Great Plains Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about great planes which as you can see from the box is a strictly two-player board game designed by trevor benjamin and brett gilbert this one came out in 2021 and is published by lookout games and the game takes about 20 minutes to play so one of the main reasons i bought this game and i will say this is pretty much a blind buy is because of the designers and because of the company because the last game that that was uh designed by these designers was one of my favorite games of kind of well of recent memory ready with mandala so i was really excited to try the next game by then and to see how it played considering it's another two player only game so this one is very different to mandala where you have this modular board here made up of all these different um these different hexes and you know these are completely modular so in double sided you know they completely change from game to game so the ball state is going to be very different each time you play this one um you're going to have or the board is going to consist of kind of three different types of terrain so you've got these mountains here which are kind of just like territory which you can't really land on and can't do much with you've got these green tiles here these green hexes which correspond to these different tokens you can collect which can give you bonus powers throughout the game and you've got these yellow hexes here which are areas you're trying to control with your pieces because whoever controls the majority in those regions gets victory points depending on the number of hexes in there plus any of these water kind of streams in that region so for example this region would be worth one two three four five six points if i had the majority there each
player is going to have a bunch of their player pieces so you've got the blue snake player and you've got the fox player here and the first phase of the game is going to be very simple where you are in turn placing these cave tokens corresponding to your player color so you can see the blue player has choose chosen to place their case here here and here and the fox player has done there there and there and that's quite an important decision because it really does lay the foundation on how your strategy is going to go throughout the game so the person who played the last tile is going to be the first to place one of their tokens onto the board in the second phase which is essentially the main part of the game so when it comes to the second phase you have two options which is either to place a player piece on a an area adjacent to one of your caves so for example i could go here like this and then from then on in the future turns then i can maybe spawn off of where i already have a piece so i can go here for example but of course this will be being done in alternative order so it's going to go the snake player then the fox player then the snake player and the fox player and so on until until all the pieces have been used so of course we are trying to deploy these pieces onto the board to control these areas but let's talk about why you might want to venture on to these different green hexes here with these different animal symbols on so whenever you deploy one of your tokens onto one of these animal symbols you are going to take the corresponding token from the supply if there is one and that means on future turns you can choose to use these to do different things so they're all pretty
simple in what they do so let's start with the horse token so on your turn if you have a horse token you can choose to put it back in to the supply to skip over a space so you can basically move two spaces at once like that for example and that can actually allow you to skip through other players so if another person was there you can actually run through them in order to maybe try and claim territory which hasn't been claimed yet so that's very simple the horse that's the horse symbol the bird symbol allows you to basically fly over a mountain so if i got rid of one of these um bird tokens on my turn then i can choose to fly over that hex and go straight into this one but it has to go directly over one of those mountains and again that can be used strategically to jump into new areas that haven't been claimed yet to maybe jump in block people off etc so you can probably imagine what they can be used for the benefit for and the final token is the bear token and this is what really does inject a lot of confrontation into this game because this actually allows you to push players from certain spots or even potentially kill that piece um should the right situation arise so let's just say for example here the uh the fox player played this um this bear token then they can actually choose to deploy a piece and onto this space and push it back into that area like such now that obviously is good for trying to fight back territory etc but it did have to have an empty space behind it because if i was to maybe use a bear token again because there is a piece here then i couldn't actually use that however if i
would say here and i use the bear token i can actually push him off the board and eliminate that player piece and the same applies for the mountains so again if there is a player base here and i and i played a bear token i can choose to push him into the mountain crushing him and then killing him so that is really where a lot of the player interaction comes in and how you're going to start claiming back territory that you think is already lost so at the end of the game the board is going to look something like this where every piece has been deployed onto the board and then meadow by meadow you're going to calculate points so you can see here that the blue player has claimed three points for controlling this meadow uh two points for controlling this one because again one for the hex and one for the water on that hex the fox player's got three points for this one um if there's ever a tie is in terms of you know one piece here controlled by the fox and one controlled by the snake then actually nobody is going to get those points so they're going to cancel each other out all the pieces on these dark dark pieces or the um the token pieces are going to be worth nothing so they're completely just used to collect tokens throughout the game and not going to affect scoring at all and of course the player with the most points at the end of the game is going to be the winner so as you can tell from the demo that this is a pretty straightforward game so it's not going to be a tremendous amount of info i can give in terms of reviewing this game um however you might be familiar with a lot of the mechanisms here so it almost reminds me of one of those classic rhinocannicia root building style games made famous by
