Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dogfight 1917 Review: The Pizza Guy?!

Transcript 13:52

All right, question of the day. What is your favorite historical era that you don't think gets enough love from gaming? Because today we're taking a look at Dogfight 1917. I am a huge history nerd fan. I love it. Like one of my favorite things to watch besides like woodworking videos and things like that is like Cold War documentaries. No, that's not a joke. I legit love history. Um especially 20th century history. I think it's to me the most fascinating thing on the planet. First century, 20th century, to me the best. But I love history. And today we're taking a look at a game Dogfight 1917 in which you were playing a dogfight. Like it's it's what we remember besides the trenches, All Quiet on the Western Front, all that sort of stuff in World War I.

It's this kind of stuff, right? Like you think about man the airplane dogfights and how just crazy and precarious that was to have a single person fighting a single person in the air with airplanes in order to stop them from doing other damage of course to the troops, right? Um World War I is one of my favorite eras. I think it's fascinating. I think it's a humongously fascinating with all the facets that tie into it between uh even the stuff that wasn't directly involved like the Russian Revolution and all that stuff happening at the same time. So, it does any of that play into this game? No. This is a straight-up shooter game in which you're playing or a um tactics maneuver game in which you were quickly fast playing this game shooting down each other's planes. So, let's talk about Dogfight 1917 from Arcane Wonders right now.

All right, this is Dogfight 1917. You will pick a certain airplane and the opponent will pick an airplane. This is one-on-one mode. Now, there is actually I think it actually starts like this. There's actually multiple variants in the back where you can do two-on-two or Battle Royal Battle Royale, however you'd like to prefer to pronounce that. Each uh plane will get a hand of cards. You will also choose which pilot to put in here. So, in the Fokker Dr. 1, you've got Manfred von Richthofen. 10 points if you know his real, you know, moniker, the Red Baron. That's right, the pizza guy. Not the pizza guy, but well, yes, the pizza guy, but he's more important cuz he was a an ace fighter. And you get the hand of cards. Now, on your turn, you or at the beginning of the game, you will shuffle these up and you're going to start with five cards.

And on your turn, you're going to draw a card first in what we call the reconnaissance phase. So, then draw a card. Now, you can do an optional phase here of the assessment, which would be a tactical improvisation. Now, you can spend uh you can discard a card to gain another one of these tactics tokens. And I'll tell you why that's important in a minute. Then is the engagement phase. This is when you take your actions. Now, you have to must do exactly one maneuver cards. You have to have a maneuver card in here and you'll see the types of cards here. You've got evasion maneuver, there are tactics cards as well. Um but right here we have basic maneuvers, turning maneuvers, and high-speed maneuvers. Now, what you do with these, this is how you move essentially. So, this one says advance one to three spaces. Now, the arc and the front or at least the spaces on the front give you an idea of how you can move. So, if we're going to advance one, it's any of the three spaces ahead of us. Now, if we advance to this space, we would turn our airplane here to where you're facing front. Advance here, stay there, you would turn that way. Here, advance up to three spaces. So, let's say one. Now, we have these three available.

We say two, cuz that's still an advance, and three. So, you could essentially in one move like that do a slow 180. Now, it also says at the end of that basic uh or this is high-speed maneuver, turn one time as well, optional. You could choose to turn like this. Now, the reason that's important is you cannot shoot unless your red uh crosshair mark lines up with the back of their ship or the back of their plane, not ship. So, right now, let's say this was happening right here. Now, we are in a space where let's put it here and just direct. Now, we can shoot if we wanted to. Now, if we're two spaces away, there's a penalty, right? A basic attack at two range, you roll two dice and fives or better count as a hit. Now, they can choose to use an evasive maneuver if they have one or evasive action, so this would be roll roll a dice.

