Skip to main content
Loading video...

Finspan - Board Game Review - Something Smells Fishy

Transcript 31:35

hi everyone I'm luk G and this is the broken me a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games but usually more the latter part we'll get on with the view in just a moment but first I just need to say a quick word from the sponsor as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want a supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are kender's got it Wings man mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually I hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it yeah you didn't think I was going to let this one escape from me did you know thanks to a fellow viewer who is a star champion I'm able to actually get a copy of this before it officially releases in the UK and give my full votes on it yes this isn't a speed review we're doing a full whammy for this so to put some cont context behind this this is effectively a wingspan spin-off so we've already done this before you can check out my last year review for worms span where I gave that one a seven I think it's more closer to a six by now and I like it but I had some problems with it it felt like wingspan with too many extra steps and a worse theme but that's debatable but the idea with this is that this is meant to be a lighter wingspan so it's changed it from birds to fish still keeping the whole realistic approach but this is meant to be a lighter version of the

game easier to get into less rules you know less complexity you know that all falls to be seen but what's what do I think of wingspan in general it's one of my favorite games ever I love wingspan and my wingspan copy has got is absent because it normally is on the Shelf I think I took it to the club last night but it's got all the expansions in it so it has got Europe it's got Oceana and it's got Asia in it I don't like every aspect of the expansions I mean flock mode can die in hell you know I don't really care about the extra one to two player mode they put in Asia because I tend play it with groups mainly and you know Oceana is kind of a must have in my opinion because I think you really want those revised player boards that allow you to balance the fre object the the three different uh powers that you have like food eggs and cards but also because it introduces the nectar resource which allows you to play more big birds so you end up playing more cards I've got it fully complete and I love it it is one of my favorite games it is 10 out of 10 territory so this already is kind of fighting an uphill struggle here but I don't expect this to replace Wings band just as I didn't expect worms band to replace Wings band the idea is is can you have both can they exist in their own right you know or you know are they is it better to just go back to the original wingspan so I'm going to look at this in detail pros and cons give my thoughts on the game in general but also I can't really review it in a vacuum I've got to compare it to wingspan I mean hell it says a wingspan game and the title is still dumb as bricks this whole thin span thing yeah

you remember the meme that were sent out for the stain it was kind of ridiculous but uh I have to just make that context very clear before I dive in so is this worth all the incredible hype that this got or are we just basically repeating worm span where it's kind of it exists but is unnecessary so bold strategy cotton let's see if it pays off for him so if you've played wingspan you've already played 90% of this game but allow me to explain nonetheless in this game you're basically building up a tableau of fish cards on your board which consists of three separate columns for the three main sort of diving actions that you've got the cards themselves come in all sorts of different unique shapes and sizes where they all follow the same iconography in which case they tell you the cost where they can go what size they are what victory points they are what onplay bonuses they give you or what game end or abilities they give you but the main thing is that they are all different unique types of fish we're talking everything from the tiny little uh let's say you find a nice small one here the the tiny little pikm seahorse to a short spine spur dog and I'm pretty pretty sure there's a big Atlantic shark in here somewhere you know we're talking small to big fish of all kinds on your turn you play six turns in a round and you have four rounds effectively four weeks as they call it in each turn you have a choice play a fish card or do one of the three diving actions playing a card literally just means paying a cost in the top left of the card and playing it there we go and typically this usually involves you spending cards or egg tokens or possibly even little fish tokens you know whatever is necessary some of these cards consume other fish

which simply means to overlap more on that a little bit later in the video but the idea with this is that after you've placed some of these cards down your alternative action can be to place a diver on the top of one of the columns and work your way down triggering all cards that come in between the top and the bottom of the board much like in wingspan when you went from left to right but there are a few little differences firstly you can play the cards here wherever you like really I mean yes you are restricted to what the card tells you it might tell you it has to be in a particular like Sunny zone or the Twilight Zone it might even tell you it has to be in a specific column but the idea is is that I don't need to fill the board up top to bottom I can fill it up in whatever order I like and so once I've got a few cards out here let's see a few nice cute little fishy fishy fishy fishy um the idea is is that when you activate the column you move down and once you get to a particular card you trigger any when activated bonuses on it so they appear in brown boxes for example this uh what it called skip tuna uh allows you to hatch an egg with all players so some of the these are interactive but not too many of them you work your way down to the very bottom of the board but at the very bottom there is a little extra bonus you have for your first diver that goes down there in addition to that the zones are broken up into as I said Sunny M I forget what they're called but uh you know free different zones and the idea is is that if you have a fish in that zone when you dive down you'll get a Zone bonus which is typically cards for the left one uh you know uh sorry making eggs for the middle one and hatching eggs for the right one but why exactly

