Skip to main content
Loading video...

Forgotten Depths - A Smallish Game in a GIANT BOX!

Transcript 29:30

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive daniel here i hope you're doing well and if you're not i hope you are soon okay today we are going to be taking a look at forgotten depths if you remember a year or so ago i did take a look at the prototype of this game and it has recently started delivering from kickstarter and i wanted to thank peter the designer of the game for um sending me an extra copy and i'm giving away that copy right now on the dungeon dive patreon so i think the contest is going to be running for a couple more days once you hear this on sunday so if you want to join the patreon and have a chance to win a copy of forgotten depths uh go ahead and do that so if this game is going to be divided or this review this overview i should say this look at forgotten depth it's going to be divided into two parts first part is going to be focusing on the game and the first part is going to be very positive because i like this game a lot i think it has some interesting twists on established mechanisms on tropes on things that we enjoy from these kinds of dungeon crawl and adventure games and those twists um are just twisty enough that forgotten depths feels different even though we are participating in the same kind of action verbs exploring maps having encounters fighting bosses fighting monsters getting loot having characters even though we're doing all of those similar things that we often do in these games forgotten depths

just twists all of those things in such a way that makes the game feel a little bit unique but it's not trying to reinvent the wheel and so it's pretty easy to grasp the concepts behind the game so the first part is going to be a pretty positive look at the game the second part of this video is much more negative and it has to do with the overall production of the box and rule book for this game because yes this giant thing right here here's my hand um it's all floppy it's like almost the size of a newspaper this thing this is the rule book for this game it is the single largest rule book i have ever seen in a game for a little card game and the box is one of the biggest boxes i have seen for a game of its size as a matter of fact you might think of this as the first in a series of videos called small games in giant boxes and i'm not quite sure if there's going to be um other examples but um i did that the second part of this video is very negative because i was incredibly disappointed by the size of the box and the size of the rule book and i've talked to many many people who received this game in the mail and they were absolutely shocked people had sent me messages emails commented on patreon

commented on on uh on the facebook group like have you seen the size of forgotten depths and i was not prepared for it even though i knew that the box was big i was in no way prepared for just how huge the box and how huge the rule book is for this game but let's do a little basic overview of the game and then we're going to talk about five ways that this game kind of differentiates itself from the others five little twists on core mechanisms on core concepts that makes forgotten depths feel a little bit different so in forgotten depths you are doing very standard things you are taking a number of characters this game plays from one to three and it scales pretty well at all player accounts one two or three you can play a true single lone wolf mode so you are taking your characters there are base characters like the rogue and the wizard and then on the back of each one is a kind of a combo character so a dual class a wizard rogue or a rogue fighter you are taking those characters you are going to be moving through a map you are going to be starting at a dungeon entrance looking for the dungeon floor down to the next level fighting a boss before you can get to that next level and you are going to be progressing through levels one levels two and levels three as you move down and then at the end actually it's level one two and three and then at the end of level three you fight a major boss and that is how

you win the game there is leveling up you can collect experience points you can gain loot you can make your character better in combat you will have random encounters you will have encounters with monsters and you will be looking for these kind of like great legendary locations within the dungeon in order to gain experience in order to gain a lore and knowledge about the uh the ecology that you are exploring in because what this game is really about is you are kind of like map makers you are adventurers you aren't necessarily great warriors but you are going to be going through this dungeon looking for things of interest looking for interesting locations and making a map of your experience of your journey as a cartographer might so one of the main ways this game is different is in how the map works and how you create the map in a puzzle like way while you are playing the game so you always start at the entrance and then you take your tile your your um stairs down so this is the last tile we're trying to locate and you mix uh those stairs up into a few cards and place those into the bottom of your uh deck and then everything else is shuffled and so this is your deck of cards that you're creating your map with so in most games you're going to lay out a tile and move your guy into a new tile

