Stardew Valley: The Board Game | Solo Thoughts | Procedural farming adventures!
Transcript
hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I'm going to discuss stardo Valley the board game uh this is the second printing which I got a couple years ago uh and it sat on my shelf of Shame for a while uh so I finally decided to go ahead and pulled this uh out and and gave it a shot okay uh and let me go ahead and give you my perspective as to where I'm coming from with my review of this so uh I have played the video game uh but I only played it for a couple hours uh and it was both on mobile and on switch but I never played past a couple hours uh the game didn't really capture me uh as much as it did other people I like the idea of it uh I just would rather play other types of games personally but I like the idea of the game a lot and the the atmosphere and the Art of it is very chill so I did appreciate that a lot about it and uh in that realm of farming games uh or you know Animal Crossing style games that's the only game of its uh genre that I've played I've never played Animal Crossing or anything like that so uh what's been my experience so far so I played this uh solo okay and four times I played um four times I played uh one just with one character and one time I played uh controlling two characters okay and I've only won a total of two times okay uh so
I won using the two handed uh characters or you know controlling two boards and I also won one solo okay uh so now uh let's uh go ahead and and talk a bit about about an overview of the game okay uh so you are going to control up to four characters okay and uh you are going to have Grand Pass goals so the setup is pretty variable so one thing that I want to point out already is how variable the setup is which adds tons of replayability uh but uh there is uh Grand Pass goals okay so in order to win the game you have uh to complete four of Grand Pass goals that are uh drawn uh that are drawn randomly uh during setup okay uh so you need to complete all four uh and then you need to also complete all six Community Center Renovations okay uh so uh which which by the way uh there's um six types but each of them has a a various that are that can be uh added during setup okay so the bulletin board uh has um five different ones that you could draw from uh that uh each of them will ask you for different requirements to fulfill it okay uh so each of the community center uh rooms will uh or bundles will uh you know ask you for different things so incredibly uh variable during setup okay so yeah you need to complete all four Grandpa
goals and all six uh Community bundles okay and uh you're going to move around the map uh collecting resources from these seasonal uh tiles uh you're also going to be fishing okay from this fish track uh you're going to go through the season deck okay uh so the season deck is acts as your timer okay uh so you're going to have um Four Seasons to go through okay the seasons are uh made of normally of four cards each okay uh and there's a pretty uh uh substantial deck for each season which adds tons of replayability okay with a variability with that uh and yeah once you reach the end of winter the game ends okay um all right and you also when you finish a season you have to replace the seasonal tiles as well okay so it's like everything grows back okay uh so you have the three tiles all right which they all give you wood but then you also have these forageable tiles okay that will give you different resources okay when you flip them uh all right uh so uh you'll also be donating to the museum all right which will give you uh hearts and uh also making friends from the villagers deck okay so heart is a pretty important resource here because uh in order to reveal uh the community bundles which start phase down okay you don't know which resources you need to collect in order to complete your goals at the beginning uh so you need to use Hearts which you collect by making friends or
um by donating to the museum uh so you can make friends by going to uh this area here with your pond and uh you you're going to donate a resource uh of some kind to them and if their birthday happens to be in the same season you're in or if you give them one of their preferred resources you get extra Hearts but hearts are pretty precious here okay uh there's also another reason why you might want to get friends and that's because uh friends also give you these uh abilities that trigger when you flip certain season cards okay and they can give you pretty good advantages okay uh so typically it's a pretty good idea early on to acquire a couple of friends not only for their hearts but also to have some of these abilities if if you don't have any of these abilities uh you're going to miss out on uh on certain season cards uh you know triggering that um gift box okay uh and uh there's there's both good and bad things from the season deck sometimes you're going to have crows eating uh you know your uh your crops okay um but there's also event cards which most of them are positive okay uh so uh there is a lot of variables in this game okay as you can see so you're going to have um the option of uh you know placing your Pawn to do the action that's specified on the board and then move around uh so you can do two actions in the same on your turn two actions in the same space or one action in that space and then move between spaces okay uh and then
flip so you basically collect those tiles just from moving between locations right you're going to also be exploring the mine uh so you roll these dice uh these dice are used to uh for the fishing purposes okay uh and uh they're also used for exploring the mine all right uh and the mine will give you uh geod for uh upgrading your uh tool which you pick up uh at the beginning okay so you have a tool that you can uh in you know improve all right for your profession uh and then you also have Pro uh the profession board that you pick at the beginning where uh you're able to gain upgrades for your profession which will give you advantages and you'll be better at doing things okay there's also these um bags that come with the game where uh there's one for fishing okay so every time that you fish something out of the fish truck you renew it uh you know you refresh it or refill it with uh fish from this bag and then there's also this bag where you draw minerals and artifacts okay so when you're instructed to draw either you know you just draw a token and if you were instructed to draw a mineral uh you know you get the mineral side if you're were instructed to draw the artifact side you pick the artifact side and you put it in your inventory and as I mentioned these go to the museum I mean you can sell them or give them to friends when you're trying to make friends with villagers but you can also donate them to the museum for hearts which again is a pretty important uh resource okay you also have this um
