Dogfight: 1917 Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Dogfight: 1917
Reviewers generally treat Dogfight: 1917, published by Arcane Wonders, as a quick and enjoyable First World War air combat game with a distinct identity. The Dice Tower gave it a 9 out of 10 and called it a fun game that the hobby sometimes forgets to value. Tabletop Turtle placed it ninth on a list of team-based board games and argued that it works best with as many people as possible. Rolling Dice and Taking Names scored it a 7, praising its chase-based play while noting that it is not especially accessible. Board Stupid discussed it as a streamlined, accessible title that had been well received in the Korean market before Arcane Wonders brought it West. The one note of caution came from Board Stupid, which said the host was skeptical of the four-player mode until it had been tested.
Core Mechanics That Define Dogfight: 1917
Card-Driven Hex Maneuvering
Movement is the center of the game. Each turn, a player must play exactly one maneuver card, and each card shows the spaces a plane can advance and when it can turn. The Dice Tower explained that a basic maneuver might let a plane advance one to three hexes, with an optional turn at the end, and that a well-chosen card can even execute a slow 180-degree turn in one move. Rolling Dice and Taking Names described the turning rule as a 60-degree change when a plane moves into a side hex, which the hosts noted was easy to misremember. Because a player who cannot play a maneuver card crashes, the hand itself becomes a constraint on positioning. Reviewers consistently tied this system to the feeling of a real dogfight, where planes keep moving and cannot simply hover.
Your Deck as Your Life Total
Damage in Dogfight: 1917 is handled by cards rather than tokens. When a plane takes a hit, the player moves a card from the draw deck to a damage pile, and the plane is shot down when the damage pile grows larger than the remaining deck. The Dice Tower praised this as an unusual approach, noting that a player can be badly damaged yet still have a maneuver card and keep fighting. Rolling Dice and Taking Names added that running out of cards in the deck also ends the game, so the hand and the deck both function as the plane's health and resources. Spending cards on tactics, pilot abilities, or reshuffling therefore carries a real cost.
The Dogfight: 1917 Experience
Quick, Social Chaos With a Partner
Tabletop Turtle presented Dogfight: 1917 as a tactical party game that is strongest with a full table. The reviewer described a 30-minute match in which a team tags up to pursue a single enemy, and argued that coordinating with a partner adds depth rather than reducing it. The same review placed the game alongside Gas Lands and Thunder Road as examples of beer-and-pretzels games that still reward planning. Board Stupid framed the four-player option as the real test of the design, although the hosts were not yet convinced it would work well.
Tense Cat-and-Mouse Gambling
Reviewers repeatedly emphasize the tension of the chase. Tabletop Turtle described each decision as a bet: a player can turn wide to reach the enemy's rear or cut in tight and risk stalling. Because a player must predict an opponent's next move, even the opponent's turn stays engaging, and a successful risk produces a strong payoff. The Dice Tower made a similar point, describing the game as one where a player can skate down to the wire, much like a real dogfight.
What Makes Dogfight: 1917 Stand Out
Production and Painted Artwork
Production is one of the most frequently praised aspects. The Dice Tower highlighted the lighter color palette, which avoids the grimness that often accompanies war games, and admired the hex mat and acrylic bases, where the firing arcs are painted onto the plastic rather than embossed. Rolling Dice and Taking Names rated the production in the 7 to 8 range and noted the biplane standees. Board Stupid called the game beautiful and said it looked fantastic on the table.
Movement Shown Directly on the Plane
The clearest praise concerns how little measuring is required. The Dice Tower noted that the arrows on each plane's card show which spaces it can advance into, from which spaces it can be shot, and where it can make a front attack with a special action. The reviewer contrasted this with the measuring grids and guides used by X-Wing or Tail Feathers, calling the design a simplified version of aerial combat that suits a 30-minute game. Board Stupid similarly described the rules as streamlined and likely to be accessible.
Potential Drawbacks
Turning and Edge-of-Board Gaps
The most specific criticism concerns what happens when a plane runs out of room. The Dice Tower could not locate a rule for a case where an optional turn follows an advance that can no longer be completed, or where a plane would fly off the board. The reviewer scored the game a 9 for this reason, saying it would be a 10 with a clear answer. Rolling Dice and Taking Names also found the turning system difficult at first, calling the movement purposely cumbersome in the way real planes are. The hosts said that the rule became manageable after the first game, but they still rated accessibility lower than the other aspects of the design.
Reliance on the Luck of the Draw
Because every maneuver depends on the cards in hand, a poor draw can limit options. Rolling Dice and Taking Names acknowledged that the player is at the mercy of the draw, but pointed to the tactical improvisation option as a partial remedy. A player can discard a card to gain a tactical token and shuffle cards from hand back into the deck. The reviewers believed that this helps, though it costs a card, and a player must weigh that cost against the card's value. The Dice Tower also described the card economy as tightly connected to survival, so a weak hand can quickly become a serious problem.
If You Enjoy Dogfight: 1917
Reviewers consistently point to X-Wing as the closest point of comparison for movement and the feel of pursuit, with Rolling Dice and Taking Names describing a similar sense of maneuvering through cards and dice. For players who want a more tactical wargame with recognizable hex-based maneuvering, Board Stupid compared the map and presentation to Memoir '44, while The Dice Tower noted that Undaunted shares its visual approach. Tabletop Turtle pointed to Undaunted 2200 Revolution as a strong team-based game in the same family, and to Gas Lands and Thunder Road for fast, competitive play with partners. Top Gun fans will recognize the same spirit of high-speed aerial rivalry that Tabletop Turtle invoked when describing the game's celebratory moments.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"The simple fact that your deck is your life is your actions. I love that. It's very simple."
— The Dice Tower
"That's the cool thing about this game is that every action you take feels it feels like a gamble. You know, do you turn wide and attempt to get behind the enemy or do you do you cut in tight and risk running out of maneuvers and stalling?"
— Tabletop Turtle
"If you've played X-Wing, y'all, it's going to have that kind of X-wing feel. You're playing with cards. You know, you're rolling some dice and everything. You're trying to position. So, it has that feel, but you are reduced to this hex grid."
— Rolling Dice and Taking Names