and do whatever that new tile says well in this game you're creating a map and it's kind of like a puzzle like nature it's a little bit of a simple tile laying game because you don't really move your character until you decide to interact with one of the elements on the map tile and certain elements will block progress so you need to build your map and then choose which of those things you want to encounter so there's a door there there's one of these nodes and these nodes are we will talk about in a little bit but i really enjoy this aspect of the game of building out the floor of kind of mapping your progress through a tunnel or through um the dungeon and it's a kind of uh represents this kind of slow questing in nature this this this is a slow this is a a thoughtful adventure through a dungeon you could say and so you are building out the map and then you are choosing as the map gets built you are then choosing where to go and what to encounter so another way that this is different is in the puzzle-like nature of this map creation because one of the main things you are looking for are these nodes here and as those nodes are connected they will form

a certain shape and those shapes will coincide to these other cards of these legendary locations and you are looking to create those shapes with those nodes so you can encounter these legendary locations and you can get more experience maybe fight some strong monsters maybe get some loot from these places you have the level one legendary locations which are pretty very easy to create because those only need one node connection and then you have a level two which needs two node connections and a straight line so those are also pretty easy to create you have the level threes these are a little harder to create because you need to create this l shape and you may find it difficult as you are laying your tiles out to actually create that shape but this is represented by it being more difficult to find so this these two legendary locations are a little more difficult to find and so building that shape is a little more difficult and then finally you have a level four shape and this one is even more difficult to find and even more legendary and will offer even more rewards so you can kind of choose as you are as you are creating your map you could choose to take the two easy ones and build those out or kind of push your luck to hope that you can make these shapes to find the more legendary locations and then each one of these

is a different location so one of these might be a crypt one of them might be an exterior wall one of them might be a sunken section of the floor and then each one of those will have a couple of cards a couple of cards that you can build out that location and then some of these will have certain things that you have to do certain tests or maybe certain monsters that you will have to fight but as you progress through them you will learn a little bit about the dungeon you will you might gain some um some lore some knowledge you might have to pass some tests or fight some monsters and then each one of these is going to give you a number of experience points as you encounter it and so the level 2 you have 2a 2b 2c and these will help you also so if you've come across this one you might find a platemail and you might find some new armor or something maybe you find these tiny glowing beans a small glass vial of a clear blue liquid or maybe you find this uh this uh library here where you have to face off against the skeletal sentinel before you can find his leather uh bound grimoire so just very very cool i love this concept it takes the idea of a of random encounters mixes it with a puzzle-like element so you have to think a little bit about how your characters are going to discover these really cool locations and there

are a whole bunch of those for the different um the different environments as you work your way through the game you will find more and more different legendary locations and more things to discover another aspect i like and it does also have to do with this map creation is how you um can choose what you want to encounter and when you want to encounter it because as you build out your map certain elements certain icons will block progress in that direction so if i were to lay this card here i could not continue to lay cards in this direction until i faced off against that monster if i were to lay this card here i could not continue to go in this direction until i had a key to open up that door so this area would be blocked off and there are also these eyeballs which are features and they will also block progress in certain directions until you choose to encounter one of those and have a random encounter so while you do need to encounter each one of those doors monsters and features you have a choice of when you want to do them and which one you want to do so you might have all three laid out like that maybe uh like that and you might say okay i want to go over

here and encounter this feature first because maybe i can get a bonus to fight the monster and then maybe i can get some xp to buy a key to unlock that door so again it's in this map creation process this puzzle like element of these tile placements and offering these choices to the player and how they wish to proceed and this uh these encounters are one of the other reasons how this game feels a little bit different and that actually has to do with the art on these cards the art on the monsters the art and just everything in this game even the art on the character cards has a pastoral feel it's kind of whimsical uh soft muted colors a very kind of european comic book feel and so it gives the game just a very different kind of vibe it's a very kind of non-aggressive vibe i think you could say some really cool evocative images that while it can be creepy and while there are monsters and spooky things to discover the game just feels really inviting and even in the violence feels a little more subdued i don't know it's a really interesting vibe and that is all because of this art uh the art is absolutely gorgeous uh the