are you doing with these eggs and little fish well the main thing is that once you've got an egg on the different fish they can hatch into little cute little fishies and the idea is is that with a particular uh symbol in the game you can move these fish and if you get three of them on the same space they turn into a school of fish this doubles their points value and they can't be broken up it's basically another way to score points at the end of each week you have a scoring tile that dictates uh where everybody gets a prize but whoever has the most gets an additional Point bonus if you flip over to side B you have these random ones that you can pick for the game but side a is basically pre-printed for you but it's not a first second third fourth it's literally who got the most they get a bonus otherwise get what you achieved simple as that once you get to the end of week four you activate any game end abilities on your fish and then you score the victory points which is essentially six points for scores of fish one point for various little fish tokens and eggs and consumed fish underneath and also the victory point value of your fish in general Whoever has the most is of course the winner of course not a lot to learn is there at least from an overview standpoint it's definitely a simple game to learn though but there is a good and a bad side to this we'll touch on the bad side to this later on but for the good part these aren't the most complicated rules for somebody who is a gamer or somebody who has had experience with wingspan the rule book is not particularly thick there's iconography guides on the back and supplemented for each player which is nice it tells you the anatomy of a

card and what all the icons in the game are pretty handy and I respect the fact that they do this for each player I keep banging on about this but the rules are not particularly plentiful I mean there's a reasonable amount of text I might have liked a few more pictorial examples but you there isn't a huge amount to learn in here and it's a simple game if you've played wingspan you can pretty much skim over the rule book and you'll get 90% of it down you just might miss one or two very little niche rules now and again but yeah when I was learning this it really didn't take that long and if you really want to go to next mile you if you've got the daed app di Zed there's even a tutorial for the game on that so you've got multiple ways to learn a game if you really want you know these are still pretty nice I mean they're all very different fish you know I I know very little about fish I know less about fish than I do about birds all I know is that I like to eat fish and on the Mediterranean diet it's kind of required but you know in general I mean all of these ones here a white spotted puffer a pennant coral fish a Mediterranean damsel fish they've all got such weird weird crazy name smooth Oreo Dory what so half of it is from Finding Nemo and half of it is a um chocolate biscuit confection it's like how does that work but you know all of these fish cards are nice to look at and everything is clean the graphic design is generally clean some people will trip up over a couple of the symbols on here but you have got the guide to read if necessary and you want to understand the little nuances with each but you know nothing feels cluttered or crowded the only slight negative is that you are squeezing quite a bit of information on these cards so you know certainly you know you you

you've got a lot on here I mean you got the title symbols you got the when play you you got the special bonuses you got the flavor text you got the fin size which is relevant victory points what zone it can go in what cost it has you know all of this is squeezed onto a horizontal card and it it can be a little bit like oh Christ especially when you got to look at like five of these in front of you maybe there's just a few too many there but it's it's not a big deal for anybody familiar to the wingspan games you're not really going to struggle with this we'll get on to the negative side if you're not a wingspan player though a little bit later short answer yes with an if long answer no with a butt if you're going into this expecting it to be a shorter game than wingspan then it kind of is shorter but not by a lot probably by the same length as one of these fishes thins to be honest it's it says 45 to 60 Minutes on the box and it will keep to sort of that you are probably looking at 60 Minutes to 90 minutes though when you're playing this with four to five players much the same as wingspan if you're only playing a solo or two to three players you can zoom through this game pretty quickly and it will beat out wingspan in that regard just don't expect for it to be like a 30 minute filler it just simply won't be 40 seconds but I want to know the game also comes with a solo mode and it's a pretty straightforward solo mode all around really I mean it basically stems down to flipping a card and depending whether it's a dive action or play a fish action you do what's required and the iconography is pretty straightforward I mean the rule book here is simpler than the other one there's not a lot of pages

