TCbH Podcast - Stolen Harmony (PAX 2024 Wrap-up)
Transcript
hey everyone and welcome back to the cardboard Herald which I have normally opened these things as my chance to talk with creative Gamers and game creators and yet I am here in another form with Eric hey how's it going man it is going well how are you doing this evening Jack I'm doing good in the not quite so evening we have to coordinate our time because now the cardboard Herald is coast to coast yeah Co real Coast to Coast you're I mean we got a 4our time difference is what we're working on and for anyone who's been following the channel uh for a while then you know that Eric has been doing stuff we did a p kind of preview of a wrap-up video and in that we talked about how we wanted to resume the focus of the cardboard held on podcasting and that's kind of what we're doing right now so this is most likely going to go up as an audio podcast we have some video recording maybe uh that'll be a thing but maybe not we'll see how this goes I didn't do my makeup you know we're we're all about the looks here at the cardboard Herald yeah we're we're definitely doing a little bit of experimenting but we mainly wanted to get some audio out there where we just talk about this bananas time we had at this convention which uh was a bit of a whirlwind um and had some high Jinks I think it's fair to say there was some high Jinks you can't
I you jumped out from a closet when you first saw me yeah that's first time seeing Jack in a month he jumps out of a closet he's standing on top of a laundry machine after a different friend of ours had already also scared me yeah that was the ruse uh scaring uh we were trying to have like the initial scaring to catch him off guard and if anything it alerted him to what could possibly be going on uh but did it in the wrong order like I knew you be there you could have you could have flip-flo you and Sean but uh yeah hij Jinks I think it's very fair to say hij Jinks hij Jinks were Upon Us yeah from from the outset it uh th this was the good occasion to kick off uh working on the podcast uh we intend on uh doing some uh regular podcasting between and I talk about the games that we've been playing talking about gaming news and all that kind of stuff uh and then also uh resuming more interviews that we've done in the past and then figuring out how we want that relationship between the podcast Channel and the video channel and are we going to try to do video Everything are we just going to have audio on some of it and we're we're figuring out those details but that's kind of like the stuff that no one cares about um but before we get into packs itself I really haven't had a chance to ask you about this how was getting the games home on the train did did things manage all
right well for the most part yes uh other than my train I've not had a good track record with trains in the last like two weeks okay uh my train was delayed again which is fine it is what it is I I don't you don't typically take trains to be on time um but uh yeah overall I got the new I got that that bag and that worked pretty well yeah we we got the allplay uh shout out to allplay here um the the instead of board game tables they should be known as board game bags for how many of these bags are at the conventions but um they have a new we're not being paid to say this uh but uh a new roller bag they have roller bags converts to a giant backpack or you can roll it or it has like handle so you can just carry it almost briefcase esque yeah and it was really fat oh very fatty briefcase yeah that is a wide thick briefcase but uh it was uh yeah all pretty pretty simple I think the biggest thing was I put it at a weird spot in the train where it was closer to the front and there was a lower ceiling all a bunch of nonsense but that wasn't the bag's fault everything came back and it was totally fine especially actually your copy of harmonies yes it traveled very easily and it was very easy to steal your copy of harmonies the game so nice that you
needed it twice uh that is mail to you along with uh the button shy game that uh you were interested in oh okay well then I I guess we should actually talk about some games so harmonies button shy seeing friends playing games uh looking at prototypes drooling over games that are yet to come out there there was a bunch of stuff there and I don't know I just I I just want to be a gamer and be super stoked about talking about games and some of these I played with Eric and some of them I didn't um but like off the top of your head is there like a game of the con for you because I actually have one that I think for our group was the game of the con even if it's a game that I had already played in advance of the con um I think the game of the con for me was drop hter oh man okay I was not expecting that that's that's a dark horse Contender it is uh I it it is the most like super pure joy I've had in a game like there I've had I played a lot of games where I had fun at the con um uh but there is nothing quite like the the Elation from stealing the ghosts out from you and Christina's hands that was like uh s so
much fun that I was really not expecting when Christina was explaining it and I was like oh yeah you drop things and you pick it up uh I came home that's the uh first game I played and showed uh my wife and her friend who were here uh as soon as I got back I was like we have to play Drop halter uh it's one of those things that's like intrinsic right you know like as soon as someone sees it happen that they go oh I could do that better and then they realize they're huous as soon as they start playing as soon as they start dropping Bells yeah yeah so you know quick overview of drop hter uh since I don't know how much of this is on everyone's radar yeah I don't I feel like I hadn't heard anything about it before Christina just came into the airb be with it yeah I I think she saw it being demoed this is an oink game uh there were a bunch of oink games uh that got played um and I would say uh well I guess the only ones that we ended up playing uh were this and Scout oh and a new new version of Deep Sea Adventure I have the classic version and my buddy uh or our buddy John picked it up and was also playing that and he's like wait what the hell are these extra Dice and I was like I don't know what's going on here it's some new addition with like an added bit of rules uh which is pretty cool drop poter uh drop poter drop it's really sad that it's not just
drop Poltergeist like it's a portm it's a port man terrible um but uh yeah drop hter is just a real quick dexterity game where uh you have uh some uh odds and ends objects and then you flip a card and everyone is trying to drop all of those specific objects listed on the card from their hand while maintaining all the rest of the objects in their hand but you have to do it all with one hand and if you're successful you steal the ghost token and that gives you a point and what I think is absolutely brilliant about this game is when you get the point it's a bell which is fun because it's a little tiny bell and it's like ooky spooky and everything but it's a catchup mechanism right yeah you know how often does that happen in dexterity games where you have like Point track and catchup mechanisms that's cool yeah because it goes into your hand and then if you if you drop the Bell while trying to get the other things out you've lost that point it's gone right so it's it's it is uh you know there's no strategy to it but it is a very fun game uh I I think for me me that's the game of the con just because we played that so much right uh I think that there were other games that I am more excited to play again uh but that one is the one that we played the most that just was like a
such an immediate dopamine hit like right right in there right in the cerebellum or wherever dopamine is yeah cerebellum I think you shouldn't have called it out you just that's what podcasting is all about is you just say something with Authority and whether it's right or wrong people just more or less believe it yeah um it's the power of podcast um if it works for Joe Rogan it's got to work for us um Sky team is the game that I I recognize that it's the jarling of last year but for whatever reason I kind of slept on Sky team and I know now that I'm not alone because I ended up realiz in I needed to get a copy of it for uh Game of the Year purposes and right before um the convention I made a list of all the games that I wanted to make sure to check out at the convention and my local shop by chance had it and it's only 30 bucks so I was like I'll pick it up and maybe I could do something where I'm playing it on the plane with uh Christina and as soon as I played that I was like oh oh my God I get it I get it I need to play it again and I played it a bunch more times and then at the convention I was like prizing this game like I I was just showing anyone that I can and I probably ended up selling like five or six copies of Sky Team you me to buy it yeah uh you
got a copy John got a copy I was showing uh Rita and Brendan from uh post curious like it it it was everywhere Sky Team super excited um one of the best two-player Cooperative games I've played um but I I also thought that was a good segue because I think the real theme of this convention and really where we're at as like a gaming hobby is that two-player games are hot right now they are really hot right now yeah I think a lot of the games that I saw at the con and there most of the games I feel like we played like we had the night where we just half of half of the Airbnb was playing two uh two-player Pagan and then half the Airbnb was playing two-player kelp and like both of those I think are really solid games that are like new and there are a lot of those where it's either two-player only orl best of two players that I saw at the con this year I agree that that's the one of the bigger takeaways for me of where we are in the hooby yeah I I think it might be a whole other podcast that we could do but I imagine that's symptomatic of just some of the evolution of things coming out of Co you know during Co we had uh the ubiquity of solo games right it was already a thing but then it was like if you you want your game to be marketable you got to have solo as an option yeah and then I imagine a lot of board gamers
