Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 141: Pablo Clark on The Old King's Crown

Transcript 1:13:56

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond solit podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to some amazing things their next game hydr logic cycle is scheduled to come to Kickstarter on March 26th clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course classroom game design yes we can will be taught by one of my absolute favorite teacher Gamers Dr Christian hints it begins on March 4th and you should definitely sign up for it I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com beon soliter thanks to listeners like you I've been able to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to to streamyard and more but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davids from beond soliter and I'm here in the Pod this week with a very special guest uh this is Pablo Clark he is from Eerie Idol games a new publishing house and he is the designer and artist for old king's crown which s which was successfully crowdfunded this year how you doing Pablo I'm very well I uh I've been enjoying the post campaign uh was still very much working on the game so uh I've been enjoying that and uh yeah it's just been it's been an amazing uh last six months so uh I'm I'm still high on that fantastic so I kind of want to talk about um I think your career trajectory is really interesting so you are now essentially a full-time board game designer and publisher yep and artist but you started

your career in video games yeah so want tell us a little bit about your dark past and then we can and then we can get into the board game very selective about what dark past bits I share um so uh I was freelanc artist for years and then I uh I did a lot of work in video games Main in uh AAA video games um and which is is a great space there lots of very interesting things and it was it was a great uh education about uh learning things with high state there's a lot of money involved there a lot of pressure there big teams uh it's a very exciting one um but uh when this opportunity started to present itself I was really excited to kind of jump on it um and it the way it came about was I started working on this game as a as a little passion project and then it grew arms and legs and then grew more arms and legs and became like from the thing or something um yeah so that's that's how I ended up uh what I'm doing now fantastic um in your personal gaming life uh would you say that you were always more of a board gamer or a mix you also like video games what do you what's your actual like gaming life off the clock look like good question um I've I've got this thing about games I I really love uh

what I term like PlayStation 2 uh style games which are what I mean is that was an era of of video games where they were super ambitious um but but but not uh not not so tied down by the obligation to be like Photo realistic or to so they could experiment with these much weirder ideas um and still get made and still get funded was much harder to fund games now and it doesn't mean that there aren't incredibly interesting indie games out there but I just mean it was this very specific kind of strangeness and jankiness so I I really like that in games um I play a lot of solo games even though um the all Kings Crown is is although it has a solo mode and a good solo mode I think I hope um it's you know it's it's like a really social game there's a lot of bluffing and there's a lot of like um misdirection and things like that um so yeah I like I like those kinds of games I like complicated games um and I think there's probably huge holes in my uh in what I've played I think I think sometimes it's quite useful to preserve a little bit of naivity when you're making something um because not ignorant I think you should like you should look things out but sometimes not having the full shape of something means that you think about things in a

different way and that can be really useful um so yeah I've probably got big holes in my in my gaming knowledge um and I I like falling in love with a game I think that's really important like I like I've I've just I've just narrowed down my game collection to 25 games whoa that's brutal cut yes um now some some of them are going in storage so I haven't quite made that final but it it was a really interesting process and I did it and I did it on love alone I didn't I didn't try to to sort of um or actually that's not true it wasn't all love some of it was just I'm I'm the most interested to play this there's a few games in there I've never played and I I just I'm just like that's what I want to play I I just asked myself that like just do I want to keep these and everything else if there was some doubt you just go just go straight um so that's been really interesting I'm really excited I'm the most excited about about um my game G collection uh than I've been a very long time uh there's too many games recondo your board games there just too many it's too many uh there not enough time and there there's too many games oh God there's never enough time never never to do all the things that I think both of us want to do um but you know I want to talk about old king's crown I was really impressed with the Prototype um I'm excited for it and for whatever you'll

do next but where did the idea for this game come from because on one hand it feels so familiar like there's lots of sort of fantasy things that make sense in there and different ways for factions to interact that makes sense but you know just if you kind of have any background of like reading history or reading fantasy or having like generic ideas about how people interact and there's also little twists in there that really feel specific but to what I don't know so yeah so so well it's probably important to acknowledge like uh uh bias or or um environmental factors so I grew up in a place called uh when when we moved to Scotland from Spain grew up in a place called the kingdom of f uh which has you know there's like I'd grew up in a little village and there's a ruined Castle in that Village and you can walk around the ruined castle and the little village is surrounded by woods and that was that was my childhood just spent in like the woods and R castles so there's a kind of inate um uh like love and and fascination with with with that um and then as far as as far as fantasy and history and so there's a writer called mvin Peak who who's also an illustrator and somebody who admire a lot and he wrote a series of books called Gorman

