Detective: City of Angels - Saints and Sinners: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock and today I'm doing a discussion over detective Saints and Sinners this is the newest expansion to detective City of Angels um and yeah it's three new cases so there you go uh that's it everyone so I hope you enjoyed obviously I'm kidding um this is kind of a it's an interesting review that I'm going to do because obviously I'm not going to go into the the nitty-gritty of the cases because that would just ruin the who done it mystery um and so these kinds of expansions are it's kind of like well why am I doing a a review over it because basically the the short of it is do you like detective City of Angels yes get it that's it that's that's it like it's it's three new cases to a fantastic game detective City of Angels is one of my favorite in the who done it genre because it's the only one that I'm aware of anyway that is competitive by design it is a competitive game where one person plays plays the chiseled which is kind of a DM they're more of a game manager because they don't act out they don't really do a whole lot except actually compete against the players while the players are competing against them you know each other you're all you know beat you know homicide detectives that are doing
whatever you can to get the get your scoop and get the answer not scoop because that'd be a like a reporter to get your uh the the case solved and I have done a uh you know run through and review um over the original way to play the game with the chiseled and then I've also done it for the I think it's called the sleuth mode which is where it's fully Cooperative but in this discussion I'm also going to talk about uh the expansion which is mainly giving me an excuse to talk about the other way the play detective which I had never played before until recently which is their head-to-head mode um because this game has had two expansions previously uh for it it had smoke and miror and Bullets Over Hollywood and those added new cases as well Saints and Sinners gave three although I think there was some weird confusion about this one I think there was a case called clo and Dagger which was kind of its Standalone case but it's included in this so I I don't I remember seeing something about that but at the end of the day this comes with three new cases so let's talk about this one first because this is going to give me an excuse to kind of talk about detective City of Angels um yeah it's it's three new cases and they are all of the same difficulty they are all uh veteran difficulty which so there's no gum shoe and I don't think there's a hardboiled one I'm pretty sure
they are all veteran um yes uh I'm taking taking a look yeah there's Cloak and Dagger blast from the past and I guess I am going to have to look up look up some stuff in this box is packed cuz I have somehow managed to fit everything in here um but yeah like I also haven't I didn't do a review over those other two expansions cuz it's like well what what am I going to say that uh besides oh more cases no you like it's more of the same you like it then get it a one last hit for the Hitman oh no that is gumo okay well what's weird so there's a misprint because in the uh in the chiseled book it says veteran um but I guess in the uh other books it says gum Sho so there is a gum Sho which is the easiest case to solve and then the other two are veterans which is kind of weird like if you're going to do three cases I almost feel like you should do an easy medium and a hard but uh who knows now here uh I love this game so if you love city of Angels then just get this because it's new cases and the thing about this genre is they're one and done you know once
you know the answer especially if you're the chiseled if you're the one who is running of the game and knows the answer then yeah you can't really do it again um but I can say at least from my standpoint there I put one and done in quotes because I have redone cases from Chronicles of crime from detective a modern crime board game and Sherlock Holmes because if it's years since I've done a case I'm not remembering so maybe going through like be like oh yeah I do kind of remember that he was weird that'd be the best like I I kid you not so these yeah there's cuz now this brings up the um the the case to 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 to 20 cases I have no idea van Rider games is going to keep making more content I would absolutely love them to I would love van Rider games to just be final girl in detective City of Angels that's all like if that's just what their entire Library they just kept pumping cuz I love love the genre I imagine that these cases are difficult to write for especially because um it is competitive so you have to have in enough misdirect rioting information that is going to pull people in different directions given the chiseled enough to do uh so that he if someone comes to him and questions a
certain suspect he can he can have like if you're playing a full like let's say a four player game three detectives like and they all ask the same question you you would have enough writing to potentially give each of them a different answer uh and utilize the beverage uh mechanic and stuff like that so I I'm a little disappointed this has three cases but I understand that why there's only three um one of the cases I mean and they kind of do a little bit more it's not just oh here's the suspects and the items go ask these questions like the the one that they recommend you do which is blood on the pier that's their like tutorial one um they got a a lot more creative in these cases adding in extra actions and neutral uh neutral people that have different rule sets I think that that is a nice change of pace versus just oh it's another who done it let's you know kind of go through the go through the motions and ask these questions uh and they've been doing that with the other expansions and I'd like that they continued it here um one of the ones that they had that uh I did the head-to-head mode was very um like the overall them was not what I was expecting and as I was reading it I was kind of like huh okay this isn't your classic you know Knives Out story that's really cool so I like that um