games like babylonia or through the desert um lots of different games samurai all these kind of traditional iranian canadian games this one does share a lot of dna with those star games however this one is of course strictly two players and i do quite like how simple this game is because this does have a certain degree of elegance to it very simple rules first phase deploying the cave second phase just either expanding from where you already are or spawning out from one of your existing caves so i do quite like the way that works it's certainly an easy teach you're not going to have a lot of room to kind of misconstrue the rules here um however i do think the actual player of the actual story the us special power tokens do add just a little bit of spice into the game to keep things interesting and to keep me more flexible and what you can actually do so particularly i do like these eagle tokens you can really capitalize on those and jump into some spaces you know for example if you were here and you could just completely just spend one of those tokens just to jump in there to not waste any movement and not to waste any pieces because even though it might seem like you have a lot of these pieces they do get gobbled up quite quickly and using them efficiently is quite taxing because you do really want to balance out claiming those points and of course claiming the tokens in the first place in order to get the most out of them so it does have that quite cool balancing act and that kind of sacrifice in in claiming the powers in terms of claiming points so very clean mechanically very simple to calculate scores etc but the actual pieces do add quite a lot of interest in though is it just going to make you just spawn across the board quicker but
i suppose the the main kind of polarizing factor in this game for me is these is these bear tokens so of course this is what makes the game more confrontational than anything else because it does it does mean that even though you've secured something or at least you've claimed something it doesn't mean it's secure from being stolen from another player now generally i don't really like confrontational games but this one it's no issue at all so don't be put off if you think it's going to be too confrontational for you it's not the case it's very simple and it's pretty much an abstract game so even though it might feel a little bit nasty at times it's two players and you're not you don't feel like you're being picked on and to be honest if they claim one of those bad tokens in the first place it means that they actually sacrificed a pawn in a formal turn to claim one of those better tokens anyway so you know it really is swings and roundabouts and it is a kind of a push and pull style thing on what you're going to do and what you're going to use these pawns for the allocation of these cave tiles can actually have quite a big impact on the game and i think maybe sometimes before you're even out of the gates you can have actually realized that you haven't really given yourself a good chance of winning um simply because of that however of course you can kind of fight or make ways around it based on the tokens etc to make yourself more flexible but i do think that good deployment is very important in the initial stages but of course that's to be expected um however the the time investment and etcetera for the game is is very good and this is an ultra quick game it does take 15 to 20 minutes to play um you can teach this game in 30 seconds and the actual turn times is lightning quick you are simply just putting a
token onto the board and um and going from there so it's just one placement one placement and back and forth back and forth and there really isn't much scope to lose interest there's going to be next to no ap in this game you know even though you are thinking about what you're going to do next and try not to waste your turns it certainly doesn't have that much scope to be bogged down and to get bored when it's not your turn i think this is a nice production i think the visuals are pretty damn solid to be honest in terms of how the clarity of the board you can clearly see where the mountains are you can clearly see where the caves are and the kind of the different terrains here so obviously the yellows are your point scoring and the dark green ones are your token scoring it's very easy to see everything visually and what it does additionally the actual meeples themselves are high quality these are all um they're different you know the snake players it's clearly snakes and the fox player are clearly foxes so i quite like the effort there and they're not just cubes etc so it has a nice simple strip back production but one that works well and it really does encourage modularity and variability game upon game you know sometimes you're going to have big areas here like this one and sometimes it's going to be a bit more choppy and all over the place and the tokens here as well they're all high quality and i do like how the fact these are actually limited so if they've been taken by the players and someone does land on one of those bird tokens you actually haven't got the opportunity to stockpile up on those so just these little things are quite well thought out of quite quite well thought of and it's quite stripped back quite simplistic but it does work well for the type of game that it is so overall i have to be honest i'm a
little bit underwhelmed with great planes which is a bit of a shame and i suppose a lot of that illness is on me because i did kind of blind by this one simply because of those designers and publishers um because i i just loved mandala that much so i think it was a bit of a victim to that which isn't the game's fault so this one is much more of an introductory style game it doesn't quite have the nuance that a game like mandala does however i think there is a bit more here than meets the eye in terms of you know what you're going to prioritize and things and how you're going to use these workers but ultimately i think it's been done better before in those kinetic designs i would rather play a game like this at that three or four player account and play one of those quenching games rather than play um you know great planes at two players um however i will say that this game does do a great job of keeping things moving it's extremely fast and it really does fit that 15 to 20 minute time frame which is is a great tool to be used as a filler literally a filler waiting for that next player to arrive at your game's night so i've already used it for that circumstance so i do think it's a good go-to because you can actually teach this one in in less than a minute but ultimately it just isn't it isn't great it doesn't stand out amongst the pack it feels quite generic and it just didn't quite have the magic for me so unfortunately this is going to be a past me i can't really recommend it despite it being mechanically sound yeah there's nothing wrong with this game at all it just didn't have that extra punch and that extra level of enjoyment that i'm looking for and that level of uniqueness which um keeps me interested so unfortunately this is going to be
leaving the collection and it's not going to be something i'm going to play much more of so that's the great planes thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time