who may have been playing with their friends or other play groups ended up turning to their partners and going like hey let's play games together and whether they were already Gamers or not it became a much more dedicated thing and so that opened up the space to make more dedicated two-player games in conventional wisdom it was always said in the hobby that you know dedicated two-player games don't sell and now they're everywhere I mean we have Sky Team selling like bananas we have seven wonders duel we have Splender duel everyone's getting duel it's like everything's getting a d yeah everything's duel yeah let's just duel it up duur Island um but uh yeah so uh we saw a bunch of those you mentioned uh Pagan and I guess I didn't even really get your your Takeaway on that I have a copy of pagan that's in my like 2B played but that was one of the really hot games at the convention 2 uh Capstone was selling it and I want to say it's like a partnership with someone like wor worm gold or something like that yeah I I freed off top my head but uh that's probably something we can look up here and uh figure out but yeah uh I played it with our friend John uh in I played that and not kelp so I'm also interested in hearing your thoughts on kelp but uh I thought it was really interesting I think that there
was uh the a symmetry is really intriguing I think it didn't land for me quite as much as I was hoping it would but it is still a really solid game and I think a lot of that can be solved with I know that there are like promo packs and different villagers that you could have in the middle there um I would be really interested to try out I only played as the hunter I would be interested to try out playing as the witch because to me that seemed like the more intriguing uh way or faction where it was like you know the hunter was really uh low and slow and you were doing things like really slowly but surely which felt good because I always was progressing towards my goal but the witch just seemed like it had a lot more you can really pop off and have a really big turn if you play your cards right but then there were a lot of turns where you just had to reset and Garner up or gather up resources to go again and to me that seemed like a way more thought provoking faction to play as to try and like make sure your turns count a lot more right um it's a deduction game right it's not hidden movement you're you're actually like the witch is obfuscating which of the villagers that they are and the hunter is trying to eliminate potential suspects and you
know like then identify who the appropriate uh character is for the witch yeah so there are nine villag in the middle that all have different actions when your character visits them uh it's not hidden movement but the witch is one of the nine villagers and the hunter is trying to figure out which of them and as you play as the hunter you will do actions that you draw from a deck of the other eight villagers and you just randomly get told okay this guy is not the witch it exonerates them that's exonerates that is actually I do think the the term they use uh in the game's uh mechanics but yeah it uh I think was one of the better deduction games I've played where there's there's a lot more you can do as the witch to fake out the Hunter and there's also a lot of reasons to do that because if you get a uh villager to a high enough level uh you you double their action for yourself as the witch so it's like even if you this person is not who you are also as the witch you have to visit yourself a lot so that you can then perform the final ritual which will then win you the game so you have to build up like a lot of presence I think they called it uh I think it
is Secrets it's Secrets I was reading the rule book earlier today I I think it's secrets for them and uh Clues clues for the so you have to build up a lot of secrets on one of the villagers which is your self as the Witch and you have to visit yourself a lot but if you are visiting another character a lot or another one of the villagers and giving them Secrets then you are able to double that action so if it's like a draw two card space you're now drawing four cards after you've reached a certain threshold and so it kind of rewards you to have multiple people that you're visiting often and not just yourself in a way that is more than just you're diverting the attention of the hunter I'm really what I'm really curious about with this game is if it's going to be one of those ones where it actually becomes more Rich if you play more with a dedicated set of two players and both players are more familiar with it or or if what's really making it exciting right now at least at the convention and uh for the people getting their hands on it for the first time is the novelty of the new experience right you know and yeah that's a hard thing for any game and one of those things that as I look at the massive pile of games that I brought home and I'm
thinking about the the consumerism of just mountains of games is I'm always trying to think about like what are the ones that actually are going to stay fun or if anything get even better as you have more experience with the game um and I think hidden movement and deduction games are particularly prone to that because in some uh you're going to end up finding the the solution right um so like the the The Hider or you know the obfuscator has the Vantage of unfamiliarity on the part of the other players whereas um there's a barking dog in the background yes oh yeah uh that's okay Bastion wants to say hi or maybe that's Bastion I missed you Bastion and Nora and maybe also era but I don't think that was Arrow yeah Arrow does a bizarre howl um but uh with um uh with hidden movement games the the ones that are my favorite are like White Hall mystery where it's clean enough that you can develop a meta that's based off of the previous games that you played you know what I did last time is now uh going to inform what I do um this time and I can kind of account for uh what you're expecting and throw it in a completely different direction
uh John and I played the hell out of ninja Legends of the Scorpion Clan which was a two asymmetric hidden movement um which uh we played probably like 40 or 50 plays of that and had that exact kind of meta so I'm maybe not concerned but curious about what sort of levers pan is going to have in the long run um yeah I I can see I fully agree that that's the thing that I would am worried about to with a lot of hidden movement and deduction games where there there is very easily a oh well this is just the way that the game is going to go I think Pagan has a chance to get out from under that because with the different villagers that you can end up being your game play is going to change because if you're the Villager that you as the witch are I I'm saying this from The Witch's perspective the Hunter's perspective I don't I I feel like it might get very dry and Bland to be the hunter but but with the witch I feel like just depending on who you get that changes your gameplay a lot and then the other thing about pagan and I am not really uh fully up to term or up up to speed with everything going on with it but there is a deck building aspect to it where you there are going to be more
cards so you can change out the 50 card deck that you start off with and that uh does not appeal to me but there are going to be some Gamers that that is like a very exciting aspect of this game where it is you can really like if you are playing as the hunter you can build a a deck that perfectly counters your opponent's deck if you can if you can figure out what kind of deck they're running probably I don't interesting interesting like a like deck building it as you play or is it a constructed in advance constructed constructed in advance that's wild I I didn't even uh realize that there was that element in the game I'm going to have to check that out because you know a big part of the appeal of box board games is I never have to construct a deck you know like I I'll leave that for building armies in Warhammer or building magic decks or whatever but we we'll see um there's none of that in kelp where kelp does have deck building as you play if you are uh the squid octopus the squid squid I think it's squid I think it's squid okay no no no it's an octopus it's an octopus it's an octopus it's an octopus okay we're we're on the same page octopus um real quick uh kelp there there's been much discussion about kelp
at this point so I don't think we we need to get into it too much but asymmetric uh hidden movement I didn't expect it to be hidden movement two factions one player's shark one player an octopus the uh octopus is trying to either outlive the shark um which is based off of uh a series of turns not a fixed number of turns um or the octopus is trying to eat all of their food so they can GTFO uh before the shark ends up finding them the shark is just trying to find the octopus who is one of these many pillar tiles that are really beautiful tiles um that are for the most part facing the octopus player but are are revealed in order to pay for card resource costs and I love the idea of using information as a currency in the game uh and you restore uh those to a an off fiscated State but then the shark still knows which tile is which tile so you have to do certain things that allow you to switch them up put them back in a bag and then take them out and replace them there's all kinds of things you can do it it becomes a tight cat and mouse game probably about both players know what they're doing about 30 40 minutes um and uh similarly it seems like the
octopus is kind of where it's at as far as really feeling like you uh have real interesting ideas to cultivate but the shark does have the suspense you feel like a predator like you feel like you are going to be chomping down on some octopus before this ends um and uh there there's a couple really Grace uh solutions that they do to handle like finding the octopus isn't a guaranteed Victory but the first time that you do it it's a one-third chance that you're going to win the game then second time it's a 5050 chance and then the third time guaranteed it's going to uh win um it's smart it's beautiful everything that they say about it it's uh really impressive and I didn't expect to find it at the con it's getting delivered to Kickstarter backers and I was like all mopy like I wish I had a copy of kelp and there it was at the convention um which we just dived into games there's so many more games we can talk about but like we didn't even do the general like convention experience like uh you know like do do you want to talk from your perspective about like yeah what it was like just going to the con or you know like UPS or Downs what you expected