the uh so yeah like again like I said if you're a fan of detective City of Angels and you have Bullets Over Hollywood and you have smoke and mirrors Saints and Sinners is pretty much a duh but but at the same time I would also say what kind of makes this expansion and this box is empty like I said I've been able to fit everything in here it is packed if they come out with another expansion I do not have an alternative I do not have a way to figure out how to uh store it at least within the one box um I know they actually said and I forgot that they mentioned this the smoke and mirrors box said it was designed to hold additional cases I don't have that box anymore cuz I'm like that's stupid I can fit everything in here and I technically can uh but yeah eventually if you have every expansion you're probably especially if you sleeve cards or whatever you're probably going to have to use this box and you can like you could get creative and just have this box be the tuck boxes and just put have the tuck boxes in here and like miscellaneous stuff and then fit everything else it's it it is duable but I don't really like having expansion boxes if I can try and fit everything in the base um so before I talk about the head-to-head mode if you're interested in that detective Saints and Sinners I love this game more cases uh it's still fantastic writing it's still head to like uh not head to head still
competitive all of the same thing um so this is going to get a I mean God hold on let me let me let me let me let me let me let me look up some uh some some something real quick uh detective city of angle yeah it's a 9 out of 10 cool Saints and cers is n out of 10 I was double checking that for some reason I didn't lower this um but what's also kind of interesting and I mentioned that this was only three cases and I say only because I love this game and I want more and because they're one and done like oh you solved it move on do another case uh 20 cases is a a lot like most of these modern who done it games Chronicles of crime and detective modern crime board game which is now weird and portal games has basically abandoned it and did Batman everybody lies in Vienna uh connection anyway 20 is a lot compared to those the only one that kind of out does this I'd have to check Chronicles of crime to see how many they have overall but Sherlock Holmes is the only one that has more cuz there's four boxes and 10 cases in each I think there's 10 so that's 40 but still that's been going on for a long time this came out in 2019 which Jesus Christ that was 5 years ago uh they having half that amount in
half the and and not even half the time of Sherlock Holmes is extremely impressive uh and those aren't even really difficulty ranked these are so in 20 cases you have four gun gum shoe six uh veteran and that means you have 10 hardboiled and hardboiled is just that like have fun figuring out the case they are easily the thickest boxes with the most content and the most complex writing um although I still think gumu is still good riding and and still a lot of fun and Veteran is equally the same so even though they're harder scaled off difficulty it doesn't mean it's like uh that's that's riding for the gum Sho ones anyway what I was saying about this having three cases if you're the person that plays the chiseled meaning you're the designated group DM and you don't get to play The Other Side ever uh what's fascinating is that because this game is competitive if you're the Chisel and you already know the story you can actually do the same case just with a different Group which is cool because unlike the Cooperative version you're not working with other people so like I can't do the same case with I mean you can I could do another case of Sherlock Homes with other people I just stay quiet but with Detective City of Angels because it's competitive and the chiseled is competing to win uh I could
do like the one I did today with Cloak and Dagger I can do that with a different group and because I was the chiseled I'll be the chiseled again but now I'm still trying to win like it's still just as fun which makes this game even more expansive in terms of competing with those other games in the genre uh so yeah three cases but still have multi-use and legs more so than some other Cooperative cases that if it's like oh yeah we solved it together well it can't really do with another group unless I want to just watch them solve it and just kind of be a we didn't go to the scene of the crime like you know be that guy anyway yeah this gets a 9 out of 10 I really hope this isn't the last expansion uh like I think I mean they they can just keep going they can keep pumping it out uh if they do another expansion I would like to see more just cases in the box but I that's just kind of how it's going to go so now the head-to-head which kind of gives a more justification of why I'm doing a video over this the head-to-head mode is a game mode that is if you have two players so you can if you have two players you can you can do sleuth mode which is basically hey it's fully Cooperative uh we're solving it and it kind of turns into any of these other ones I've mentioned detective Chronicles and Sherlock uh which is fine because the writing again is still really good and you get the same exact feeling and it's still a blast the head-to-head mode
is kind of a simplified version of the classic mode um because now you still have a chiseled you still have someone who is you know who knows the story and is competing against one other person and they're still trying to solve the case but couple key differences here one you don't use money so scratch is not a thing in the head-to-head so that's all gone you don't have to there's nothing to bribe because in a classic Mode you bribe to kind of get info that someone else is looking for um you still get leverage on um on suspects and stuff and the chiseled still gets leverage on you except or on the detective except now the chiseled can only use that leverage to basically block a question so if someone asks yeah I want to ask that guy about that weapon uh you can and I have a leverage on that that detective I could spend it and block the question meaning they can't ask that specific question until the next day the game also starts out it's 12 days instead of I think it's 98 or seven uh going down the number of detectives so they have full 12 days and the biggest key differences is they don't get a solve and a final guess they get one solve the detective player gets one attempt to solve and typically they should wait till just the final guess so they get the full amount of all 12 days
