The Reiner Knizia Special
Transcript
this video is sponsored by skillshare this man's name is Riner Kenia and yes he has designed over 700 board games and we will review every single one of them well okay so we're going to review three of them in part one and the another 697 plus we will review in part two which I'm sure is going to go live any moment now here's some fun Riner Kia facts to get us going he used to be an operations director of a multi-billion doll mortgage company before quitting the life of High Finance to become a board game designer the root of his last name shares the same root as the Russian word for Knight Kaz and finally if you type in Kia into Google one of the first result is just people asking how much is this man worth all right I hear you 700 games not very impressive if they're all rubbish fredman free for example designed 504 games in just one box and they all range from not very good to please take that away from me but that's the thing you see Riner Kenia is the hunk with no junk his games frequently range from this is okay I had a f time to this
might be the best game I have ever played shamefully in my 7 and 1/2 years reviewing board games I have but one Riner kenit video review under my belt and when I say belt I mean a YouTube playlist of our reviews today we will fix that mistake with not one but three out of this world fantastic games and at the end of the video we'll do a lightning round review of some of the others just in case part two never comes out monar is the only board game in the world that I own two copies of which also by default makes it the only board game in the world that I own three copies of and if you want one of these you can pry them from my cold dead hands Mona is one of the earliest Rhino kitu designs ranging as far back as 1992 and in pandemic years that makes it as all this chess in modern art You'll Play competing museums putting up art for auctions you'll start with a hand of cards each representing paintings from five different artists if it's your turn pick any card from your hand and put it up for auction if you sell it to someone great you take the money and squirrel it away behind your screen this is very good because whoever has the most money
at the end of the game will win and will be crowned Dr money pants that's a real rule by the way I didn't make that up you can however bid on the auction yourself and if you win it you spend your own money and adopt that sinking feeling that says oh no have I have I made a horrible mistake great now I have this worthless p P of junk what's art good for anyway it is literally the opposite of money not to worry because sometimes art is popular and if art is popular you can sell it purchased Art stays in front of the respective owners the five different artists will be evaluated at the end of each round the most popular artist will be worth the most the second one less and the third one least whereas the two least popular artists will be worth nothing and here's the catch at the end of each round after the artists have been judged and found either pretentious or wanting you are forced to flog all the art that's right sell all of it even if it's worth squidly squat if I had to find common ground in all of Rhino kinia 700 plus games which obviously I all played it would be the sensation of ooh I get it now wow Rhino Kenia likes to make you feel stupid but not in a nasty way he
hides the fun tucks it in a little box to be open later as a surprise this is why you frequently hear that his games are dry which a is nonsense and B is only understandable if your critique ended at reading the rules rather than playing the game itself mon is exactly the same here's some art sell it in an auction forced to sell it at the end of the round then there's four rounds and the game ends but actually it's littered with light bub moments like Clues to be found in a scavenger hunt first up there's four different types of auctions with a fifth semi- type to really spice things up the type of auction depends entirely on what piece of art you put up for auction so for example if I went with this cigarette thala we would have to hold an open auction that's the type of auction you typically see in movies where anyone can name any price as long as is higher your typical can I get $1 $1 anyone $2 $2 $3 can I hear $5 $100 million clowns sold to Young Richard E Grant other auctions include a hidden auction where everyone secretly puts some money in their hands and then simultaneously reveals it a one-time offer auction where in clockwise order players either bid hire or pass but only have a single chance to make an offer and finally a fixed price auction where the auctioneer sets the price and in clockwise order players either buy it or pass every
auction turns into a surprise a change of pace ooh what's this one going to be a hidden auction we haven't had those in a while what two fixed price auctions in a row by the same artist things are getting spicy but nothing is as spicy as the double auction if you put up a piece of art with the double auction symbol you have to immediately put up a second piece of art by the same artist and the type of auction on that second card will determine how both of these paintings will be sold together Thunder crackles in the distance something changes in the air voices hush when someone puts up a double auction because it's a signifier nay and Omen that we're in the big leagues now it's also one of those light bulb moments because at the start of the round you might have a lot of one artist in your hand and you go huh okay if I put up a double auction of Manuel carvalo right now well there's going to be a lot of Manuel carvalo paintings out and then everyone knows that Manuel Calo is valuable and so when I keep putting manual cavalo paintings for sale during that round I will get a lot of money from it and then you realize that you're selling the popular dude to everyone else and everyone else will be making a profit off of him because the round ends when any of the artists have a grand total of five of their paintings sold
