are lots of ways to earn points in this game so you're not only focused on the leaderboard but the leaderboard does earn you lots of points if you're near the top and if you're near the bottom you're going to lose some points because you're going to be relegated I'm not going to go through in detail about all of the aspects of this game and how to play play it because I looked at some how to play videos and they're an hour long so it like I said it's complicated and there are multiple ways that you can play it there are expansions that add additional but everything is modular so I'm going to talk more about the basic game which is how I played it as I learned through this thing and I'll show you some of the parts as we go along there's probably going to be lots of photos that I'm going to have to bring in because this game is a table hog I've got a large six by four foot gaming table and we've played with when we played with three players it took up the entire thing so it is a big game and we'll look at some pieces of it here on my little camera as we go through uh one it's an economic Sim you're building an engine that's going to earn you these four different resources of course you want to earn some money there are fans your soccer club you need to have fans there are operations that's a resource that you

can spend to get extra actions and then finally there's the fitness stat where you're that's what's going to allow your players often to use some ability during the game but even to play in a game at the end of the week you've got a board of directors the first thing you're going to do is have a director's meeting where some problem is going to come up that you're going to have to solve and that's on Monday every week and then this little wooden Chip is going to move through the week to show you your progress through the each round of the game so the round of the game lasts a week and it's going to finish on the weekend with match day this was one honestly one of the hardest things we found about the game was remembering to move this little chip to keep track of how many actions we had taken that's our issue that might be unique to to the players who are playing in this case I haven't moved anything in the engine here based on the directors but at the beginning of the game you're going to draft your three directors and that's going to influence which resources you're going to produce at the start of every week so it's an engine building game you're going to be spending your resources money primarily but fit Fitness as well you're going to be spending resources and building an engine you'll be buying upgrades like anything you can think of that you would need to do in a professional soccer club is included in this game players can be injured if players can be suspended there's all kinds of things that can happen here you're hiring staff you're upgrading your Stadium you're you're building up a fan base and you're hiring

players selling players there's all kinds of things you can do with the more advanced rules you can bet on games you can transfer players to other clubs there's a marketplace where players in different positions are going to have varying values so there's a lot of things you can do and you might feel like you know how to manage a soccer club after playing this game like I said I haven't set everything up I just wanted to show you some of the pieces here you've got this dual layer player board on on the resource thing and you're going to be moving these things around round so that at the beginning of the turn this player is going to get three euros and and three fan tokens and two operations and two Fitness and it is kind of a storytelling game so when you do that board meeting what's going to happen is you're going to draw one of these cards which is uh you're drawing this at random and there's some event that's happening to your team in this case you've recognized that the gym is too old and you might need to upgrade it so your board of directors is going to decide are they going to spend money on a new gym which will decrease their money but increase the player's Fitness or are they going to do nothing at all so you're going to roll a die at the beginning of the game and that's going to determine how the board of directors votes but if you don't like that if the fans don't like it you can spend a fan token in order to re-roll that die so there's some Randomness but even those random events are kind of telling the story of your Club so normally in this

game uh the the match day and the board meeting day are things that all the players would do simultaneously but we found when we played we're still getting used to all of the cards we wanted to hear the story like what's happening with your Club what are the things that you're rolling on what are the things how did your your directors vote we wanted to know about that we were interested enough in the games on Match day that we wanted to see how things played out rather than just everybody doing their own thing in their own corner of the game in terms of your Stadium these are very well designed boards um you're you can add in this dual layer board some extra stands so that more fans can come to the game you can increase your fan base by putting Stadium Lighting in so there as you're upgrading your Stadium it's going to give you some kind of bonus in addition to some victory points for the end of the game one of the things that we like best about the stadium boards is just the way they've set things up for sponsors so one of the things you can do in this game is hire sponsors and you might just give them a shout out and earn some instant cash and discard regard the sponsor cards but you might put an ad board in your Stadium where if you want the dice tower to sponsor your team and you want to put their logo on your board you're going to earn some ongoing cash for that advertising and then you've got the little Dice Tower logo that's poking out from under your ad board so that's the picture that's going to show up on the walls of your Stadium maybe you want a jersey sponsor and that's going to give you a different