versus what it actually became yeah definitely um I this was my first like big convention so for me this was uh everything about it was new and so I was entering it with very fresh eyes um and it was so much fun and I I was kind of expecting it to be I mean we we have a board game convention in Juno but it definitely is more of a we are going to all come together to play games and not this is a indry Showcase of where we are at this moment what is coming out next year uh platypus conon which I loved I volunteer that frequently is more just hey we all live in this really small town let's get together to play some board games this weekend uh this was massive I mean I it every board game publisher that I feel like I had heard of was there uh slinging games uh and just getting to see all the things that are coming out getting to see a lot of these games that and again this is especially coming from uh Juno which it is very surprising to find a game that came out uh last year depending on the game like Sky Team I am surprised that you found Sky Team in Juno like happen stance uh and then to have every game there uh was like just eye openening to how many games there are I mean there are so many
smaller Publishers uh out there that have some really interesting things going on uh and yeah I think just being able to walk through the booths and then go to all these different talks about board games and board game design and other industry topics uh right was really cool and also we played so many games yeah which was awesome you know like just being able to hang with friends and play games and that that's something that Eric and I were talking about in advance of the con is you know what we were hoping to get out of it and there have been years in the past where I've gone and been like I need to schedule like 20 interviews over these three days and get all these show floor interviews with PR people and for the most part I like interviewing creative people um I don't necessarily love interviewing marketing people people I like being at the table with the marketing people so we made a lot of those appointments and Eric and I got to do those um and those people are so valuable for the industry and it's such a great way of seeing uh and cultivating interests in these different games but it's not really going to be super helpful to have someone from cge interview on camera about how showing set is going necessarily we did
uh a couple show floor interviews uh with some of the creative team of leader games so that was cool um we did a lot of appointments uh this is the first year that I went to like a corporate ass corporate appointment yeah um for uh asthma day uh which was fascinating um and uh we like a full like they have PowerPoint for us power you and me and also the other people in that room but a PowerPoint and people clapping for you know like people talking about things that they're doing and good on them that they were upfront like anything that's here you can take pictures of you can you can film there were a lot of content creator media type people uh in addition to us um but they they had the whole like swag bag and Power points and it it could have been televisions it could have been you know like a new washer and dryer or something uh the type of presentation could have been replaced with uh um any sort of industry but we did get to see some cool games there um yeah particularly um what I I know I was like we should talk about the con in general but while we're on the topic um the the Great Western Trail El Paso uh we played
um along with uh Candace from BGG which was really cool um that uh looks really nice especially because Great Western Trail is like a beast of a game and I think this is going to be more palatable to the modern gaming audience um because from my perspective uh having played at least the first edition of um GWT uh a few times this seems like it preserves the majority of the the mechanisms there but in a much easier to manage uh format um Asma day was talking up the cloth map I I wasn't so sold on the cloth I was not a fan I'll be perfectly honest I was not a fan of the cloth I saw uh I I didn't realize that was like an add-on I saw a picture of it uh when I was like like on BGG reading the news earlier uh and I saw like this the normal cardboard uh uh board and I was like oh thank goodness okay oh thank goodness that that's not a permanent thing okay I mean I I like a good cloth map um but I don't know what he's talking about like clearly he's never played uh um Pax pamier because Pax Premier is on a cloth map and it looks jaw-dropping whereas this one was like you know like times neoprene mats they like have a little faded printing on them and it doesn't look very good this
was all right but aside from that the game itself played great uh I had a great time with that um selling some cows uh and then what what's the cosmos game crafting the cosmos crafting I was gonna say I of all the games that we played at the con that one is the one that I most interested in playing again I don't know if it's the one I'm necessarily most excited about but it just the the mechanics seem really interesting and we just didn't really get to play it yeah uh it but it it it feels like it might it might have the juice for me like it might have just enough weirdness that you have to navigate and puzzle through uh for me where it is like uh yeah crafting the cosmos I'm pretty sure is the name of it yeah that that is uh and I think it in my mind it's kind of like zulin meets uh I inste theory of relativity I guess it's uh pretty cool um seems for uh an an idiot like myself um a Layman like myself like it's based in pretty sound uh uh physics um at least as much as a board game about crafting the fabric of
the universe is going to be um it looks really cool uh but yeah that that made a big impression on me and then there was um this uh like shadow puppet Shad yeah uh and that's uh one of the cooler games that's coming up so the there was some cool stuff at asthma day um corporate presentation um honestly of asthma day itself I had a better time with uh getting to sit down with the designer of the Fellowship of the Ring trick taking game um so Christina my wife uh who's appeared in a couple videos in the past uh or lots of videos as like one of the gamers in the be roll um yes yes um uh I introduced her a lot as kind of like The Unofficial third member of the cardboard Herald because she is instrumental to pretty much everything I do around here and she's come to the convention and built up relationships with various people that uh we game with and um so she's fairly recognizable at this point as well and the three of us and the designer of Fellowship of the Ring sat down uh and narrowly lost uh one of those yeah one of those scenarios in in my I was like yeah you know like I I really like it but I don't know how difficult it's going to be uh and he's like well have you played this scenario yet uh and I was like I don't know uh I
don't think so and he's like all right let's sit down and play this this what's going to separate the boys from the hobbits um and that he he broke out he was like we're going to jump to this scenario and the people around him were like that's too high that's too high of a scenario they couldn't possibly comprehend this that's the highest you've ever gone yep yeah made me feel really good about my gaming skills even though we did not win yeah we we came to the The Bitter End of that uh but uh that was a fun experience um and then overall you know like just doing stuff like that we had a um a crew of friends that we were hanging out with uh We've developed um uh over the years uh close friendships with uh particularly the windsmith games crew uh and then um the post curious crew and went out to dinner and did a bunch of um gaming together after convention hours and talking about uh just you know what they've been doing and things that they've been uh checking out and so we had this big group um our Airbnb was right next to the convention center which was fantastic didn't have a table uh no and didn't have chairs uh sleep six seats zero um or I guess seats two and a half on a very two and a half that is also my bed yes yes um the couch is also my bed just to be clear so we pulled a Marines and improvise adapt
overcome uh and we had um David from windsmith games bring down a folding table uh he was arriving the next day and then we ordered overnight uh because you can do that when you're in the lower 48 and you Prime shipping to be delivered the next day uh some like collapsible stools um very tricky stools very tricky stools very tricky stools just uh for the audience I need you to know how tricky these stools were I sat on them the wrong way for all most of the gaming convention I I would sit on them well and it's hard to uh verbalize it where you can't see the chairs which we don't have them because of hyinks which we'll get into but I sat on the bottom end and it was painful and I just assumed that's how it was and that was not very tricky stools yeah yeah uh cone points upward uh surfaces are about equal area on top and bottom but uh one has Pokey NS that I just didn't realize it was just that one side that had Pokey NS and I I guess elaborate a little bit more so for the um hij Jinks here uh because I only came in on the tail end of the H Jinks to hear tail in retrospect from Christina uh Eric is being a complete Jack and apes and just like rocking
