FJORDS | Kickstarter Reprint | Let's Talk About MORE Than Just Artwork!
Transcript
so the fjords artwork is bad the fjord's artwork is good we've heard tons of different opinions about this uh kickstarter campaign in the comments on bgg on reddit everywhere um and at the end of the day this is a game that has been out of print for a long time and there's a lot of excitement a lot of strong feelings about it coming back i know even from us as well i was thrilled when i heard the fjords being reprinted because i loved the original there's a lot to talk about with this one and we're going to break down everything you need to know about the fjords campaign so stick with us so i'm dylan this is carlo we're from all you can board and today we're talking fjords so fjords if you're not aware was a game that came out back in 2005 it was designed by franz beno delange and it is a tile lane game and it's a game that i personally loved when i played um and it has been almost impossible to find it like if not impossible very very hard to find for a long time and this is obviously the reprint of it unfortunately the designer did pass away after he designed the game so this is being uh you know brought back with his design intact but also with a bunch of new elements added on if you want to use them there's a whole bunch of new stuff but there's also everything you know and love about the original fjord so for anyone who doesn't know fjords is like i said a thailand game and it basically plays in two phases and it almost kind of feels like two distinct games the first phase you're very much building the map you're essentially building your game board and there's going to be things you remember from other games like carcassonne and different things that we'll get into um but you're essentially building your game board and this is the game where that you're going to have sort of an area majority or you could
area control type game in the second phase so it feels like two distinct games but your first game influences how your second one is going to go and you're planning things out you're putting down these long houses and you're going to be able to start from those long houses in the second phase uh putting your vikings into play and trying to take control of the map so it's very very interesting it's very simple and it's execution but it does it so elegantly and in a way that when i played it i immediately and it was it was funny because i played it at a at a game cafe uh and it was recommended to me i had no idea what it was got lucky that it was recommended to me fell in love with and i've played it a couple more times since with you and uh and with my partner as well so um i really love it what were your thoughts when you played it yeah i've only had to or been able to try it the one time uh with you there at the at the game cafe and i liked it a lot um i don't know if you mentioned but it's it's a two player only game so i have seen a lot of comparisons uh made to carcassonne and as someone who's played carcassonne like hundreds of times um there's still a lot of value for like if you're a big hearthstone fan if you've played it a lot it's different enough because you are still building this map together but like dylan said not only is it a two-phase game but um in carcassonne only one of the like you're building you know you're you're fighting for the majority on the land and you're doing all this stuff with claiming cities and roads in fjords you're really only like the land is all that matters kind of thing like there's mountains and water but it's just kind of to develop the land you're only placing pieces and actually fighting over the the kind of terrain the grass so it focuses in on one spot a little more and it's a little more like blocky right you're putting down your
tiles and you're trying to cut people off in the scoring phase at the second part so there's a lot that still makes it different enough from carcassonne um and it's just it feels a little simpler and cleaner but it still has that kind of tension where you're trying to figure out where to put stuff to plan for that second phase so i really enjoyed it i only had to uh i tried it like i said the one time a couple years back but i've been waiting to play it again and uh yeah i'm super happy that the reprint's here yeah if anyone has played blue lagoon recently it's not exactly the same don't don't get me wrong it's not like basically that was you know a follow-up to fjords or anything but there's elements of blue lagoon that when i played it for the first time which is a writer can eat the game if you haven't played it um and it felt felt kind of not inspired by but just close to in some of the elements parts of fjords that's the closest comparison i can make besides carcassonne like you did yeah like blue lagoon has the same two-phase thing they literally call it the same thing the exploration phase and the settlement phase because you're putting things down that you can build out from in the second half so yeah definitely definitely good comparison there yeah so um first thing we're going to talk about we're going to get right into it um most of the discussion and for for better for worse about this campaign has been about the artwork so for those who don't know the artwork was done by beth sobel who's obviously done a whole bunch of different board games out there the box cover i think is gorgeous i'll say that first off i think it's amazing and we've known about the box cover and that artwork ever since it was first revealed so we've been had a chance to look at it for a while um a lot of the discussion has been about the tile artwork um a lot of people um in the community or at least a subset
