Golem Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at Golem which is a one to four player heavy Euro strategy board game designed by Virginia Julie Familia prasini and Simone Luciani who are some of the best designers in the game today and this one takes around two hours to play on average uh before I get to my thoughts on Golem I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order so Golem is a pretty heavy game so please don't use this little overview as a full rules explanation because no doubt I'm going to miss a few things but essentially the main board is going to look like this which is going to be divided up into these three different streets and on these streets you are going to have students and Golems the general idea is that you're going to use the Golems to activate the actions which are on these tiles next to them and these have been semi-randably allocated but they do get better as they go but you need these students to keep up with the Golems because if you don't you can potentially lose points um if you lose control of them but we'll of course talk about that in a bit more detail later in the top left hand side of the board here you have these character cards which can potentially give you little options should you draft these particular marbles at the end of your turn you have this little Card Market here and you have this structure to the side of the board called the synagogue now this is going
to be one of the main mechanisms in the game where you select your actions and that is going to go hand in hand with this other board here where you can take additional actions using this worker placement mechanism you've got a bunch of different resources such as gold coins clay and knowledge and a big part of the game takes place on each player's individual player board where you can upgrade a bunch of things and get better and better as you go to go climbing up these tracks Etc but much like the main board um your personal board is divided up into three different colors you know the blue the red and the yellow and that is all going to correspond to a different path or strategy that you can take throughout the game so for example the blue track here the knowledge track or the uh I think it's called the knowledge track is going to relate to how many different cards you get played here and because when you do certain things in this game you are going to unlock these little Menorah symbols here which are going to be an end game multiplier based on different things so again the blue one is going to relate to how many cards you get played the red menorahs which you're going to gain by upgrading your little Golem piece here is going to relate to how many Golems you have deployed um and the yellow menorahs which you can unlock by getting these upgrades and buying these artifacts are going to relate to how many artifacts you actually purchase throughout the game you're also going to get given some personal objectives to try and aim for throughout the game like for example here I want to try and get three Golems out and I want to reach at least stage
six on my book track here but if I do six and seven I can potentially get these bonuses at the bottom by getting more than one objective complete so how does the game actually work so the first thing you do on a turn is you have a look at how far you are up on the Golem track and you're going to pretty much climb up this track as you deploy more Golems onto the board now you can see here whenever I purchased one it's going to reveal this fifth symbol which relates to this track here and if I climb it throughout the game game I can end up generating more victory points but again it will make you move more places which is not normally a good thing so you can see here I'm currently at this four spot which means I'll have to move my golems and I can divide this out as I like for spaces look at that so I can go like one here and then maybe I could go like two here and um let's say I had another Golem deployed I could go say I had one right at the beginning I can go here like so now you can see on the character cards you've got an additional movement which you may have to do as well and if you don't have a specific upgrade and once you've done your Gola movement you're essentially going to go into the main part of the game where you take your actions and the actions are going to come in two different forms the first of which is to draft a marble and take the corresponding action and the second of which is to place your worker um so you're going to get two marble drafts and you're gonna get one worker Place action you can see here I've already drafted my marbles I've got a blue one and a black one now the colors of these marbles are important when you draft them because as
soon as you draft a certain color like the red yellow or blue you can move your student one spot of that matching color so that's great because it means that you are more likely to control your Golems at the end of the round the black one is really useful because it lets you move up to two or two of your students and the white ones are basically dummies they don't really do anything but not only is the color important the number of marbles in each of these columns is important because that is going to correspond to the different actions you can take and generally it will correspond to a certain resource you could take so if I drafted this one at the moment I'll get one knowledge token if I drafted two one one from here because there's two marbles here I'll get two coins or one clay this one happens to have more actions or more marbles assigned to it which will give me a discount on activating my Golems so you can see here that normally to activate uh three Golems it'll cost me five knowledge four Gunners will cost me eight knowledge but because I have four marbles here I can get four discounts so it only actually cost me four knowledge in order to activate four Golems let's quickly talk about the other actions here so not only is this one going to get you clay you're also going to get the opportunity to do one red upgrade or a Golem upgrade and you do that by looking on your player board paying the amount of Clay on here and flipping it over to the reverse side and these will all give you a benefit that you can use throughout the game such as not having to move the extra movement on the character card or whenever you activate your Golems you