Gast about this oopi um social hierarchy that exists in this kind of unending Castle so the castle is never really defined it's it's as big as you want it to be kind of thing and it's about how a character comes up from the kitchens and sort of upends the whole social order and how the the monarchy which is so so um hung by its own Traditions has no way of adapting to it and and and the the the castle kind of comes apart so that was a huge huge book I mean there's three books in the in in the series but what I like about it as well is it's it's fantasy but it's not it's not heroic and it's not like like the the nobility are they're not even cruel it's not even as simple as that they are just very strange and flawed people um all the characters are and I think that that to me is interesting that I think a lot of fantasy presents and a lot of historical fantasy presents these kind of heroic ideals um which are enjoyable and they're fun to play around with but they just interest me less and so I think the game is about um it's about like factionalism

which is a h huge thing in in in the UK as well this stratification of society based on based on these kind of uh social classes that are baked in you know if the if the the American dream is that you can you can totally subvert and upend you know where you came from and that's the the like ideal that's of striven for then the UK doesn't doesn't work like that you know at least at least not historically and it kind of Embraces its state in a lot of ways um and yeah we were talking just before we started filming there as well about stories and about I think that's the other big point of it is that the game has all these named characters but but in a way a bit like history which is well when exactly did this happen because maybe those in those vagaries we don't know and and were they good or were they bad you like the the very open of the the kind of the description of the game presents two kings one like a miserly tyrant and one who died surrounded by the love of his of his you know um peers and so which one is it I I don't know I mean you know I have my own I have my own thing but I'm not interested in in in telling that to people that's not that doesn't interest me at all and it doesn't interest me that the kingdom has a name that doesn't interest me name characters

are useful because it we can ab the with a with a sense of character in that moment that's useful but like their direct relationship to each other or ages or things like that none of that interests me um Vibes over Vibes over uh facts I mean if the Vibes are strong enough I think I think it is working actually Little King's crowd um so that's really interesting like a mix basically then of what you see in the world things you've read um but yeah that's that's a really cool Insight that I'll kind of take like the next time I play that game and kind of look for look for what it makes me feel like to run across a named character yeah yeah yeah like him no you you uh you are very qualified to talk about history in a way that I'm absolutely not so and and for me history of swirls about me like like I think that that's like myth and Legend and history I'm at my happiest considering history when it's all soupy and swirling together which is which is I realize is not often the way you should treat history should be like this thing happened at this time but but that that to me is is when my imagination takes fight and it's when I enjoy it the most see I actually don't know so the thing that's interesting about history is that

I think a lot of people are taught to think of it as a set of dates and like facts but what it really is is a way of interpreting what we have which is often not a whole lot um you know we we never have as much evidence as we want especially as you move further back in history and so sometimes all you have is Gossip that people told a hundred years after the fact sometimes um you have a building but there's no explanation for who it was but like maybe there's some cool wall art and you're trying to figure out when this is from and like why this was chosen I mean history is really I think I think the real work of a historian is interpretation of difficult sets of facts as opposed to assembling reliable sets of facts right like I read this thing recently and I just thought it was an amazing like um uh what am I trying to say amazing like almost like logic puzzle which is the they determine or one of the metrics that they use to to determine stability um in I don't it it was it was somewhere in in in the UK I was it was and it was I don't know what year but the it was the frequency or the closeness of of of gold hordes being found and and the the difference in times because the idea being that you would the currency would be active if it

was if it was a stable time and you were more likely to bury it if you it was a period of of you you were trying to hide it from from Raiders essentially and so so they the frequency of Viking raids I think it was Viking raids or or or unrest along the coast has has been tied to to to the the like hoarding of gold as a as a kind of means to to to to protect private wealth which is which is fascinating um because I suppose the other way you could look at it and I'm sure I'm sure they've considered this and just rejected it is you would bury it in times of immense wealth because you'd be like hey it's the you know we can we can give this over to day so um I just find that very interesting and the whole idea of like rumor and gossip prevailing um you know and and and if if you want to like if you want to condemn well that's a bad example if you wanted to condemn Henry VI 6 then you should make fun of Henry the you know like the records should show that's a bad example because obviously Henry the fth was not was not um was not raged on um but yeah that's that's um yeah it's fascinating yeah I mean I'm in my favorite unit in my Latin Advanced Latin class right now which is that we're watching I Claudius and we're talking about the early Emperors and what's interesting is that some of what

we have is true to their times like we have some things that Augustus wrote or we have some records of archived letters that Augustus exchanged with people we also have just tons of gossip and a lot of times the ancient historians who compiled the work that were dependent on were not contemporaries of these Emperors chunks of their work get lost and also like we know like for example suetonius had access to archives so some of the stuff that he's reporting is like archived information but some of the stuff he's recording is hearsay and he doesn't really think to distinguish all the time for you either so you have to decide what of his reports you want to buy and what of his character what of his characterizations of these people you want to buy um and people choose differently yeah yeah like that's active history like at work and I I really enjoy teaching out to my students because I want them to feel like the uncertainty of looking back at something and trying to decide what happened like in your story right like we have gold we can kind of determine when it's from we don't actually know why it's distributed the way that it is we have yes and so you could put together the best argument but you'll never be able to go back and just like ask and so you just you just do your best with like incomplete information and I think the reason I thought old king's crown was so interesting is actually it has this in common with a lot of what leader doing now too which is I love historical games but I also love historical allegory

where we are not dependent necessarily on having to stick to history but we can still talk about it by creating a world where it's safe to talk about it because I don't know if that makes sense yeah yeah yeah I mean for me I'm very flexible with it like the there is like a people's Uprising which is which is modeled much more closely on on the social changes that went on in the industrial revolution or and there elements of like um the like um uh like the French Revolution as opposed to anything that happened in you know uh the 11th century or anything like that um and and just having that flexibility is is me to me is is is fun and interesting and also the the the idea that if you're going to tell a story about an an old place that you should it should be a a paleness of all this different information laid on top of it and some of it comes through more brightly than others and other stuff drifts away and and I think I think ambiguity is is great I love it I love it I think it's the best like I think it's the best as a storytelling thing because in ambiguity the the imagination could take as much root as as it needs to um so I I