of the community um doesn't like the artwork and you know it's not to their tastes or what they would you know want or what they were expecting from fjords which is valid um it's it's very simple artwork i would argue that the you know even the original few words is pretty uh straightforward and simple um carcassonne as well like a lot of these talent games when it comes to the tiles there's information you need to convey and it can't be too busy because you have to be very distinct between the different areas of the terrain um so yeah it's simple and i would even agree that you know the artwork that's on the cover of the box isn't necessarily translated into the tiles in terms of its beauty it's a lot more uh it's a lot simpler on the tiles than it is on the box art so there has been a lot of dissatisfaction for at least from what we've heard um on the tiles and i guess what i'll say is that me personally fjord's coming back and having uh me having a chance to purchase this game and actually have it in my collection which i've been wanting to do for a long time is the driving factor of me backing the fact of the matter is it's a for a canadian price it's a 32 game um which is a more than reasonable price for me to get fjords into my collection and that is number one the reason i backed it immediately i want fjords in my collection i've wanted it for a while and to me the artwork whether you think it's could have been better whether you think you know it's better or worse than the original in my opinion it's it's no it's just a sideways step from the original it's it's not something that's a more amazing it's not something that's worse it's it's just there and i'm completely
fine with that i feel like if the artwork is more important to you on your tiles which are going to get covered anyways with with along hosts with uh the viking pieces um if that's something that's you know a driving factor when it comes to campaigns for you then absolutely don't like you know don't back it and don't feel you need to and i can understand there being some disappointment there for people who potentially you know were really excited for the artwork specifically when they heard about fjords and now are let down but it is absolutely and you're right not tobacco for that and i would you know encourage you if that's something that you know you want from your games and you're not getting it to not back it but at the same time i would argue um that it's not that shouldn't be what we're talking about with with fjords here this is a game that we have not been able to get our hands on for a long time and the designer passed away and for i think you know a lot of us and me included i just thought i would never get it unless i got lucky and found it on ebay or found it on you know uh the secondary market and now i have a chance to get it there's a i can play with all the classic original rules if i want to try out new things there's additional ways to play it to me that is the most important thing for me whether i am 100 satisfied with the artwork on the tiles almost doesn't matter to me personally because i am 100 satisfied with the gameplay and i just cannot wait to play it and the artwork to me isn't a detriment enough to to ruin that experience for me no absolutely not and if anything i think it's it almost pays tribute to the original it's like you you mentioned a couple times how the designer friends benno delance passed away just a couple years after the game came out and i think it's
if anything it can be a tough task to be first off in phil walker harding's shoes like being asked as a designer to come on and sort of add additional content to the game you want to be respectful of you know paying tribute to a game of someone who has passed away you don't want to change it too much and i think first off that was a great choice to have phil walker harding do it and then we go back to the artwork it can be a tough thing as well like as the artist you want to show off the best work that you can do and a lot of games that go on kickstarter do have a lot of sort of extravagant artwork really fancy components and stuff and i have to tip my hat to beth sobel for sort of paying tribute to the game by keeping that simple kind of look that that simplistic look to it that still to me looks beautiful and to me again it comes down to the whole theme of the game is exploring this island and like literally again the phases are the exploration phase and the settlement phase and i saw some of the complaints were not even that the colors or whatever on the artwork but that it's like there should be more stuff on the tiles like more background little like sheep and things but to me it's like the whole point is you're exploring this island and then you place the pieces on and it kind of develops as you play and that's part of the beauty of the game is you're exploring this unexplored land that has nothing to it and then you're settling it yourselves and that's part of the charm so i think like you say to criticize the simplistic artwork is like that's what the original was going for and that's kind of what they're trying to preserve is like kind of just bring back the originals so i i think it was the right choice to take the approach they did with the art so yeah it's definitely not an issue for me but again like you said everyone's entitled to their
opinion about where the art is i just don't think it should be again the focus of what's making you choose to back the game or not because if the artwork's going to make you like if that's going to be the deciding factor then maybe the gameplay isn't enough to hook you in the first place yeah exactly like i i i will stress if you have not played fjords i think this is like a fantastic two-player game and it would be a shame to miss out on it just because the artwork unless you feel so strongly that you just like think it's ugly and cannot look at it but i just i find meat for that that's personally hard for me to understand because i don't think that there's that much wrong with it um but again my recommendation would just be try to look past that because there's a fantastic game here and i don't think when i look at the artwork on the tiles if there's anything here that's going to ruin that experience for you um and again like you said i think we're also just we're all a little bit spoiled with kickstarters because we there's a there's a type of kickstarter that is you know predominant which is you know the the title blades and the the frost havens and you know all the come on games where it's about miniatures and and art and presentation and deluxe components and all this stuff but if this was a a 70 game um you know base level i would i would be a little more understanding about some of this because there would be way way higher expectation i feel like for you know in our region a 32 kickstarter game that's one of the lower ones that i've seen like that we've been wanting to back a while normally i'm backing minimum 50 60 70 canadian that is way above or like beats my expectations of what i was
