Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 88: Ada Sayin on Hybrid Threat Rising

Transcript 36:27

it's at break time first i want to mention that i have a patreon so if you love this podcast i would deeply appreciate the extra support at patreon.com beyond solitaire second the beyond solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by central michigan university's center for learning through games and simulations which continues to do amazing things in the world of academic board gaming their first kickstarter monumental consequence has now entered fulfillment and you can still order a copy through cmhpress.com lincoln's show notes their next kickstarter rising waters will hopefully launch the end of october and if you were interested in a certificate in applied game design clgs is offering several courses throughout the year starting on october 10th eloy lasanta will bring back his art of game crafting course and starting on october 11th lamar smith will teach visual storytelling game art design and branding so sign up and get your learning on for now though let's get on with the show hey gamers just a quick note there are a couple of sound issues on this episode due to a faulty internet connection uh but i let the interview stand as is because i still think it's well worth listening to thank you so much for your patience hey gamers it's liz davidson for beyond solitary this week on the pod i have a very special guest this is ada scion she is the peace and conflict program director at kuzmushina which is an ngo based in turkey and she's also cube center room get to that how are you doing i'm doing very fine how about you i'm doing great so you're in turkey right now where it's really late at night so thank you so much for coming on to talk to us no worries at all it's it's nighttime for me that's perfectly fine

so how uh tell us about kusamushina uh how um how new is it as an ngo how is it developed and then we'll get to your game eventually but i just want to know the basics yeah absolutely for sure um so we are at women's rights ngo and just to kind of like explain it a bit um because bashana means just a girl in english and just in case you might wonder why does a woman try to ngo is named just a girl it's because here in turkey usually you know growing up you hear a lot of you know you are just a girl so you cannot do that you are just a girl you cannot go there etc you know the sayings um so we kind of wanted to take that saying and then kind of bring some empowerment to it and then kind of say you are a girl so you can't do that you are a woman you can do that that you have the power to do something so that's kind of like in the back of our minds the whole time um we are founded in ankara so the capital of turkey and basically we um are concerned with anything about women's rights um civil rights also but um it could go anything from women's empowerment in any any part of the world um to femicide so you know kind of domestic violence um all be tried to cover anything that concerns women um so we've been operating since 2017

and um since then we did a lot of great projects i've been i've only been in the ngo for the last two years so i'm just like finishing up my two years now before i joined in um they did many one-of-a-kind projects um some of them were about directly femicides in turkey so basically we have sadly a lot of them um so and once you have a lot of femicides going on you some at some point you kind of stop keeping track of it and it's it gives you so much pain that you start forgetting sadly so um they kind of wanted to put that into perspective and for example they just um researched every the history behind every one of those femicides and then they created little um codes the qr codes and then they put it where those women have been killed just to remind people that here a woman was killed it was called digital carnation project and it was awarded by facebook's p2p project um and then they also did um turkey's first um domestic violence um courts you know court case so basically they just took different groups of you know lawyers you know people interested in law and legal processes and um they kind of did a mock trial and which was one of a kind thing because we have again a lot of these types of domestic violence or pemcites going on but

no one is trained pretty much they don't teach that in law school here so they kind of wanted to teach that so it was also one of a kind and then we have you know continuously going projects um and i are one of our latest and one of the biggest ones was the women in command project which is probably why i'm here for her it is but we're gonna get there a bit more so you're a peace and conflict program director what exactly does that mean that sounds like a very cool job yeah so um how it came to play that i kind of started as you know your regular volunteer i would do anything they would give me um and then i kind of went into different projects i did one with um i had a chance to actually coordinate one with nike it was on women's empowerment and sports etc and then panini when i started doing the women in command project um we realized that we are actually expanding in that area as well because while most ngos might just go into one area like protecting women um from you know domestic violence or just responding to homicides we kind of try to expand in all the ways possible so we have for example a humanitarian program director as well once the women in command project started we realized that we actually needed one for peace and conflict women who got hurt in peace and conflict and as well as women who should be deciding during peace and conflict as well and in the meantime we had the chance to kind of expand not only the women in command