during that round you might do a lot better quietly buying up manual Calo paintings and then just end the round with a double whammy of a double auction and suddenly you have free paintings of the most valuable artist out there but the best part of of Modern Art is the theatrics there's certainly no rule that says that you have to Big up the art that you put up for auctions but if you don't you're missing out on some prime comedy hello everyone today for sale we have Daniel mim's oil oil of course represents the sheer existential dread that we all encounter when we realized that oil isn't actually good to eat and we've eaten a lot of it and and and now it's in our tummy and we kind of go oh no oil so so that's what that's about and I will see the bidding star at $1 million that's cigarette thas does ryzen rod and that is of course about about the universe because you see there's a ferris wheel but you see every booth on the ferris wheel uh has only a single lone occupant so that represents our loneliness in the universe and that we're all ultimately just going around in circles alone
without anyone to keep us company and we'll start the bidding at $2 million art is a funny thing no literally art is funny and how we interpret art is also funny and that's precisely why I own free versions of Modern Art sure mechanically they are 100% % identical the mood is so suddenly altered based on which artists are on display the seon version of Modern Art which is nearing the stage of hard to find so if you want a copy grab one now has easily the worst art and when I say worst I don't mean it looks bad it's high contrast vibrant has broad appeal basically it's very kid which makes it perfect for this game because you can talk endless bull about it bonus comes with a tiny gavl which is very cute unless you have the Korean dice tree Games version and when it comes to gavs well this is pretty much just an actual gavel if you think this is excessive wait till you see the other components these metal coins feature a relief of the artists in the game with the 100 coin featuring a relief of Riner kitzia himself and whilst I do have to knock some points off for replacing his signature B tie with a regular tie I mean this is just
special right bonus there is a tiny wooden easel although it doesn't really work very well and two different sets of artwork one Western and one traditional Korean and whilst none of this stuff is exactly Modern Art like the Western Art is just mostly impressionist paintings but you do get to talk bull about this scream all you like now let me show you the mayther version hello this you will have to find secondhand if you want it but you can probably find it very cheap and I recommend it highly the art is out of this world which is just the right level of kit for Modern Art but also there's someone called light metal honestly this is just an endless amount of bizarre weird and delightful it's a real shame that the other components are a bit pant I've gotten rid of mine and just kept the cards and the board and use bits from other versions of Modern Art and if you have some metal coins from another board game or some poker chips the Mayfair version is a bargain get Modern Art if you want a great introduction to board games or if you like a bit of theatrics or if you love a good auction and Tim wott makes you w to oh no best yet there's other versions too if you visit the board game geek entry for Modern Art and go on the versions tab there's a whole lot of
Modern Art from different countries and in different languages but there's never any text here so as long as you get yourself an online rule book in your language you should be able to play any of these warning do not attempt to buy the Japanese stamps version of Modern Art not only is it so rare that it asks a price of 500 on the secondhand Market but also you have to B up stamps which is probably rubbish I don't know I've never played it cuz I'm not going to spend £500 on another version of mon
not let's talk about another game people are designed to recognize patterns it's a genetic tool that's been passed down for Generations so that we could survive Ikea when we hear that a man has designed 700 board games one question immediately Springs to mind what have I been doing with my life but also what unifies them I don't know how to tie up that many creative Endeavors from different genres mechanisms and settings but I think one way we can recognize a Kia game is iteration Dr Riner sometimes breaks ground with Innovation but most often he's seen taking an established idea stripping it down and exposing what's most fun about it my city takes two established board game tropes that being the Legacy genre which are type of campaign games where rules change cards are ripped stickers are glued and a pen is applied liberally to board game components and polyamino tile laying which are you know the tetris pieces which I now realize are also a type of pattern recognition blimy gertrud he gamified our lizard brains once again describing the rules to my city will make it seem drastically dull but bear with me in my city you'll have a board with some trees and rocks and you'll also have some polyamido pieces each turn a card is drawn displaying a Ted tree and you'll take it and place it
on your board adjacent to the river but not Crossing it or if it's not your first piece then you can place it adjacent to another piece at the end of the game you'll get one point for each tree you haven't covered up but lose a point for each Rock still visible and each light green space you haven't covered up aside from some nuances and particularities that's it that's the game Draw a card take a piece put it down but do not mistake the rule set for the game for my city is some of the most fun I had with stickers since that time I ended up in A&E with sticker ritis my city is a masterclass of emerging game design the entire campaign is split up into eight chapters each chapter is a play session but it's once again split into three episodes each episode representing a game meaning that when you sit down to play a game of my city you won't be playing one of them you'll be playing three yet each time the rules will change thankfully I don't even need to spoil anything in these deceptively stuffy looking envelopes to show you what I mean the basic rules are enough when I flip my first card I have to place that piece that's simple right sure but I've just reduced the available space in the game the river already makes things awkward because I can't overlap it and I also don't want empty green spaces so I better make sure that