uh this joa um tiles that you might randomly draw due to a season card that will block your spaces and sometimes it'll outright block them like you're not allowed to fish here or they'll restrict them okay like when buying seeds for your crops with that one uh you can't buy more than one okay so this will uh add some obstacles and sometimes there'll be duts and that's fine just that just comes with the uh with how random the game is uh and you know if you draw one of these and it's a dud that you know you're going to pray hope that every time you draw one of this that it's not really going to um you know uh interrupt or getting your plans so uh this game has definitely has many there's many things going on here okay uh but yeah so that's a bit of an overview all right uh so there's no scoring it's a hard uh win or lose condition uh so that's one of the uh first things I want to comment on okay now that I've given you the overview all right so um this having the farming theme uh many people might expect that is going to be some kind of very tight uh efficiency uh Euro all right and uh it really is not because there's just a lot of luck here now that doesn't mean that it's not fun okay and I'll get to that part all right uh but in a second but uh there are way too many variables in this game in order to um
to uh get too attached to a strategy early on you kind of have to adapt as you go now there's a lot of luck uh and it it can be good or bad okay there's not a whole lot of lock mitigation but lock can sometimes give you some powerful um um bounds all right sometimes you might draw an item that uh combination or at a very opportune time that will really give you an edge okay and give you that push that you need in order to complete your objectives uh sometimes you might also flip one of these okay and it might give you an artifact or a mineral which are important for the Museum or for certain goals okay and and sometimes when fishing you might get a uh legendary fish all right and those sell pretty expensive and they can be used to complete goals so there are good aspects of the lock here okay and it can feel pretty great when you do get the die roll that you want or you draw an an item or a friend that gives you a um you know a a powerful ability all right now uh so yeah as a now the the downside of that though is yeah uh this game is not very um you know strategic per se uh I really want to invite you if if you're going to approach this game in my opinion I think that in order to enjoy it you're going to have to look at it as a um as a sort of um pseudo uh farming Adventure generator if
you if you will if you will like a procedurally generated farming adventure and once I look at it like that uh I have been having a good time with this game okay initially I there's a couple of things that threw me off initially one uh when you play with just one character uh it might feel a bit punishing okay and a bit swingy for sure um but as I played more uh I and I got the nuances of the game I got better and closer to completing the goals the game does scale uh so goals will require you to collect certain uh things based on player count okay uh so one of these uh crafts um rooms bundles might uh require you to uh pick up a forageable okay which are these tiles okay um and if uh you're just one player you only need to collect one but if you're two players you need to collect two so playing with um playing with more than two players doesn't help you in in every front it does help you in some fronts and I would say that overall when I played two-handed I did feel more advantageous okay um and I did win that game okay playing two-handed but uh I'm going to be honest with you I did not enjoy although I did feel like I had a bit more power uh to um mitigate the lock and and I was able to have more options against the the amount of luck in the game um I did not enjoy controlling two
characters uh there's a certain level of coordination that you need uh here U that it's strange I I am used to controlling multiple characters in many games but this one with its worker placement element where which is pretty flexible by the way you're able to uh when you place a worker uh you your Pawn to do actions you can uh you can CH there's a planning phase where you decide what you're about to do but then when you start taking your actions you can you know change your mind uh so that you know that gives you these branches of what you could possibly do so when you when you're doing that with multiple professions um I don't know uh that kind of gave me a mental load that I'm not used to and also the fact that certain um certain seasonal cards uh instruct you to change the player order so when you add the variable player order to the variable turn element uh it it makes it hard to it makes it a bit tough to plan it ET turn uh and I did not enjoy the mental load of that so I went back to just playing just with one um just with one uh character after that uh but if you don't mind the the uh controlling multiple characters you'll definitely find a much uh you'll definitely have a better chance all right at completing the goals but again keep in mind you do have to in general do double everything okay you're going to have to uh not goal
though but a lot of goals will require to do double everything so there's a goal that will require you to uh uh you know have certain amount of buildings uh and you know if you're two players you're going to have to make two buildings uh have a certain amount of animals in your uh barn or or or or coup so you're going to have to have double the amount of animals so it does scale in that regard uh but it I think one of the biggest things in playing with two characters though is the inventory management this can feel pretty restraining early on all right uh not having that much room uh to place your things this this can be early on learning how to manage this inventory can be tough just having the six slots for um you know uh resources and then only two slots for items it can feel very restraining all right but you kind of uh you you learn how to work with it just controlling one character but one of the most liberating things for sure was when I controlled two characters having more uh having more of these inventory uh spaces for resources helped a lot okay but uh even then I think the mental load was not worth it so yeah I still personally I just prefer playing this uh just with one uh character all right a little commentary on the rules so uh I did not find this game particularly hard to learn uh I think just with one rule book read I got it for the most part there were a there were a couple things that I overlooked initially one that was very