at all and you got multiple ways to adjust the difficulty you've even got a variant in the game that allows you to basically sort of turn on what's called Ravel mode I think it's called Ravel and it forces you to be a bit more selective as to where you place your um fish cards because doing so at the wrong time could give the automa a lot of points and it's a good thing that this is not a like you know try and rank yourself game this is beat the aomar the AER doesn't have a playmat they just gain tokens and fish cards and spend them as necessary as per the cards they score points at the end of the game on certain criteria and you can adjust the difficulty to make them score a little more for certain things but you've got to beat the autometer that's basically it so it's good that this is not just beat your own score cuz that would be a little bit boring I approve that this is an autometer that is very easy to Pilot very easy to use and doesn't take up a lot of your time in fact you will actually end up at that 45 minute mark on the box easily if you're playing this solo it is nice and super quick this is why Superman works alone now in the good section I talked about how simple the game was to learn however that is from the perspective of someone who's played a lot of games before or has played wingspan and fully understands how that works if you're in that situation you'll blend over quite nicely but what this game isn't and I'm kind of disappointed that it's not is that this is not Gateway level wingspan it is lighter than wingspan but if you imagine that worms span is essentially wingspan with extra steps this is a essentially wingspan with less steps and it's not that much simpler than wingspan

you know worms span is not that much more complex than wingspan there's just more fiddly steps you have to jump through you know more Hoops you have to jump through to achieve all what you need to achieve but the rules aren't that much more complex in it well here same kind of deal you have less Hoops to jump through for certain things but the game is not that simple for someone who's not played games before who has not come across these wingspan games before yes I'd probably advise you teach this one to a brand new gamer before wingspan but honestly there's not a huge amount of difference the difference and complexity between the two is not as big a gap as it should have been if this could have been Gateway level wingspan that would have been fantastic it would have put it in the you know a good bit of the market it could have been something you could have introduced to brand new Gamers without any worry at all but one thing that Gateway games do not do well is when you have cards with unique abilities and icons this sort of thing just frows off brand new Gamers and I noticed because I have played this with multiple groups and the same thing happens those familiar with wingspan pick this up like no trouble those unfamiliar with wingspan but familiar with games take a little longer but they get the hang of it relatively quickly but there's usually at least one person there who's never played any of the wingspan games is not that much of a gamer and they're struggling they don't know necessarily what to do with the board you know what their main tactics should be and they have to spend quite a while going through the different cards trying to ascertain what's good and what's not it it can drag the game out

on that respect I mean I tell you if you play this with four or five you are looking at that you know 75 to 90 minute range for a game and that's basically comparable to wingspan at the same level I mean wingspan will probably be a little bit longer but yeah for a game that's meant to be lighter than wingspan you'd expect this to be done within 60 Minutes without any like Rhyme or Reason you know any no no excuses it should be done within 60 minutes and some of the times really isn't but you know I wanted this to be Gateway level I wanted you to be able to teach this game to just about anybody I can barely I tried teaching Wings band to my parents and they're in their 70s and they struggled to get it you know they struggled to get wings band fair enough I wouldn't be able to teach this to them either I don't think this is simple enough to we're not talking the Simplicity levels of something like Cascadia you know one of the best Gateway Games out there this is just a little bit lighter than wingspan and it needed to be more than just a little bit lighter to stand out what is it like in your fully little brains it must be so boring now the rest of the section is going to concentrate more on the changes from wingspan to finpan and it's in the bad section because for the most part they are worse than what they were before or they don't work quite as well as I hope they would firstly let's talk about the changes to the interaction level now wingspan was never that much of an interactive game in the first place you know you had a few powers that keyed off other players you know once between rounds but you kind of did your own thing but somebody might Nick the card that you were after expansions improved on this but still not to a great extent you know European was a particularly good one for that but