gonna have to pay when i was like uh anticipating this campaign in the first place so for me i was excited about that and still love the the box arts love the gameplay and that's just sort of what's driving me to it so um yeah i won't spend more time on it again i think everyone's entitled to their opinions i just think we need to kind of leave it at if you don't like the artwork and it's it's a non-back for you because of it that's totally fine but i think to just drive the conversation so much about that to try to you know i'm going to keep this conversation going until they change it for me so that i can back it like that's that's not what kickstarter is about like this is their this is the game and if you don't like it don't back it that's totally fine or wait and see when it comes out that you can see the physical version and and make that um you know make that choice for yourself i think that's completely valid too and i think that's kind of what we have to remember with it so uh that's the artwork uh big conversation going on but uh not deterring me from from my instant back on it uh so next thing i want to talk about is there are some other things with the campaign that um i wanted to mention that i think are legitimate things that should be talked about with with some of it there was some confusion and even i was confused about uh the two levels um and just so to clear that up especially if you're considering backing it um the there's a yarrow level it's gyro carlo's my guy just always asks if i'm pronouncing things correctly um so there's a url uh level and there's the the base level which i think is called the viking pledge um so the url level adds something that says the secret runes and then there's bonus components to play an epic two player version and there's deluxe upgraded runestones
so much of the mini expansions in addition to this game involve runes that there's so much confusion because on one level it seems like we get the runes in the base box and put their cardboard and then all of a sudden it's like back the url pledge and you'll get secret runes the clarification there is is that you are getting mini expansions in the base box you're getting one additional mini expansion in the url level called the secret runes and so that's the extra incentive there and then of course the upgraded runestone components and the epic two player version is literally just more components that you can play the two-player version on the new expanded um larger board that accommodates three and four players which i guess we should have said yeah this version of the game plays up to four players which is uh another big change you can enjoy so and all these mini expansions are done by phil walker harding which is something else we didn't mention who's done a whole bunch of games sushi go uh he's done barron park gizmos there's tons of these kind of light to medium range games uh great designer yeah pretty cool that he has his touch on this and stuff so um so yeah that was the one thing i wanted to clarify that for me it's a it's in hindsight it's a minor thing but when you have a campaign for a game that's really there's not a lot to the campaign it's a very simple game and has a very simple campaign which i think is absolutely appropriate there's only two pledge levels if you have confusion between those two pledge levels you've done something wrong with the way you structure your campaign like you shouldn't need to have confusion there when there's simply two pledge levels anytime i've had confusion it's because there's you know four different levels and i'm trying to figure out which ones i get and what i feel like that was a little bit you know disappointing for me did you have the same confusion with them at all or a
little bit yeah i mean it wasn't entirely clear i was kind of wondering the same thing because like you said it mentions the deluxe but it's and at one point i think on the page i saw that there's four of these but then i think somewhere else i saw that there was eight so then i wasn't sure is the yarl just upgrading the four or is it yeah so yeah yeah so just a little bit of and i noticed that in the comments too so i at least i had some validation that i wasn't just a complete or something no and to be fair i think grail games like they've been to their credit they've been in the comments responding and i think they clarified that and said that they wanted to put it somewhere where it is a little clearer but it's just something to be aware of if you're looking at uh pledging and considering and actually looking at those levels so yeah and then the other thing i wanted to uh mention but i'll ask carla question first is if uh if you were coming to back um uh fjords uh when would you think you were going to be getting forwards of course well i mean all down the side it says estimated delivery november 2021 and that's where i tend to look because it's i fee i find that like so i will say that it's not like this is hidden it's in the campaign if you scroll all the way down to the bottom you will get an entire section way down to the bottom and it talks about timeline for a delivery the thing i don't like here and it could just be my pet peeve but i feel strongly about it is that everywhere on the side when you back on the actual like estimated delivery when you back the game it tells you november 2021.