but they could guess early if they are wrong they just lose chiseled wins and that's it if they are right they win and the Chisel loses that's the head-to-head mode and I was very curious cuz I was like really it's just one person cuz my favorite thing about being the Chisel in City of Angels if you have multiple detectives and some players are weaker than others at these kinds of games the Chisel can I know the chisel's trying to win but for me I still kind of run as a DM I just want I think it's I feel it's more of a you know competition between them than it is with with me this is how I personally play but if one person's struggling and they feel like they're not getting any answer well the Chisel has every in their power to constantly give them answers like oh you want to ask this question about this person okay I'm going to give you the truth every single time I'm going to give you the best answer that lets you get more information that person is better he's kind of figuring things out I'm going to make him use his resources I'm going to make him spend his money use his leverage uh like spend leverage against him because to even the playing field so I thought that the head-to-head would kind of um lose that and it does obviously but if you only have another person to play this with excuse me if you only have one other person to play this with and
you're like well it's competitive and like if I think it needs three um I am very happy to say the head-to-head works very well in fact sometimes having to teach people and be like oh okay yeah so you have money and money is used for these different things uh and you have to bribe and now you have to compete with other people so he got there first so that actually removes this card because they were the they got there and you can't now get it you don't have to bribe to learn to get knowledge on other stuff it's just oh you got knowledge on this you just flip it like there's no evidence removal stuff there's no like knowledge tokens it's just cuz it's one other person you just flip it and the other thing that I personally found very fun from the head-to head because I mentioned that the chiseled I always kind of described as a DM but that's not the case cuz in a multi multi- detective game whenever they question someone the Chisel looks at the Matrix picks a response SL slides it in an envelope and then hands it to the person and then they read it and document it the Chisel doesn't DM really um like they can kind of you know artsy it up as much as they can but they're not acting out as these characters they're not sleuthing they're not doing any of they just kind of manage the game and and I'm not understanding the Chisel I I absolutely love playing the Chisel but I'm what I'm saying is in the head-to-head mode because there's no secret information that players are
keeping from each other uh I actually got to role play like I got to read out the you know case briefing and then whenever you know they would ask a question I would actually just read out their response because I don't it's just one other person I'm reading to I know the answer already so I got to act out as all these different characters I get to play music and really Ambience it up which is only allowable in well in the sleuth mode because it's fully Cooperative but also in the head-to head and I thought that that was just really fun cuz it's still competitive but because I get to look at the Matrix and pick a different response and read that it gave the characters more life then just and you don't have to do that if you're not comfortable doing that that's perfectly fine you can play it you slide it in the envelope and hand it to him um but it was just nice cuz I felt as the Chisel I was a lot more involved than normally in classic Mode now which one do I prefer I still prefer the classic Mode out of everything because that is what sets detective City of Angels apart from all the uh other ones but it's just amazing that this game that stands on its own as a unique competitive who done it but their sleuth mode is just as good as the rest of them and the head-to-head where it's one V one and you still get that competitive feel of like well now I'm trying to basically as a chis I'm just trying to prevent you from getting the right answer that's fun too and you can still
curate it if you're playing with someone that you just like the person I played this with um had never played this game before and so I helped him out I was like hey why don't you check your case briefing again you know and we did one of the cases from here um I'm like you know cuz like they they were just getting a lot of different answers obviously I'm still misdirecting lying they're using leverage very well uh and but I was like you know hey check your case briefing cuz there there's something in there you might missed and they were like oh I didn't go investigate the body that's just something that this game is amazing for and allows like any type of DM to kind of do that CU I didn't care if I won uh I just wanted them to solve the case cuz I'd want the case to be solved so if you are hesitant on this because you might not think it works at a low player count know that sleuth mode exists the fully Cooperative is amazing and the head-to-head to get the feel albeit a simpler version of the game is also equally good so that's my that's my thoughts That's my kind of R talk about detective City of Angels with the Saints and Sinners n out of 10 expansion but I also will say it's kind of one of those expansions that if you don't like this game this expansion isn't fixing it's more content that's it and I love that for these game so uh Evan I hope you're not done I hope
there's more content for detective City of Angels maybe just a big box maybe just some sexy ass big box that they just really go ham and double the cases there's 20 more rounded out at 40 with a big nice organized box and I would cry I'd be so happy but that's it we'll see what they do uh here on out and yeah that's that's my thoughts on detective Saints and siners and the head-to-head mode for detective City of Angels let me know what you think in the comments below other learn that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever upd is for you