at the end of the day you have some powers that influence you know that influence multiple players and people could take your dice out of the feeder and such well here this game is pretty much devoid of all interaction bar a tiny little like tiny little single caviar fish egg worth of interaction and I do mean tiny this thing has basically a few cards a few and we're talking a small percentage of that deck that have all players if activated do this or something and they're not even usually that major Powers at the time but yeah there's not that many fish that affect all players most of the time they will affect just you and that is it there's no other interaction in this game there is no face up Tableau of cards you don't have food from a communal pool that you have to feed your your fish with you know your hand is your own you know your board is your own nobody can manipulate anything so the whole concept of this being up to five players well that was pointless if you play this solo you're basically playing a simplified two-player game which again might as well just play it solo but every time you add a player on all you do is add down time and more time to the game that's it there's no other reason to add more players why would you play this with five it's just entirely not necessary five is right out and W beti you if you try to fit that many boards on this table this vertical board is actually more problem than it's worth you know the photo you're about to see now this is not the biggest table in the world I will grant you but this is that game Cafe okay this is the table

designed to have small games on for four players or be ideal for two players head-to-head right I'm barely able to fit this game on that table yes it will fit on my massive gaming table fine but this is meant to be housing things like lurs not struggling with something like finin man and mainly it's just because of the shape of everything is weird because you've got to have like one board in front of you for yours and then you've got another board jutting practically in your face on the other player and then another board to your to the right of you or whatever going out in that direction so it's kind of like this weird Zig zipper zigzag thing of boards but then that doesn't lend well to where you've got to put the card display because that's got to be at least miles away from two players and really close to two others but then you've also got this achievement board you've got to fit somewhere and I honestly do not get why this is in the game but they actually state in the rule book your hand size or your hand is public information so you've got to have room for anywhere between zero to 10 cards at a time you could end up with it has happened in front of you good luck finding the space for that but also what is the freaking Point why this is going to be a game that's meant to be simpler than wingspan it's meant to be introducing people to the whole span series why would those people be looking at other players cards I can't influence what you have I can't deny you those cards you have so what does it matter with their public information it doesn't make any sense stupid it's stupid such a dumb idea and I don't get why nobody

pointed that out in the play testing side or in the proof reading but okay you've got your hand of cards fair enough you've got this one thing I do like is that they do give you a personal discard pile so if you discard cards as part of the cost they go into a personal discard and some effects in the game allow you to look for your discard pile and get one back that is a decent effect I do approve of this one although you're trying to make this easier for players to get to grips with adding more choices like that does not make this beginner player friendly I mean you're telling them that by the end of you know by like halfway through the game they've discarded Lord knows how many cards and now every time they get to look through their discard pile they get to look through Theus Board of cards trying to find one that is perfect for their situation yes some people could take their turn while you're doing this and I do recommend you do it that way but again it's forcing the beginner player to look at a ton of information that's just going to overwhelm them they won't know which one to pick you might as well just say draw the top card of your discard pile and make it simpler but it's you know some of these things kind of detract from what I think the game was aiming to do stupid it's stupid so now consuming fish consuming fish is basically tucked cards every card underneath a fish is worth one point so in order to consume a fish it's essentially the case that you've got a fish whether it's pre-printed or other and the fish will go on top and the one below it is effectively out of the game but it's worth a point there is only one time you really need to do that though and that is when the fish card requires you to consume a fish you know some of

the larger ones specifically having a cost consume a fish right put it on top of a fish it's a predator fish it makes sense the one below is worth a point so you probably want to stick it on top of a fish that's only worth one point because then you lose a point but then gain a point so it's not much of a difference there's no incentive though to do that at any other time because you've got all the spaces in the world you're not restricted as to where you know how far down the columns you can go other than what's on the card so why not just play your fish in the spaces that you have you might as well fill up your entire board before you consume any fish there's no reason to there's no penalty for having your spaces filled there's no blockage or anything like that so what does it really matter it just feels like an arbitary mechanic that's thrown into the game but it only applies as the cost of certain cards and the fact that they reward you points for it just I don't know was that just a balancing tool but for a mechanic that's essentially like what tucked cards used to be tuck cards was actually a valid strategy in wingspan here it's just an arbitrary thing that's bolted on to a a cost mechanic in order to justify why you might play those fish well you got me by all accounts it doesn't make sense you've got the achievement board for side a and side b side a is good if you just want to teach the game and side B at least allows you a little bit of variety with these tokens but there's not a lot of variation in the scoring tiles you have I mean most of them are basically to do with young fish or schools uh they're to do with the size of the th size so small medium or large fish and how many eggs you