all of these pieces fit perfectly and if I place this here I already made a mistake because I can never fill that space because the river prevents easy placement I also have to account for uneven borders formed by this mountain here and this Forest here and I have to account for every single piece in the game because even if I make one slip I have to cover up trees and that is literally the only thing that scores me positive points in the game involuntarily a plan starts forming in your head the blue square blog goes here the straight one goes in this corner and then you draw a card and go I I had no plan for this piece I guess I could just put it here what could go wrong what could go wrong indeed if you're asking yourself wait a minute what's up with all this other stuff like why are the Tet trees in three different colors why is there a forest why is there a mountain why is there this space on the side of the board all of these questions have an answer but not one I will tell I will however say that the good doctor uses the Legacy format to once again return to his design tropes and it works a treat remember when I said that Rhino kit likes to put plot twists in his games those little moments of understanding where you go ooh I think I get it now well my city is like a roller coaster ride of plotwist where each time you start to get a handle on how it
plays it introduces a new rule that just seems utterly ludicrous but that changes everything I understand about how this game works you will say to yourself upon reading the rules for the next chapter and then you'll be like okay okay no worries I'll just play a little bit and ooh ooh I think I'm starting to get it now wait a minute what are the rules for the next episode it's a bumpy ride for sure and I don't think my city is for every everyone if you hate having the rug pulled from under you then this game is like having your face hit with that same rug over and over again for no particular reason I love it but I'm a glutton for punishment and rer really uses his understanding of our lizard brains to punish you extra realizing that humans recognize pattern is one thing but using that knowledge directly against us is some Next Level Sith Lord meddling hey guess what's fun about recognizing patterns it's that we tend to group them together so if we see a z-shape we're like cool that's a z-shape I have that I will use it and when you have a z-shape gap and the z-shape comes up you're like cool I'll put it here only to realize that it's the wrong z-shape and the z- shapes in my city Only face one way so you have no one but yourself to blame right right my city is a game of
frustration groans and a shared sense of commiseration at your own Folly and mistakes but there's one final rule that stops IT from being a misery Fest and turns it into a comedy of errors every time you flip the card that tells you what piece you place you must then immediately place that piece you've not got time to think now that might sound awful you might say what's the point of playing a thinky game if you haven't got time to think you might think well I think that it's the spirit of the rule that matters here rather than the rule itself what my city is trying to do is to stop you from overthinking it because you could literally sit here and analyze your board for 5 minutes between every card flip to find the perfect placement instead it just gently rushes things along to be polite to all players but what that rule then achieves is a different sense of timing and Pace you might have just made the silly mistake of your game but oops too late time to make another one and another one and another one you can't help but laugh at the misery this is also where my city falls apart a bit somewhere around chapter 6 things get a little bit more thinky to the point where if you follow this rule at all the game would stop making sense less of a house Builder and more Burning Down The House but the mileage you'll get out of it by then is already double the entry cost so there is no way that'll stop me from
recommending it also whilst we're on the subject of criticism I should note that there is an eternal mode that'll let you play your copy indefinitely but it is nowhere near as fun as the constant sense of Discovery you get while playing through the campaign bonus if you plan to play my city with just two people you should be theoretically able to play through the campaign twice as there's enough components and stickers in the envelopes to dou the trouble but also if you plan to play with just two players please consult BGG for rules advice because the rules for two players scoring in the rule book is unclear also consult BGG for rules advice regardless of player count each time you start a new chapter because ambiguities abound otherwise in my city rer kitzia fathered one heck of a baby and since we're talking of babies it's time to move on to I am so sorry but I had to do that because much like an actual infant Babylonia is a game that will demand all of your attention I know this is becoming a little bit formulaic but every time I mention a new Rhino Kia game I can pretty much invent a new connective tissue between all of them so instead here's another connective tissue
