Undergrove Underdelivers - TCbH Review
Transcript
since her smashit debut wingspan Elizabeth Hargrave has been one of the most in demand designers in the biz working with numerous Publishers and cod designers to bring about games with Innovative mechanics and a strong emphasis on naturalist themes including aeg's most recent strategy release undergrow a game of mushrooms and trees and cubes and cubes and cubes and discs and some cardboard pieces here or there to make a more verdant and more sustaining Forest deep in the forest fungus and trees live in symbiosis relying on the nutrients and chemicals provided from one to another to grow and flourish your job is to establish saplings at the intersections of mushroom tiles placing and expanding those sapling roots to utilize the mushroom abilities they point to and have access to their sweet sweet C carbon for absorption both climbing the carbon track for benefits and ultimately triggering the end of the game but also growing your tree so that its roots can fully count for Pine conb points at the end of the game tets consists of a single action often flipping one of your four flavors of mushroom activation dists and spending pottassium nitrogen phosphorus and carbon to create new saplings expand Roots The affir Mention absorption of carbon using the abilities of mushrooms your tendrils touch or rest ing to
reactivate all four discs and generate some spare carbon cash solo plays effectively the same but the adjustable AI deck drives two competitors that largely consolidate resources takes up hot sapling spots and populates the board with more mushroom tiles and carbon for you to consume in either case once someone tops the carbon track and caims a little tasty reward one more round is taken in most points by way of tree tips touching Mondo mushrooms and points from Bonus scoring cards randomized and fulfilled throughout the game wins so here's the scoop with undergrove I went in really wanting to like this game like I was legit excited about it it's got a cool theme an interesting designer and the transferral of resources via abstract cubes and the smog likee accumulation of said resources is so my jam and the commitment to Wood and paper based products in the packaging materials and insert is right up my alley and I just found it okay like totally functional but just fine strategically aesthetically it's well put together but just okay which feels doubly disappointing when otherwise you expected it to be a really great don't get me wrong there is some originality here and some albeit clinical levels of fun to be had and the packaging is very
commendable but overall the game just feels kind of bland take actions almost all actions are in exchange of these tiny cubes swapping colors for other colors and the colors don't really have any Identity or thematic foothold of their own yeah each is associated with a different action but because of the pretty neutral exchange rate and that aside from carbon these cubes are all produced in essentially the same way there's nothing really to grasp on to or to care about they don't feel like they're unique resources that you're juggling or investing in they're just more cubes that you happen to accumulate and happen to spend same is true with the mushrooms four different types four colors of action icons to interact with them but almost all of them are just clones of a couple different types and different mushroomy colors which in a more streamlined and focus game wouldn't be an issue but this is a meteor game with loads of text rules and abilities propounding depth but my experience it's just flat there are more and less efficient ways to play the game and good sequencing can result in rarely having to rest but it's perfunctory rarely feeling creative cunning or dynamic the strengths for the game lie in its commitment to ecology both in representation where clearly there's research to back up the systems on display and again in the packaging and the Solo System is a thoughtful implementation of the game so if someone did find this to be right up their
musher me alley this would be an easy game to recommend even if you were planning on playing primarily solo but for me it just doesn't make the cut so in spite of loving some and at least liking most of hard Graves prior work and generally getting geeky about naturalist themes and midweight Euros being my gaming comfort food undergrove just never gave me enough to care and as such I don't think that it's going to be finding a spot on the shelf and that's our review but let me know what are the games that you went in really stoked for but it just for whatever reason didn't do the thing for you or you loved the designer's prior work and for whatever reason it did not sing put it in the comments and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting thanks for being such an awesome Community you know that I've been jacked for the cardboard Herald