Search for Lost Species: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Zach and I are doing a discussion for the search for lost species which is uh the renegade's new re-theming of the search for Planet X yep so let's get this out of the way if you don't like one you're not gonna like this one if you don't like uh search for Planet X you're not going to enjoy this game exactly um they are both uh like logic deduction puzzles um although I will say at least there's a little bit of difference between yes there's definitely different so it's not a complete re-theming but still the core of the game is a logic deduction puzzle yeah 100 um and I think it's great I thought it was great yeah um I actually like this theme a lot better than the Planet X one so I like space a lot so for me for search for Planet X but I will say both games are a hundred percent on point for thing like yeah 100 that's true um I felt like you're a nature Observer I thought there were things more cleverly done in this game than the search for Planet X yeah but that should be kind of because I mean this is at least three if not four years newer oh yes when did this uh on the search for Planet X uh I got the kickstarter for it search for plant came out in 2020 so
three years ago three years ago so I mean again in the in Renegades does a good job of taking feedback before they build expansions before they put out second editions and so what I feel like is they took all the feedback from search for Planet X and built another game that you could say as version two right feels different right feels significantly different yeah exactly this one uh I mean the major difference for me is you're actually present on the board so it's not so abstract that you're really just like hopefully remembering or getting your notes down correct or actually where you go matters yes uh when you use your camera matters because that's that's like a one-time you're guaranteed to get an answer here for a while right then you're like all right can we all like correct but the cool thing is in search for Planet X you only get to use the NSS camera twice and that's it you never get the tokens back here depending on how long it goes you go and get the camera back more often now I think we got maybe twice yeah um and almost spent them immediately well I spent mine immediately I spent mine pretty soon yeah and that's how I got my my Lorry because uh it was funny you're searching for Lori's up there I had zeroed that there were no lorries in the entire environment well because I got I mean all the research that I got no was actually the opening thing was kind of like okay Lori's can't be here
and I was like well like the first thing was seven and eight couldn't be Lori's and I'm like well then there's no way right this can be placed so I already knew Lori's weren't up in the north and then I think my first camera told me Lori was here yes and from then you were praying I think I just kind of maybe I just kind of gassed yeah a little bit um but uh like the scores um like for our score was like basically the same yep um if I didn't miss click I would have won so I hate this game no so um so I love the actual maneuvering around the map and being like okay if I want to join and spend three time to search it's like you want to cover as much ground as possible but then that's just gonna widen your range of answers it's like okay if I go to 13 14 and 1 I search for toads and it says there's one toad it's like okay well that didn't help me really right um and then the research and Conference notes that we had like I was able to zero in on the Toads because of all the research I got got it like all that basically I'm just trying to figure out how you do it on the Toads as fast because so here's because you did research so the python and Toad was the no Toad and the same terrain as the python got it exactly one toad in the swamp okay exactly one toad is adjacent to at least one couscous got it uh exactly one animal and the swamp isn't is the same as in the Hills
and uh yeah so those were the four I got which zeroed in on a toad was up here and I was like oh they have to be adjacent to exactly two which helped me over over in that area uh so then I was like okay the couscous has to be here oh that means that uh the python has to be over here because the couscous are in this area so that's how I got like all that all that info so on my research I because I did B was the hills um there's only one animal type in each Hills so like I figured out like the toad was in that Hill location then I knew there's no toads in any other Hills yep and that happened to coincide with the a toad is the same is in the hills and the swamp so it's like that's how that's how that worked out and so again it's a great puzzle game it's a great logic puzzle game yep um it has a solo mode because there's no reason again because it's a logic and puzzle that you can't play it's solo and just play to try to figure out your score in essence yeah this game does like allow you to like write down what actions your opponents are doing right I don't think I've ever done that in any cert because I don't think it's like well I still don't know what you learned um I put things together so in a few times once I started really getting into plant X I could especially see when people were uh alcohol what we were
doing with the search is where they would do a pie wedge for asteroids and then they would overlap a certain amount of their pie so I kind of knew is like oh you found a asteroid in this field and you knew there weren't a few there gotcha so now you're trying to figure out where the other four are I see and so that would give some information but if those type of things yeah when people start overlapping the pies and plant that yeah and then here um what's interesting is because in Planet X you're you get more points for being the first one yeah in the thing and getting it this doesn't have that yeah at all uh and I actually find that fine just because you have you have more things to consider it's not just figure out what's in this section it's like you have so much so many spaces to move around and the whole board's open for the entire it's only half the board at any one time is ever open yeah exactly so it was like I mean you you can uh find out information before others and once they're revealed and correct then that's out you can't obviously jump in and get points but because you can see what's going to score right and then what's going to get placed later and it's like oh okay like I got my toad in here after you did prior to its scoring and and I like that yeah I feel like it feels more free it allows players to kind of be like well I also knew that like so