bonus but you can only have one of these so Rodney from watch it played maybe would be excited to see that some players are are being sponsored by his channel on YouTube so you're putting different things here in the board you've got a limited amount of space so you can't have everything and those are all going to earn you some cash and potentially some victory points at the end of the game there are hidden objectives that you're going to be working on and those tell a little story about your team and you might earn some extra victory points in my case the last hidden objective I play blade was one where we didn't want to be beholden to sponsors so if I could make it to the third week and only have one sponsor on my board so no T-shirt or maybe only the t-shirt and no ad boards then I would earn a few victory points for that so there are secret objectives and they tell the story and you're buying these contacting Contracting these sponsors to earn you some cash as you go along so we really like the way this board was laid out just because you're sliding logos in and now you know what your team's Jersey is going to look like not only are you going to have some sponsors but underneath that Resource Board the director board you might be hiring staff and some of the staff are quite hilarious you can get trainers who can improve the stats of your players on your team you can have tacticians who will allow you to be more flexible in terms of the tactics you can use on Match Day you could have a Doctor Who's going to heal injured players more easily so there's all kinds of things

you can do and you can spend some extra operations token in order to use those actions this one is a bit of a gamble they don't know who this guy is but he's the ultra fan so he's going to have some potentially some impact on the game or on your game if you take his action so they're very thematic I think the most that the final staff I hired in the last game that I played yesterday uh was a dog named lady who is kind of the the mascot of the team and she prevented my fan resource from going below three now even though I would love for Rodney Smith that watch it played to sponsor my soccer club one of my favorite sponsors was budget shrinks so this these psychologists are going to allow you to increase some of your stats these are the team therapists who are going to help your team out throughout the game the meat though of this game what you're working towards here I say the meat but really all the other things leading up to this is really but you're leading up to match day at the end of every round because you will get lots of bonus points if you're able to be at the top of the table at the end so through the game you're going to be hiring players and maybe selling players to earn some cash if you need to and you're you're going to be playing against uh there's six rounds so you're going to have six of these cards uh on the side this is the the opponent stack of cards now I just grabbed a whole bunch of them and put them here I haven't shuffled them up or anything but you're going to have six cards you can play in three different

divisions uh I we pick third division because that was the easiest one we were still learning the game and I have no idea how you would ever win a game against first division teams because uh even even the third division teams were tough for us so you're going to start with three weaker teams and then underneath that you've got three random teams that are a little bit stronger but they're all sort of third division second division first Division and you're deciding which division you're going to play and all the players have to agree on that so you know at the beginning of the week a little bit about the team you're going to be playing against at the the end of the week because you'll see the scouting report on the back of their current and you know what kind of formation they use when they play the game so you might be saying to yourself oh here's a team that's it's The Scouting Report says they're strong in the Midfield I need to get some midfielders here and the players have little icons indicating where they're going to play when you hire them you're going to have a veteran player on your squad at the beginning and a youngster and the youth players are neat because they don't have a face or a number but once you train them you kind of get a surprise you don't know what sort of power they're going to have when you when you hire them at the beginning but then I was lucky enough in my game to have a a director who allowed me to begin with one extra stand for lots of fans and I was lucky enough to have a staff member who a security guard who could allow more fans to fit into those stands and then I had a youngster when I promoted him who could score an

extra goal if he was playing to a sold-out stadium so the fans really motivated that youth in in order to score a goal at the end so that was a great little engine I had going I had lots of fans coming in I was making money from my fans if I placed enough fans in the stands I would have a player who could score a goal so it was it was a neat little combination that I was able to get going in this case you're not going to have that combination but you can hire a goalie he's not represented by a jersey but you've got numbered jerseys you've got players who are going to be the ones who try to get involved in plays to score goals or players that are trying to block the others from scoring goals so you'll have a shield or a ball and then once game day comes around you'll put your fans in the stands and then you're going to have some of these tactic cards if you manage to hire staff members who can earn you extra tactics tactics cards then you'll be super flexible in your formation so in this case I just have a basic formation and I decided Well these guys are playing four four two so probably if I play 442 that would be a good idea I didn't even look closely at The Scouting Report here I just adjusted things on the Fly you also get to decide which of the players that you've hired are going to play because they need to be fit in order to play so you're going to be putting these little Fitness icons on them and decide oh I want to play those guys this guy's going on the bench I'm not going to play him but if you're lucky enough to have