can activate another one and do one instantly as soon as you flip it over and as you can see all these different upgrades have these menorahs on which are going to correspond to these deployed Golems at the end game scoring the money action here is not only going to give you coins it's going to let you do a yellow upgrade and when you do the yellow upgrade you're going to have a look at your player board here and pay the corresponding amount of coins and then deploy one of these tokens on that matching spot so let's just say I ended up paying these four coins I could move this token over to here which means that if I managed to get this artifact built which I have and when it comes to the income phase I will not only get this income I'll also get this income as well and much like the other parts of the game the more you upgrade things the more of these menorahs you're going to reveal and this one here you simply pick eight coins simply to flip it over to get three more menorahs the coin action also allows you to pay three coins in order to take a gold and when you take the gold you are simply going to deploy it somewhere on one of these artifacts and as you can see they do get more expensive and but they do get better as you go like for example this top artifact here although it's going to cost me four gold it can end up generating me Five Points income at the end of every phase which is pretty good the knowledge action will give you knowledge and it'll also let you do a blue upgrade and or buy a book so when you do the blue upgrades it's going to correspond to these top actions here where you have to pay the knowledge on the reverse side so this one cost me three knowledge I flipped it over like so and you can also actually flip up flip over this main part here which means that you could end up um basically
getting more um or makes it easier for you to place these cards because not only do you get to do a blue upgrade you actually get to buy one of these cards at the top here which have a cost at the bottom it can either be moving one of your students back or it can be just knowledge itself like for example this card here means it'll give me a I have to pay for knowledge to it plus an extra one um depending on where it is in the row so as the game goes on the cheaper they get but let's just say for example I chose to buy this card paying that five knowledge I could then tuck it somewhere under this player board here I'm bearing in mind that the colors have to match so I could only ever put the yellow in this column because I've already committed to Yellow here however you do need to end up climbing this track because the higher you climb the more cards of the same type you can deploy in each column so if I was in this spot here each of my columns can only have one card each but as soon as I went into this top spot I could end up putting two cards in each and when you do that you are going to get the benefit instantly on the bottom half of the cards this could be a point on a coin and then starting from the bottom and working up you'd activate every single card you've already bought in that column and you'd even get the bonus from the bottom one here so this could be a gold it'll then let me trade in a coin for a gold and then it would then let me move my yellow student one spot forward like so and the final drafting action corresponds to this Mirror action here where you spend a coin and then you can use the strength of this which is at the moment is zero um to take any of the other actions so it gives you that
flexibility there and then you can actually spend three coins if you wanted to to move up that knowledge track to um again give your give you more options when placing cards and even generating your endgame points in addition to the drafting actions you always get to take one worker placement action per turn and these are modular so each round they are going to change um but there's going to be more or fewer based on the Play account so in a four player game all four of these spots are going to be filled up um in a three-player game only the first four and I believe in a one or two player game only the first three are and these do all kind of different things such as giving you a victory Point based on your leftmost student and letting you use a Golem action instantly and this one here lets you buy a book card without having to pay that additional cost and so on you know such as going up or down the um the Golem track getting points going up the knowledge track and buying a book um so you can see all the different things that these tiles do here and they will change as the game goes on so once all the players have done their three actions in any order they want so you can actually do like a draft and then a worker placement and then a draft again or you can do work replacement first and then your two drafts Etc but once you do that you're going to have a look at what marbles you've drafted and if you match with the characters up here you can take one of these bonuses so depending on the round it's on so say it was the fourth round um you could end up spinning five coins to you know get a point for every upgrade you have or even take the three coins instead and what's that stand you're going to do basically a bit of admin you're going to shift the cards along you're going to put all the marbles back in the um in the synagogue but you'll also get all your income based on where your students are so you
can see here that this machine here is stood on this clay and points and you're just going to generate these passively these ones here and this one here as well getting you points and knowledge I mean you're also going to get all the income based on your player board so you're going to get knowledge based on the knowledge track of course you're going to get points based on the on the Golem track here and also all the income you've generated from your completed artifacts that is a very rough explanation about how the game works but you can probably tell a lot of the flavor and the crunchiness of the game comes from the tiles themselves here and because as you can see these do lots of interesting things such as giving you discounts on upgrading your Golems or you're like moving your red student back and getting rewards for doing so um yeah moving your student along getting discounts um the yellow track here will give you just like coin benefits just you know by being able to buy gold for your artifacts um whenever you see this symbol here it means that you can voluntarily choose to kill one of your Golems like if you have no hope of catching up with it and potentially losing um victory points because I didn't mention that if for every spot that you're behind your Golem at the end of the round you have to spend a knowledge for to bridge that Gap and if you don't you're going to suffer negative five victory points but say they really started to run away they're even starting generating you negative points by Crossing these lines um you could add voluntarily kill them and put them in one of these Cemetery spaces and get a benefit instantly like this one here will give me say you know let me move another student or get me victory points and let me climb up the