why am I punished for just being oh it's like for going in second you know it's like if we both know something we should both get rewarded for it but I know it before you by the time it comes around to score well then yeah you can't come in and get it um so here's my here's my problem with this and Planet X um and we actually experienced it uh in two different ways in this game that we just played this is a problem with really all logic games a turing machine has the same thing if you misread or mishear something right your game's over right like unless you're unless you're really detailed nodes and you're able to backtrack a lot um because yours was uh you missed you uh misput the uh first conference right no I didn't know the blue came out with the creature oh yeah so I was playing the whole game without that information right that they can't be adjacent to toads right right and so I was so I guess it was in location four which was correct I was going to guess location 11 because it was only two animals next to it yes and um it was the only one that fit and then when I started looking over it clicked when I looked at four that the mountains removed the adjacency requirement so it's like now there's two of them yeah and also it doesn't defeat the Lorry thing because it's not adjacent anymore right and so it doesn't break that rule and it's like because that's why I marked it off oh yeah because I was
thinking the lorries are there all those three spots are gone it's just an empty space right so I clicked through again like you said I took detail enough notes of my own from my own spot to say okay here's the logic puzzles I know these are the spots I just I already know the answer for what animals are there so we kind of Mark those spots as gone exactly and then it's just working it through and I happen to be able to get it right right so yeah so uh because I did know that information that marked that out because 11 was my second thought whenever I was like oh wait a minute no they can't be adjacent to a toad and I know no that's a toad so the issue that I had and this is kind of a problem because it's on an app is uh on my notes I have the Lost species circled for four and the couscous in five and the snake in three but whenever I was putting it in the app I misclicked on the Lorry and it's like no you didn't find it and it's like that was directly after you had did it so it's like oh well that's [ __ ] annoying because I clearly have it right but I mean it is what it is because the problem is I don't know a great way to fix it because you get information if you input it wrong uh but yeah potentially and you can't have someone else check you because you're giving them information exactly yeah it and that's that's just an inherent problem with logic games if you just kind of Miss click or you I will
say so one thing I will they do give you a spot to say are you sure which in plant X they did not but here they did they said so you put everything in yeah so it's literally four Windows the three Windows you put where it's located put one adjacent put the next adjacent and then ask are you sure yeah and that point realistically you do need to just double check yourself that's true and then go yeah which I'm happy because that is a problem X there is no hey are you sure here's your answers this is what you put in are you sure I can't remember is there any is there anything stopping you besides the time mechanism of just searching for it oh no because you also have three things you'd have to get like super lucky yeah could you imagine starting a game it's like I'll search for it and I put for the snake in that it's when you get it I mean if you get that awesome yeah it's like all right dude I've memorized every algorithm the app can give but that's I think that's why they do the whole can see because at that point the chance like I would have to go through and think the calculations but it would be astronomical it would the number of possibilities for that to not be true no I know it would be wild uh the other addition that this has that I don't believe Planet X does because you're just searching for Planet X or the fact that you are searching for a very specific lost species that has its own rule right to it so not only are you
picking between six six options that has a rule on how it's placed um where the five diff the other species the Lorry couscous toads and pythons where those are gonna be right I think this is a really neat addition that's neat I like the fact that so implant X and again we are comparing it because they're made of the same company the same game basically is when you pick the beginning you pick your level but it's basically how many Clues you want to get up to 12. yeah so before it was in sets of two so it's zero two four six and then sorry I think it was up to 12 so it goes in like increments of four or something yeah now you can pick literally from zero to twelve if I want seven clues for everybody everything gets seven clicks or just different uh it doesn't even have to be for everyone it's like it's like oh I've played this game you know a lot more than you I'll give myself one hint and you can have seven right or whatever it's just a sliding scale and what you personally start with which search for Planet X was just kind of it did have that it did have that but it was it was fewer options it almost felt like it was like a beginner medium hard like just kind of it was very limiting it was four I think there's four options and now yeah because I have I have the app um yeah search for Planet X do uh start new game okay so yeah then expert mode