enough of these little icons then you can play all of the players in this case that I've hired if you've earned enough of these Fitness tokens so you can do that through your staff members maybe you're putting a gym in the stadium so that your players can remain fit maybe you'll get lucky enough to build a new gym and your money will go down but your Fitness will go up these Fitness things are very important if you want to get anywhere on the leaderboard once you've decided which of your players are going to play in the game and you've figured out your formation this is something that was really quite fiddly we would spend some time looking at The Scouting Report and looking at the formation and examining our players and their abilities and shuffling things around to kind of figure out what where how am I going to have the best chance to win this game sometimes you might have a player on the wing and only one here in the center trying to shoot on the net so you're it was quite a strategic kind of spatial puzzle with some Randomness because you don't know how this team is going to play until you flip over their card then you see where all of their players are and what their strength is how good their goalie is and then you're going to go through each section of the board and figure out who scores moving these little counters on the scoreboard as you go then at the end if you're lucky enough to have the player like I did who gives you an extra goal that will work out quite well some of the tactics cards will give you an extra

bonus I had one where if there was a team that was ahead of me on the leaderboard I could score an extra goal if I played that formation so you it really does help if you know something about soccer you understand those formations and you can move these players around the board that has Turf on it I don't know if you can tell on the camera but there's a felt coating on this thing which makes these these pieces slide around quite nicely but it feels like a soccer pitch when you're moving these things around so then you're going to either win or lose or draw and then you determine the consequences of the match by Rolling this die now you roll a die at the beginning to determine how your board is going to vote in the board meeting and then you roll a die at the end of every week at the end of the game to figure out what the consequences are for the match if you win you might get more fans you might be able to promote train one of your players you might get some temporary strength from that but if you roll this die and you get a low number something bad is going to happen you might have to roll the 12-sided die because one of your players is injured because they work so hard in the game and you know there are worse consequences and fewer bonuses if you've lost than if you've won there's no way to mitigate or re-roll this die at least in the basic rules so the consequences of the game are completely random and unfortunately didn't feel that random when we were playing I think I roll it rolled in the

first four games I won the first four games and I rolled a one each time and what are the odds of that I rolled a one each time so my players were constantly being injured I mean thank goodness I had a doctor who could make sure that they were ready to play in a later game but I really had a tough time rolling anything good on that die finally at the end I got a draw and I managed to train one of my players when I rolled a six but my die rolls were not cooperating once you've figured out each player has figured out whether they won against the team that they're playing against they're going to be some other teams on the leaderboard and their stats are determined their their win and loss and draw rate are determined randomly you've got look at this you've got a dice tray that looks like a soccer pitch and so there are some teams that are red and you roll a red die for those teams to determine where they're going to go the red teams are tough there are three number threes on here of course you get three points if you win a game you get one point if you draw the blue teams are kind of in the middle they've only got I think two number threes on their game and then we've got the weakest teams only have a one and often one number three pardon me and often they'll lose or draw in their games so you're rolling for each other team there's I think there's there are eight additional teams besides the players or maybe it works out to eight I I yeah I think it was eight I don't remember off the top of my head but in the game that we played last I think there were eight because there were some doubles uh in the six card decks of opponents that we were playing

against so you it it is so thematic this game uh in terms of what you're doing and it really does feel like managing a soccer Squad now another thing that happens once you've done everything you've figured out the leaderboard you know where you are on the table and where all the other teams are and maybe you're starting to think about what you're going to do next week because you've discarded this card uh well then you have to pay for your club and your maintenance costs are higher depending on how many staff you have how many uh in infrastructure upgrades you've done to your Stadium how many players you have on your team it costs more and more and more luckily you do earn some money by putting fans in the stand ends you trade those little little wooden fan tokens to get some coins and that can help to pay for the upkeep of your squad so what skills are you practicing and developing when you're playing a game like 11 this is a complex game where you're planning ahead to the end of the week to match day where you're planning ahead to oh what's going to happen in the next week with the game that I'm going to play You're budgeting those resources you have a limited number of actions and when you're planning and budgeting and working efficiently we are talking about executive functioning skills there is a lot going on here in terms of thinking and planning ahead and it's so there's so many different elements of the game that like I said do work together well enough that once you've played a few rounds it it's almost second nature you don't have to refer to the rule book too much but

