Summoner Wars: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for summoner wars second edition which i absolutely have to give plaid hat games praise because i hated this game like whenever i was first in the hobby the first edition um just absolutely pissed me off and it really just kind of came down to like whenever you're fighting um like it was just it was i believe it was literally a d6 and it was like oh okay missed missed and it's just like what the [ __ ] is the point of anything that i'm doing if i'm always gonna be missing here but i gotta say um second edition is a lot of fun granted i also have come around to the 1v1 because i also hated magic and games like that you had that at that time um but my perspective has changed quite drastically where i love unique like factions and 1v1 head-to-head uh kind of games and this is exactly that but it is cleaner streamlined um but you still get that kind of skirmish that quick skirmish with very simple rules yet interesting kind of um like gameplay uh and and i mean it's it's quick like but still has some depth to it so
yeah this is this is one that i'm absolutely excited to keep getting because i mean from what i understand they have a bunch of factions planned they have a [ __ ] ton in first edition i mean that's good uh so yeah josh what do you think uh i even though i got uh stomped uh this game is really fun yeah uh the uniqueness so far from the different factions i've played um they do play drastically different from one another yep um i played the goblins in this uh goblins i did a little better uh i never did damage to you however um i think the only thing i don't like this versus the other games is i'm i have to attack this person i would think destroying your gate would be more important i mean it is important like if you destroy the gate that limits drastically the spawning or the spawning especially because there's only three regular gates in in your deck and there's they're very much weaker so yeah if you if you pummel into the main gate this just gets destroyed and there's no way to go out and get it back so i'm left with literally what i have on the board as well as hoping to draw those gates yeah and then wait till my next build phase to bring it out which then i have to wait till my next summon phase to start summoning from it uh but yeah uh this
it plays very well uh the mana system or uh magic generation system works really well uh simple kill a thing get mana for it uh you it's very clearly cut out how your game is supposed to go on your turn uh the factions so far have seemed real different yeah that's spawning around gates uh the units feel very unique other than like the ways that they attack because it's either ranged or melee yeah um and then like your guys have to deal with buffing one another mine for like if i kill a thing i can teleport essentially and transfer souls uh i can deal damage to myself to resurrect stuff um they it's very nice i like the placement of the grid that half yours this half's mine yeah and then like you can only put a gate in the first uh back three or around your champion yep um game's very solid yeah what's interesting is because what what a lot of people loved about summoner wars was its actual price point a lot of skirmish games which is exactly what this is which i use skirmish games i usually don't go for because they're either extremely fiddly or it never really seems like a i don't know it's weird because it's like i just never i never get anything
out of it there's never any depth to them for me um but they also are expensive because they're miniatures oh yeah and with this one it's the only game that i'm aware of that actually uses cards as your unit yeah i was looking around you don't have the game rage anymore i don't think ray it was no it was rage i thought rage was uh it came with miniatures or pre-built really really detailed miniatures uh the about from the from the graphic novel like the really brutal graphic novel about like mother earth being like raped and it was like this apocalypse like post-apocalypse ah i can't have it was like a really i never pig i didn't get like like with like chain mail on it yes hate hate hate not rage i mean there's synonyms there uh but yeah i don't know how much that game costs but i mean it was pretty expensive and also it was boring like that's the thing but here because of the uniqueness of the the faction abilities and how you actually get combos off one another placement matters maneuvering matters how you're going to attack matters because it's like you can either all focus on one to try and weaken the champion and hope you kill it because but you're only gonna gain one magic uh for that or you can try and whittle down the rest of them because
to try and gain more magic because that's uh that's gonna be more that you can do on your turn yes um i also i do like that because it's also kind of a risk reward you can either have one champion in your hand like i had uh meeting mumboy who cost eight and just sit on do you just it's like okay i'm gonna try and kill two of yours i'm gonna burn four cards for my hand just to get four magic and just so i can on my next turn play him um what's interesting is that because it's a skirmish game we just played their their other game ashes and we were talking about how like you have your turn and i have my turn and there's no interaction really between the two um it works here though because it would be really annoying if you spent like the whole game saving up for eight mana and then it's like oh i'm actually gonna cancel that uh i think the key difference is like that's a deck building card game yeah where this is i'm i don't know if you can deck building this but like uh well even customization yeah even the deck building part you still have a grid right and you have to abide by the grid yeah so uh this mitigates a lot of like oh well i intangibly i'm just gonna attack you with these three things from however far [ __ ] away i am exactly and then i'm gonna block with x amount of so-and-so's so this grid mitigates all of that right where that's why this works and the other one doesn't yeah yeah this one i'm i'm actually just