around on this stool and is like just willy-nilly and then uh proceeds to perhaps fall down or did you just straight up break it no no I just fell down the first time I'm pretty I think in future uh I don't I don't know for sure if I did or didn't so it was a stool that you pulled apart like an accordia and then rotated a little bit so that it locked into place right the my current uh belief is that I was rocking side side a little bit too much the first time and rotated a little bit which unlocked some of the stool so I dropped down and fell down backwards off of the stool uh and we were like oh H that's funny that was probably bound to happen and then I reset the stool and sat down and it held for about 30 seconds and then the second time is when it broke okay very good very good very good and then I I fell again and just snapped some of the pieces off of it like in half half uh but I was able to renegotiate them back into the stool so that it looked totally fine and all of this occurred while I was as one does in the bathroom um taking care of some
business and I was like okay I'll C I'll be out in a minute and so I come out and they're in the middle of a game and now I can see that this was all staged perfectly so that our buddy John who has a a history of being like you know like poop pooing this or that and he he actually said something that just felt very like H John's you know kind of me on the game so I was focused on that can I say the exact words he said oh he okay yes you have the script uh he was like I don't know if I want to play that but I we're kind of setting this up right now and Jack we have a seat for you yes there we go there we go and thus I sit down it was drop poter and that seemed like exactly the type of thing that JN would be like oh gosh this type of game and I was like oh of course you know John doesn't want to play uh and so I sit down and just immediately fall down everyone's laughing and I pack up and leave and never talk to anyone again until this pod um no it was it was good it was good guys got me hi it did make me nervous about the rest of the stool uh usage for the rest uh anytime you'd hear like a little creaking uh it was um real touch and go there for a second but
yeah the rest of the rest of the trip I was just always was that right right and so the point being with these stools and with the table we had a um a Airbnb that wasn't exactly set up to play games but when you go to one of these conventions the expectation is that you could just play a ton of games at the convention itself but that closes at midnight and sometimes us Gamers we want to continue playing after that and fortunately we were able to go back to their BNB um and even have some of our friends that weren't staying there come with us cuz it was right there right next to the convention center and play some games and and so you know like generally we were up to about 132 playing games uh during the nights of the convention itself um and then on the we had a couple days on either end where we could fit in a couple other uh games too so um yeah that that was kind of the the mission was just go in um do some appointments to see upcoming things um uh meet up with friends play a ton of games and just kind of have a sense of Discovery at the con um was there any aspect of the convention now that you know a little bit more for context the things that if we went to this one again in the future what you do for a similar
convention um put more time emphasizing yeah I mean I think that with this being my first big convention now that I know uh how many Publishers are there and how many games are going to be available uh I would set aside more of a budget to buy games to just prevent myself from future regrets of oh I really wanted that game I should have gotten it but I was so worried about how much money I spent at the convention I mean and granted we got a lot of games separately to be clear we got a lot of free games we got a lot of free games there were also doll dues there were a lot of games that I was like oh I probably shouldn't buy that uh so I will I would budget more in the future and also I think that I would I feel like there we did a pretty good job of making it a leisurely thing and I think that I would maybe go in with that mindset uh again where it's just like you know I think especially for us being there on business I'm I'm saying in quotes where it's like but we are like trying to establish connections re reup connections that you already have and also in this one introduce me because this was my first time meeting so many of the connections that you've already made in the board game industry uh I think that it would have been if I would have done it
alone I would have I would have approached it a lot more busy and probably would have done the like 30 right right meetings a day which would not have been like I wouldn't have got as much out of the Convention as I would have wanted to because I I agree that for me the just playing with your friends and making sure that you are like you're there to play games and like see new games and try things out uh I think I I would maybe focus more on just being like Oh that game looks interesting I don't have a set schedule I'm gonna go try that game out right now right right and I guess you know like we have the advantage of the cardboard heral being fairly established at this point it's not a gigantic Channel but it's not a tiny Channel either like you can point at that 10,000 subscriber on YouTube number and just be like okay so here's something to show that we aren't nothing um so you're not feeling like you're inconveniencing someone just to talk to them um and I much prefer the route that we did in talking about how the the channel got to start doing interviews which we've continued to do but want to uh refocus on in the future um kind of resurrecting the the audio podcast format that we've done in the past and talk to some of these uh Publishers designers artists different individuals
in the space and be like hey we want to do this can we set up something for the future and we did a lot of that and there were so many people from um Brian bom who we talked about earlier the designer of the Fellowship of the Ring trick taking uh he's a staff member at um office dog under Asma day uh to the uh I guess current director maybe director I'd have to look at the business cards uh for um uh the the convention cookie guys the cookie Patrol is it the cookie Brigade cookie Bri yes um shame on me for forgetting that um to uh all kinds of uh Publishers who have vested interest in wanting to talk about their company but also have really interesting histories and stories of as the company uh changed and evolved or maybe have done something really different in the industry like I I would love to hear what button Shy's development as a company uh was like and what are the internal mechan going on there or oink games with so many Imports or all play there's a lot of really fascinating stories that are not only interesting to hear about but they are of value to so many people who come to board games and then realize it's
something that they'd like to try to do as a as a profession or at least as a side gig so um we did a lot of that kind of networking and setting up um contact so that way we could schedule future interviews y yeah and I think that again it's especially because we're we're a channel that is I think pretty well defined in who who we are for the most part where we you know do have a lot of that podcasting and interviewing uh to our Channel and we are kind of refocusing on that uh basically turning our attention to make sure that we continue having that be a part of our Channel but it's it's a thing where because we're pretty well establish of who we are we can just have these hey we're g to interview you later and have it be like a more sit down Chat thing um but yeah I think the big takeaways of the convention for me are have fun and in enjoy it meet people so you can chat and then make connections to talk to them later if you're interested in doing that but also just like as a person who this was my first time attending a convention this big focus on having fun and trying weird things you're there to see all that the board gaming industry has to offer and I think that this is the place to go find games that are weird that might be super up your alley like go to the go
I mean you're gonna see you're G to see the allplay games you're going to see the as Day games uh on your radar coming up soon if you're looking for those those are probably going to be coming up on your radar just because of how popular they are go down to like the weird side aisles and find find something that might just suit your fancy such as adventuring party which I had a lot of fun playing yeah yeah I was going say um you know our buddies over at windsmith games uh they did a collab uh with smirk and Dagger that's this Adventure Party game um which is is just such a uh like a it has a great hook to it which is like a collaborative storytelling game uh that's part RPG part party game uh with really simple prompts that anyone even if they hate um uh being put on the spot for that type of stuff it gives you a lot to pull from so that way you can get as granular uh or uh as high level as you want uh essentially just giving you like an something to yes and off of right yeah um and in a fantasy role playing sense that works beautifully and I could see it being reskinned for every theme Under the Sun but uh that seemed like it was getting a lot of uh traction at the convention it was cool playing with them
um kelp certainly was getting played I saw that uh a lot of places uh one of the big games I I mentioned it earlier but seti uh has made a big splash and seeing that uh really prominently at the convention I mean it has such a distinctive box art that like bright bright blue uh like Ultra saturated blue with the um kind of rusty Reds on it um has such a great visual aesthetic uh to the Box uh that they really leaned into that for marketing we did one of the the marketing uh meet and greets with uh cge sat down learned a little bit about the game uh Eric and I played um like three rounds uh out of five before I had to scadaddle and catch a train uh that's his excuse I guess uh he threw in the towel because yo those aliens were getting discovered by the Eddie population I had no clue what what I was the first few rounds I was like oh why track aliens I'm going to Jupiter contributing to this alien search and then I was like oh I'm very far behind the aliens have been found right I no contact with them I I want to play a lot more of that game and I got to really uh figure out what were how I settle on it because it is one of those games that's just a giant