knowledge track or get me resources of my choice okay so apologies if that explanation was a little bit rushed but there is a lot going on in this game and I would rather spend my time talking about my thoughts on the game rather than the mechanisms and explanation itself so I'm going to start with the synagogue mechanism here which is actually a well basically recycled from another design from these designs called Grand Austria hotel which in that game it was done based on Dice and when you're rolling the you know d6s and depending on the face it landed on was the action you could take get the more of that number was rolled it means the stronger the action it was and I like that conflict of you know do I want to take the really strong actions and get like huge discounts for a big bunch of resources or do I want to take the less frequent actions because you know although this um a one knowledge token might be pretty pathetic it's the only option to do it there so it's scarce and if that's part of your game plan then you're gonna have to take that sacrifice so I actually love the mechanism itself it's really cool and again not many games if any games apart from Grand Austria Hotel have ever done that and however I do think the actual physical component of the synagogue isn't quite as functional as just a simple D6 is the actual synagogue isn't a brilliant randomizer because you're simply just dropping it in there and you know depending on how you drop it in it's probably going to skew a certain way so it would have been nice if this was a bit better to randomize the distribution of the of the um marbles but other than that it's it's a
great mechanism and I like the kind of pairing of it with the the color itself because you know you might really want that black action so that you can move two of your students but the black action is associated to something that you're not looking to do right now and I suppose you can even pair that additionally with the fact that you might want to draft certain colors based on the character displayed for that current round so again you've got multiple levels here and layers about why you're drafting what you're drafting I also did enjoy about how this mechanism is merged with the worker placement and that you can do anything in any order you want and it really is about prioritizing and you know putting your actions in the right order because certain things might be better if you do it before or after another action but things are going to be limited because of the passive player interaction here these marbles might be taken before you're ready for them to be taken it's going to make your actions weaker or it means that you might have to draft a different color that you initially wanted to I love the rotation of the worker placement spots here um because something that a lot of these worker placement spots are absolutely fantastic and depending on the Play account they might not even recycle around again um because there is quite a few of them meaning that the feel of each round is going to feel quite you know significantly different I think the general Vibe of this game is one of discomfort and I don't mean that negatively the game puts on you under a lot of pressure to constantly keep up with your golems and the fact that you only ever get three actions per round and yeah you can end up taking a few actions with a single action if that makes sense by triggering four Golems
for example and even then that might synergize with different things um it still does not give you a lot of margin for error you know there's only four rounds in this game and each of these four rounds you're only drafting or taking three actions so essentially you're getting 12 main actions through the whole game which is no not much at all so I do like that again that idea of pressure and not being able to make too many mistakes it's probably going to bite you pretty hard if you do but there is a lot of ways to overcome these things as I said you can string some actions together and certain um synergies between your player board and the main board will just unravel and develop and reveal themselves as the game goes on that you might have not initially have seen which of course is like a uh a thing that these designs are known for just merging all the different parts of their game there is a fine line you have to walk between you know exploiting the position of your Golems because yeah the best actions are right at the end but there is a fine line and a fine Tipping Point to when it starts you know bleeding you points and losing control of it so you need to make sure you have some knowledge in your reserve to make sure you're not losing those additional points but also knowing when to pull that trigger and know when to retire or kill that Golem to get these points as well because all these are benefits at the bottom because these again are they're finite they're going to get grabbed by the other players and you might want to take the initiative and grab the best bonuses before they do I am a big fan of how many options you have on your player board and again they all tailor towards a different strategy there's just always something good to do and just not enough time to do it you know you really want to have all these blue upgrades because buying cards is a
great thing because not only do you get instant rewards you also get permanent rewards if you keep again spamming the same color but that's going to tie it to this track meaning that you might want to climb it as quick as you can so you can keep playing the same cards in the same columns but this thing is upgraded itself so you might want to do an upgrade because it's going to be a lot better and you're going to have to climb fewer steps in order to get more cards down and all the time they're doing these upgrades you're getting more and more of this specific colored menorahs which are going to tie to that certain strategy the same goes for the Golems yeah you want to get the Golems down but getting the Golems down means that they're going to climb this track which means that they're going to lose more control of them because you're going to have to divide the movement or have more movement on the board and which you might not have the knowledge to tailor towards that but the more you go up these tracks the more points you can get when it comes to the income phase and there's lots of cool mitigation tools from the Golem upgrades themselves such as not having to use the movement from the character card or I think there's even ones like this one if you manage to buy it and which means you only ever pay a maximum of two knowledge no matter how far the Gap is between your character and your Golem because normally this would cost like one two three four five knowledge but if you have the upgrade it's only going to cost you two so you can see how all these different things are worth having but there's just not enough time to get it all done and it's probably one of those games you're gonna have to pick one and maybe start bleeding into the second strategy um and probably not you know spinning all three plates and diluting your you know your resources and your energy between the three strategies I think