floored because whenever this was mentioned that they're making a second dish my friend who like the first edition was telling me about it and i'm like [ __ ] that like the eye there's no way i'm gonna get it and then i tried the the demo and you're like i guess i'm like all right i'm like that wasn't as agonizing and the the big key difference here is these custom dice yeah these were real nice like you're almost always gonna hit and that's rewarding it at least once because they seem pretty uh there is only one miss for melee and i think the the uh the um one miss for range two is there one two two oh there is two misses okay four yeah so you have a uh two and three chance to hit or 66 percent yeah 66 percent chance to hit with range yeah and then a was it five out of six yeah uh so 90 something percent yeah uh to hit with melee and what they did is they rebalanced the actual like common units like uh some of them actually have um more health to kind of keep them around to compensate for the fact that you're most likely gonna hit but it's rewarding even if you don't kill it then at least you hit it besides constantly missing uh i noticed the leveling between like so for instance both of our archers have three attack power which is a lot
yeah but to mitigate that my archers uh they have three attack power f2 health yeah so the likelihood of them dying still very high right it's an extremely quick skirmish game oh yeah almost borderlines on filler because of just how quickly uh your units died yeah but that's good because that means that you're gonna be generating magic to be able to do something cool in your next turn and it works for both sides yes um i like that a lot of the wording especially for this deck says just a unit it doesn't say enemy units isn't say friendly units it just says units yeah which that in most games if your anything dies and it triggers something it's pretty nuts yeah that it gets to do that yeah there's also some pretty good strategy with the gates is if uh because typically in my experience with the first edition is you just kind of wanted to turtle up with your summoner you never really wanted to do anything with them um but i mean you're the goblins want to like he just wants to have his zero rush and then be like oh no it's me and then he hits him and then he backs out again uh she wanted to she was interesting because she could hit for a [ __ ] on the damage from range um but she didn't have as much health but she was kind of maneuvering around to boost all her other units to make them stronger um and then he was all about taking some damage to
res it could be anyone if i killed your champion you'd be like oh two damage he's back he's back and it's like took forever to kill him and then also like i could go to discard discard my champions and then the next turn pay to life and just summon them oh my god i didn't even think you could do that yeah that's true you discard them to get magic and then boom that's why you you were like i didn't draw any of my champions and i was like yeah they're kind of expensive and you're just like not for me there are only two life that's why i was like think of that yeah yeah whenever i was like okay what's he do oh graveyard recursion that's broken somehow and then i was like oh i can't discard you all right i'm just gonna discard my uh but they were all six yeah yeah you have three champions 666 yeah that's that's interesting because i'm over here saving up eight magic like an idiot and then you're just like uh i have one i'm gonna two life yeah i'm gonna just stab my heart real quick and then he shows up and it's like oh because like my champions were nuts because it's also really cool because your decks aren't um they're not super thin because once you run out you're out and you're left with whatever you've got um which that is brutal but they're also not um super thick that you're most likely going to be able to get what you want especially because you don't you can willingly discard down and to try and search for that particular card um and i also like the fact that you're
not you're not limited i mean you're limited on how many units can move and how many units you can attack with but there's ways around that like the goblins once again um they have relentless so it's like okay we have these other ones i'm gonna pick for my three and then these three other relentless goblins are gonna attack so now i'm attacking with six units and it's like uh yeah the uh like okay so my best one in my opinion is like elute ball it's six mana six health six attack dice but it says summoned by fire if i paid the cost so if i paid the six i could destroy a unit and then he comes in with whatever unit i just destroyed so i just play him wherever oh interesting uh this one has life drain uh i can destroy a friendly unit within two spaces of wherever he's attacking and then all the lightning bolts on a dice count as a hit oh ew and then ray so is there he's melee yeah so there are okay there's there's only one result on this die that would be two hits yeah which is still nasty and then no actually you would you would never miss yeah you can't miss uh and then this guy says for each damage on him he gets an extra strength and he has eight health health is there a max on that uh i mean up until he dies so he could be at one because like some some of mine said max five so oh no so he could he could get like nine seven i'm gonna take nine dice and