sandbox and I don't think we necessarily struggled with how the mechanics worked in performing any individual mechanic um there was a lot and we only had the beest demonstration to kind of prompt us and then we were going through the majority of it together and that was fine but deciding what you were doing to make use of you know your limited amount of time because it's only a five round game and resources are precious and you have so many options that that you're like okay it's a Sandbox so I guess I'll just test this or I'll test this and then by about end of round two or beginning of round three you start going ah I see what I did to completely shoot myself in the foot um and you saw that I saw that you did not see that I saw that I saw what you did to completely shoot yourself in the foot um but that can be a really punishing experience but it can also be a rewarding experience if that sandbox leaves you room to come up with really interesting things that don't shoot yourself in the foot right you know like you you want in a game for someone to feel like their Victory is earned or even if they didn't win that they got to do something fulfilling or creative or interesting in some way that you know gives that you know dopamine
hit of you know like ah I was able to lean into this one specific weird thing um and unlike let's say uh Ark Nova or terraforming Mars or or a lot of the Euro games dour of recent years um where everything is defined largely by the cards in your hand and so you have a few limited choices but you know what costs too much what's not going to be feasible what has restrictions before you're going to be able to do it this really does have a huge amount of open space that is going to be incrementally obtained after a series of turns and you will have to start investing resources in and hopefully you're able to Pivot that into something and we were starting to really uh see that cook um but we don't want to end up in situation where a new player is going to do something and feel like because of decisions made in round one there is no chance of recovery in rounds four and five we didn't actually see it come through it was a learning game a train was coming we'll see that train was Eddie winning that you you I felt like you were leading up to that no yeah yeah I'll take it I'll take it I had a tough
time seeing at at the start how my actions were affecting the game MH and then two or three rounds in I was like oh got it I've completely ruined this for myself but you know I think but I think it was that is part of that game is discovering how these systems work and interact with one another like I fully was like oh I don't really know how scanning data helps me like I just feel like scanning data adds a little little Cube to my board but I'm not doing anything with them and then you like oblit you got so good at that uh I and I but then at the same time like I was visiting planets way more than you were and that did help me in a way that you never really got to like I you know I think there is just a lot of uh figuring out how the game works and I do think that there is something to be said of this game works really well if you un if like if you can see from point A to point B and I am totally okay with that I think that that's something that I just you know it was my first time playing it was your first time playing we were both trying things out and I do think that the sandbox aspect of it where there are a lot of systems in this game none of the systems on their own is that confusing but you have to and you can you can specialize in any of them but you do have to do I feel
like a little bit of everything and that's the part where the complexity of the game uh goes up but it isn't I feel like overwhelming except for when we were very first starting and didn't know what we were doing but that was so just we we were we were absolutely raw dogging the rule book yeah uh I I do love uh how unapologetically old school it is in some ways like there is no insert whatsoever in that box there are so many systems uh it is just like we are a big beautiful game and curvy is beautiful uh and and by curvy we mean orbiting planets yeah yeah Jupiter Jupiter size game um and I think that lack of handholding is also kind of enticing to me so I I want to think that I would be able to guide another player into having a better first experience uh with the game as well um so like you said raw dogging uh the rule book there raw dog the rule book never raw dog the rule book unless you know you're like well we got to kill some time and this is a cool game to check out we need to we need to cultivate opinions on um so that's one
of the more Curious things uh from the convention I am really excited about it I hope uh that it's uh going to be good I had a good time uh as we were playing it um but uh that one's definitely going to need some some more time for opinions to develop um and then uh were there were there any like straight up Duds for you uh at the con like things that just didn't work yeah well we tried this was also at the as Day presentation we tried pergola which just didn't land for me it just felt like it it was a bit Point salad in a way that I didn't like I mean that was a preview so I don't I mean I think it's pretty close to being done but that would be the one that we probably spent the most time playing that we didn't go all right and we're right we're out yeah it visually it also like to me um I hate to say this uh but it kind of looked like the board game version of Hotel art you know like there was nothing really uh dramatic or enticing about the the visual look of the game um it had a lot of systems um that felt peripheral to the experience uh and in a way that you
know seti has a lot of systems but they feel like they are contributing something no matter how abstracted or off to the side they are it's like I can see that in some way this is connected to this to this to this to this yeah I could see that there are connections via point uh in it but uh it just wasn't really driving anything home um and then uh I I got to play play it again but uh we played flock together um which felt like a weird experience like something was getting missed uh and I read through the rules again I don't think anything was missed but um it could be that it was a game that we were expecting it to be and it just wasn't but it's a fully Cooperative boss battler beautiful incredible component chicken themed yeah chicken themed boss battler um Christina was over the moon I just want to point Chicken theme pun heavy boss battler pun heavy pun I feel like were a very big character in the game yes um absolutely uh the uh look is beautiful had these little uh like spiral bound character sheets that as you leveled up your chicken you would um flip to the next page to show your progression the enemies also had that it had uh systems so that way could um fight different enemies each time um but
it also felt incredibly punishing in a way that was like whoa this is at odds with the depth of the game itself um and it's not like something that feels really alive in the way that even pandemic you know pandemic is a really rudimentary Cooperative game or um forbidden island is a really rudimentary Cooperative game but the the world feels alive the uh opponent being the game itself is doing things to you whereas flock together is very stiff the enemies are just there and you take damage as you punch them so it becomes an efficiency engine to have the resources to fight them to do damage before the time runs out yeah and if you don't do that fast enough then all the enemies get a little bit harder and then eventually you're going fight the final enemy who's the hardest and so initially we're going into it just going like well we want to build up as much resources as possible or minimize damage as much as possible but then when the enemies leveled up it was like oh holy [ __ ] like these are way more punishing to do a single attack against and how are we supposed to do that much damage and by the time that we got to the end it was like there there's no possible way that we can afford the amount of resources necessary to commit to the actions to fight the
enemies who are here which was a really weird experience for a game that has a lot of more shallow systems you know like it it does not seem like it presents itself to be a really crunchy strategy game that intends on you really maximizing the efficien of sing you do and yet that's the necessary uh effort that would be needed at least at the level that we were playing um to take on the the bosses and their final stages for me it was a matter of I am not going to say we played perfectly because I don't yeah our first time playing the game I don't think anybody can rightfully say that uh we feel like we're constantly making progress we got actually pretty good luck all things considered like there were a lot of roles that we landed that I think were really beneficial um and we got to the last boss and was just we needed I think we mathed it out in like we we needed 40 actions to kill this boss based on how much damage it was doing back to us and how much damage we could do to it and we had like 10 like it was so so far out of
reach that I and I didn't go back and reread the rule book but it really felt like we missed something to make the games exponentially harder for ourselves and I don't know if we just shouldn't have picked that person as the last boss but it was randomly Chosen and maybe it just was that last person because the other ones were did not deal that much damage to us like it was just which the one that we randomly grabbed right because that's how you're supposed to choose it um yeah and then also on your point of the enemies just kind of stand there they're like the little punching bag that like falls back and comes back and whacks you totally uh they they didn't feel like they were really affecting the world or prevent I mean really in in some ways it felt like we as the chickens were just trying to take over the land around us and we had to get them out of the way like they were just there minding their business colonialist chickens yeah we're colonialist chickens and also on your point of it wasn't the game isn't presenting itself as being this necessarily as deep or crunchy game there is a character called Wyatt chirp in this game is like the deepest hardest game we played at the con and it's just like you know I think that there is a little bit of Disconnect between the theme and the mechanics in that way uh yeah and and you know like