really enjoy ambiguity in in my story tell other people I I love that personally so I I make my boyfriend crazy because I can't answer a question yes or no usually because I'll be like well you have to consider but I I don't know I enjoy conversations where there's not like a right or wrong answer uh because for me like the act of thinking thinking about it and talking about it is more fun than like deciding what the answer is if that makes sense yeah yeah yeah yeah I think I think you can you can learn a lot that way um just by being it it it not being totally cut and dry and I think a story really benefits from that not all stories obviously but I think I think again I think fantasy lends itself to to you you know there's lots of talk in in modern fantasy about systems of magic let's say right and to me that is completely antithetical I'm just I'm just not interested I'm not interested in in that at all um and I'm I'm not trying to condemn it's just me personally I just don't have no interest in it and it's because it it should be unknowable I think I think there's a fundamental the the interesting part for me is that it's it's magic that it is that is unknown that it's something closer to to God or or fate or like like like

whatever it's something something strange and biger than than us and and it being vague is is more useful I think more I yes I actually agree also so many scary like horror movies have been ruined for me by like too much exposition of what the evil actually is I'd rather not know actually the uncertainty is what brings out the most feeling I think so you you're talking about storytelling in the context of your game and I I like that I do think that games can tell stories and that they there's so many interesting narrative possibilities but I also think that there's like a school of well you know can a game really tell a story where do you fall on that and where do you fall on that specifically in relation to the old king's crown I I mean my opinion is is a game does not obliged to do anything like um like it's it's capable of doing whatever it wants to be I I don't think it's it's like art like I'm not really interested in defining what art is um I I think I think a game can tell any story um and I think I think the main advantage that the game has is that it has this odd mechanical component to it obviously made up of mechanics but they can they can kind of tell like an absolute truth about something so like let's talk about the all Kings Crown I'm not saying this is a great example that just comes to mind um which is attrition so to in the game there's a mechanic where there's

deck building in the old king's crown and it encourages you to to get new cards into your deck and take some out and um however unlike a deck builder if you have a run out of cards instead of cycling them back around endlessly you suffer attrition which means that you have stretched your supporters too thin you've gone too far just like a classic thing in in in medieval warfare I'm thinking like the levian campaign series of games right which like really focus in on this this idea that just the logistics of raising an army was this huge thing and in that one mechanic you can sort of Express that one idea and you make it you make the player feel that they they feel it not because you're telling them there's nothing in the cards that is saying uh uh uh watch out you know um or or you you don't need to draw everybody as as anemic and like like impoverished on the cards it's just when you run out of them it it conveys that sense so so I think I think games can can can cover so much ground because of that little spark that exists the conju between mechanism and story will the way that they rub off each other gives there's so much potential in that I think and I think leader a really good example of of um you know a company that do that or or um like I'm sorry I'm just looking at this Games Collection or um Imperium

Imperium Legends and Imperium uh Classics and the new on Horizons they they express in that game uh they have systems for all these different factions so many factions and they express themselves in different ways and it's mechanical and so you feel in that moment the like you playing that fashion and so that's covering a lot of historical ground by saying very little so yeah I like that yeah I like I I like the art of saying a lot with little so I'm not good at it I just appreciate it in others same um but yeah I think I think I think games totally totally do that and again I maybe my preference would be that they they wouldn't be so literal sometimes um and I do think as an industry we are guilty of uh telling the same stories again and again and I'm aware like I'm I'm telling a a story about medieval warfare oh that's a new one you know it's been it's been it's been done a million times um but you know that's that's as we spoke about earlier there's reasons why why I was personally interested in that um but yeah I I think I think there's definitely been a lot of very clumsy storytelling um and arguably very inappropriate storytelling sometimes and

I think that that can harm you know uh the ability of as an industry to to feel proud about the stories we can tell and to and to sort of and to show that to Outsiders don't play and go hey this is a good example of Storytelling in games well there's plenty of bad examples as well yeah I kind of feel like we're all feeling our way there over time board gaming is such a young like I mean it's old like board games have existed forever but also board games as we appreciate them now it's it's a relatively new phenomenon yeah agreed agreed oh and I was just going to say and you know the other thing is it's it's it's tied to commercialism as well you you know certain things sell so so you understand why why certain things happen and also just as a game can tell stories they also not obliged to tell stories I think that's important too you can have a game about nothing I think that's F in fact I like a lot of games that are about you know Hive is about a bunch of bugs like moving around or whatever you know and it's a great game a great design um it it does not need to does not need to say anything as well yeah yeah I think that um yeah giving people room to say as much or as little as they wish is like part of the fun yeah like like um like witchcraft that that it's a reimagining of of an

existing system the solo game that got released last year um and mechanically it's so similar to to resist but the the the juror system where where essentially the the the the Covenant female which is that you are piloting throughout the game will eventually be judged by their their their peers like the elders in the village and like it's such a neat little storytelling thing that you have this you now have this like external or so internal pressure really so you're fighting all these monstrous things and then you have this final kind of uh judgment thing and it's such a smart little it solves the mechanical problem I don't know if it's a problem that resist had which that had less of a conclusive end you just had to kind of pull the plug um yeah I mean also fitting for it for its theme of Spanish Civil War but um witchcraft kind of advances that forward then also just is really neatly you you know talks about the kind of paranoia and and his well hysteria is bad word to use but um uh the the hostility toward towards these people historically which is great absolutely so we've mentioned leader a couple of times and I know so the first time I ever saw the old king's crown it was actually when I was in I was in Minneapolis about a year ago like in