might have and occasionally there's a couple for tags and you know little abilities so there's some here but they're not like crazy amount in terms of variety but it is good that on side B you can at least have a little bit of variety in how they score but ignore these at your peril because honestly this is kind kind of your bulk of your points you know they come from two sources the cards that you place down and the achievements and some of these achievements can be Bonkers powerful for example in one game we played the other day we had uh the large fish on week one two points per large fish it is not easy to play large fish in your in your Tableau so people are barely getting two Four Points by the end of week one for that then the second week was three points for young fish uh it's definitely an there somewhere I definitely had it yeah three points for every young fish you have that's Bonkers because in the second round basically nobody bothered to make schooles of fish and you're just littering yourself with a ton of these little fish tokens and we're scoring something like 30 points plus for this bit for this one objective compared to four in the previous one super easy barely an inconvenience but despite those other negatives I've said which at the end of the day each one is kind of a small negative that add up they're not like individually major negatives the main thing I grew up from this game is kind of like a sense of mediocris it doesn't feel as impactful or as fun as original wingspan does you know when you play wingspan you've got a lot of these different abilities on those cards and

you can go for like the predator birds you can go for the tuck cards you can go for loads of eggs you can do uh you know card drawing strategies you can do like heavy food strategies and stuff and this you know the expansions help even more now granted the expansions are a separate thing you know we need to kind compare also not just wingspan with expansions to this but also wingspan basic to this but even the basic game of wingspan gives you a little bit more variety in what you can do compared to this one this one pretty much pigeon holes you into doing you know other than the massive achievement TS now and again your whole what you do on your board is basically draw a bunch of cards play some fish lay some eggs hatch them and move these things into the same Zone to make schools of fish that's pretty much what you do for the entire game and that gets a little repetitive even when you've effectively only got what 6 12 18 24 actions in the game you still feel a lot of the times like you know by the end of each round I've done four things and in the last two are like well I guess I'll draw more cards then um I've already done it three times already fine it's like I might as well just lay these eggs and probably spam them as well because that's all good it it doesn't feel as mean as interesting as what wingspan did and that's not to say it's bad or anything like that but I just by the time I'm three qus of the way through the game particularly if it's a game that's dragging out a little bit too long like you've got four or five players in there I I feel very much on the rinse repeat like the individual fish cards do not get me excited I'm more interested in Reading their flavor text and like commenting on their ridiculous names and their visuals than I am about what abilities they do or

what you know what victory points they we of or what their cost is that just seems to be you know the idea that this is wingspan with less steps I think hurts this because if you really enjoy wingspan I don't think you're going to get as much enjoyment out of this well that's a lot less hot so this verdict uh this will probably make a few enemies by the end of this but hear me out here Wings ban is shall we just accept the daddy of the three okay worms ban is Wings ban with too many extra steps and fiddly Hoops to jump through it's still a decent game I like it fine but it doesn't have the same Elegance or you know interesting interesting theme as wingspan does this one on its own Merit bio has some good aspects to it and is still a light simple game that still gives you a decent amount of fun but compared to what they did in wingspan wingspan is still the daddy of the free even if you don't factor in the expansions I think wingspan is still the daddy of the free but if you do factor in the expansions then wingspan kicks these two to the curb you know pretty much instantly so what is it about finpan that holds it back well I like its theme fish is cool you know I prefer Birds but fish is cool I like the fact it's about real life fish and you actually get to learn something from this it is still very aesthetically pleasing it's not as good as Wings band But Wings band's kind of top tier on that level this is still a nice goodlook game with a very nice colorful board and well produced cards and you know like enough that what you need it's also a simple game to learn