oh man it it just feels like it it was kind of lifeless in a way that um the Aesthetics were pulling all the weight I guess uh and that's a shame because it does look really great the Andrew Bosley artwork is amazing um and and I'm going to have to play again like I I have no problem with a a shallow game you know like there there are some really lightweight games out there that don't even have a a ton of depth um but are fun uh what they uh do um and you can have a lighter weight game that does have a ton of depth right you know low rules but you know lots of replayability strategic implications meta development all that kind of stuff I'm talking about like there are good games that are shallow just purely shallow games but still have a fun factor to them that that keep you coming back um and this uh is shallow in a way that's asking for a commitment uh of your attention um at a level that the game doesn't necessarily reward and like you said that could be us having misinterpreted some rules or just strategically played poorly like maybe we shot ourselves in the foot whereas if we had met the game
on its own terms right away we could have uh done a lot better this is a game where I went straight to BGG afterwards to look at the rules FAQ to see if like someone else was asking you know some of the same questions what am I missing and it's not covered with people going what am I missing or anything like that so maybe it is um it's one of the ones that uh is high on our list uh to get to the table again uh I suspect that at two players it's going to be better anyway uh because of the scaling in general um and it'll be a lower time commit which you know if you're sitting around and playing a game that is fairly shallow but it only takes about 45 minutes to an hour that's a different thing than something taking an hour and a half after learning the game um but yeah that that was probably the the most rickety experience of the con for me as far as sitting down with any game um but uh I think uh you know like the there are so many games that we played uh that we really enjoyed you know like I I think uh harmonies is one that we both uh absolutely adored ended up with copies of um in fact uh funnily
enough I had that on my list of games I wanted to get along with um uh Sky team and uh seti actually and I was like oh they have it I'm going to pick up a copy so that way it could be part of the game of the year discussion bought a copy and then in our asthma Day presentation they're like and each of your teams is going home today with a gift bag that includes a copy of harmonies uh which was great um it was great and then Jack turned to me and said huh what am I going to do with my second copy of harmonies to be fair to be fair I did initially think that we were getting two gift bags out of that uh and uh then quickly was um uh I I guess relieved of that assumption uh and so we got one copy I thought Eric was going to get a copy and then I was going to have another copy to maybe give away on a podcast or something Eric uh but no instead you greedily stole my copy of harmonies in I don't know what I'm going to do with my second copy of um but that game's rad you know yeah that game massive massive hit for our for our gaming group I think it's going to be a massive hit for a lot of gaming groups out there uh just the systems are really F like well tuned and
I feel like it is a great theme for a lot of people like I we've seen this theme be successful with a lot of different games and it's gorgeous like the the the presentation is both minimalistic but really Dynamic um the layering of the wooden pieces seems at first like it's going to be um maybe a little messy uh to deal with but I I found it very easy to just kind of hop in there and and figure it out and on the table uh similar to Sky Team actually uh I think it looks better on the table than it does if you're just kind of browsing on BGG um and Eric and I have differing opinions on Cascadia uh we've talked about that uh together on a video now uh but we've also uh separately uh talked about Cascadia um this to me is the game that I wanted Cascadia to be uh it is uh very tight relatively short uh naturalist theme abstract kind of puzzly very uh in the vein of something like aul or zata uh but it delivered the meat and interesting uh choices that you get to make um that are sometimes at the expense of what other players are going to do what you might be able to scoop out from under them or the opportunity cost in going One Direction or another because you know that if you leave
something sitting around long enough someone else is going to take advantage of it so uh it it really uh hit for me um have you played the solo mode yet not yet no no not yet I know that was one of the things that you were looking at for like how it's going to rank against Cascadia in your own mind yeah I mean I think for me that's going to be the big determining fact too because I think as a multiplayer game I despite the fact that I do enjoy Cascadia quite a bit uh this hits the things that I I want from Cascadia in a way that I feel like is more fun without more complexity like I don't think that I'm going to have I'm going to have roughly the same amount of time to explain the game to people as I would with Cascadia uh and I think that the uh solo mode is where I am going to kind of make my decision of whether or not I keep Cascadia or not uh just because I I think that they are in such a similar ballpark of what what kind of game they are that I like Cascadia solo mode I like that it's relaxing I like that there are achievements if you do want to get like really into it um but I think that if Harmony solo mode hits the same uh I I agree that this is the game
that Cascadia could be and isn't um but Harmony is I I one of the best games we played at the con I was between when you asked me at the very start of the podcast I didn't really have uh time to think uh and I said drop hter was my game of the con I still stand by that because we did play that one the most and I I'm still the highest moment of elation I felt in a while is playing drop hter and stealing ghosts from people uh harmonies is definitely I think like the most most well polished game that I think is going to be like I can easily see harmonies being like one of the modern classic games just in that it is easy and approachable for people who aren't necessarily into the Hobby and it is still it it feels like it has the depth to keep more seasoned board gamers coming back right right well the uh last thing that I wanted to kind of touch on is we did get a a cool experience of uh playing a couple uh upcoming games um which was really nice uh at the con or or not even upcoming just like games in development um so I think one of the highlights for both of us was uh we um got to play uh a potential a hypothetical maybe uh leader game uh with uh Nick
Brockman of leader games he's their senior uh game developer over there uh he has this um uh game he's talked about actually on the cardboard Herald podcast a couple times uh swarm uh which I don't think we even had a name up until this point I think that also is like a maybe maybe yeah yeah it doesn't fit the four-letter name title I was just about to say needs to get to the four-letter title uh they could really go into licensing with Warner Brother whoever owns the ants franchise but with the Z oh okay yeah yeah whatever whatever franchise that is I don't I have zero clue what production company owns that they could they could go into licensing and do that right right um well it's this game that uh Nick had originally uh described it in an interview um that I was talking to him about the aoy expansions uh but as inspired by Pikman meets Sim ant uh and I guess it was initially a competitive kind of Civ building resource Forex type of thing uh but it pivoted into a Cooperative game and let me tell you if you have any familiarity with Pikman or Sim ant and you're like is the game going to really kind of feel like that yes absolutely it feels like Pikman
meets him ant uh where you are uh cooperatively um trying to uh rescue your queen on a developing uh map that kind of mimics a fog of War system from like old rtss where you go out you discover um you get additional resources and you have this kind of automated management of sending your uh workers to do your bidding and those workers might be of different types and then they're essentially on cool down systems as they return things back to your hive or your colony and uh it's in a very early state but it was so cool seeing some of the uh decisions that were being made into to make this game which kind of felt unlike anything else that I I've played yeah was that uh like I I know you have uh game design aspirations I mean I've played some of your game designs in the past but like I don't know what was that like from your end because I don't have a lot of aspirations for game design on for myself but was that different seeing like a professional published designer who works for a very highly regarded company just be like I don't know we're working on that how about for today because Jack opened his mouth about it could be a little more difficult we're just going to take away some time and you know like actually yeah you're right
let's Pi this harder yeah um I mean I think for me it it made me a lot more confident in where some of my games my my designs are or have been where I'm like uh this isn't working and I feel like I keep making changes and I know that that's like it's frequently told that that is part of the process is Play Change Play Change Play Change until you have a good game um but I think seeing it espe from this is like this is his realm like this is his absolute wheelhouse he is very good at game design and development and seeing like him do really offthe cuff decisions of you know what this does need to be more punishing I'm just going to make a change right now uh or him you know just where where the game is and knowing like seeing how I guess not it didn't feel like there was a lot of pressure like this had to be the best game like it was you know we're going to try things out we're going to keep working at it and also like the game was fun despite all of these rough edges that he's like working on like that's right part of the board game design is find the rough edges and then cut those out as much as you can