February um to play Elder Scrolls at the chip Theory offices but I went over to visit leader uh as well and I saw a copy of the old king's crown there and so I know that there has been some intertwinement in the you know between y'all what involvement did leader have in the old king's crown and how do you feel it impacted the game so they probably had more involvement than they meant to have um and that might have been because I was knocking on their door a lot um they um so to to we approached him with this game and it had a bunch of artwork already done for it and it was a mechanically more simple game um still had so much of the the the skeleton was the same so it's basically always stayed the same um this kind of bidding fog of war game about uh competing for for these resources and watching out for for for not stretching supply lines too thin so we started talking to them and you know I there was part of it that was that was you know how does this industry work how does it because I had so much experience experience coming from video games and and also animation as well so it was it was it was helpful to just know what it was that how this all ran how how how does the relationship with

Publishers work how do and you know we uh we really admire leader games' approach um to making games and the way that they conduct themselves and the way that they encourage uh um art and and like the design in the game to be to be totally intertwined and that they operate a kind of Studio system in an industry that otherwise seems to keep things quite separate at times um and so we just started talking to them and they started giving us more and more advice and then they eventually we kind of came to a sort of like a development pipeline where we we we were interested in growing the game and they were interested in seeing it grow because um they thought we could we could make it bigger and weirder um and we did we made it bigger and weirder it's better as so um but but but without them it it wouldn't be the same game because we were we were at that point we were getting a lot of interest from Publishers who just wanted to print the game they just want they just wanted the game out there essentially the artwork was looking good that was the General consensus and the game play was Snappy and and it was it was doing what it wanted to do uh for those Publishers and they wanted it out the door and leader with the one company that

went do you want to work on this for another year you know and uh and we we did I mean we absolutely did we had spent enough time on it that we knew that we wanted to to to make it right and that's what they really instilled in us and and even even to this day day like we had a CO call with Cole uh a couple weeks ago we' got another one this week coming up and a lot of his guidance and advice is still at the Forefront of our minds when when it it felt like we've had this amazing mentors in our Corner um and there's been other people in the industry who who've been like that as well it's been it's been wild just the the the support and not so much like video games video games is a bit more it's been a bit more ruthless at least in in my experience um and this has been much more nurturing um in a way that's really really amazing that's awesome so speaking of kind of the intertwining between art and game uh one thing that makes old king's crown so interesting is that you are its designer and you are its artist um how did those processes work together for you and like did which came first do you do you think of images that then need mechanisms to kind of bring like how do you or do you do you like how does how does it work I'm a like that's my job I've always been an

illustrator that's that's what I do but it mechanisms first like like the the game was was um on bits of card for years for years it existed in fact it was called super warar and it was just it was just it was the most um it didn't even have a theme it was just it was just that was funny to me and and it was it was um it had it had no kind of theming beyond that um and then then when we we played it and the the Prototype had gotten so written on that it was completely illegible what it was that that the cards even did anymore because we've written on it so many times that's when we knew look we wanted to make the game so we've been playing it for for for years at this point and the the play testers were getting bigger and bigger the group and so we um we we just started doing that and then from then we we started giving it a theme um and and it was always right from its very conception because it was was like a we we first designed with a normal deck of cards it was its very first conception was called like the the Four Courts or something like that and it it had the castle the Harvest field and the the necropolis and and and then it was called yeah I went through a bunch of things but basically what I'm trying to say is had like a vague theming of like supply lines and things like that

um but then the process of creating art for it is like um I think it's so fundamental because even if it isn't informing the mechanics necessarily it started to inform the the feel of the game so so we knew we wanted to make this this we took about nine months to make the art style um and in that time there was like five different art styles that we that we employed we could have gone with any of those but I think the one that we went with was was the right one so being allowed the luxury of time I think made this ultimately much better and that was one of the great things about being the designer and also being the the the the artist is I could I could tell the person running the project the to to shut up for a minute and let me let me it was me uh let me um figure out how to draw it and you it's much harder to do that if you are a freelancer who's brought in for three months to do you know 60 drawings in a certain way um again there's nothing wrong with most of my career has been like that on video games but um yeah this is such a a luxury and I think It ultimately made the game much much better because over time we could just start to develop this world so it started to move away from just being uh like a proxy of a medieval world and it started folding in these

ideas of of palm sest history and storytelling and of strange obscuring of different eras of time and uh um we we I could start to to be to be to question my own biases and my own the inate biases that we have so for example um you know uh the the game is gendered right at the gates it's called the all king's crown who's competing for this crown and how can we maybe uh have fun with with with um who is a strong character in the game what does strength mean in the game and what what does and it allowed us to I didn't want it to make it too martial so there's not very many weapons in the game and there's not very many um like like there hasn't much direct violence and there's some but it's implied um yeah like for for example there's war machines each faction has a war machine it's overtly um a kind of you know a weapon but the one for the uprising which are like this secret kind of uh faction all about trying to undermine the the power their war machine is somebody uh University lecture pointing at a Blackboard full of sketches of potential war machines and then the the flavor text says something like you know I hope we'll never have to deploy these or something like that and so there there's

