Undaunted Stalingrad Review: The Undaunted System Turned Up To 11
Transcript
hello I'm Farrell this is Tommy we are part of it and Welcome to our review of undaunted Stalingrad the red hot game of the minute and probably the most stressful board game that we have ever played yeah uh I cannot stress enough how much emotion this game gives off and we nearly broke up twice I think during the later stages of the campaign yeah it was tense if you're unfamiliar with the undaunted series it's a wildly popular uh series of two-player head-to-head deck building War Games set in different conflicts in World War II and one thing that makes it so wildly popular is it has a very simple rules overhead very simple core easy to grasp yet there's such a wealth of strategy and a kind of an amount you can Tinker with to build on that core system that you really do get some epic head-to-head conflicts and if you even if you don't like War Games honestly it's something worth checking out just because it's so engaging 100 and coming to undaunted Stalingrad this entry in the series turns undaunted into a replayable campaign Legacy Style game based around the Battle of Stalingrad the series already has some campaign Style Elements but here we have permanent Soldier death Soldier promotion surprises unlocks branching narratives and branching
scenarios the core of undaunted's gameplay is a deck building system you usually start off with a small deck of around eight or so soldiers of various types with unique actions each Soldier is part of a squad and these squads are represented by tokens on the main map showing where they are located you'll also have leaders and commanders in your starting deck which will allow you to recruit further soldiers into your deck both players begin their turn simultaneously drawn four cards from their deck and then they'll simultaneously discard one of these cards for its initiative value whoever discards a high number can't gets to take their turn first and in the main portion of players 10 they will play all of their cards and for each card they can do one thing they could take one action printed on the card they could return the card to their supply hunkering it down or they could spend that card to flip a suppressed combat token something we'll get to later but Clays have to be careful because not every card in their deck is a soldier that can let them do actions some will be fog a war cards which you'll start with at the beginning of the game and gather more from exploring the map but essentially they have a very low
initiative value and they don't have any actions so they're there to clog up your deck and create a bit of a problem as you try and deck build so the actions are quite simplistic but we'll go through some of the common ones that you'll be doing so you have the Scout action which allows you to move your Scouts and Scout terrain and once train is sculpted you can then do the move action to move your other units onto sculpted Terrain you'll also be able to do the control action which will allow you to take control of a scouted tile and this is often required to win scenarios or complete objectives then you have the fighty actions suppress and attack and both these work the same way and they're a little more complex but they're still not hard to get your head around essentially you'll roll as many dice as you're told and then you'll see if you get a hit and the way you calculate a hit is you give the unit you try and Target a defense value so they have their own defense value printed on for example this is Gunners and it has a four then you'll add up the defense of the train it's on in this case a three so then four plus three and then how many tiles away you are so one two so then I need to roll a nine to hit the scanners over here from where I am and if you get a successful hit on a suppression you flip over the token which then means they can't take actions
and if you get successful hit on attack the defending player will have to remove a card of that unit first of all from their hand if it's in their hand secondly from their discount panel if it's on their hand and then finally from their deck if it's not in either of the previous two each scenario will have a novel map layout and a unique goal although many of them will be about players trying to control x amount of command points on the tiles different goals that require different strategies although you can always win by routing your opponent's Rifleman which means there are no more left to draw once they've been successfully attacked also you can always withdraw and forfeit the battle but scenario will usually end once either side has achieved their goal now we won't spend too much time on the undaunted system because there's already a lot of available content out there from the previous games in the series but let's just highlight the best parts firstly nearly every decision you make in this game is a really really tough one which for us is one of the best elements of game design for example having to choose a card to discard for initiative at the beginning of each turn it's an absolutely monumentous and stressful decision and a really excellent way at deciding turn order and surprisingly it doesn't get any easier when it comes to actually playing your remaining cards as each one has various actions that you can choose so more than one but you're only allowed to pick one when you play it so it's pretty tough and then you get to the deck building
