Solo Thoughts | Fallout Board Game + Expansions | Peak Emergent Storytelling!
Transcript
hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to discuss Fallout the board game by Fantasy Flight games and uh just so you know I also made a video on Fallout Wasteland Warfare which I'm going to leave a link to if you want to hear my extended thoughts on that uh and I'll also make a comparison video between the two uh between this and Wasteland Warfare uh if you're trying to pick your tabletop Fallout fix uh so when I do eventually get to do that I'll leave a link here but today we're discussing uh Fantasy Flight games approach to creating a tabletop Fallout experience okay so uh I acquired this a couple of years ago uh and I heard um that the um Atomic bonds expansion uh fixed uh the or improved upon the solo experience from the base game okay uh so uh I acquired it with all the expansions and my experience from the beginning uh has since I started the playing the game about a month ago with all the Fallout TV show craze okay decided to finally get this on the table but um I added all the expansions uh from the beginning which is something that I don't tend to do to be honest with you uh I really like typically try just playing the pure base game experience and then adding expansions um to see what you know how they integrate into the game but this is one of those exceptions I've made
because the overwhelming majority of of people feel that the atomic bonds expansion is atomic bonds expansion and how it changes the solar experience is essential okay so I'm not going to be able to tell you how the the base game experience feels with the atomic bonds expansion so my opinion will be just with every all the expansions integrated new California and atomic bonds okay all right so my experience with the game has been uh playing um the uh Commonwealth scenario multiple times which is the the initial scenario that that's suggested um if you're playing the game for the first time so that that's what I have set up here okay that's the end of the scenario okay playing with the Vault dweller character uh and I also played uh the um Capital Wasteland scenario uh so uh just so you know the scenarios are based on different entries to the video game so Capital Wasteland is based on Fallout 3 uh and uh the Commonwealth is based on Fallout 4 uh and from what I understand other scenarios are based on Fallout 1 and two and so on so there's various scenarios for you to explore but those are the two I've experienced and one thing I'll get out out of the way uh uh just playing the Commonwealth scenario which is a relatively basic scenario uh it played extremely different multiple times so I never felt bored or it never felt syy to me playing
just this Commonwealth scenario so just a a great Pro great property of the game already how varied it is from uh you know just playing the same scenario very varied extremely varied so I like that um so yeah that's me my experience with the game played that multiple times and I also played uh controlling the majority of my games were just controlling one one character I also played a couple games controlling two characters so one cool thing about this game is that it lets you play with just uh it lets you play with just one character which for this adventure in games uh I usually uh I um I much more prefer playing with just one character um there's um a couple RPGs like party based uh games I'm okay with controlling multiple characters but um for these adventuring games to give you other examples runebound um Gloom of kill forth um I I just much more prefer controlling one character um uh but um certain scenarios you might be uh you might be a bit um motivated to try controlling two characters because it might uh really leave some of the pressure so let me explain what I mean by that so uh when you add the atomic bonds expansion the game goes from a competitive uh game uh which in the base game expansion you um there's some modified rules to get around the competitive development for you to play
solo uh some people feel that that might it might have been a bit of an afterthought um but some people enjoy it but anyway with the atomic B expansion it it makes the game truly Co-op and uh solvable and uh what it does is it changes the scenario parameters right so in the base game expansion you are supposed to um or you have the ability to as the scenario progresses you can change Al allegiances between factions so there's a faction element here when you do the quests right so uh with the atomic bonds expansion you have to pick a faction to align yourself to from the beginning okay uh so uh what that does is with this Atomic bonds sheet uh there's two sides so you set up the scenario the same way you would in the base game but now you use this sheet to keep track of the scenario progress okay so uh you pick your faction from the uh beginning okay uh and then uh and then you stick with that fraction for the duration of the scenario um and uh so you pick you stick with that faction for the duration of the scenario so uh it kind of puts you on uh so in when you complete quests you have to only com in order to progress towards the victory conditions you you can only um do quests uh because you have choices for the quests right as you can see here uh so you have to only do quests that complete Quest objectives that benefit that
faction okay but I'm okay with that some people uh say that the the ability to change allegiances in the middle of the game and that Dynamic is lost here I don't really mind but I have heard a couple people say that it's it's a bit of a bomber that that Dynamic is lost but uh again I have not played the game without the without any expansion so I I can't speak to that but I'm okay with this uh what this also does is it it increases replayability because now you essentially have two scenarios in one so you go from having one scenario with Dynamic and now you have you get to pick the faction from the beginning so that that increases the reply ability so I I like that I don't mind that now uh speaking of the quests so uh one really cool thing this game does so um I if you don't know if it's not already um evident so there is an adventuring game okay uh so you're going to pick your character you're going to move around the uh you know there's an Overland element you're going to move around explore so there's an exploration element uh you're going to level up there's the RPG elements you're going to level up your character you're going to gain loot allies perks um you know currency there's even even a bit of um uh with the expansion content there's a bit of a um working on um like your settlement type situation so these are uh workbench cards that you gain by completing U you know quests uh that Grant you U you know uh