a fun kind of I could have just drawn a big tank you know I could have but instead it was it's fun to let that stuff percolate and that's the luxury that's that's the best thing about this and I've gotten much better as an illustrator as a result because I just got to hang out in this world um I'm still hanging out I mean I've got lost lost to draw to draw oh man uh so this actually this is fascinating I am really looking forward now to like looking very carefully at the art for this game when it arrives in its final form um and I want to Circle back talking about art and games because you have some very welldeveloped opinions about it the other thing I want to mention is that so you said that you felt like your game is now in a good place it's had some kind of post uh Kickstart um growth so what has happened since the last time I checked in with the old king's crown and what's gonna what's gonna surprise me when it shows up at the door so the we um I think I think I think the big thing about this experience has been a lot of like learning so at at its at its um at its smoothest we've had a bunch of people helping us like leader games helped us a bunch and for the logistics of the game um you know I think everyone would be relieved to know that I'm not coordinating the the logistics of the game because your game

would never arrive right that's it's not we have like an independent company doing that so there's it's been really useful learning you know what you're good at and when you're not good at and one of the things that that happened was this game has been play tested for years and then with leader games it went through this whole other testing thing where we were pulling out wires and like changing things and it it was amazing um one of the things was I didn't really know how to manage a community so that was a very interesting thing we had a huge influx of people who all got like you know very strong opinions some of them very good opinions and very very like valuable even if I don't necessarily agree with them and so the the I was definitely guilty of um in real time fiddling around with the game while we were running the campaign and and doing things because there was some fundamental things with the system that were really close but were just not quite right and then so the game probably went a little bit backwards as the as the campaign went on because I was tuning it in in weird ways and the faction balance got got real kind of goofy for a while um but uh the when we could finally step back that made a huge difference so so we we just had a little bit of time and uh and then in that we got to solve these final issues that we've been talking about and

um the the the big one is um the gamers are kind of All or Nothing uh and it always had this in design it's really important it drives the conflict in the game but we've given a way to access the most exciting parts of the map and the play area through a kind of consistent means so it means each winter you can move forward your game State and it was just a revelation it was an absolute Revelation it all the rules were there it's not like we we we were right new things what it that stability meant that your long-term planning could increase dramatically it meant that you it's almost like there's like a little bit of a Euro game happening there now because it's it's pretty consistent and that meant we could expand those things so before for example um I promise I'm going to start rambling but um you you you could gain cards from your sight of power and most factions only had one or too and the reason was you could it was limited by how many times you could actually get in there um because it was tied to a region you were competing for a region and then you could get into these things right so it meant that those cards were burdened with having to do a lot because they had to be so powerful in the late game that they felt important that you got them but they but they couldn't be so powerful that if you managed to play really smartly in the early game you

would whitewash everyone CU you would just you just have this car that you could keep like pulling round and round um so as soon as we added stability to the whole thing it meant that now everybody is is competing on equal terms now if you want to expediate that you can still you know really try and focus in on the top region and that you that was still move you forward and it meant we could also so now there's more cards there because it means you can get more so now there's much more of a a deck building element and we can do that because it's stable um and it's the same with the court the court used to be this binary anything you held the court or you didn't hold the court got Advantage if you held the court didn't if you didn't have it well now that more people can get in it becomes we've turned into these councils so three councils each one of them going a special ability and it means that you now are running the Kingdom so you might have the Council of uh steel or the Council of masks and it lets you do different things and the reason why we can do that is because everything's more stable and it was such a was such a small thing and sometimes in design I'm sure you've experienced this as well you just I didn't I mean obviously we have tested it so much but as the moment I wrote it I was like oh this is I I don't this is done this is good this is this this St I know this St um so yeah it was it was like a huge Revelation and uh and I I cannot believe it took me years to reach it you know a

better more experienced designer know I imagine would just been like hey just did that right way um I don't know I mean the more I talk to I mean I I now have like a very young designer life right but you know I think that some some things just take a minute no matter how far along you are it's it's about you know we talked about kind of creative process right you have to do the process in order to get the best result yeah yeah and and maybe had we found it ear in the process we maybe would have fallen in love with that and then we would have lost some of the the the like sharper uh more competitive element of the game so I think I think where it has landed now I'm just I'm just so excited because all all the testing has been going fantastically and it just it just creates it creates the opportunity for you to make good on expressing your because we have these asymmetric factions and I think that they've always expressed themselves well as asymmetric forces in the game and then we while developing with leader we introduced this neutral deck which is the kingdom cards and you occupy those and each one of those that's what creates the kind of various from game to game because you might be uh you might be a noble faction that it's employing a bunch of mercenaries to do a bunch of work for you and that sort of stuff or you might be running a