between some of them if Dr Riner is known for galvanizing other ideas and iterating on them he's also known for cannibalizing his own ideas and giving them a bit of a tweak one of his early designs is through the desert a game in which you build roads out of camels I'm not really sure how that works you Skip Along humps maybe but he later RIS did that design in Blue Lagoon where you also build roads out of people from Polynesia best not to dwell on that another one of his famous designs perhaps even one of the most beloved is Tigress andraes a TI laning game of Shifting chairs you try to sit on one and oops your bum is on the floor which he again later Revisited in another title called yellow and yangi and both of these will touch on a little bit in the lightning round and in true Marvel Avengers crossover fashion ideas from both of these kinia branches into mesh in Babylonia plucking the juiciest fruits of each to be delivered on your table in Babylonia you'll try and win the game by having the most points but whereas other board games make you chug along at the start here you rev up to 60 in the first 10 seconds and the pace never lets up until one of you crashes into the Finish Line at the start of the game each player will be dealt a hand of five Clan tokens in your color these
could be Nobles represented by pots beards or the Illuminati or they could be Farmers where the artwork shows an uncomfortably contorted person with a sickle probably a Soviet zombie on your turn you get to put down two tokens on almost any space of the board there's no funky adjacency rules you just plug it down wherever you like and there it will live immovable forever here's a trick deploying Nobles is great once a city is surrounded by tokens completely it'll score everyone points if the city shows beards as part of its scoring condition you will get two points for any beard that is hanging out by that City in your color but also any opponent that has beards adjacent to that City will also get two points per beard furthermore if you have an uninterrupted line of tokens with beards in them then also those tokens will score you two points per beard in that uninterrupted line and the same is true for your opponent let me illustrate something clever let's say there's a city with four tokens around it I could spend both of my token placements to surround it completely and then it would score and it would score me six points in total that's pretty nice but what I can do instead is plun just one token down now Whoever has the most
tokens around the city will get the city tile itself and that's potentially extra points so no matter what happens in this game when this is complete I will score a bunch of points from it meanwhile that other token can go somewhere else and fight another important battle that might sound smart and if it is but then you realize that by delaying you've given your opponent an opportunity to link up that loan token with a row of other ones and now when the city is complete they will also be scoring a bunch of points and that's just cities I don't know what was happening in ancient Babylonia but if we're to go by this game there were probably points everywhere place a farmer on a tow with a farmer that's points place things next to a zigat that's not only points that's points equal to the number of cigarettes you have things adjacent to did I mention that if you only play Farmers instead of playing two Clan tokens a turn you can play as many clan tokens as you like that means that hypothetically if my hand was composed entirely out of farmers I could go uh Bam Bam Bam Bam Bam that's 15 points good night everybody feels so great I know I'm making this sound like Point pin ball and to a large extent it is but I like how much scope there is for careful and considered moves I could for example place a tile here place a tile here and
then this city would score and that's 2 468 points that's great but that's also 2 46 points to my opponent or I could spread out a little bit and start populating my tokens in various corners of the map but then am I giving my opponent too much ground over here who knows and of course you saw it coming here's the Riner kinia plot twist except this time it doesn't appear during the game and it's not so immediately obvious it lies in the weeds and roots of Babylonia when you finish a game you'll go huh that was pretty close you got some points I got some points and you got some points again but the victory that was pretty decisive that's because as much as Babylonia paints itself to be a game about shrewd opportunism the real Victor is the person who wo the best plan throughout the game secretly it was about building an infrastructure all along connecting the land together you might even say it's less of a Riner Kia game and more of a Riner Kia game in this video I'd rather not pick at how Kia games are themed because we'll start plucking at the ugly scabs of board gaming but I feel like there's something emergent here the villains of the story are opportunists eing out an unfair Advantage but the heroes are the people who build sustainable systems that will Outlast them a tale as old as time I
haven't even mentioned the special powers you get from winning majorities for Zig rats and those are also exciting but we have precious little time in this video and there's some things about Babylonia you need to know before you hit purchase first of all this board is ludicrous it is so over the- top big that I could almost forget how poor it is for comprehension is it gorgeous absolutely it's got greens and blues and that color palette Is My Jam but it is also impossible to tell what is a land tile and what is a river tile and that's very important for scoring there's the faintest width of a symbol identifying Rivers but you can barely make it out also these wooden token holders might look really cool and they are until I tell you that for them to properly function I had to put blue Tac underneath them and finally would you like to know how I feel about the rule book that's right it's hot garbage with many rules left ambiguous would I recommend Babylonia in spite of those issues yes frankly I think it's pretty great but only by The Virtue that the better Rhino K T Lane games are out of print and mega expensive and I will tell you about those in our credits lightning round that will happen right after a word from our sponsors so much Kia so little time this video is sponsored by skillshare the online
