Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brass Birmingham Board Game Review

Transcript 12:12

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings would generally like to talk a lot of bollocks gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about a reprint of an alleged timeless classic we're going to be talking about brass birmingham and in this game you will be building canals and railways you'll be placing buildings on a map hoping that you can flip them that will give you victory points that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules by telling you what we do like we don't like we'll come back and tell you whether or not brass birmingham is worth your time and bother and also whether it's better than this ugly munter so remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing this channel hit the like button all right youtube we'll see you after this bollocks so brass birmingham how do you play this game so brass birmingham is essentially a train game i think martin wallace's fame default is train games like age of steam and railways of world which is beyond me and what you'll be doing you'll be building canal links in the canal area and you'll be building railway links in the railway era and you'll be trying to link buildings together to produce resources it's going to give you victory points right so beginning of the game you're going to have eight cars in your hand each card will have a different thing on it you'll have a location card you might have the wall ramson card you

might have a birmingham card right and this allows you to build a building in a specific location there's also cards that relate to specific types of industry you might have cotton mills you might have breweries and then there's also the wild cards which are later built anywhere and anything so on your turn you'll be able to take two actions apart from the first turn where you only be able to take one right you'll always have to discard a card when you take an action and dependent on what you're doing you might have to discard a specific card or not so the first action you can do is you can build something to do this you'll have to discard a specific card whether it's the industry card you got or you've got the specific location card like we talked about a second ago you'll look at your playable where you've got all these different industry titles and you'll see that they're numbered in ascending levels you'll choose the lowest numbered building you'll pay the appropriate cost which is on the right hand side and then you'll place it on a linked location right you haven't got nothing on the board and you don't have to worry about being linked there's a couple of really confusing but really important concepts you've got to understand about brass and that is the concept of what your network actually is and the concept of what is actually connected so something's in your network if you've got an industry token on that location or if it is next to jason to one of your link tiles right that sounds simple right a location is considered connected if you can trace a link whether it's your link tiles or somebody else's link tiles back to another location i know it sounds really simple on paper when you're trying to explain it to people in person people look really confused as if you just tried to kill their mother-in-law so you can only build certain buildings in the canal area and you can only build

certain buildings in the rail area there's something called overbuilding i haven't played brass for over a decade i don't generally see this happen very often and even less so in this iteration so i can't be asked to talk about it so you'll place the industry tile on the board and if there's any resources on that tile you'll dump them on top of the tile right if you have a link to one of the external markets then you will have to place any excess resources into the market first so if there's a space for four coal then you'll have to put four coal in there if you empty your load on the tile not like that then you'll flip the tile and you'll claim the reward it will initially be a boost in income and at the end of the canal era or the rail era at the end of the game you'll score victory points for the building itself and you'll score victory points for any players links that surround it right so the next action that you could do in this game is you can sell your you'll discard any card from your hand and you'll flip a tilde is connected remember we said connected means anybody's canal or rail tiles right and you'll trace a route back to one of the external markets you'll have to consume the correct amount a bear because people in birmingham in the industrial revolution that's all they did they didn't eat they just drank bleeding beer and if you consume the beer barrels from the merchant you get to take the bonus whether it's extra victory points a nice big lump of crystal mdma or a new pair of slippers just remember you can do this for as many buildings as you like right not just one any of them so the next action you can do is you could take a loan right because these capitalist pigs want you to borrow money so you can get interest on it except in this game you don't pay interest on the loans just take 30 quid the only thing is you have

to move your income market down three spots and that is like a kick in the bollocks next thing you could do is you can perform the scout action this is how you get hold of those wild cards right you'll discard three cards from your hand and then you'll pick up a wild location and a wild industry card next thing you can do is you could develop you'll discard one card from your end and then you'll remove one or two tiles on your player map right this allows you access to the more advanced level tiles without actually having to play them right because iron magically teleports around the world when somebody wants it you'll have to consume iron from anywhere on the board whether that's from the market or somebody else's title right so the final action you can do is you can network this is how you get your transport links on the board you will discard a card and then you'll place your tile on a link in your network can you remember what that means because i can't and then you'll consume the correct amount of resources in the rail area you can also build two links but it's more expensive and requires beer right so once the deck has been completed and everyone's gone through there and the cards you'll come to the end of the eras in the end of the canal era all the level one buildings will be removed all the canal tiles will be removed you will score victory points depending on what tiles you have flipped and then you'll go into the rail area doing the same thing that i was waffling on about earlier and when you get to the end of the rail era you'll do the same scoring right once you've completed the final scoring the player with the most victory points will be the winner of brass birmingham so what do we like about brass birmingham so the first thing that we like about it is the way that americans always say birmingham when it's actually birmingham it never fails to make me chug no i'm just kidding right so if we look at the original brass it looks like a complete