it's only when you scroll down to the bottom and look at the timeline graphic that it says that for the three most popular regions that i would imagine are back in this which is the us the eu and canada um and australia um or a part of the australia um fulfillment is all january to march uh 2022. so again it's a couple months it's not like i'm upset that i have to wait a couple extra months to get the game i would have been fine with that had it been uh labeled that would that way it just to me it seems silly to put the estimated delivery at the earliest it's going to ship which is only to asia uh that to me is a little disappointing like that's not your primary fulfillment centers you i know that the the highest amount of backers are coming from north america and europe for sure so it just seems like a sneaky way to say like you're going to get this game early and then people back and say oh i didn't realize i'm not getting until march seems pointless like just tell us up front when it is be you know put the latest date in the estimated delivery they should just said february or march 2022 and then that way if it shows up early it's a bonus rather than us knowing like there's no way that we in canada are going to get it in november 2021 but that's yeah yeah you'd rather be a pleasant surprise than be disappointed by what you find out so to me that was just something that could have been changed and updated i didn't personally like that but again it's not something that at all deterred me from back and it was just an unpleasant surprise um but other than that like the shipping costs are what you expect i could talk about them and say i'm disappointed that shipping ends up being so much on kickstarter campaigns but at this point i think we've said that enough to blow in the face yeah yeah we're always a little disappointed um with that but yeah overall my my thoughts on this is
that this is a fantastic game that was basically lost to time you know like you couldn't find it um or if you did it was hard to find it was through the secondary market it was out of print um i found i played it by fluke because of my local game cafe had a copy this is an opportunity to get that game into our hands from a designer who is unfortunately no longer with us and be able to experience that game and introduce it to more people and to me that's the most important thing that we're taking away from this campaign you know we can we can all debate the artwork uh and and technically we're all right like i i'm right if i like the artwork and you're right if you don't like the artwork exactly everyone is entitled to those opinions i just think that the conversation being so focused on that when it should be focused on the fact that we're gonna get to re-experience this game finally and some people are gonna experience it for the first time yeah and if it wasn't for this that might never have happened that's to me where the conversation should be and whether we choose to back or not back it does all our individual choices um but that would my recommendation is that i personally think this is one of the best two player only games i've played yes it introduces another about a whole bunch of other modes and and ways to play but to me i'm just excited to be able to you know play that with my partner more and introduce more people to it and actually have fewers on my own table that's what i'm excited about absolutely and i want to say just going back to something you touched on before is that um even though there is a three and four player mode and there's these variants and stuff like i i'm excited for anyone out there who might have played the original really liked it and might be concerned about any changes they've made the design has been very clear there is a specific section in the rules that says like classic rules like
all the rules for how to play the original two-player game the way it was i think there's been a couple of minor tweaks to the to the regular rule set in here and then there's others that are considered variants but i feel like this is about as good of a job as you can do to pay tribute to something without kind of messing too much with the original and making it your own but giving people enough to make it feel like it's not just the reprint of the original so yeah i'm really excited for it um if you had if you hadn't backed that i would have already backed it because you backed it i'm on the fence about either backing it if not at the worst i'm definitely gonna get it as soon as it comes to retail um and yeah like dylan said it's a fantastic two-player abstract game uh lots of tension and just yeah a great great game and reprint you should be keeping an eye out for yeah so those are our thoughts on the fjords campaign uh thanks so much for watching if you have any questions if you want to talk about it in the comments we'd love to discuss it i'm so excited about this game so i would just love to talk more about it um one final question because it's i think one of the most important ones is does this game have any relation whatsoever to use fjord no relationships you're serious right no relation i don't think so there's not many games out there with fjord in the title so i have two i'll have two of my collection with news fjord and fjords just want to make sure there's no this isn't like a secret secret well i believe the fjord is a type of region like a valley or something whereas noose fjord i think is a specific place in norway if i'm not mistaken or a word for a fishing village i'm not exactly sure but this is great because now we don't have to have a bunch of comments asking this question in the exact video we've just answered it for you so there you go thanks so much for watching and we'll see you in the next one see ya