something along something that it equates to uh working on your improving Your settlement um from the video game all right uh it grants you it can grant you some pretty powerful um booms all right when you do that but uh so yeah you're going to gain your cards allies you're going to explore the land complete quests so when you pick a scenario there's going to be a starting quest line but as you explore uh and you know you encounter locations uh other quest lines are going to be added so uh there's these Decks that you're not supposed to shuffle you're you're supposed to keep them in um numerical order and every time it Quest uh instructs you to stage one of these quests you're going to put them in this area and those are going to be quests available for you to tackle okay and typically when you finish one of the options when you complete one of the objectives so most quests are going to have uh two two options and uh when you you know whichever one works out for you at the moment maybe you don't want to have combat maybe you want to choose the non noncombat option for the Quest right so uh you're going to pick your quest uh objective completed and then it'll instruct you to Stage other cards um and you know so it'll be this Quest chain that you continue so um I really really like this uh and I know I I experienced this from the Skyrim board
game which I know that they actually took from this uh so um it's a bummer that I didn't end up liking Skyrim uh I much more like this game uh but this is just such a cool element so one thing I want to go ahead and say is just I think this is one of the most amazing storytelling um sandbox tabletop experiences that I've played uh the way that the the emergence stories that it tells is just so so good at that um uh so uh you know as you explore these quest lines are going to come up uh funny like situations are going to happen with like your companions uh or um or the uh you know if you decide to play with two characters uh the the the type of board stays that can occur with enemies chasing you around the board and the exploration the radiation uh there's so many little elements here that um just it it lent itself for creating awesome emerging stories one of the best in in the in this category of adventuring games and I think a lot of it is is thanks to this okay because a lot of these adventuring games um they'll have they'll be more a bit more mechanical and they'll have they'll have a bit of flavor text but um the there's just some and that really is it like there'll be some like you know you'll gain an armor or complete an event there'll be a bit
of flavor text and that's it but these Quest cards uh they just add that magic like it's like that magic like uh X Factor or right or like that magic touch that these the quest line cards that evolve as you progress is just great how it creates these emerging uh stories all right and like I said I played this Commonwealth scenario multiple times you know siding with both factions and it could have not played any more different every time uh just from the um uh from just the loot that I acquired uh the character that I picked uh to cuz I I played with multiple characters uh the enemies that that were drawn to the board um so just great great storytelling um device right uh just one of the best emerging storytelling uh tabletop experiences I've had now I do have a couple issues um and one of them is um I've I've never had this issue with a um Fantasy Flight game this is like a a first for me with a Fantasy Flight games product but um learning this was a bit miserable um and especially like with adding all the expansions uh learning this I I had such a hard time learning this because the expansion content adds um they add some rules that modify the base game rules so you're going to you read the base game learn to play right and then you read the expansion and then you have to unlearn something that you read from the
learn to play uh and then so there's just so many uh things that you have to like unlearn without even having trying them if you want to play with the expansions from the beginning right um which everybody recommends but also um uh there's so many little rules that are easily missed this is one of there this this is one of the worst examples of this that I've encountered with with with the many board games that I've played there's so many rules that are easily missed or can be misinterpreted or or nebulous uh it took me it wasn't until these last couple games that I played where I I felt like I played correctly and it's okay it TS to many such cases with when I played the first couple of games uh over a board game lots of rules mistakes but wow I had so many rules wrong the the first time I played like you're not going to be prepared just from playing just from reading the rule book once uh I'll tell you that now not even closers so many important rules that are or details that are omitted from playing from just learning off of the learn to play booklet okay just be be prepared to very carefully study the rules reference and the learn to play and then when you add the expansions there's just so there's just so much I had to create a cheat sheet for it which I'll link uh but yeah this was very very tough uh to
learn properly uh it's a very obtuse rule book and we're very weird learning experience um and I have never had this experience with a Fantasy Flight game uh typically this um learn learning experiences with the every Fantasy Flight game that I've experienced has been pretty spotless has been great great rules reference great um Great learn to play uh but here uh I feel that this could have this could have been a bit more time this could have spent a bit more time in the oven uh and a lot of people feel that way a lot of people feel that um Atomic bonds kind of it's like this patch that they added to the game to um get rid of the competitive element which a lot of people had ISS had on BRD with took on BRD with why is this game a competitive game so this game does have some issues definitely uh but in my case just from the solo perspective once you add all the expansions you know that's gone the competitive element so that fixes that my biggest issue is uh just The Learning Experience uh I wish there was a official um uh a official rule book with all you know with all the expansion content added and there's so irata too um there's even a a broken quest which I do mention this in my uh in my um cheat sheet there is a quest line when playing as The Enclave in uh when siding with