important for example which was the fact that um you are able to sell things at the end of most seasons uh so uh this if you draw this icon during the the season uh during the season card if you draw a season card and you see this at the end you're able to just sell whatever you have any amount of items you want from your uh backpack right but uh I didn't pick that up initially and I thought that I had to go to this um to this um uh location in order to sell things every time and that made it impossible the first time but uh for the most part uh that uh that there were a couple other things in there but for the most part rule book's fine one or just within a couple reads you'll be fine uh PR it's a very unique game there's lots of systems that are connected okay so it wasn't too too bad uh to learn all right uh rule book uh I would I I didn't see any major issues so uh I I gave the rule book a thumbs up okay so now let's focus a bit more on summarizing the cons and Pros okay so I'm going to start with my cons uh first so um setup is a bit of a pain okay uh even with the insert that the game comes with okay which I do appreciate it really helps a lot but even with the insert um it it takes a bit uh it takes a bit to set this up even when you know what you're doing uh you know resetting the season deck and
the fish track the seasonal tiles the goals your character board your tool your profession all of that is just a pain reshuffling the decks is it's it takes a bit okay now when you know what once you know what you're doing I would say it takes about 10 minutes if it's just for you all right for solo uh about 10 minutes I would say okay uh but yeah so I'm not a fan of how much setup there there is uh with that the upside of that is how variable the game is okay which uh some people might see that as a con okay with how variable the game is no two games will be the same uh but yeah so that I'm not exactly thrilled of every time I have to reset this okay um now the other issue I have with this is the the scaling and the the solo mode okay the pure solo mode um I I like the the solo I like the gam playay but I I feel like the solo mode which just one character I feel like it's missing something um with two characters I felt that I had a better chance but I just did not feel like controlling two characters because of the planning and the the flow of the game with two characters I did not enjoy uh now it is perfectly it is playable not I shouldn't use the word perfectly play it's it's playable with one character um but I feel like it's I'm missing something in there I think one I mean to give you an example there were a few cards there are a few card Parts where you're you know you're missing out on some effects from
having interaction between two uh players all right so that's just one example right there but being able to divide and conquer and and and having different professions and all of that um there's definitely something that you're going to miss out on from just controlling one character the some of the uh goals here or combinations can be a bit tough okay uh the one of the infamous ones is the legendary fish uh Grandpa goal where uh you know you're you're supposed to just buy lock have a legendary fish come out of the fish bag and sometimes it might just not come out uh if you're very unlucky so no matter what you do no matter how much you fish and rotate the fish track it might never come out uh so there might be some scenarios that are just impossible to win okay uh just it's just uh the name of the game here with how variable some of these goals are there are ways of trying to mitigate that based on your profession okay if you pick a fishing profession uh that might help but yeah there there's going to be some setups here that are going to be kind of tough to work with from Jump Street and also another negative is that based on uh and I would say especially if you're playing just with one character based on what goals you draw there might be things in the game that you'll never get to do so for example if you're not uh if exploring the mine is not one of your goals there's very little reason why you would ever go explore a mine so it it lacks
that open-ended element um uh where you really can't waste uh actions um you really can't waste actions uh in this game okay so you if you know if if you don't have an incentive to go explore the mind you're not going to waste a turn ever doing that okay uh unless there's like a very specific circumstance that might arise later where you need a certain resource from the mine uh but uh for example this last game that I played for the last two seasons I completely neglected my crops just because I just didn't have time or money to go plant them and I was pretty close as you can see um I was pretty close and keep in mind that in this game I had I had horrendous luck okay I had horrendous luck early on even then I was pretty close I was only one goal away from both I was only only one level away from completing the explor the mine and only a hard away from completing the boiler or at least revealing the boiler room um The Boiler Room uh uh bundle but uh yeah so but I had to neglect certain uh mechanics of the game uh so yeah it you know it doesn't have um I wish that it was a bit more open-ended like if if you had a bit more free time uh where you could just go explore the mine for fun or something but you really can't you kind of have if you want to complete the goals you really have to stay focused especially if you're only