project but also going to you know little tasks and little projects similar to that one so we decided that it was time to kind of create a program under that title awesome so you've designed a game called women in command so tell us about the game so the project's name is the woman in command and the game's name is hybrid threat rising so um basically i i should maybe just talk about the project a bit so why we designed the game makes a bit of sense um so the project's aim is to empower women going into defense peace and security industries because when we started the project last year in may we realized that there were a lot of conflicts actively going on everywhere in the world and some of them were actually you know active conflicts um you know military you know real life conflicts and some of them are just political or maybe even social conflicts and women and children during all these processes got hurt the most because women were not placed in decision-making mechanisms so they were being left out all the time um and although some of the organisms like it could be nato it could be u.n have different titles and different roles for these types of conflicts and this type of situations like gender advisors etc in turkey where this industry is growing tremendously in the defense industry we do not have women in any of the decision

making tables so we decided to put women there by um training them through workshops but you know just training through workshops as in i mean in these days is quite ineffective especially training young people like i mean i kind of give myself as an example whenever whenever i talk about this project because i mean i i am kind of like the target demographic of it so whenever i just like maybe start a workshop or just listen to someone talking for maybe an hour an hour and a half i get bored of it and i usually end up not learning pretty much anything so having our mentor who had a huge background in gamification was a great source because that's where we came up with the idea of using a game as a training tool because it's interesting it's fun and it lets us deliver the learning outcomes so that's kind of how it started and basically hubert threat rising war game is a hybrid conflict war game um it's about a three hour war game and you have your classic red and your classic blue but i think what differentiates it is that they have different winning mechanisms so um they win the game by doing different things and it you know it's supposed to be that way because it's

supposed to kind of imitate the 2014 um ukrainian russian conflict so we thought it would be best to give them different abilities and needs and it's also very interesting because we also put an influence mechanism so you get to not only play out different scenarios of combat but also you get to play out different scenarios of influence um and we included a lot of things in it i could talk about it for hours probably but um you also have your cyber attacks you have your multi-domain on a very basic level and yeah a lot of a lot of mechanisms in it i think that's what kind of differentiates it but it's still quite beginner level so had you ever designed a game before and like are you a gamer outside of this project oh so this is where it kind of goes downhill um before i was not your you know best gamer um i say this with a bit of i think it's like a guilty pleasure of mine but before my favorite game was like monopoly whenever i say it any of the gamers i know just go absolutely crazy because all gamers somehow hate monopoly i mean usually the game develop developers hate monopoly or like very you know hobby gamers hate it but to me it's so fun like what makes it fun is that i have fun so to me that was quite enough and before i had never ever designed any games i um i did kind of

like simulations i had organized a mock nato um conference so that was what came to closest to designing a game um but that was pretty much it for me uh so um when you begin to design this game then uh what were your influences and who did you get some help from because it's so hard to do something like that for the first time especially if you don't game a lot so what were you playing and who are you talking to to get started oh gosh yeah so uh so when we first started okay let me let me respect that we started in may 2021 uh when we first started the project and before actually we started it what kind of got me into this into this role of leading the design team of a game we started the project in may 2021 and um how i got into the role of leading design team of the um hybrid threat right the game um was in about february 2021 our mentor becky chaplin who is chair who was then chairing um sas 129 research test group of um nato science and technology organization um he was working on this gamification um project through this research task group so he was supposed to facilitate a game and then he just

like put out this message to the slack channel saying so i'm doing this and i need you know assistant facilitators who can just help me write some crises situations etc like inject to the game and then like i saw it i didn't really care about it i had exams going on and then at the very last minute i thought i have some information on this like i know how kind of like nato works i have like a little bit of knowledge on what may happen so let me just write my name down and then i did and then it kind of like got going and we were supposed to write like crisis injects and i am one of the most pessimistic people you may know especially when it comes to crisis situations so it came really easy for me um i wrote like many of them and i knew how to before because of like model united nations projects etc so and i'm also kind of like an ambitious person so i wanted to see how my crisis played out so i was like kind of pushing them forward so that he put them out as inject and the more i saw how they played out and how people responded to it especially you know these people i never knew from before who were you know um from the military or who were experts in their own areas on cyber security um i was really amazed of how fun it was to create something and then see people react to it see people kind