art was done by i forgot i think i forgot to mention the artist's name when i originally uh did my review so the art here is done by marion churchlin just absolutely fantastic art i love their work so much it does make me want to explore the game and really get into its world and its lore and learn about the different ecologies and how everything fits together very inviting and i really do dig that kind of chill vibe that the art gives and then also the combat so yes there is combat in this game that is another kind of normal thing that we are doing in a game in a dungeon crawl but the combat is also a little bit different and part of the reason why it is different is it is card based rather than dice based but you're there also is kind of this trade-off that you are doing in how you are dealing damage and how you are taking damage and again there there is this element of choice and this little kind of puzzle like nature so combat in the game is determined by deck of cards your characters will have a deck of cards that will have different attacks on there the art is just there for uh for artistic purposes but i do like it it kind of represents the um the strikes and it will have different powers and those powers are the damage and if you play a card that has a higher number

than the monster because the monsters also have a deck of cards the monsters have level one cards level two cards and level three cards and so you might deal out you know at the beginning of the game you're going to shuffle your action deck and then at the beginning of combat you're going to draw three cards you're going to look at the cards you drew okay a four a five and a three not great you're going to choose two cards probably most of the time you're going to be choosing two cards to attack with and then the enemy is going to take their cards and they're going to also deal two cards you're going to deal those like that and like that and then you're going to look for the results so if the monster has a higher result than you do that triggers first and the monster attacks you the next thing that triggers are blocks so blocks if the if they are the same so these would block and the final thing that triggers in a combat round would be if your hero has a higher total than the monster so this would be a hit for my hero if this block wasn't here five versus three i would do five damage but then there is automatic return damage that is the difference between the two cards so if you played like a really powerful attack here like let's say you played one of your eights and the monster retaliated with a 3 well you would do 8 damage to that monster but that monster would do 5 damage back

to you so you kind of have to think about do you want to go for a really powerful attack and possibly leave yourself open to a big counter attack or do you want to just kind of chip away and do less damage but also maybe have less of a chance of getting pounded in a counter attack and i do really like that as your character progresses you can unlock these other action cards to add to your action deck and these are going to be unlocked by getting different treasure and as you play through the game you will also have the ability to unlock uh treasure and the loot system is another kind of way that this game is a little bit different because each of the characters has their own unique loot deck that you are going to be able to draw from at certain points during the game and you're going to be kind of finding your character's iconic eye iconic gear iconic equipment to kind of like make them look like their character which is super cool so you might find that helmet and maybe her axe her cool looking sword there or that axe this serrated battle axe or the girdle of power the branded oak shield or the heavy broadsword and then those will coincide to unlocking those more powerful items and then also each of the characters also has their own unique ability deck that you can use you can buy new skills in

order to make your character more powerful as you are progressing through the various floors of the dungeon so as you can see the game does all of the things has all the elements of things that we like in these games but each one has a small little twist to it that overall makes the game stand out it makes the game feel different but none of those twists are so outlandish or so clever as to make the game more difficult to learn so none of the twists none of the little wrinkles none of the little the new folds in the mechanisms feel too clever or too outlandish or too out there they all point strongly back to that core theme of this being a dungeon adventure game and a game that is more concerned in thematic thematically with exploration and mapping and the adventure rather than that crunchy kind of trap avoiding monster fighting loot gathering crawl that we are more used to i love just about everything about playing the game and the way it looks and the way i feel while i am playing it it just it it's just it's a kind of a chill mo game that gives off this really inviting vibe that i am super super into what i am not into though is the size of the box and the size of the rule book

and we're going to talk about that next okay now let's talk about box size box size is super important for a game and we have two examples here so this portion of this look at forgotten depths was recorded before the detailed look at the game because i wanted to illustrate a point but i did want to start off that video with this uh somewhat negative criticism of the game so we have two boxes here forgotten depths and stars of cardios the boxes are relatively similar in size the forgotten depths box is just a little bit smaller than the stars of a cardios box in every dimension it's about i don't know about an inch inch and a half not quite as tall about a couple inches not quite as wide but it is almost as long stars of acarios the contents of this box is it it is completely jam packed i mean just all the way packed to the gills packed to the rim filled to the rim with stuff this thing is heavy uh this is a huge epic game with tons of stuff packed in to