gambling Den or you might be you know uh you have access to a hidden library or whatever um and this felt like then the step the final step up from that which is that you could engage with these interesting parts of the world from a stable platform oh it was amazing it was amazing it was it was such a relief because I definitely I was tuning the game based on on on when we were running the kickstarter I was tuning it in some pretty weird directions and there was definitely a few a few moments you know in the shower or something like where your head is just pressed against the tiles and just going what am I doing so uh yeah it's it's it's I'm feeling a lot I'm just feeling really happy and excited I can't I can't wait for people to play that's awesome so I have one more question before we just talk art which is you mentioned so now you're full-time working with um Eerie Idol which is like the publisher that you've Co started um do you and you also mentioned that you know having time to develop things and really get them right was meaningful for making sure that you had a good game do you think that you're going to have a conflict between your desire to let things get enough breathing room and your need to keep going now that this is what you do yeah that's a great question that's a great question um I mean some of some of so much of it is tied to a

broader ambition with what you're trying to do so let's say that we wanted to take this and we wanted to then make three games in the next three years then yeah time would have to crunch time would have to contract on each project massively for that to work that isn't that isn't our ambition at all I'd like to support this game for for for the foreseeable future um it doesn't mean a million expansions I just if we stay small then the financial pressure is is is a lot less um and the time pressure is also is also a lot less um but you know we we've definitely developed skills that we would like to use uh on other projects down the line we have this idea for a game which is now I'm not saying this will happen but but but we like it a lot which is it I goes back to that thing I was saying at the start about PlayStation 2 games in that era one of the things that happened it happens still but like a game within a game you know like you you get a big RPG and then you've got you've got like a card collecting game inside that yeah like gwent inside The Witcher or something yeah I love that I I love I love the weird mental conceit that has to happen that it's like yeah you're in this medieval Kingdom but also every has got these cards and we're not sure how

that how that's quite working I love that I I just think it's great um so so we have a design that that is that is let's say you you want to play The Old Kings crme the Old Kings crime takes like an hour and a half two hours it's a big strategy game um it's it's pretty complicated game but we have this design that is the a tournament and the conceit is that the people in the world of the Old Kings Crown play this game about tournament and it's it takes like 20 minutes and you can the winner of that game becomes the first player in the in the O Kings CR so it would it would be really fun to if if this is an expansive look at a kingdom in flux over time and all this factionalism things like that it'd be really fun to then take that and zoom right in and go like well what does a single event look like in this game and the game kind of plays a little bit like the old King crme but just everything just distilled right right right right there um and we sort of love it and then we we have another design I mean we have a bunch of designs we work on stuff all the time CU it's fun and it keeps you it keeps you sort of sharp but we have this other like much more ambitious game but I would rather um work on CR um so that that's that's the immediate thing but for sure like

like pressure to to to produce stuff huge huge um so we'd rather stay small and allow this thing still to keep percolating um you know if if if we make an expansion let's say we made two factions I'd want to give it the time to to make those two factions interesting and to and to make mistakes and then hopefully correct them and to to go to have the time to go do you know what that actually doesn't that doesn't work we we put in a bunch of time on that but it's not that's not right and as soon as you start those deadlines start screwing in you start having to commit to things um one final point on that was you know when we ran the the kickstarter campaign we didn't add any stretch goals or anything like that and also some people were like this game's it's going to be the same price at retail as it is at Kickstarter and it's that's kind of expensive right we we as the buyers are paying for the for like the V for example things that these are all like business decisions but the way we looked at it was that allowed us to to insulate against Rising costs and insulate the game the the the because we're all trying to make the best game and hopefully people want to play the best game it insulates that process

enough that for example now that we've expanded the game and there isn't just one Court there's now three well that's a whole new board and and we we can make that a tuckable board I you can tuck your cards into it and why do you want to do that well it saves table space it's got like utility but it means that we priced the game in such a way that we could add that stuff on and instead the option might have been oh we've come up with this idea but we can't do it because um we run out of cash on it you know and I think that's going a bit slower and going a bit more like conservatively in in that sense I think I think it's useful I think it's useful and as we were saying there's lots of games so so many games get made and speed is is a thing and and so I I don't I don't know if we we can stay competitive that way I I don't know I don't know what what our finances look like in a few years but for right now stay small stay true uh stay on target the aim hey it's a good motto um and I sort of feel like you know you're an illustrator you're now a designer and publisher um you know and and we're talking about very real you know issues of time pressure and giving ideas enough time to breathe you know you we're also in a world where people are trying to present generative AI as a possible

solution so um I I guess I wanted to sort of talk about you know all this giving yourself time giving yourself a process um what do you think that that is doing for you that even spending a lot of time on a mid Journey query cannot give yeah so so um I think I think a a lot of this stuff is is about learning so so so um you learn on the job so so let's say you're somebody in using generative AI to make the artwork and you're maybe also make making it do maybe the UI as well so so how the information is presented well it the ability for for it to generate those images maybe a very high FID Deli and maybe as as very close approximations to to AI uh to to UI for example there two separate things uh might be really high the quality might be good I I would argue against that by anyway um not just in it terms of fidelity but just in the the feel of the thing um but even if it is really good have you learned the requisite skills to know how to put those together in in successful ways are you actually communicating information well or are you just approximating what something else has done but it's inappropriate that it's used in this way and so I've see that a lot like like you know this this this generative