playing with one character and one other little nitpick is that I the the tile uh the tiles were a bit of a nightmare to remove from the tile boards uh the cutouts because they kept ripping okay it was it really was such a pain I had to remove them very carefully uh they were very poorly cut uh so I don't know if in more recent print printings they have fix this um but I hope they have cuz that was a pain uh none of the tiles that I removed were damaged Beyond repair or anything but they I really hope that they sort that out uh and the the card quality is all right uh component wise um uh I think I'm definitely going to SLE this haven't gotten around to doing it but I'm definitely going to SLE this and finally I think the biggest issue with the game uh is that um it doesn't really match the chill atmosphere from the original okay um I this I know this is supposed to be a relaxing um farm game um I'm not saying that it's a bad game I'll get to my positives in a second but this a relaxing game it ain't okay you're going to be under pressure cuz you know you have very little time to accomplish your tasks and it is a hard win or loss condition and you know my motivation to as I play it is to try to complete all of the goals okay so I don't want to meander I want to get to completing my goals and you're going to have some dead turns and it's
going to suck okay but there's also going to be some powerful effects that you're going to get from friends and and items and things like that it kind of balances itself uh for the most part with the the cool powerful effects versus the the dud turns all right so now I want to mention my positives okay so first I just want to say that I did enjoy this game ultimately uh one of the first things I want to uh point out is how gorgeous this game is I love the presentation uh the art is uh spectacular it has a I love the greens and and blues uh the character art is very cute I like it uh and I did play the game briefly but I think it does Justice to uh the look of the game um you know they did not go with the pixelated look obviously but uh it really does translate very well okay so I would say that uh presentation wise uh and not only the art the graphic design the font Choice it's very clear so 10 out of 10 on that front no problem there okay uh game play now here's where this is the most divisive element okay uh why some people just bounce this off of this game completely uh how variable it is how sometimes you feel like there's no choices or whatever you know could be true in some in in some turns or scenarios but hear me out I think that you just have to uh if you want to enjoy this game you have to come at it from a mentality that it it's to me the way
that I look at it it's almost like a farming Adventure almost okay uh that happens to also be pretty tough once I looked at it that way I have really enjoyed this and look there really isn't a game like this in my collection I can't think of a game that is like this okay I just when I look at it like that it's very unique okay it's it's like this procedurally um generated farming sandboxy situation okay that um I I do I do enjoy ultimately even if I lose that's fine okay uh I know that some people might be disappointed by how um futile it might feel towards the end of the seasons but um conversely I have read um testimonies of people playing this that they think that they're not going to win but then you know they pull it off in the last couple cards of the Season uh so it is complet it is perfectly winnable okay but yeah that luck it really can be swingy okay between what you draw with the goals and the roll of the dice it really can be but uh I enjoy games uh like a merit trash games and and games that have this High lock element and I know that you know for the the terministic uh Euro Enthusiast this might be radioactive I completely understand I respect that and I do like those types of more strategic games as well uh but you know when I look at it from this
this from that angle I've enjoyed this uh my biggest issues that I mentioned earlier uh definitely um could uh I think the biggest issue to me from the stuff that I mentioned I think is the setup uh the setup uh I wish it it took a bit less to set this up it's slightly fiddly uh but I can look past the other issues that I mentioned and I I have enjoyed this um and I really appreciate that this is not a beat your own score there's a hard win condition lots of these farming games it's all about or Euro games it's about picking collecting points this one isn't uh so uh it's just it's just very unique uh and I you know I have enjoyed it but I would say you know uh approach it with caution uh okay and you know do your research my that's my take on it I think this pretty unique even from someone who's not necessarily a fan of the ID that much of the IP that much uh and I have been I've been enjoying this I just love the procedural aspect of this and how variable it is love that it does sacrifice the some strategic depth as a result though all right so in conclusion uh I would suggest that you avoid this game if you don't like swingy games or games that are very random uh this might um you know give you the impression because of its farming theme and resource Gathering theme that it's a tightly uh designed machine it really
isn't uh it's extremely random and variable okay uh it does have a bit of a lengthy setup and the experience controlling one character uh your malage will very weighted Some people prefer playing it with two it's definitely easier playing it with two characters uh controlling it with just one character there's some elements that you're going to miss okay now on the uh upside of that though uh I think that this uh offers a pretty unique experience that it still is uh playable solo despite some of the elements that are um you know left behind by just picking one character it's still completely possible to to win okay and uh the no two games will ever be the same with how how much variables there are here between flipping the tiles when Gathering resources uh the different profession upgrades what villagers you're going to meet the item Deck The Epic item deck the events the mine map okay uh so the goals that you're going to draw early on which profession you pick uh and how the the season deck is going to be structured from the beginning it's going to be so different every time and it is going to be h a race okay this is not a relaxing game some people might find it relaxing uh and and I'm not saying that it's stressful I wouldn't go as far as saying it's stressful but it definitely is not a relaxing game like uh how
stardo Valley has that Fame uh but I think it's still an enjoyable a flawed but enjoyable game you know I'll I'll keep this in my collection very very unique uh title all right so I hope that helped to figure out if this title is for you or not and I want to thank you so much for watching if you have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section and if you enjoy this content make sure to like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next one