and him I mean just being very open with where it is in the design process uh I think that it is a Big Boon for me to just have been able to sit there in the in in that part of game development game design where you know there is there are this is a very flimsy con con uh concept where it is he's got everything on paper that could be torn at any moment and it's just that's where it is um I think that gave me a lot more confidence in just continuing on with some designs that I have maybe given up some Hope on and just think giving myself more confidence get back in there and just keep play testing them uh I mean and the tough part is so much of my uh time recently has been moving and getting that that throws a wrench in things I suppose they had a lot less leisurely time but now they were getting back into you know like I I am getting more of a set schedule now uh I'm I'm definitely focusing on how do I start getting my uh designs back to the table and then also just I think seeing some of the games that have been published and part of it is like not necessarily disparaging those games but just being like oh this game is weird and doesn't land for me whatsoever uh and like seeing all of the different small Publishers that are all
up and down the back row publishing like this is their one game this is it it is maybe good it's it's certainly interesting most of the time um I think that as a person who does have aspirations to design and publish board games uh was really inspiring to just go okay there are a lot of games published every year my game would have just as much chance as any other game here like I might be able to publish it through one of like I'm probably not getting my first board game published through Asma day or leader games but like you know maybe I start my own there's a lot of board game Publishers out there um there there's a lot of people who are making it happen one way or another um that said this is one where even though it is very clearly in a rough State oh yeah God I just want to play this game like swarm like I went out of my way to we all did uh but like to to find Patrick leader in col Worley and be like hey you guys are the bosses here this was really dope it is rough it has had some recent changes but all three of us have not played this game before um we're not like close personal friends with Nick Brockman or anything we had a really good time playing that and would EAS easily play that again we could see
where it could go from there had a really cool action system in it I don't know if that's going to be part of well none of it is guaranteed to be part of the the end product um but where uh the players are you know like you play a card in your hand and then that card goes to the other player but it does a different thing for that other player uh and so you're you're making more availability and you're thinking about not just what's the best action for me to do but what is giving my uh my partner the capability to do the things that we need to do uh and work uh in harmony um was really cool and just seeing what sorts of levers can be pulled with this uh sort of automated system to send out groups of ants that can only carry so much and you have a maximum Squad and do you leave them in vulnerable positions just really cool ideas that like I said isn't really getting played with uh in other regards uh so I really hope that one um ends up being a a cool uh additional pillar for uh leader down the road um we played uh or I played uh one of wind Smith's uh uh prototypes that they're working on right now uh without giving too many details on that it has a cool Cooperative hidden movement type of element uh where one player
sees everything uh as is on the board and the other player just kind of sees the board uh and they have to navigate uh via uh I I guess the the person who knows everything has to give directions and clues and information to the other player who has to actually perform the board game interaction with the game Space using that information which ends up getting clouded in some way and that was really cool uh to uh check out uh and then um we also had Greg lauring Albright's uh new religious design that's kind of bananas um light playing religion game keep uh I think the title at the moment is keep the faith yes it is keep the faith uh it's coming uh here pretty soon um it's another sort of role playing game you know like where you're telling stories together ostensibly there is a winner like a way to win uh but it's more about giving interesting prompts but I played this for the first time as a prototype a couple years ago at a coffee shop uh with Greg uh who I have become um at least casual get together at the convention and hang out at least once uh friends with um and he uh he uh
uh played it with me and some people I had never met before and it's a game of like uh fracturing faiths and how uh these uh schisms and upheavals end up shaping societies and cultures um and makes for some really interesting discussion uh and I had a great time when I first played it and I had a great time playing it with uh you in the pretty much finished state that it was I don't know what what was your takeaway of my game oh I I enjoyed it I mean I think that it's a it is a light roleplaying game so people have to be into the fact that you are contributing a lot of the story in this game like it is up to you as the players but you that's the fun of it is figuring out how to yes and things on the board uh there is like a as you said there's like a winning there there is a ultimate goal that you are guiding yourself towards which I feel like with a lot of these more looser roleplaying games or systems uh there is a structure in keep the faith that I have not found in other games of a similar ilk uh where you are playing not as like a person but you are playing as an ideological goal for a
religion you are you are not playing like any specific person because as we played a lot of our people just died uh that was a running theme for our religion that was not very uh uh was definitely prevalent and I think that the looseness of of it combined with the structure that is you do have a wind condition that you are aiming towards um was I had I had a lot of fun with it I mean I think that there's a lot of uh artistic discussion of what is religion and how is religion built and shaped baked into this game which I I know was one of his design goals was to have it be a bit more of an artistic take on that think that he succeeded at it it seemed like it could be something that uh could I mean he's a professor right he's a professor of game design uh he was there with his students um but it felt like something that could be played in a school as like a fun silly thing but also talking about like what happens when there are diametrically opposed uh um uh needs or purposes uh that are pursued by different members of the same group you know and like uh what sort of tribalism
does that invite um it it invites a lot of discussion but it can just be like a a silly game too um and the mechanical nature in which the game uses the the terminology of uh religion and theology um and then also the the the existing template um to build off of uh is really cool how you see these um ideals shift around the board so anything that you've already said about it in the past you now are connecting the dots for how it relates to this new thing um allows you to kind of collaboratively develop a universe and a a world or you know the story of this uh religion which is really cool um so it's one of those games that you know has sunk its teeth into me I don't know what space it's going to be best for but as someone who doesn't do a lot of role playing that has really uh made a big impact for me um or on Me Maybe it made an impact for me as well on my behalf um yeah I mean yeah and I'm definitely of the two of us the one who plays more role playing games so it was interesting to have I think both of us there to to play it um yeah I think that was a really great game I'm glad that we got to try it out uh what are your like if you just real quick to maybe end off
end off the podcast top five games that you either didn't play at the con or are hoping to get to the table soon that you took away from the con yeah yeah so I'm GNA guess we might have some overlap on this yeah we might uh definitely um there are a lot of games I took out uh some of them I've played uh since like uh just earlier today I played catm uh which is cool um it's uh an osprey release that's planned to be available in 2025 so it's one of those things like do we consider as part of game of the year deliberations for this year or do we consider a 2025 game probably uh leaning towards the ladder uh but it's um an even more narrow game than I expected going in uh but I think in a mostly good way uh of bears uh in Alaska uh like this is an actual uh area of Alaska uh which is beautifully Illustrated and presented here and it's just about um these Bears struggling for territory uh and dominance uh in the catm uh region of Alaska um which is cool that a British traditionally war game publisher uh has kind of stretched outside of their standard themes to make this which
kind of fits within their head-to-head struggle uh uh ethos um it was fun uh I really enjoyed it it's presented beautifully and it's one of those games where I don't think it has a lot of depth and even for you know like a a game that has strategic implications to things that you do I I don't think it's going to have a ton of death but it is satisfying so I had a good time with it um that was one of the ones that I most wanted to play kfire Chronicles no no no kfire delve um I do really want to play kfire Chronicles so that that's all been like a mystery to me there's like five games that have been released all in this kire thing but I hadn't played any of them uh I got the releases for kfire delve um and that was one that was like I need to get this played uh Christina and I played it's a dedicated two-player Cooperative game really enjoyed it uh beautiful visual aesthetic um and in some ways it reminded me of the Pathfinder Adventure card game in like what I wish that game uh was uh it's much more strategic uh in being just like hard numbers with more limited dice uh influence outcomes um not as obvious at decisions and it's cool that it's mix and matchable with um uh the