Threes or better uh will cancel out a hit, and then also, if you do that, you can have a chance to kind of come up and over behind the enemy like this. You know, do a barrel roll, so that's not a barrel roll, but you know what I mean. And that allows you to move there. Uh six or better allows you to do that. Now, you can evade and take a shot off if you roll three or better, but a six will allow you to do that. Um we call that a dead six, where you get right behind them. Now, once you've done a regular basic attack, you'll advance one. So, now you can do another basic attack if you want to, and you have better odds now, so it's fours or better count. Um you can again, like I said, you can evade each time you're attacked. Also, you cannot attack from the front unless you do one of your special attacks. And there are two special attacks or two special actions on each plane. Plus, you also have an action on your pilot. Now, the pilot action can be used once per game, and they're all different, and they're all really powerful. So, once you do it, you flip this over to the B side, you can't do it anymore. So, ours would be win one space from the opponent do a dead six. So, you can just flip and fly really quick.

Turn it over if we've done it. Or, you can spend the tactics tokens to do these. So, this one is the spend all machine gun. It's a range one to three, roll four dice, and threes or better hit. So, it's a really powerful thing, but you have to spend two of these. Now, if on your turn, you don't have any maneuver cards, you then crash. Essentially, you stall out, you crash. Cuz you can't do a maneuver. If you take damage, you will actually discard a card from your deck into damage pile. If your damage ever exceeds the amount when you attack if your damage ever exceeds the amount in your deck, you why that matters I'll tell you in a second. You crash. Um the reason that matters is because based on everything I'm seeing in the rules, let's just say we have four cards in the deck or five cards in the deck, four cards in the damage, okay?

At this point, when I go to draw my card, I technically have more damage in my damage deck than I do my attack, but it specifically says you crash from taking damage and your damage exceeding your hit your deck. So, just so you know, that you don't lose immediately. If you ever run out of cards, you also uh lose as well. Which is why cards matter. You're going to play until somebody beats the other opponent. And that is how you play Dogfight 1917 really, you know, simply. Now, some of the other special powers would be things like slip turn. The other thing is if you land on one of these spaces at the end of your movement, you take the tokens. So, that's one way to get tokens. The other way is that tactical uh engagement phase or sorry, the assessment phase where you spend a card discard a card to gain a tactical token. You can also change your hand out. So, you can discard or not discard, you can shuffle in a couple cards into your deck, reshuffle, and draw that many back. But, at the cost of one card. And again, your cards are your life. So, you don't want to spend too much willy-nilly, but you do have the ability to do some of these tactics cards as well. So, like killer instinct just straight gives you two tactics tokens. So, everybody's deck is slightly different, everybody's plane is slightly different, but it's not so different where you're like, "Oh gosh, I got to learn how to use this plane." Everything plays pretty much the same way.

Now again, the only thing that I'm not super clear about and maybe you guys can clear this up for me in the rules. I could not find it in the rule book. It is possible to go here in this space facing this direction. Now, if you do not have a turn um card, oh my gosh. Cuz this is optional. So, they'll say right here, "Advance one to two spaces, and then optionally you can turn." Now, you would have to do that action first, but you can't advance from here. So, I'm curious if you could just skip the advance and turn, or if you fly off the board, you're leaving engagement, forfeiting. Like, I I don't see a rule for that, and maybe I'm crazy. So, if you can help me out with that in the comments, I would love to know if you've ever experienced that. It's a really rare that you'd put yourself in this situation, but there are a couple spots where you can do this, where you're flying essentially off the board with nowhere to advance to.

Let me know what you think about that in the comments, because I could not find it anywhere. Again, it's super rare. You probably shouldn't be doing that anyway, but the game is just fantastic in how you It's simple, right? You're not having to do measurements. And that stuff's cool, right? But you're not doing like measurement grids or guides or anything like that. You just see it on your plane, which I really love that. The three arrows tell you, "Okay, I can advance to these three spaces. I can be shot from these three spaces. I can hit a special attack from the front." It's a really simplified rules of aerial combat, as opposed to like X-Wing or even Tail Feathers or things like that, right? But to me, this is such a great idea that is absolutely right for future expansions. You get four planes in the box originally. It's SPAD S.VII S.XIII, Albatros D.III, and a Fokker Dr.I, and then over there is the uh Sopwith Camel.