of play it out and then see how they thought about and you know just kind of observe their thought processes so i was kind of like amazed by it but then i just forgot about it because i had more exams um and then time passed by and um he kind of um came back and said so we have this woman increment project going and then would you like to take part in the lead design team and i somehow said yes to just say i don't know what pushed me to do that because i had no idea what was kind of expecting me but i said yes and then i was in a different city in turkey and they got me here in akara and we started kind of rolling this whole design team and it was a lot of blood sweat and tears for about a whole summer for about four months um but i think what made it the most i mean it had it's of course ups and downs because it was my absolute first time doing something this big um but also it was really amazing because we got to work with absolutely amazing people i had um burke as my mentor we worked with imaginatic from canada we worked with tom fisher and stephanie game from there our design team was amazing i think one thing i should maybe mention is that in turkey we have no um serious you know war game designers we have game designers who design you know apps or maybe just you know fun games not serious games so we had to create our own serious game design team

by kind of you know doing different interviews pulling people here from here and there and it came out just amazing and i got to work with absolutely brilliant women designing this game for women mostly um and our influences so at the beginning we started you know by playing games to kind of get some inspiration from it we played i think my first ever war game is memoir 44 which is a great game yeah it's a good start it was really fun um and i remember being completely like lost it's a very easy game when i look back at it we still do tournaments but uk fight club but when i look back burke had told me to kind of like learn how the rules work how it's played etc i was lost i was long gone i i was like just reading the rules and i was just so confused like what does this all mean because to like a beginner who knows nothing pretty much nothing about war games it's it's not fun it's just confusing it was just plain confusing but then more i learned about it the more people who were experts in their areas like burke or like tom explained those to me it became more fun and i think what made this process this you know passionate was that people were so nice and so accommodating so memoir 44 that's a really

i don't i guess that is probably a pretty ambitious place to start so what about your experience of jumping into a war game impacted your design of this game later because you've mentioned that your game is um it's very beginner friendly so how did you communicate what you wanted to communicate while also keeping the game accessible because you now know how that feels to jump into a game that isn't yeah absolutely so um when we first started we worked with you know again imaginatic with tom fisher as mentor and he knew absolutely perfectly what i was thinking when i was you know going into a game he kind of like put us through a series of workshops where he introduced us to how to design a serious game and i think that's the process that made it so much more easier to design the game because i mean i did not have maybe years of background into this but i kind of knew the fundamentals and i knew how the beginner mentality worked and how a you know maybe like a basic turkish movement mentality worked so working with the design team who were you know people like me um about my age about my background um more to design side but i mean we were pretty much thinking the same things we always turned back inside and asked would we play this game is this game

easy to understand and does this game teach me something so these were these were about three fundamental questions we always asked and designing the game um so we are quite the ambitious team and we wanted to make it as perfect as possible i'm just going to admit that um no game is perfect but we wanted to just make it you know one of a kind thing you know having all the learning outcomes and then we have like a whole whole table where we have so many like learning outcomes like this was connected to this this was connected to this etc and then as we continued to add them and add them and add them as you can guess it got a little bit complicated and then at some point we had to kind of look at it and say okay this is just too much um at one point even our own design team was kind of getting lost into all of the mechanics all of the you know different roles etc and then at that point we had to kind of back inside and kind of simplify the game level by level by still keeping it informative and just keeping the learning outcomes in it and what makes it accessible i think is that um design process because i mean i always say this but it's not mutually exclusive it's a game designed by women for women it's also for men or anyone else but we kind of know how we think especially in turkey especially about

turkish women who have no background of wargaming or you know military abbreviations military sayings etc so we know how we think and that's kind of like the first step of it and the second step of accessibility is that we added so many facilitators to it that we have for example an awesome rule book it was consulted to many many many experts if it's designed in maybe like three months just a real book so that you just do not get lost in it but you actually follow like kind of like a way and then you kind of flow right into it you are able to find what you search for and we kind of like we could pre-guess some of the questions women asked and we had a lot of time actually play testing it not only during the summer but also going into like september october etc so we kind of like put all those questions and put all those outputs into the rulebook so that when you have it for the first time in your hands you were able to actually learn about the game and then find what you're looking for um a second aspect of it were play rates so once you have so many mechanics and then like so many stuff going on because that's kind of like the truth you have a lot of going on in the game even though it's easy we call it beginner level it's still a lot for someone who's just starting because you probably don't know about all these