The Enclave in the capital westline uh capital Wasteland Quest where you get stuck basically and you can't progress so uh there is an AA there that needed to be add it so the the game definitely has some rough spots but uh it is a great great great uh storytelling device once you once you're learning and once you're aware of the ARA and all of that um it's it's a great great game combat is quick uh it's very lock dependent do keep that in mind if you have if you have um if you have really bad luck early on uh you know you could be doing from the beginning but in my experience it that really didn't happen in my multiple Place uh I didn't really have horrendous luck where I was doomed from the beginning um uh you can actually get pretty damn powerful in this game uh just from acquiring the perks on the loot the perks are amazing by the way uh they're really good they're they really make you feel like a like you have superpowers or something it's it's really the acquiring perks is awesome in this game you can pull off some some awesome stuns with the perks here um and uh one other thing is uh with the the the exploration here is not very chill uh there is a timer element uh you do have to make sure that you tackle the main quest uh you're not going to be able to explore at your own Leisure uh
because if you don't um if you don't keep tabs on the main quest uh you you'll run out of time really fast uh and that might be a bit disappointing uh for some people uh because they might you might be used to in the video game you can just set aside the main quest indefinitely pretty much not really the case here uh but I am uh not really the case here but um I really don't mind I mean there has to be some kind of element and the other thing some kind of timer element but the the cool thing about this game is extremely modular so you can uh I haven't played with any house rules there's infinite house rules that people have concocted if you go to borain geek there's so many house rules for catering the experience to how you want I'm not big into house ruling things I have not played this with a single house rule uh and I've enjoyed the experience fine uh it seemed really difficult the first few times but there were tons of rules that I was getting wrong uh and now that I have a much better understanding uh game plays fine with one character I'm willing to play with up to two characters the two character experience is it's it's tolerable um I don't some people play with up to three characters I think that's a been much for me too much to keep track of too much table space um so two two characters is fine for me uh sorry up to two but obviously much prefer for these adventuring games I just prefer playing one character some games it might feel that you don't have enough time uh so this is very modular uh you can either play with two
characters or you can just give yourself more actions you can um you can extend the the the track like the timer track for the for uh the faction uh you know you started uh you started a bit back here right so just instead of starting here just start here or instead of ending the game here end it here right so there's this is just extremely easy to modify to your taste uh now I don't tend to do that like I said uh so far I've had F experiences without adding any house rules okay um but uh yeah so those are pretty much uh my thoughts on this I do think that these a great I think this is a great um uh adventuring uh experience uh with it's very lock dependent but it creates some amazing emerging stories it does evoke the video game pretty well this is one thing I'll give it uh this one thing I'll give it uh now before I com do a proper comparison video between this and Wasteland Warfare uh this does evoke the video game way better than Wasteland Warfare now is it a better game I don't know necessarily uh there's both games have many pros and cons they're very different so it'll be interesting making a bit little comparison video between the two to help you choose which one is your better Fallout experience okay but uh with the expansions added uh which brings you more scenarios improves the solo experience adds more loot more enemies
more of everything more quests uh you know this is an amazing uh storytelling sandbox uh and it does convey it does um it does convey the F the spirit of Fallout The Fallout video game very well uh and with the special the perks the leveling up the loot uh it it just um it just does the it does it justice um it it does suck that the learning experience with with all the expansion content added was kind of painful to be honest with you I did not enjoy learning this and this is the first time this has happened with a like I said with a fantasy FL Games first time that's happened to me uh but yeah a painful learning experience uh rough spots it feels that they could have spent a bit more time in the oven developing this for sure uh but even with all of that uh this is one of the best adventuring games I have played really really good plays great with one character as well uh and uh yeah so that's Fallout uh the board game by Fantasy Flight games wanted to uh you know just discuss my thoughts on this and again make sure to check out my comparison video between this and Wasteland Warfare once I get around to that or in the meantime you can just go ahead and check out um the Wasteland Warfare extended thoughts if you want to hear what I have to say about that what I think of that as a solo game very interesting uh game uh in its own right not even necessarily when you know talking about the fact that it's a Fallout game this a very interesting
game in its own right so make sure you check that out uh but I want to thank you so much for watching and if you have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section and uh go ahead and like And subscribe and see you in the next one