the core of the game and it's very easy to add cards to your deck very easy to remove them and put them back in your supply this means you have incredible control over your deck so you can build it how you want and this means you can adapt you can strategize on the Fly and it's I can't stress how much fun it is to have that much control over the deck because you can play how you want to play and I think for my money not enough deck building games give you enough control lastly in terms of mechanisms you have the mechanism where when someone scores a hit the defender will permanently lose a soldier from their deck this is an inspired design because it means every role of the dice filled with tension it means that every hit is a crushing loss every Miss A Cause celebration you have to be smart you have to be strategic when you play because of this because otherwise you're literally going to lose your death and be unable to compete it's such great design all round now moving on to Stalingrad what an experience now this will be a review with some spoilers if that's something that you are worried about but we'll really try to be as vague as possible so as not to ruin proper the twists and turns but we're not really sure how much there is to spoil given that you can see a lot of what might be coming from the token punch boards and the decks in the Box
so what makes styling grad more of a campaign game than other undaunted games which were already campaigns in their own way well in those games your deck will stay the same aside from adding new types of soldiers as the scenarios get more complex whereas in Stalingrad you will permanently lose soldiers from the game whilst others become more experienced and therefore will get upgraded both are really nice touches and tend to make the post game clean up particularly engaging at the end of the scenario you'll likely have a big pile of dead soldiers you're going to shuffle that up and then draw a number which is based on how many you lost total and those that you draw will be lost permanently from the campaign if they're part of the kind of core squads you'll get a reserve unit sent to you which is worse in some way but if they're part of the specialist squads like say snipers they've just gone from the game they're permanently lost for your campaign and that means you can have less snipers than the other player and you can even lose entire squads this way so that you have none of them and this just completely changes how you play and daunt it because before there's always a worry losing people but now you can't just win at any cost throw your people to the meat grinder because you still have another 10 games to play in which all of your soldiers are reserves or you don't have them at all
it's just such an engaging mechanism and it's just adds so much flavor to the game and on top of that you actually also get to upgrade to people per scenario you'll again Shuffle who's left and two of them will be upgraded they'll get new actions they'll get better actions which is also really exciting fun and kind of leads you into wanting to play the next scenario because you want to try them out you want to see what's new what's changed what's different but it makes it all the more heart-wrenching when you inevitably get them shot and permanently killed in the very next scenario because you wanted to show them off in a similar vein you also have buildings that can be destroyed throughout the campaign it makes the landscape and your actions regarding it a particularly strategic decision given that you have to live with the consequences if you destroy your opponent's building to rubble and you win that battle and take it over you'll likely find yourself in an undefendable position in the next scenario also these destroyable terrains creates interesting considerations about how to tackle a scenario as well as giving you a unique campaign experience speaking of campaign elements one thing that's great about Stalingrad is that it's replayable because in one campaign there are certain game parliaments and units and troops that at minimum one player won't get to experience because
of how the story goes let alone all those scenarios that you both didn't get to play and of course you can also swap sides that's even more replayability but one thing we loved about the game is the fact that each side gets their own scenario booklet because first of all what this means is that you can kind of read the story at your own pace and sort out your own deck and set up and the other is that it immerses you further into the campaign because you're getting in the minds of your troops your learning story elements the other side doesn't know and often well not maybe not often but sometimes there's special secret surprises that you can pull on the other player and they don't know that so it just again it's so immersive it's so much fun and it's just way better than having someone read you for four minutes and then you know you've got a pass around the set of your decks separately yeah that's this does lead us to one of the rougher elements of Stalingrad as you just said sometimes there are surprises and the other player doesn't know that it's coming and just has no way to predict it until it's happened basically on the one hand that's of course very exciting very dramatic and if you're the one doing it it's very uh get a big buzz to be like yeah surprise this is coming and the other person didn't know but on the other hand if you're on the receiving end of that it can feel a bit unfair