AI look to games very high fidelity usually and it's like very detailed but you know the colors are like they're cooking real loud a lot of time and so it means on the table I mean we have a very busy game but I'd like to think we spent years working on it and as a result the colors are like balanced whereas this you you like I've seen games where there's no correlation between the color of the cards and the factions so you've got like these bright UI but then they'll they sink a bunch of colors into this things it's really noisy but you don't get any information either you don't know what faction you're playing as tonally it can be really weird um and all these things are just things that you can learn so I'm not saying that people you know depending on the legality I don't know how this is going to go you know the the future of AI but what I don't think that doing something very quickly even very efficiently is the same as doing it very well and there are just things there are skills that you just need to learn I'm not talking about drawing necessarily talk about understanding the tools that you're using and using them well right if if if you there there's entire industry is built around UI and there's a reason why it's because it it's it's crucial to how the game works and if you're just if if you're just taking two generated things and just plonking them on top of each other the the results are are just not they're not good and more

broadly what is it that we're buying like why is it that that I'm not sure that the argument that you know it's faster or or it can be done by more people is necessarily a good argument what is it that that we are buying here what you are buying I I I I would like to think you're buying care and consideration and time and uh all those things allow I think the thing to become better if if we had put the game out when we were talking to leader in the first place and we went with another publisher it would not be um the game is now and it would not be as interesting um that's just a fact I mean it was the game took less time you could play it quicker and it was go it it just a different different thing but it's better now it's better and the artwork has gotten better and I've gotten better as an illustrator and I think I've gotten better as a game designer as a result of of of the thing taking time and you learning as you go and this idea that we can if if you hand in an essay on on you know uh on Rome and you generated that you don't know any more about Rome right so so so

yeah you haven't Advanced you the the amount of uh essays that you need to submit in a term has advanced it's Advanced by one or as many as that you use this but you don't know any more about it and as a result you you're you're you're no more capable and isn't it like isn't one of the great things about life that you get more capable that you become smarter that you advance your understanding that you become more empathetic to people's struggles that you realize your own limitations like all these things are really important and just fundamental things about being human they're not I'm not talking about drawing or anything like that and I think all of this is just baked into that um I am very skeptical of companies at the moment in particular that are using using generative Ai and the reason is they're running ahead of the legality of it which I think I think is irresponsible um I think it's very telling as well what what they value but I think it's also just sending out this very very odd message which is um the the the we're we're going to pump this thing out we're going to pump out quickly and we we're being pretty naked about about that being what what we're shooting for here um and I just don't I just don't think it's interesting and just on a very Baseline uh I just believe in people I

just think people are more interesting um and if something was made by somebody and it's imperfect I just think that is is is just better better so speaking of people being more interesting the other aspect of your career up until now has been that you have worked for clients and produced art um according to their requests and their specifications what makes a human artist despite creative differences despite Time stuff despite the fact that people need money to live what parts of that process do you think have been meaningful uh in a way that a generative AI uh attempt at doing visuals for a game uh cannot be yeah uh I I think it's it's that same it's the same conduit point between uh like we were talking about mechanisms and story well there's a leap the the the the Live Wire has to cross has to cross that point of space and in that is where all the magic happens I think so so just two people working at odds can be can produce interesting results challenging results some of the some of the jobs that I worked on that were the hardest that that either took the longest or or were maybe most fractu produced the most interesting work because it was two people you know rubbing up against each other with interesting results um I

think that you develop new things that way I think I think think new is very um is very important because um at it at its worst a brief is purely regressive it looks backwards and it goes I want the this to be an approximation of this other thing um and the best kind of brief moves this thing forward and I think that the humans uh are great at moving things forward uh under certain circumstances and um and and that's one of them like if you just think how far a medium like film or a medium like uh board games has come um and that's being Reliant just on people's imaginations coming together so so I think I think you I think the best kind of hires for a job are often hires are to do with interest you find the person interesting you find their work interesting and that in itself is going to generate ideas for you um if you're surprised by what they're producing that can be invaluable invaluable um and it can also be useful and that you go no that is not what I want and that's useful as well because it it defines these limitting ations Define all these interesting parameters that that make for more interesting things um so so I think I think engaging with human beings like that is is really important when making things just so

important the most important thing um because it's that thing of growing together learning just invaluable yeah I think that also comes into so one thing that I worry about anytime I make anything from lesson plans to now board games um is I always you know even videos on my YouTube channel even the stupidest video on my YouTube channel I always wondering like what is it that I'm offering to other people that makes the thing that I'm putting out there worth their time because when you engage with other people like that's part of a creative process but I also think that when you put out creative work you are asking that people engage with you and I personally spend a lot of time wondering if I've made my offerings to the world worth the time mhh and I guess for me um you know it's sort of like I sort of feel like making sure that the work that comes out from me um I mean at least I really gave you something that I had myself yeah if nothing else that's that's exactly it like like I think I think at your moment of of uncertainty that that is and it's it's always um question I think you should ask yourself it's like I am asking someone's time for example I'm I'm to play The Old King CR here you've got to give me an hour and a half got to give me two hours right um that's that's a

big ask so but I think also that that that by going through some of the steps of scrutiny that we've talked about you become you become broadly more confident what you're asking for is at least at least measures up to to to what you would hope would be would be asked or be given to you if you were if you were uh on the receiving end um and in that comes a certain confidence it doesn't mean you're right and it doesn't mean everybody agrees with you people have vastly different metrics for this stuff some people don't really find that stuff valuable either they just want to play something and they don't don't really like or they want to consume something very readily very easily um but I think I think that that level of of scrutiny will help that that that feeling because I think you go yeah know at least I did I put in my time you know yeah yeah I mean I don't I sort of you know it's just like with my students like I always remind myself I shouldn't ask them to do things that I think that it's BS to do yeah because that's not good teaching they're people as well as students and then I also you know I try to give people what I would want to be given um right right and I think that you're honoring that when you spend that time with others and