learning community with thousands of inspiring classes for creators you don't have to design 700 board games to make yourself feel good but you'll certainly benefit from broadening your knowledge and Horizons skillshare offers thousands of online tutorials for almost any subject imaginable from cooking to photography to Interior Design to even board game design it's never too late to brush up your skills even if it's something you're already comfortable with I've been making videos on YouTube for 7 years but that's not going to stop me from learning from people at the top of their game so who better to learn from than Marquez brownley and his class YouTube success script shoot and edit with MKBHD that man has interviewed the president and not the bad one skillshare lets you set your own pace and follow along with a comfortable structure there's no ads just the tools you need to become better best yet the first 1,000 of our subscribers can click the link in the description to get a one month free trial of skillshare Premium so you can start exploring your creativity today welcome to the unscripted lightning round aka the most terrifying thing I have ever done in my life where I will view a new Rhino K board game every 30 seconds or so and I don't even know which one's coming next ela's going to pass me one it's her decision what it is and if there's a jump cut you will know that something has gone wrong Elaine let us begin oh my
God Michi the dice game so this is Michi was uh Rino Kenia auction game so they took what's fun out of the auction game that being the auction part and made it into a fairly average roll and Wright I did not like medich the dice game and I would not recommend it to anyone simply because the game is fine but there's better roll and rright games out there oh my God Winner Circle where do I even begin this is from the dice tree games again the Korean publisher I mentioned that for Modern Art in the review uh as always dice Street games do a lovely production and this is uh this has horses and it's a game about horse racing which is probably the most vile sport I've ever encountered and the only reason for its existence is to give Clare balding a career now in in Winner Circle you will you will bet against horses who are racing and what's great about it is that it's sort of like a roll and move game but like really great for introducing people to board games check out winner circle is really really good I have to move on to tigers and Euphrates tigers and Euphrates is a classic one of the eight board games to ever have been on bgg's number one best board game of all time uh I love tigers Freddy's it's this sort of game where you it's kind of like Game of Thrones uh where you have all these advisors and you have to gain points from them by laying tiles next to them but there are other players advisers and you want to kick them out so there's like Wars and everything on this board but the most important thing about it is that your
score is uh the least type of victory points you have out of four different types of victory points yellow and Yan is the sequel to tigers and Euphrates and it's kind of like tigers and Euphrates and if you want tigers and Euphrates you can't buy that as out of print this you can still sort of find it it's going out of print uh but it's not as good as tigers and eup frates some people say because it's a little bit looser because in tigers and Euphrates you have um you have tiles that are square as you can see on this square and these squares and in yellow and Yi you have hexagons and hexagons have more edges to them so it's it's a little bit looser and a little bit more free oh my God it's royal visit uh in royal visit you have an amazing production from yellow the it's a game that's been republished with a different theme before the theme was not good uh I'm not going to say what it was but you have this like cloth board and you have to move pieces about and you have to get the pieces in the right place it's a tug-of war game I would recommend it it's pretty nice but I won't because Watergate exists and it's a little better that's royal visit uh ra another rhino need a classic um uh auction game uh it is the total opposite of Modern Art Modern Art is this freewheeling uh loose uh Rhiner K auction game ra is very strict and it's got set collection and you bid on tiles and you don't want a bid on anything but you also want everything and you never get enough of
anything it's also out of print but I hear there is a new version coming with an artist that I am very very very excited about Stevenson's rocket that's cheating Al lame because I've not played it no idea this is this is a train game by Rino Kia I've not played it it's got trains and I hear it's not good with two players but I also hear much like tigers and Euphrates is notoriously hard to explain uh there's surely not going to be any more games because there's H quest for Al Dorado this is really good uh I really like it it's got a very colonist appropriative theme that I don't enjoy uh the theme I wish was anything else but it but it's a deck building game with scantly a few deck building cards but they're all very powerful all very very cool and you have to move your figures across a map um that you compose and there's different maps and there's also Standalone expansion and that Standalone expansion in my opinion isn't as good because it's not as pure an experience uh whereas in base Game Quest for Dorado you just sort of uh run through the map and whoever gets the Finish Line first wins there's no points or anything like that is that it that's it that's it that's Riner Ken everyone uh I hope you enjoyed it in case it wasn't clear from the joke at the beginning there will be no part two um this is it this is our retrospective of Riner kenita games but if you want to know some more about the games that I talked about in the lightning round there will be a future podcast episode
and you can go to no pun included. comom podcast and check it out in fact go there now uh or watch some of other the videos that are appearing some somewhere over these board games uh thank you very much everyone um if you like us support us on patreon bye-bye