just roll that's all of them i think well i'll go over my champions that now look like [ __ ] compared to those monsters it's a good thing you never drew them yeah so we all saw mit mitwi mumway mini mumway he just has 11 health it's uh what's his name um tree beard he's an e yeah yeah yeah uh yep he has imbued strength uh this he gets plus some strength for each boost on iconic trample uh dealing damage he can just run through common units which is real nifty it it worked out i mean i honestly the only reason i did right he's just like but it was uh i i honestly the only reason i did as well as i i did was i had the perfect event combo where it's like i had enough to summon him next to the rhino and then i had the other one that swapped that they gave each other their powers yeah uh but then i have uh mccain da roo she has uh nine health prepare so she's literally like the um border archers instead of moving this unit you can boost it once per turn after the cena attacks you may spend one boost to resolve an attack with it so literally it's just the same thing except she has five extra health and then i have a lion nice uh i just realized hold on let me go over my champion okay i didn't interrupt you know metis uh inspire after this unit moves boost each friendly adjacent unit
um and withdraw after this unit attacks you may either you may spend either one boost or one magic if you do force this unit one or two spaces so he can get in boost everyone then get out that's pretty good now there's nasty but all my characters basically boost each other he's he's not as good as i thought it it specifically says undead it has to have undead on the card oh no undead okay i was like ew uh for two life but still like six magic is uh it's pretty low that is pretty low uh it's not impossible to get up to six especially if you have like two of them in your hand you just because he can just summon you'll almost always have units you could save up and be like okay i have 12 now boom these guys are here so uh so yeah i i'm super excited i have seen i don't remember who it was in the [ __ ] demo i know for a fact it was the goblins but i can't remember if it was the clerics it was one of the the it was i know it wasn't the elves it was either her it was one of the female leaders there's like three there's four females actually here so i don't remember but i've seen another one played then we then we've uh the elves and then the got and then the undead now so it's one of the blue ones but yeah also they do plan i don't think you can do it outside of the base game from what i understand from what i was told you can't deck construct yet however you're getting there you can
construct your own summoner decks by mixing cards from different faction decks to construct a custom you have to have a summoner 110 life gate three it gives you basically a list you can do two starting units so of your summoner you have to have the two epic events and then six standard events three champion units and 16 common units each unit and event in your deck must have at least one deck symbol so like these right here um they have to match so you can only build with her units that have those three symbols i see kind of like in commander you can only use colors sure of your commander yeah i i like deck construction that's limiting like that otherwise i think it's too wide open yeah it's too ambiguous yeah that's why i like commander so much because you pick a commander and you build off of that you have to pick from the colors yeah listed um and the theme and the theme so i like that because summoner wars it would be if it was just like oh pick a summoner and deconstruct here's all the cards it's like i don't wanna i don't wanna do that i don't have the time uh yes plaid hat games this uh really really impressive for the record guardians is also plaid hat oh well guardians is also a very good game right so typically does does solid um solid 1v1 this has been one of their staples for a very long time um yes this is far better than uh the other game do you have any negatives um i mean you could always say i mean a negative for a lot of people could still
be dice but these dice are way [ __ ] better uh the gates make sense actually because the other ones you you in first edition you had like i said walls and you summoned from your walls and it didn't make any thematic sense but here it's like yeah we're going to pull up a gate and then you know run through run through that to fight each other you could also people could say oh you didn't say you didn't get any champions so that's why uh i guess my two biggest things are card advantage but like you get the discard and then draw that many you'll always have at least five yeah i can't by i guess my biggest negative and this is gonna sound real petty it's that your cards are sideways it is very weird to be like oh time to draw oh now i have to weirdly hold these yeah uh yeah i kept doing it like i was holding my cards like this yeah um it's extremely strange um that's really all i got this game is very solid yeah to counteract the fact it's like yes i happen to draw champions and you didn't or whatever example you want to give for for drawing cards the games are super short yeah i can't complain it's like okay yeah let's just quickly do it again uh i have no real negatives really what do you think of the art uh it's weird it's it's nice it's fun yeah