behaviors so you have once you begin laid out without having to flip pages which you have to do just in front of you very clearly and it's also very nice looking i could say so it's actually really like fun and nice to look at it and then play it another aspect is that um we have a tutorial level so i don't think we've seen this with any of the serious war games but looking at the examples we had you know nato war games for example it takes about maybe two days to learn some of them just to learn how to play the game and you you know on top of that you have to be an expert at it you have to already like priorly know how what you're supposed to do and in our case not possible because we're looking at people who have never played four games before who don't have a background in military or similar concepts so we had to introduce a tutorial level game just to kind of teach them in less time at least less than maybe two or three hours and then kind of ease them into the game because once i think i think it's the same thing with pretty much everyone i know um when someone is explaining me the rules my head goes empty i have like elevator music playing and then i am just so stressed about learning the rules that i cannot even you know when i start playing i cannot even remember

what i was told and tutorial i think the tutorial level counter is just about that it kind of lets you discover the game in your own conditions and at your own pace and then it kind of lets you play it out it kind of lets you practice whatever you're supposed to do later it's really great because we got to test the story level at the royal military academy of the netherlands with um 90 cadets during a training and it went absolutely great i was surprised by the results um i was sadly the only facilitator who was able to go there because of cobit but so i was alone you know next to about nine cadets and i was just like thinking how am i supposed to teach this game to 90 people all at once with all the questions that i will be asked and we started with the tutorial and they learned in about 30 minutes and they played against our team back in ankara virtually for the first day and they were about you know beating up our team who designed the game and it was just amazing it was incredible so this is i think the fundamental accessibility features we have so far nice so the hybrid threat rising is definitely about then it's a large group game it's meant for maybe a classroom or for a whole team to play um so it's you can play it one versus one but also you can play it you know by teams up to five people and

then after maybe like seven or six i personally do not recommend it because in you know those group settings are in those team settings um so for that purpose we designed a mega game it lets you kind of create that you know operating team and then you have those different teams acting out you know for blue for example or foreign acting out different um parts of the game so we also did that okay so this thing can scale there's like a base version that's for like up to five and then there's like the big mega version for large groups you mentioned learning outcomes earlier and how you had some learning outcomes but then you had to cut some what ended up being the ultimate focus of the game and then what things did you end up sort of cutting because it took away from the the focus of what you really wanted to teach yeah absolutely so we have um on the like high level of um learning outcomes we have for example very like basic ones like crisis management resource management um etc and then once you kind of go into details it goes into um the cyber domain or you know it goes into influence it goes into urban warfare and different kind of types of it so it can get really detailed all at once but one one of the things we kind of had to cut out or at least simplify as we as simplify as much as we

could with um multi-domain because it's i mean it was one of the learning outcomes i was very passionate about because i think it's so much fun to test out all the different domains and then kind of like tie them within each other and then kind of try different different mechanics but once we tried to involve all those different domains it got very complicated and it got kind of out of hand um and we said okay so this we can for example add is an extension to the game but for the you know main game the the basic game we do not have to because we can just give what we want to teach through the cards you know through the existing mechanics of this but so we kind of wanted to save that multi-domain aspect of it for example to an extension or to maybe hopefully another project we'll see about it but um i think that was one of the biggest things that we had to cut out gotcha is this a game that you are hoping to sell commercially or uh like is it something that somebody could just play in their living room one day or is this really meant for a more educational setting oh i think i think it's for both somehow um it's not because like it's at this point it's our game i mean i'm very passionate about it but i think it's quite a fun game maybe it's because of our team as well but so far we played this with about 350 people in the span of maybe like a year or maybe

less and every time you played it it was so much fun honestly so i think this you can play it in your living room if you want to i can just send you i can send you the printables that's perfectly fine for us but it can also be very educational once you have facilitators or once you have um someone there to kind of support the learning outcomes of it but you can also play just you know alone with your friends just to kind of see the different mechanics and kind of get the learning outcomes out of the game that's really interesting uh you mentioned play testing with some cadets but this is a game that's by women for women what kind of responses have you seen from testing the game with the intended audience um people surprised that you know the game worked for them um you know what what kinds of connections did did you make with the people that you were hoping to play sure so so this is one of the parts of the project that i'm very passionate about especially connecting with people because you know going into this we had no idea that we would be able to connect with just many people we were very amazed by the you know the interest that we got for example even this podcast this was never ever something we had hoped for or imagined but it's great to be here um and you know kind of developing the game again we playtested it in between the teams so we always had