different sets which I do think that you can play more than two players if you have multiple sets but there are three releases each of them have two heroes in them and so if you buy it it's a one to two player game um nonetheless had a good time with that lost it still had a great time um then uh seti um partially played at the con want to play it some more um uh Pagan was one that I really wanted to see because I'm feeling this two-player dedicated thing we got catm we got uh Pagan we got kelp uh Ironwood just came out and I've been um getting ready to do a review of that um there's so many cool dedicated two-player games right now uh that I I'm hungry for Pagan um and then I think I I I think that takes me up to four um Mass Effect uh oh yeah I don't know you got that early yeah yeah I got that as another one of the games I really wanted to play for consideration for game of the year it wasn't I wasn't really expecting it to be a game of the year game but like I'm a mass effect nerd I play the crap out of Mass Effect I I needed to play the mass effect effect game especially because the designers are designers of repute um modius
is Hit or Miss um and there were some things about the release of this game that were also kind of hit or miss with me with some of the like miniature availability and some of the pricing and that kind of stuff but the the retail version I think was like 50 bucks at the con I was like oo I'm going to get this along with harmonies I did not get a second copy of Mass Effect um in a gift bag but um I was like I don't know how this is actually going to be I read the rules earlier it looks pretty cool there's some cool stuff in that I I'm excited tentatively excited to play it um I think I would have a healthy amount of criticisms for the game um but reading through the rules there are some interesting things I was like oh that's that's a cool idea to kind of make a hex-based um Dungeon Crawl type of game uh flow in a little bit easier uh package than um something like uh Gloom Haven or something right now um and to make a a campaign that is only intended to be up to five games uh is pretty cool and if it can stick the landing on each scenario is meant to be about 45 minutes and uh and the the multi-tiered way that you play through
that you have three different potential scenario ones um or at least three takes on that uh and then you can choose to do a loyalty Mission it's an optional loyalty mission for a squadmate and then do up to three different scenario twos uh and then a potential uh optional uh loyalty Mission and then three different scenario 3s and the outcomes of each of those scenarios influence something uh coming up and that's your campaign that's actually a lot more manageable than you know hey we're playing Frost Haven for the next six years yeah and got to rely on that group all working out so um yeah th th those are the games I think that I'm most stoked about uh like immediate coverage um I didn't get a chance to play Black Forest I also didn't uh grab a copy there uh though that's one that I really want to play I'm a huge U Rosenberg fan um and there were a couple other games uh that I caught my eye here or there um including uh like Kabuto suo secur slam which I played the prototype for I haven't played the final version I'm hoping to get a copy here soon but I think that's about it uh how about you uh I'll start off with the campaign game that I'm most excited about and this was for me the
big kit of the convention which is clink Acquisitions Incorporated to uh my wife's favorite board game is Clank it's up there for me as well just in terms of one of the first deck builders that I really connected with uh so I'm super stoked to play through that uh I think that give more Clank give me more Clank I about all the expansions to Clank I'm here for clank what about Clank duel can we get a Clank duel we probably could though I will say I do quite enjoy Clank as a two-player game I I'm down for a Clank duel I don't care I don't care there's of games so that are great as two- player games and they're still giving us duels let let's get everything du let's get Clank duel yeah two-player duel um along the same lines as you SEI I'm really interested in playing again now that I feel like I grasp the system a bit more so that would be one of the ones that I would be interested in playing again uh the next chance I get catm as well I am also super into the theme it's Alaska it's bears in Alaska it's Fab Bear Week the game a big big fan I went into it being a big fan and then just seeing how many people are playing it and how interesting uh I think people I mean it's so popular or or so cool and you are so hot for it that the police are coming for you right now yeah I hear that in the background this is what happens when you live in a big city yeah
we were just getting some of that flavor I had some dog you had some Sirens um and then my last two actually uh we've talked about both of a little bit already but they're the ones that I would be most interested in playing a full game of from start to finish uh would be El Paso to see how does it play like from Like A to B I haven't played Great Western Trail and so for me this was my first introduction to GWT is that the is that what call it yeah yeah I actually had to take a risky acronym uh earlier you know I was like oh can I just say GWT is that right and I I just call I'm call no I'm not letting you get past it no GWT that's what we're going with yeah yeah yeah okay cool uh um I'm excited to play that uh and just again as a person who doesn't know much about Great Western Trail uh I had a lot of fun in our like one time around playing it uh I would be interested to do a full like how does it play as a whole game cuz we missed out on a lot of the systems in there because we were playing such a short uh piece like there is a whole like Milestone system that I feel like we didn't quite get to play and then uh yeah the one that I have also already talked about is crafting the cosmos like that just seems like it was going to be right up my alley in terms of a game that I will very much enjoy uh and it it's it's just weird
enough that I don't know of all like it um but it seems it seems weird and a way that I will like the fact that you are always going to be generating the same number of resources but it the difference is going to be What proportion you're getting it in like you will always be I I think in whatever player account we had no matter what we are always generating nine resources now that might be four oxy it wouldn't be four oxygen because I think they cap out at three but yes that I think is interesting to me where it's like maybe three oxygen and two time quirks that you're getting this time around um and how do you play with that and how do you interact with that to make sure that you can build the cosmos the most effectively that was a game that I uh especially after that demo was really interested in seeing seeing how a whole game of that is played yeah it that that was it's the law the what is it conservation energ thing right that you know energy is never right uh that it's never created or destroyed it's merely transformed and so like it was trying to pick up on some of those things um it's basically like uh reading I don't know the three body problem books where you know they just throw some things at you I'm like yeah it sounds good that sounds legit sound
science yeah I don't know probably that's probably true yeah yeah of course you you've probably done a lot more research on it than I have scientist who's making this game sure I'll Trust you whatever you say exactly well uh that is just I think the tip of the iceberg for um our our own experience like as far as like anecdotes people that we talk to uh there there are a bunch of games that we played that we didn't even get a chance to talk to here that are probably smaller games you know like um I mentioned Scout earlier we have Moon rollers f f that I had on my list that I you know we just didn't talk about our time playing it but you know yeah weird weird game um weird game we played some old stuff too you know like I got a game of uh the king is dead in taught someone how to play that and we played furnace yeah um furnace was great and then um I uh got a chance to play uh Ghost of Christmas uh with these guys uh very holiday themed um so so much to do and I anyone who's listening I really encourage you to go to gaming convention and just like go to have fun make connections um hang out with people uh as far as us we're looking to do some podcasting we're going to be doing uh some more of this as we kind of figure out our schedule what the sort of recording and editing level is going to
be and um how we want to produce list we have some ideas to work on and we'll uh uh get that uh out there uh but if you have like some uh thoughts of your own then uh you can always uh comment if this is on uh YouTube or you can uh reach out to us at the contact us at the topic cardboard herald.com um for feedback we'd love to hear from you we'd probably be up for like a mailbag section right yeah we can easily we we don't have any structure right now we can throw sure mailbag section let's do it hell yeah hell yeah let's get that content in there one question a week or two I don't know I don't know how frequently we're going to get questions but you know we'll try it we'll do what we can yeah we'll we'll throw some stuff in there um and uh you know hopefully we'll have a more formed this is what this podcast is going to be in the future and then also uh get some more of those dedicated interviews with people the creative Gamers and game creators um which uh I'm I'm excited about 2025 so this this has been great Eric how do you feel do you feel like this went well I feel good I you know I drink a whole pint of water so I'm feeling like you know I'm feeling good yeah uh I I think we got good things to come uh so for everyone uh who's listening uh thanks for listening thanks for supporting and
uh we'll uh have something for you in the future how do you end a podcast is that how you end a podcast I've done over aund of these and maybe that's how you end a podcast and I'm Eric all right we're ending it there take care everyone