um it's not like grungy or gritty art it's very high fantasy colorful vibrant art cartoony yeah um it is really good it's fantastic art it's not like gritty realism or it's fanciful and it's that's kind of what they were going for and i think it matches really nicely yeah um artworks good the card structure is good i don't like that it's sideways but it makes sense obviously yeah i mean this is way better than if the grid was like this oh yeah by far just be odd at that point um but no it it works really well really really well um do you so before we score it do you remember what you gave the first one i didn't record the first one oh it was never on the channel um but for multiple top tens for multiple lists anytime some of their words was mentioned i always like i i [ __ ] i think i'm in the process of doing the top 50 worst games of all time and i'm pretty sure the first edition is somewhere on there so i would probably have to redo that list because i really like thinking back i mean i probably i really hated it um it probably would have been around the two or three wow like it it pissed me off uh with just how [ __ ] stupid it was um and i know there were a bunch of factions in there that ended up getting like really broken um because they had so many that were just never they just didn't really play test them
um so you're just hoping they so two three uh from the first edition uh this is way better than that yes oh yeah absolutely like this is one that i'm actually excited to get factions this is one that we could do a tournament for with more factions and i would be willing to do that right because i mean they're super quick you just oh okay now we have the elves going up against the hip them again we'll see for a rematch uh so because we do the tournament stuff now but i definitely want to get more factions out before we do that have like of course get them played yeah like if they by the time they get maybe 15 like 15 factions i think that'd be a good number for 15 or 16 yeah uh 16 be pretty good that's true uh you have two you know eight brackets yeah that's true and then it would go down to i think it was four then two then one yeah that'd actually be a pretty good uh pretty good tournament that way you wouldn't have buys and you can have like a tournament one with those out then like by the way yeah loser bracket right yeah so um i'm gonna give it a nine man it's right there with you it is this is a nine it no i would yeah just because it how much i hated the first one and it was just simple mechanisms of making it fast still deep gameplay and the uh and the dice like if you're gonna add randomness at least give it to where oh look at all the hits the odds of you
missing are very low like because you're not sitting there like oh god okay i just need to do two damage to that to that cultist wow i missed again i'm not gaining any magic nope it's it's like five and a six going for my i think that's what it was a one and three chance to ever hit yeah that's [ __ ] it was something it was something really really stupid i'm almost 100 positive it is it was a five or six to hit uh but like i said it's been like five years since i played it so it's like i'm not sitting here with like a visceral hate for first edition like i like i held on to it like a child uh but i remember really not liking it and for me to do basically a whole you know 180 on that yeah like oh okay yep that's fantastic four factions three times as good yeah um so yeah uh you got anything else cool you give it a nine right yeah cool it's a it's a nine out of ten the only reason i don't give it a a perfect score is because like it's just simplicity wise i can't see this being a 10 compared to other games i've gave attend sure no that's that's kind of where i'm at too like a 9 is still absolutely fantastic this game is superb i'm gonna i'm gonna dock at a point so it's not 10 because the insert sucks ass i oh i can't it's literally just it's it there's really not one wow if they came with a plastic one that you can put the uh um like at least put the decks in
there's not even that what's how much was this oh that's a good question um because i remember i pre-ordered it and it let's see i can i can find that for you real quick the summoner it was 50 50 yeah i'll dock it the the point from 10 for that right i wouldn't spend 50 for this uh uh i would i think i think the prices is dead on because you get six factions great artwork um i mean if this had minis it would be three hundred dollars that's so true so uh yeah and then i think that was also well actually it might have been 50 because i believe this is also on that same website the subscription service oh so which the subscription i think is free however it guarantees you get when they announce a new faction and it's getting released you get a chance you get no you they just charge you so you are guaranteed to get it i see um it is a fantastic service and i think they they did that with um they did it with ashes as well but yeah so that's why i'm gonna give it a nine but anyway that's our thoughts on summon the war second edition let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon
link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you