you know in the back of our heads what women you know our audience our target demographic would think of it but as we continued as we started to do you know international conferences like connections uk et cetera um we got to play it with more women or more you know people actually who were experts in their fields and we kind of discovered that it was going better than we had expected to be honest um and then we were very incredibly lucky to have this much interest and this much positive feedback and this much you know support from the people we were working with so beginning we were working with um your security from the us who did something very similar for high school level students um and was in contact with yunna wong from women's war gaming network so she kind of ended up introducing us to georgetown university we're giving society to sebastian bay who introduced us to jonathan who introduced us to you so just kind of like it was like domino's so we got introduced to so many people and we got to do so many events and in those events we got to meet amazing women who were you know some of them were just beginners in wargaming who some of them had an extensive background in more

gaming and every time and each time somehow very luckily and i'm very proud to say that we had absolute you know amazing response from it when like i was there for the most part to facilitate it so i was able to kind of see their reactions and see how they responded to the game the first time they heard about the rules or the first time they saw maybe the graphics etc um and then one of the most um common responses we got was that it was great to have humanitarian um aspects in the game which is not very frequently done in a war game about hybrid threats um and uh those humanitarian aspects have like its special lumen aspect so you would have special women cards in it which resonated a lot with our target demographic because they saw maybe not their own experiences but experiences they could relate to in you know their own minds it was again easy to learn easy to understand once you got into it and the third one was about the graphics um we always got that the graphics are somehow really good they're like really nice looking etc so it's always like a great bonus to hear that one that's awesome um so do you consider yourself a gamer and a game designer now where you didn't before oh play a lot more games than i did before because it kind of became my job to know about games to discover games i think to a point i would consider myself a gamer

um a game designer i think maybe a junior game designer you know something small or something something kind of like you know at a very basic level because um now the hubert rising war game is not my first game to design um doing this we play different simulations and different trainings and different serious games so i would maybe to an extent um able you know i would maybe to an extent consider myself a game or simulations designer at this point but hopefully more to come and then i would be a lot more confident in considering myself one well i think that you are one if you're doing the job and the game's there then you're a designer so i i always ask him i guess this what are you playing for fun right now if anything oh gosh um civilization six nice yeah that's that's what we're playing and let me tell you we've been you know we are just insane about it it's i don't know why or how but we are playing it all the time when we're not working especially with burke who also is my mentor so like we're always together who's like kind of like a brother to me so we were always together playing it and then we kind of got the whole team who were no they are not gamers let me tell you they don't like

most games but we kind of got them playing it as well and we're having so much fun but at the same time we're playing katan which is just amazing it's a very you know basic game you can just play with friends who don't really like gaming but they kind of like the competition of it you know it's fun we try to kind of discover different games um mostly commercials so we can play with friends but the one that i'm playing the most right now is civilization absolutely amazing it's very detailed it's so much fun you can you can do so many things in it it's crazy i love it and then if people want to talk to you they have questions they want to find you online where can they do that so if anyone has any questions or wants to learn more about the project they can reach me personally through my linkedin or um if you want to know more about the project you can check our website because bachelor's website um you just write conventional in the english alphabet um and that's pretty much it we also have instagram but most of the content there is turkish so um i would doubt that anyone would be interested in that but if you are it's the same thing the same name you can just search it and find it nice and i will be getting all that the show notes for those of you who are curious out there um and if you listen to this podcast you probably know i can be found everywhere online as beyond solitaire uh aydah thank you so much for coming on and giving us your time and telling us about those amazing projects thank you so much for inviting me it's really amazing to be here and you know everyone knows that i can talk

about the project in the game for hours and hours on end so it was really hard to kind of limit myself and say okay just just calm down just limit yourself and then you will be fine and just talk about the basic stuff but it's really amazing to be here and talk about how about the whole thing to someone who's you know as interested and who's having you know so much fun so it's great thank you so much alright so those of you who are out there listening please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming do

you

Progress saved