Golem scales pretty well um it's not a massively interactive game because you're pretty much just doing your own thing most of the interaction is going to come through the communal card drafting uh of course the marble drafting if people are going for the same color as you are then you know you're going to have to prioritize accordingly and of course trying to get the jump on your opponent to get the perfect worker placement spot for you and it's just a matter of tailoring the amount of marbles depending on the player count um so yeah not really a big issue and it'll generally scale quite well and however that being said I would generally probably not play this any more than three players which is a general rule for me when it comes to heavier more involved Euros because I like to be more engaged throughout the game and I'm not really willing to sit through you know three other players turns before it gets back around to me particularly When It Isn't So interactive but you are looking at a two hour game here which you know considering the depth and breadth of the game isn't certainly not an issue but bear in mind this is going to be you know a big time sync um and it might even go beyond that two hour account if you are looking at four players there are a few issues I have with the game uh the first of which are these character cards I don't really think they add much to the overall experience and it feels a little bit tacked on it's one of those things where I think if it happens it happens lucky you but other than that it just feels a little bit Surplus I've already talked about the randomization of the synagogue doesn't quite work as it should uh in my opinion and another issue I have with the game is some of the iconography it can be a little bit overwhelming at times and sometimes it's a little bit
inconsistent as well for example this worker placement spot here it actually does mean activate one of your golems and use it where normally that symbol would be the Hammer symbol so it's quite strange how they chose two different things um I know there's a very slight difference where in this example you don't have to lay it down but it just doesn't quite sit right for me um there's some other symbology as well that you just have to refer to the rule book um you know one or two more times than I'd normally be comfortable with so again be bear that in mind if you're not um a massive fan of referring and cross-examining um symbology then this one might be one to avoid the production for Golem is okay it's nothing extremely lavish um so functional and I actually do like the look of the board I know I'm probably the minority um of that um but again now the tiles themselves they're pretty thin they're not they're not ultra high quality as I said the synagogue itself isn't overly functional the marbles are nice everything else is generally fine um I suppose the biggest issue is the some of the player pieces and the currencies they're just a bit cheap and nasty like you know the clay is normally nice to have something plastic or wooden to play with rather than just a a cardboard kit for a piece of clay and the coins as well they look a bit rubbish they're tiny okay so let's get in some final thoughts on Golem and again I apologize that I've had to be somewhat rushed in this video because there's just too much to talk about and I'll be here all day if I wanted to do a full Deep dive and um critique everything in the game um but this is a very crunchy your own and it's a true brain burner and
I suppose the rules themselves aren't that difficult because you're only doing one of these actions and the worker placement spot but the way that these tiles start to merge with each other um some of the pressures that come into play as in like having knowledge tokens and reserves you know what you need to buy the cards do you want the upgrades before you get the cars to get the most output from them that's where all the flavor starts to come into play and you want to start stringing these actions together because sometimes you know a certain action might say well do an upgrade from your player board and that might tie into the next action that you want to do but all the meanwhile you're gonna have to adjust on the Fly based on what other people are taking and again with with that underlay of wanting to move your students all the time not only to increase your income but to keep up with the Golems themselves knowing when to retire the Golems it's just an absolute you know brain masher and it feels like work at times you know I'll be completely honest there is a fine line here where I'm thinking how much of this is clever design um which is a lot of it you know it's very well designed game there's a lot of you know thinkiness here um but does it start you know tipping that scale into feeling like work and for me I'm very much on that borderline on that knife's edge of how do I feel about it because this is the kind of game that I will play not not very regularly because it is longer um and because it requires the right game group to do it but that is like almost like the negative for it as well because this isn't the kind of game that you can just pull off the shelf after you know six months to a year from
playing it the last time that you're going to remember how everything works you're going to have to pretty much read the whole rulebook again and pretty much play it again as if you played it for the first time because there's just too much going on here for you to fully grok um but if this if you um are the kind of gamer where you buy a Euro game and you and your group fully like to explore every nook and cranny and to be as optimal as possible then this is definitely one for you to sink your teeth into as a group and you'll find yourself getting better getting more mileage out of your turns getting the maximum um you know multiplies when it comes to all the different strategies and I do love this um actual scoring system where you know the different things you go towards are always going to reveal more of these menorahs and give you bigger multipliers depending on the strategy you went for love that and that's generally a theme I do like in board games but yeah um am I going to rate it amongst you know these Italian designers best games I don't think so I do think it's good I think it's way better than average um but yeah it's maybe a little bit out of my comfort zone in terms of rules complexity and again the work Factor how much how much fun is it in compared to you know how clever is it and I think those are two different things so yeah I do like the game I would recommend it to the right person I wouldn't universally recommend it I gotta rate it relatively High um but I can see it not standing up with my favorites because of all those criticisms so that is Golem