particularly if you've played wingspan before but it's not simple enough to be a Gateway game or to be new gamer friendly I think new Gamers will struggle to deal with a lot of the abilities on the cards and like the different mechanics that you're doing that it takes it certainly out of Gateway level and just makes it just a little bit lighter than wingspan but this game really needed to be a lot lighter than wingspan it removes all the interaction in the game yet introduces weird mechanics about having your hands public to everybody which has no relevance in the game whatsoever it's meant to be easier for players to learn but then it introduces the personal discard pile which as a gamer I think is a cool mechanic I think that is a great mechanic but then it just makes it harder for new Gamers to learn so the game doesn't really achieve the you know the the podium spot for a new gamer friendly version of wingspan I think I would still probably just teach the normal wingspan you know to be honest you know maybe this thin span never felt like it and with all said and done regardless of whether you agree with some of the mechanical changes that they've done this game is basically just Rings span with less steps on it and those steps being removed or tweaked make this not as enjoyable you know it's still fine it's still like oh yeah I can play this and I can get some enjoyment out of it but it's difficult to look at this in a vacuum if you do look at this in a vacuum then it's a decent you know it it sort of maybe goes up a point but when you've got to consider all three of them together this one feels like a

spin-off that a didn't really need to exist and B doesn't really satisfy the criteria of what I wanted a lighter spin-off to do this you know this just feels like an alternate to wingspan it's not wingspan 2.0 it's not even what I would call my first wingspan it's not light enough or simple enough to be that and when you go through these mechanics of you know playing the fish cards and moving the little fish tokens around and getting schools it gets a little repetitive and doesn't feel as interesting you don't feel like you've got Mega turns like compared to what Wings band does it feels like you're just doing a little bit at a time little bit of the time little bit of a time but you never feel like you reach the big leagues or anything like that so it's a DEC decent game and it has some merits a half know a nice easy solo mode as well but I think the rating for this has to be based on two factors if you are basing this on a game that's got to fit in the league of the three wingspan games if worms span is a six or seven at best and you know wingspan for me is a 9 10 out of 10 this one I think overall I don't know five sounds a bit harsh as an average game um no no I think I think five is average I think rather than do two ratings let's try and conglomerate them to together and try and think of this as his own game I'm giving this one a 6 out of 10 it's a 6 out of 10 above average it I was tempted to give it a five though and certainly if I'm comparing this to wingspan it might as well be a five you know it's fine and I enjoy it but I've

got no interest in keeping this I've got far better games that I can teach to new Gamers and if somebody wants to learn the wingspan type of games I'm going to get that wingspan I'll just show that because it honestly isn't that much more complex than this one you've got cards with unique abilities yes the wingspan ones are a little bit more interesting but they're not rocket science compared to the ones in here but you know having a strict side of left to right having specifically the food that works you know is a little bit easier to deal with than you know the movement around of eggs you know movement around of fish on these boards and the schools of fish which the rules for that were a little bit weird like why bother to move schools of fish around most of the time it you know it just it trips over itself with the tweaks that they've done and this feels more like it's not not really a cash grab but it just feels like it's like taking the easy route by utilizing what is already successful but not really creating something that stands out enough in its own right to be one that I would say yay everybody should grab this one or this will go on my shelf alongside wingspan this ain't going to sit in the collection any longer I think I might donate it to the cafe uh or let somebody else have it because I've got Wings man why would I need this there's always a bigger fish that's it for me on this episode of the broken meele if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on board game gek when he goes live on the page let me know your thoughts down below I'm sure there's going to be a lot of divisive opinions about this about fins span being the best of the three or my rating being too low some people giving it nine out of 10 whether they can teach it to New Gamers fine hey I'm going from experiences here

I play with a lot of people both veteran heavy Lura Gamers and new Gamers and I'm just talking from experiences that you know this is the way it's gone down so you know I'm sure there's going to be different people that have their thoughts on this and by all means get them in the comments let's hear it let's discuss but let's be civil about it obviously check out the patreon if you want to help support the channel financially but of course uh bear your own finances in mind but this channel runs as you know as a hobby so it needs to be funded and I thank the patrons who have supported me down to this day so take care and remember regardless of whether your preference is fish or Birds it's still only a game but seriously stonem can we cut this out now and try something new take care yeah

Progress saved