like you've been cheated when the entire scenario just shifts into the favor of your opponent so yeah definitely something to consider and something new particularly got annoyed about yeah you definitely did me over I'd say a couple of times I did Pulitzer Prize and it didn't work it didn't capitalize on it particularly salty about that yes yeah I guess one of the big issues is that obviously in a campaign game you do want to have twists and turns to keep it exciting but it's a competitive campaign game so one person always might be left a bit unhappy in these types of situations another thing that we had an issue with was that some scenarios felt uneven you know we were told by the book to play some scenarios and we set them up and we played them and it was just very much weighted in favor of one or the other and I know it's kind of a thing with undaunted that you'll look at the self and you go oh well I don't know how I'm ever going to win this but you do tend to with undaunted have very even match-ups very harmful battles even when it looks like that but in this case it definitely felt like that when we did the battles as well and I can understand why they've done this because you know if one player is getting thrashed throughout the whole campaign they need a way to hit back they need a win they need to bounce it somehow and also in on some occasions it was kind of framed in the story that was a very difficult battle for one faction but the issue is when you have that it
detracts from the win of the player who's won and it kind of makes the loss feel worse knowing that you almost were never supposed to win in the first place because then you ask yourself why are we even playing if it isn't evenly balanced the good news is this only applies to a handful of scenarios and they are still very interesting to play in general the scenario design is excellent and have provided us with some wonderful experiences Stalingrad is really just the undaunted system turned up to 11 with so many interesting mechanisms to create more engaging and strategic gameplay than seen before in this series the best scenarios that we've played in this box and the most interesting units we've seen in this box example Engineers they let you put a mine on the board and when someone moves or tries to move between two tiles it will trigger the mine they'll roll and if they get hit which is very likely because they only get their base defense value as protection they will be killed so you the defender will have to lose a car permanently and it'll also prevent the move so it's kind of like a double negative for the person trying to move you know very small addition to gameplay very simply explained huge ramifications to the way the game is played it completely changes how you view the battlefield it Alters movement it Alters how you defend objectives
and this kind of thing is peppered throughout Stalingrad just small changes to the existing formula small additions that just kind of revolutionize the scenario design the way you can tackle problems and the way that you follow each other basically and there's so much of it so I mean in your campaign you might have tunnels which changes how movement works you might have bombers which is going to change how you play and how you kind of uh mobilize your units and on and on and on and just can't express enough that there wasn't anything that we were introduced to which we felt we didn't like or wasn't completely enthralling yeah I think for me it really opens up like the Strategic playing field and I really felt like a commander in a way because you can approach it in such different ways with all these things available to you that really feels like you're planning out a real battle with like real ramifications final thoughts on Dalton Stalingrad is a full recommendation from us and in fact it's been one of the best board game experiences with hunt and Pro tip we found really banging World War II playlist on Spotify that really elevated our campaign and we had a lot of fun listening to that yeah now this is a really big box and it's
expensive but we still recommend it just because it's so highly replayable I mean we've played 15 games of this in two weeks and we're literally desperate to go again and play again do it all over again but we'd also recommend if you have an experience on taunted before well you can go straight into Stalingrad it might be worth just picking up one of the smaller games you're on Dawn to Norm days you're in daunted North Africa's because they are very reasonably priced they give you a good introduction into the system and you can see if you like it but either way we recommend it all definitely and if you have played undaunted before then we definitely recommend to get Stalingrad as it's really an elevation of everything that has come before the Legacy elements work terrifically well providing immersion and adding some really quite stressful Stakes that said it's not perfect and it might not be for everyone there are some elements which might cause some people to be frustrated as it did for did for us mostly me not gonna lie like well I got pretty angry once or twice oh oh my God yes I actually blocked it from my memory but you you've maybe got more Angry than me I was more consistently angry yeah that was one time that you could really split my leg uh anyway despite this we really really recommend to get Stalingrad as it's still massively worth it despite these very very minor complaints and maybe
that's just us because we're too competitive yeah I mean this is a great way to break up with someone if you just don't want to tell them to be honest yeah you can definitely sort of spark an argument yeah if you enjoyed this video appreciate it if you give us a thumbs up subscribe to our Channel if you're not already and please feel free to ask us any questions about the game down in the comments or if you've already played it let us know if you agree with us or disagree with us and what your thoughts are on the undaunted series thanks for watching thanks for watching see you next time