there there is a lot happening here that you have to juggle and you know working memory is one of those executive functions where you're working with information in memory so you are practicing a lot of that now you do have to another executive functioning skill sustained focus and attention this is a longer game and if you've got a teenager who's kind of enthusiastic about soccer and the theme is something that they would like you've got these tactile pieces that kind of Engage The Senses uh you've you've got the Strategic element and the Really the mini game of playing the match at the end um there's there's a lot to I think draw you in but at the same time you are thinking ahead and planning ahead and you might be sort of sitting quietly and trying to stay focused on what you're doing and keep your eyes on the prize stay focused on whatever your goal might be so it's certainly exercises that sustained attention muscle too at the end when you're playing the matches you are doing some spatial problem solving there is some visual spatial reasoning here because you know the opposite team's formation but you don't know exactly where on the pitch those players are going to be you don't necessarily know where who you know how strong their attackers are you do get some information though and then you're thinking okay with probability where's the best place for me to put my Defenders where's the best place to should I have more folks in the middle and fewer on the wings so there is a

spatial problem-solving component there might be some uh you know it doesn't really teach you how to be a manager of a soccer Squad but it might uh you know spark some curiosity about that job and about professional soccer I know that my son was excited to come over and play this because it came in you know a few weeks after the World Cup was just played and and he's a university student now who used to play soccer all the time and and the World Cup really brought him back into wanting to play soccer again and wanting to watch soccer again so he signed up for an adult team and he's he's working out to get fit again and he was excited to see this game and and because he's coached because he knows about managing teams because we're excited about we're Liverpool supporters in her house so we're excited about what Jurgen klopp does sometimes disappointed maybe but uh you know we love Liverpool so we've supported them for years since since uh klopp moved over from Dortmund so we are a soccer family and this was really exciting for him and for us and it might if you've if you've got a teenager who's interested in that kind of thing might get them thinking about playing soccer or about coaching or what have you learning more about that as a job Final thoughts about 11. well this is a game that I do I can't say that these are final thoughts because I played it several times but I was teaching new people each time and I don't I don't really really feel like I've got there's so much going on here this is a complex strategic game with so

many extra Advanced rules that could be added in that I haven't even looked deeply at yet other than reading about all the different things I can do I've got three expansions on the Shelf about improving your stadium and and playing an international Cup Tournament and um yeah you know they're they're hiring international players and there's little plane tokens that you're going to anyway there's there's so much going on here this is a complex economic engine builder uh that that really I think does a good job of simulating uh that that management um that management of a soccer Squad and there's a lot going on but like I said earlier you will find yourself after playing a few rounds the actions and what they do and their outcomes become more second nature the most challenging and fiddly part I would say is still the matches you really it's a bit of a brain burner a bit of a puzzle and figuring out how you're going to place your players once you've hired them and also making sure you have enough of those Fitness tokens so that you can play the players on your squad there are multiple ways that you can win you don't have to be at the top of the leaderboard but you sure don't want to be at the bottom because you'll lose points in that case maybe if you're focusing on upgrading your Stadium uh you you'll be able to get enough points to be at least close to winning and that's sort of what happened in the last game that we played