These are all World War I airplanes, and it's fantastic. So, if you're history buff like me, if you like this kind of stuff, this is just a phenomenal quick dogfight game. All right, that is Dogfight 1917. First and foremost, the game looks fantastic. Like, it has a certain appeal to me, like uh Memoir '44, like um the Oh, what are those other game Undaunted? You know, even though it's not the same artist, it's got that feel to me. And maybe there's something about it I just really enjoy almost the lighter colors. Like sometimes we go too dark and we And to get it right, that's that's even a weird thing to say like, "Oh, war is not shouldn't be too dark." Well, it is. It's horrible. War is always horrible, but too dark, right? But, I think there's something about this of like, "Let's explore this from a not like fun cutesy way either, but more of like an academic way." Like we're looking at this of almost like we're playing battle maps and planning stuff out. So, to me, I think that's a really good. The game looks great. The planes themselves look good. These are ripe to be painted. I think, you know, keep the colors and stripes in there, but like I really kind of want to paint these planes. Uh the mat looks good. I really like the quality of the bases and the the fact that the acrylic has the arrows on them and the front arcs and all that stuff. It could have just been embossed or debossed or whatever the right one is.

But, it wasn't. It's painted on there. And to me, that's a such a good thing because one of the things that gets a little tricky with new players to this genre cuz Carla played this and she has never played um you know, X-Wing. She's never played tail tail feathers. She's never played any of those games like this where you're flying and moving and continuing to move, right? You're not staying still. So, having the fact that it's hex based and then okay, if I'm facing this direction, these are the two places I can turn on your player character, to me, that's so cool cuz you can look right down and go, "Oh, I know where I have to go next." I think that's such a good thing to be able to have that. So, as far as the gameplay itself, the simple fact that your deck is your life is your actions. I love that. It's very simple. And to me, I don't know that I've ever seen a mechanic either of on your turn if during taking damage, you take more damage in your damage deck than you have in your deck, you are shot down. That's a really cool mechanic, too, because you could be the limping along not taking damage necessarily. You could be spending your cards, discarding cards, or whatever and still be really really in rough shape, not have a maneuver card. That's another way to lose. But, you could have a maneuver card and still play that skating it down to the very wire much like a dog fight. So, to me, I think the way that this is abstracted, right, is actually thematic. It's a thematic abstraction. And that's weird to even say, but it is.

Dogfight 1917 gets a 9 out of 10. Absolutely love this game. The only way I don't give it a 10 is just because and and and if you can show me the rulebook where it says this or what to do in the event of, I will hear it now. It'll be a 10 out of 10. But the notion of like there's no rule for how do you turn around? Again, you could use a turn card, I guess, but there are I never found one that would let you just turn on its own. You're moving. You're on an airplane. So when you get to those edges of the board in those few spots that you can get where you technically would fly off the board like if I missed it, it's a 10 out of 10. If I didn't miss it, it's the only thing I'm dinging it for. Because it can happen. Like you're trying to run away, you're trying to navigate. It's like, well, what's the point of even being in that space if I can't turn around, can't get out of it, right?

Other than that, the game is fantastic. It's a gorgeous-looking game. It's a fun game. It's a really fun game. Like I think that gets lost in this hobby a lot of times is the word fun. Like man, we at some of the events and things we go to, it's like I love gaming. I love people who game, right? That's the the big hoodie we did this year for the merch store was, you know, Dice Tower, it's Tom's phrase. It's all about the people who play game all about the board games and the people who play them. Sometimes I think we lose the fun when it comes to this online discourse. Somebody will be in the comments below telling me what I did and didn't do right. And I get that. You you have license to do that. But I think we lose the fun part of gaming. And this game is just fun. It's a fun game. So, I'm Brian Drake here on the Dice Tower. Make sure to follow us on Instagram at takesbydrakes and the dicetowerstore.com.

And I'll see y'all this week at Gen Con. Come say hey at the booth. I'll be around for some back at Gen Con in a couple years. I am super pumped. So if you see me, come say hey. Let's talk. Let's chat. All that stuff. So, see you soon.

Hey, everybody. Thanks for watching another video from the Dice Tower. Hey, do you want to learn more about us, communicate with us? We have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with the Dice Tower. You can find that in our link tree link below. So, just click that, it will take you, and you can communicate with us on Facebook, join our Facebook groups. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of the Dice Tower.

Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Vasel.

Progress saved