continue spring okay so there there are four options genius zero experience for beginner eight youth 12. right as is all it is um so again it's the same range of them but now you get anything in between yeah so let's say I am a beginner but played this game once before versus everybody else the table so I'll subtract one yeah so you guys all get four Clues I get three Clues okay you have a slight Advantage not a lot but just that little peak of it I mean any information oh it's just super valuable it's it's super good um and you know what I also like about this a little bit more than Planet X is Planet X I felt it had well it also had the standard and expert the 12 sectors versus the 18. I did not like that game with 12. I felt it was just way too not necessarily simplistic um but it it felt like it was kind of it was almost samey whereas whenever you had 18 sectors to work with that it required a lot more logic a lot more things going on and I have that so we played on the easy board oh my god oh there's another board yeah that's on the other side oh didn't even know that yep huh oh and the mountains are different okay well that's cool yeah so there's more Central locations on that so you can't do the boat action as efficiently um oh yeah you're right because that's
where I think it's a major is the boat because it's cheap to do boats it's only two times we never did it though I did it once did you oh it was the only way I could get to the North as fast as I could that's fair yeah I was trying to find one yeah there's uh there's five that all the hills are in the middle right so that's necessarily the hard side versus easy side and again I don't know how much harder is versus easier but I mean from just seeing the the board it's um I mean couscous are gonna be [ __ ] annoying because I basically find one it's like well they're still everywhere right uh but I also think that the 12 to 16 sectors were so radically different in search this doesn't look to be as um as radical as radically different and also the fact that you have movement you have uh you have the the um I just realized I like dumped all those cards um you have those Village cards which we didn't talk about what do you think of the village cards I like them you liked them I wasn't sure if you're gonna like them because I felt I was wondering if you think that they added RNG to a logic game like I mean every card that came out that I happened to get was another research and it's like that'd be cool if I could get that but you know but here's what I thought it's like that would be cool if you've got if I could get but I also was saving a time every single time that you took a survey action from the very first step of the game yeah and so I was like I've probably made up in the logic that you've gained and yeah but
here's the thing it's why I think you got more tokens off than I did correct tokens yes I got more I got the same number of tokens now they just weren't correct right yeah exactly and so I that's where I felt like it felt balanced enough um I mean but the Pathfinder was another card that I could have went out and gotten to even though so now it's like well I'm saving time on moving and I happen to get more research in you so now it's no longer but there's some I mean so I carry a little bit less for fair because some of the times it's there's four options out there currently yes you could top deck into something better theoretically I didn't feel like any of them were overly powerful neither none of us went for extra points I think in a larger player game that might make care break things um yeah especially ones like with hills that you get Hill creature Hill answers more often like correctly like yeah yeah that that could be worth some real points right or if you get the python like I mean if I went and went to uh spot three with a camera it's like oh the Python's here Ryan okay oh and now I'm gonna go get that because no one else is gonna get that right because it has eight points yeah and that's what I'm saying it's like I like them it adds a little bit of variety but I can see a lot of people not because it's like the camera is like a and they'll be all on one location you could get Super Lucky and then that card also happens to be out so it's an eight point swing already that no one else is gonna I mean that's that's literally four point difference on finding the lost species
right versus um seven which is so I mean I I'll say I didn't feel bad about it um they're there I thought they were fine I didn't it didn't radically change how I was going to play the game right um I almost feel like they they took it um or they added these so it wasn't literally the same game from search for Planet X right that obviously doesn't have any cards it doesn't have any cards I'll say I like the timing tokens better than I like how plant X does it plan X I always feel like I have to think it through I just have to go from one and then go all the ways around in a clock order here with the numbers is nicer it's cleaner I feel like um yeah it is cleaner it's very obvious what's scoring and what is being placed um because you know I mean just from looking at it it's like okay so fours are gonna score now and then two things next that's whenever these are gonna score so it gives people quite a bit of time to figure stuff out I mean so I don't own plant X and I'm actually considering maybe going out and picking this one up um not that I'm probably going to get rid of plant X because I really do love that game but this is super solid yeah I think they they 100 stepped it up um because Planet X for me I just looked at what my scoring was so I had a frame of reference uh I give it a seven like