this game forgotten depths is a somewhat small card game uh this game could have been part of my big game in a small box series but instead what we have here is we have a small game in a giant box and this box it this box does not represent the game very well if i was at a game store and i saw this box i would expect the game to be a much bigger production than it is the box is nice it looks nice it has nice graphics and text and everything but i just find the box size for this game to be incredibly obnoxious but that is not the most obnoxious thing about this game the most obnoxious thing is this rulebook look at the size of this rulebook what were they thinking here is a four against darkness book it kind of a normal trade size book look at the size and difference on this thing this is the most unwieldy to read rule book the most obnoxiously sized rule book i have ever seen in all of my decades of gaming and when you start looking through it you realize that this

it was produced in the wrong size because you would think that a book this big would have nice big text to read but no the text is still super small and there is so much white space so much empty space look at this almost an entire page like three-fifths of this page are completely blank on this absolutely massive giant rulebook that flops all around it takes up like half of my table to read i feel like i'm reading an old copy of the new york times whenever i open this stupid rule book up i don't get this at all it's absolutely ridiculous but i don't even think that's the most ridiculous thing because inside this giant box with this small game we have all the components okay i'm going to take them all out and look first of all look at how much wasted space is in here with this stupid plastic insert i'm going to take everything out here okay everything can come out a plastic mini for some reason okay so if we take all of the stuff out and we remove this giant piece of plastic and then we put everything in the box here let's put in this stuff first here down there put that in put that in put that

okay this game could have fit in a box a fifth of the size practically as a matter of fact if we take this small box here for paper dungeons a very tiny little game and we start putting in the contents of forgotten realms or forgotten depths i should say sorry about that

this game actually fits completely with room to spare in this small box and i'm thinking okay so maybe i get rid of this giant box and put the game in a small box well then what the hell am i going to do with this just ridiculous uh and then you okay i could download the pdf for this and you do that and you print it out in a nice little normal size rulebook that most games come with and the text is so tiny that you can't even read it because it's laid out in this giant absolutely ridiculous size so this here this giant box that stupid stupid plastic insert like we got the board game industry has got to divorce itself from its love affair with plastic we need to be more responsible for the amount of plastic we as consumers are responsible we don't need those plat that that big plastic insert that is just a complete waste of space in here and i know because i know the reason why the uh peter the designer he listened to all the people who like to sleeve their cards but even when you sleep your cards that this that whole plastic answer is still not needed you could easily just have your cards in a smaller box in like a long box um

but the whole idea of like of sleeving cards is just so much plastic um i'm actually in the process right now of unsleeving all of my cards as a matter of fact i have started unsleeving all of my cards uh there's some sleeves from dungeon degenerates and island of d a couple smaller games also i'm unsleeving all of my cards and i'm going to donate my sleeves to the local game store so hopefully they can um give my sleeves away to to other people so people don't have to buy new sleeves um because because i'm trying to be more conscious of the amount of plastic i am responsible for as a gamer but um yeah just this this huge box i this box actually it won't fit on a on one of those like one of the calyx shelves the the the ikea shelves that everybody uses it won't fit like this it's too wide if you put it in like this it sticks out uh yeah i don't know why nobody told peter no like i think that's one of the pitfalls of kickstarter is you don't have project managers you don't have uh people who are overseeing the production the development of the physical product of your game you don't have a manager there to say no and i think this whole size of this box the whole

just overly produced hunk of plastic insert nobody said no yeah this was pretty upsetting to me uh just all this space i was really looking forward to this small game fitting on my shelf in my small game cubby and but now it's a giant game that i have nowhere to put i'm not sure where it's going to go and it's really hard to put in a small box because of this stupid manual i don't know where that's going to go but um yeah this did taint my feelings overall of the game the game is good the art is good there are some really cool things about the game i'm glad that it exists but thinking about how your game is presented how your game is stored on people's shelves the amount of wasted space that you can get rid of um just people need to think about that i want designers to think about that more so uh sorry to end this video on forgotten depths on such a downer note but i'm sure my first part of this video where i'm talking about the game will be much more positive so all right guys we'll take it easy we'll talk to you later bye

Progress saved