you put that in it like um I don't know I don't know if I've said this before but I've always think of AI as um and this idea of of like putting time in as as an apology right like like um if if I got an AI to write an apology for me and I I said I I need to I need to I've let someone down and I need I need to write an apology and they wrote an apology and let's say that in advance I'd also written an apology and the two were identical they were absolutely identical there was no discrepancy the rude mechanics of both were were exactly the same one still means a lot more than the other um it the output is is AEL in there really it it's got everything to do with the process that went into and so that that's a pretty important distinction and I think that you would be if you were to hand over those two apologies you yourself would also feel very different about them and because you had earned one and you had you just produced another one it's two different things um so the yeah the Fidelity with which it it imitates an apology is not is not the is not the issue here it is it is the intention of the of the apology itself is that yeah yeah or you can make

it a love note same concept um so kind of moving back to something positive before you run out of time speaking of respecting people's time you mentioned earlier in the interview that you're not interested in defining art so I'm not going to make you define it in an exclusionary sort of way but what are some of the things that are included under your umbrella of what art is um that are specific to board games and also that might make people see art in a more meaningful way if they listen to this podcast then go out and look at stuff oh no oh God I think oh no that's so oh that's so difficult I it I think that art is in whatever medium is just the the thrill of something that's been made that is sparking off your imagination and that can be about almost anything but it's that it's that gap between the two things between you as the viewer and the person making it and the spark that exists between that is goes beyond function and goes beyond understanding and is closer to to to something Mercurial because I

think like in the same way the same way that like love is not a binary State you you are you you are in love but what that is can be really can really fluctuate and you can hate someone that you love and you can do it's all sorts of of Grays in there and I think art invites those those same responses so and it can be everything from from like Total Recall like a trashy film that I love or you know uh some some profound uh bit of um you know uh I don't know like like a fresco in a in a church in in in Italy right like yeah I think if it invites your imagination to start um heating up and boiling then then that's it that's that's what that's what our is and that's why it's so special when it is not about what the final result is but it is about all the little ambiguities and Imperfections and interesting ideas that are uh baked into into the thing because that allows for more of that uh more more froth between the two the two like

certain points because a certain point is just that is a painting and you are you but the response it can elicit is enormous you know and and so yes there that I think maybe I like it I like it um so just one more softy question that I asked you a tough one uh what games have you been playing recently that have been bringing you some Joy okay yeah games have been playing recently um hang on I'm going to I'm going to actually like crib this and and just look at pile um I just sorted this stuff out I sorted this pile Okay so um what have been playing well I've been playing a little game called o Kings CR I've been playing that almost exclusively yeah appears pretty good well we'll see um what what have I been playing so I've been playing um I was playing witchcraft which is very good um I've been playing oath multi-hand which is not I know that's not the way you meant to play that game I've been doing it that way it's okay it it might look a little different from what you're playing right now though yes I imagine um I was playing Renegade Ricky Royals game it's really oh yeah seem to be Deckers and it's new it is yes yes um and I was playing the original um I I tracked down a copy when we first started working with Ricky on this uh on this thing i' played it once before but I I don't really liked it but we playing that a

bunch and sorry I'm still looking St um War the ring the card game I think that's really good I've heard good things about that it's really good it's really good it it has this this great Central hook which is you just pay for cards by removing one card so Marvel Champion sort of works the same way but the economy is like so much more just binary here um and you have to play a certain number of cards you can't like carry over many cards um so it's about making the best of of what you have and either planning for the future or betting in the moment that you can win and that like C is so simple that's really simple it's like play something here and you can use it later on or do you think you can win there and then you've got to do that by deleting half of your cards or or getting rid of half them so it's so simple it could just be like a numbers game in that way but then there's a whole bunch of great like John how artwork on it there's theming is great um has a nice like kind of escalating progression it's really good I really really like it um and uh that is that's it oh and I'm I'm really excited to dive into uh plantagen the the vocal RI um actually he wasn't the designer on this but he's the designer system the

the levy cam the levian campaign game so I picked that I'm really excited to to jump into that fantastic fantastic and then if people want to uh follow you online see what you're working on hear from you where can you be found so um the best way would be to if you haven't is to sign up to the kickstar because it's uh the late pledges are open and we do regular updates there so if you haven't signed up sign up um no h but eie Idol games is the best way that you can find us and that's because it's taking up all my time at the moment um that's that's where I'm posting We have a Discord all that sort of stuff and um yeah find us there and if if people want to know about the game you just ask questions and I'll be happy to uh to um procrastinate by by answering the questions oh the truth is is finally out no kidding um so uh I can be found anywhere online as beond solitier I to am terminally online and happy to procrastinate uh but pabl thank you so much for coming on this is a lovely conversation it's been a real Delight thank you my pleasure my pleasure yes I hope we have more in the future as like more things come out from eie Idol I'd love that so everybody out there who's listening uh thank you so much please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy

gaming

oh

Progress saved