my friend unfortunately was near the bottom of the leaderboard and he lost some points but he had lots of points from the his Stadium infrastructure and from collecting staff so he had worked hard on the on the behind the scenes side but he wasn't as fortunate in his games as I was because I had lucked out enough I had those fans who were bringing money in so I didn't need to do as much with the sponsorships as he did uh so it there's multiple ways to play I think I was second I wasn't at the top of the leaderboard but it was really based on a die roll unfortunately the team that was closest to me was one of the red ones so it was a 50 50 chance if they rolled a three I was going to come in second place but I could have been first and had five extra points if it weren't for that so there's some like I said earlier there's some Randomness but I knew what was coming because the randomness other than the match consequences is a sort of limited a little bit it's a super thematic game it's got beautiful components I mean you've seen them I didn't even show you the first player token which is a referee's whistle um it's it's got beautiful pieces at least in the deluxe version we played with the play mat and you I probably have put up I haven't planned it all out yet but I probably put up a picture or two of what that play map looks like which you know if you've watched very many of these videos you know I like a play mat if cards need to be organized on a grid and they do in this game I like to have a play mat to keep those with those things straight but the components are beautiful and tactile and

it's super thematic and the way the mechanisms work together it is really telling a story which I really like the story of your team you've got that secret goal that you're working towards and you've got directors that are kind of giving you an idea of of the philosophy you might say of your team you might hire a player who you know one of the players I hired was was hot temper third and if I hired him then that was going to make one of the staff angry and one of the trainers wouldn't be available to train that week so it's just it's so interesting and we like I I think I said at at the beginning you know the first turn the Monday board meeting and the match day are meant to be played simultaneously everybody doing their own thing but we've just found it so interesting what's the story you know read the flavor text on your board meeting thing I want to hear what's happening with your team I had one instance where there was a a sneaker Club who who wanted our players to use their boots but the players wanted to use their own do their own sponsorship uh so the players would be mad but I would earn some more money and the board was Voting anyway it's very thematic and I love that there's a little story each week about what's happening with your squad and then that story might carry forward as you're hiring different kinds of staff to do different things through the game now are there downsides to 11 well even in

the few plays that I've had where like I said I was focused on learning the basic game well I think number one if you're not enthusiastic about soccer you're going to sort of lose the thread when it comes to match day if you like economic Sims everything leading up to match day might make a lot of sense to you but then you get to match day and formations and midfielders and Defenders and you know that might not make a lot of sense um this game is a table hog it is huge it took up like I said my entire table so it is really big but with those great components it's also a draw you know if you were playing this in public at a great big table people would be coming to see what you're doing because it is a beautiful game about the beautiful game um and it's complex now like I said the the mechanisms do mesh together well and it all makes sense because it's so thematic everything makes sense and once you've played through it a few times you're going to get it but I think it's a game that will be intimidating to some players if they're not familiar with these kinds of economic games if they're not players of more advanced board games they might feel a bit uncomfortable or uncertain about what to do and even when we were learning it in the first couple of games I played with new players you know you might not know like what's the ultimate strategy we're having fun playing it anyway but I was playing with people who knew about soccer and were enthusiastic about soccer I think for us

with the modular rules and the fact that everything integrates together so well that um even though it there can be a bit of a learning curve it's not as steep as it as it might look and this was a real winner in our house it's one that's going to be sitting on the table ready to be played it does take a lot of time to set up because there's so many decks of cards they didn't give me enough baggies I need more Ziploc bags to keep everything separated to make it easier but um you know the theme is a winner for us the components are so I mean everyone who played it said they just couldn't believe you could touch you know the felt on that player board when you hear me revving against the player board that's sitting here beside me um it's it's a game that I want to discover more about I'm looking forward to adding some not all at the same time but some of those expansions uh and betting on games how is that going to affect things like I'm I'm just excited about playing 11 again so I think that portal games has really come up with something special and we really loved it so there are a few like this is a first printing so there are a few things that maybe were a bit confusing so I know they've got on Board Game Geek there's a frequently asked questions document that's being edited and evaluated by the game designer so that's a good thing it's one where um there were a few grammatical errors on some of the cards in a spelling error that we notice someone

was a chef instead of a chief but you know it's this is a fantastic game so uh I think that portal games has knocked this one out of the park at least for us and I'm looking forward to playing it again if you have any questions about 11 or comments or suggestions you can leave them in the comment section below the video or of course you can email me at Brian brainsongames.ca brainsongames.c is the website that's where future episodes will go and the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time

Progress saved