steaming pile of gnu it was ugly the component quality was absolutely diabolical and roxy games have really really upped the quality off the charts right for some bizarre reason they even give you the option of playing during the day or during the night i suppose this reflects the fact that the worker class in the industrial revolution worked 24 hours a bloody day right below my job but yeah the artwork is absolutely fantastic component quality has been improved aside from the cubes here they didn't give you coal or iron markers in the box standard editions probably in a deluxe edition right and yet overall the component quality is absolutely stunning it looks fantastic on the table and it's one of the best produced games we've seen in quite a long time you know so the second thing we like about brass birmingham is the addition of the wild cards means there's not really any excuses to say that i can't do anything right as long as you've got three cards in your round you can dump them and then that will allow you to build anywhere and build anything if you get down to two cars you are a little bit screwed but then i suppose you could argue that is down to your pool planning right so whereas the original brass lancashire sort of backed you into a corner and didn't really give you any escape route this has been addressed in brass birmingham so the third thing that we like about brass birmingham is that you will need a dynamic strategy no good just thinking at the beginning again well if i build in birmingham that's a central hub that's going to give me access to loads of other because you've got to consider not only the random card draw you don't know what cards you're going to get you might not get any location cards yeah but you've also got to think about where other people are building so that opens up the network in the later stages of the era and consequently you've got to think about where you're going to build your network because

other people might leach onto that and that might give them access to the lucrative external market so you constantly got to be thinking about where the best networks are emerging and how best you can connect to those lucrative networks you know make sense does it so the third thing so fourth thing so the final thing that we like about brass birmingham is the slim size box they haven't opted for one of these huge off air storage systems you know it's very very thin everything fits in there perfectly as we keep on saying space is a premium in my dungeon the fact that brass birmingham fits into a box the width of karen carpenter's elbow is very welcome so what don't we like about brass birmingham so the first thing that we don't like about it i'm tired of talking about this in modern ball games is the random card draw right i know there's ways to mitigate it but when you draw those two cards at the deck after you've played your actions you draw the that you don't want it's like somebody's put a screwdriver into your ear i know i said that you can swap those cards out for the wild cards but that is a waste of an action that might open the door just to crack so that other people can reach in and steal your stuff so whilst there are ways to mitigate the random cards all they have thought about this they it's not like they've just gone into this game blind it's still really annoying when you pull out stone really you want it leak so the second thing that we don't like about brass birmingham is there are some confusing and sort of really unclear rules in the book i mean the original brass had this really weird concept where you about some link to

burke and head right bernard beck and thankfully that has been dumped definitely about this one and also at the new version of brass lancashire but there's still occasions where some of the rules don't really make sense for instance you can use resources from somebody else's industry to build a link but you'll be taking the resources before you built the link so it doesn't really make any sense how did you get the call from there over to here admittedly most of the rules are explained but they're really difficult to find the rule but it's maybe just a couple of words explain everything so be aware when you play this for the first time if you're not familiar with brass at all then there are going to be occasions where you're going to be scratching your head and trying to filter through that flappy rule book so the third thing that we don't like about brass lancashire is it's almost impossible to reach the higher echelons don't pronounce that right whereas in the original brass it was quite easy to pile through most of the industries in this you're not really going to be getting anywhere near that level 8 right you're not going to be really getting anywhere near that that higher level beer so really just going to be building high levels in one or two different industries there's probably brass birmingham enthusiast geeks out there screaming at the tv saying you're not playing it right well you so sometimes i stare at the purple and think what's the point in having all these industries there when you're not really ever going to use them and it's like sort of tantalizingly frustrating so the final thing we don't like about brass birmingham is that every time we play this there seems to be a runaway leader not every time but more often than not it seems to be somebody that just pulls away and they are uncatchable i don't know why that is it seems that

they built their industries in the right place at the right time during the canal era and managed to upgrade them so they didn't get taken off the board and maybe that's just a little bit too lucky for me but i don't know i've played this 100 billion times like a lot of the spotty geeks out there so maybe you might want to consult with them before you start frying your birch trifle your flat screen so to summarize is brass birmingham not birmingham birmingham still worth your time with bother first release of 2008 this one's 2016. so today and in the future so we're going to say yes this is an engaging update to an all be it stuffy and visually unappealing classic roxley games have removed all of the fiddly rules of the original brass and replaced them with fiddly rules of their own it's long it's a brain burner and it's a brilliant example of long-term planning mixed with a healthy dose of luck mitigation right is it better than brass lancashire if you put a potato gun to my head i would have to pick the original so there you go that is brass birmingham remember if you know it and please consider subscribing to this channel it the like button and all that youtube see you next time

foreign

Progress saved