uh the just because it's it is what it is um so it's a top 10 game for me really yep it's in my top ten it's like pure logic games aren't like something I always want to run out for right but yet now that turing machine is out it's like oh man that's also really really good and I think right I I got more hung up on if you just miss like if you miss one thing your game's over right and that's very very annoying uh whenever it's like oh like I misread that or I'm trying to think if there's any deduction Polo games I can think of that that isn't true in terms of logic no it's not um like deduction could I mean like the Sherlock Holmes games it's just like it doesn't I mean I guess still if you yeah trying to think like if you misinterpret a clue somewhere in a deduction game it doesn't matter because if you guess wrong because based on what you thought you knew yeah it doesn't matter yeah so so the issue still Rings true for this one right uh in that if you like if you just think that uh whatever the lorries are somewhere and you dump all your tokens it's just like oh okay I'm not getting any points right but if you don't own if you don't own
either I'd say this one I would say this one um definitely it's just it's definitely a cleaner and here's the thing unless you like space better exactly uh if you are really into sci-fi but I don't know this one actually feels more thematic just because it's it's tanned like this is something we can more relate to of being on Earth and animals and stuff versus well I don't observe my favorite telescope so at school we did we actually had an observatory at school I didn't go to a cool rich rich boy school like you did I didn't do any of that actually no I think at one point uh one of like the science teachers had like a son viewing telescope I mean I went to literally an engineering school where one of the professor's hobby was to keep the observatory actually running we'll see there you go I didn't have any of that so maybe maybe that's more thematic to you right but which is why I mean I think the search for plant X is more thematic gotcha it's more thematic for me oh okay I'm like I'm like I was agreeing with your comment for me oh okay uh and also I think this game has more room for expansions than Planet X like you just do it you just do species yeah expansions more cards if you want them right uh really all you just need are more of these yeah because these are gonna drastically change you're you are stuck kind of with unless even when they're completely reprint we have to reprint and have different creatures with different launches and
have a board so I mean theoretically Whitney had changed the board because again this whatever your board is the like again the lorries you might not have something that is doing that hex but again you could create five other ones that are all logic based still based on a headstrong yeah that is true um yeah I mean just I mean a mini expansion of just more of the actual lost species there's certainly plenty out there that are right endangered that because like well are they uh okay no they're I was about to go are they all really just now that Jason no they are different like the Juan devoid tree kangaroo is uh not in the same terrain as the python got so that might lead you to try and figure out where the python is first right and Planet X just doesn't have anything like this right um but yeah you definitely couldn't have more expansions if they wanted to um it's pretty clean for what is yeah if you've played one then you're gonna be kind of familiar with the Beats of this one right uh it really just adds the camera token and then the village token um so I mean yeah it has similar beats I was worried that it was just gonna be a re-themed Planet X but it's not it's why I didn't back it because I thought it was going to be a re-theme and if I really liked it again afterwards yeah um
but yeah it's good um so on a scale of one to ten what are you gonna give the search for the Lost species it's a 10 it's a ten yeah um I do like it more than than Planet X um I'm gonna give an eight uh eight out of ten for me uh I still have both yeah um but this is and I'll probably keep both just cuz right uh but yeah this one is kind of like well why would I play one over the other you know run versus we just got done playing Great Western Trail New Zealand and no one's like oh I could play all three of those and have a great time it's like this is the same type of logic I prefer this theme over Planet X so right why would I so for in this case I don't know that you would want both I kind of want both because I take plant X to social Gatherings um because I find that a lot of people like the pure logic deduction games yeah and so by bringing both one I can basically double the size of the people playing games for it that's true and if people prefer one theme over the other or have a preference of themes get them onto the table more often yeah no that's a good point um I think the reason for me I mean yeah that's a very valid way of owning both is comparing to the the Great Western Trail Trilogy is
playing those gives you a different strategy of how you can do it here the logic is is the exact same how you get to that logic is a little bit different but realistically realistically it's the same hexagon yeah like okay writing your notes down clearing pieces off exactly it's just now you have a spatial element right of of doing this versus oh man I'm gonna try it how am I gonna get my logic different right all right so yeah so I I'll probably keep this one yep and uh get rid of the other one probably um that may make sense I I agree not really I I missed clicked so I hate this game I have to win every game otherwise I don't like it right uh that's how shallow I am it would have definitely been a nine if he had won the game I'd be like it's the best logic game out there no uh did your sheet also have like a different yeah thing on the side that is nice uh mine was Lori's okay mine was about couscous okay now there's that is just nice A little uh little with a little map yeah a little info on on the right side yep um so I'm assuming there's more on the other ones yeah but uh so yeah eight out of ten for me 10 out of 10 for you uh that's our thoughts on the search for lost species let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like I'm sure and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time updated for you hey everyone thank you
for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you