Banner Festival - Board Game Review - NOT a Tidal Blades Expansion!
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kiander stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so on today's episode in a fairly stormy Blustery Day we're taking a look at tidal blades at Banner Festival now first up let's get the elephant in the room out of the way first this is not an expansion to Tidal blades I've never played tidal blades I don't know if I would like the game or not I don't hear that many people talk about it but this is purely a separate spin-off game in the same universe so same style of artwork so same setting same location that's it they've got nothing else in common everybody got that so in Banner Festival you are Merchants trying to compete for the best sales in the various quadrants during the festival itself get the most profit year win and the idea is is that you're
essentially playing a trick taking game with a twist with these cards now first you move your quadrant to a spot four space up to four spaces away and the color of the quadrant means something now it's color it's colorful yes but there is iconography on the cards and on the board itself to distinguish for color blindness it's not perfect I mean these bit this bit around the middle ring doesn't seem very good for color blindness but the other icons and certainly the cards themselves do have an icon to differentiate color so colorblind people can play this game but once you've moved it everybody then plays one of these merchandise cards from their hand they'll be dealt so many at random at the start of around and they'll play it face down and then everybody will simultaneously reveal the card so let's say I've got a few cards out here here we go let's say we're doing four players and these are the four to get done so a nine blue and eight blue and nine purple and a three yellow whatever so what happens is that you then evaluate using a very nice little reference card that you got here who had the highest trick who had the lowest and who was in the middle the highest trick gets to move their little speed boat which is essentially a race that's going on around the rain and the more times they do laps the more times they get to flip cards off their deck which basically is profit earned from the race itself I'm not entirely certain what the Thematic reasoning is I think it's maybe that you've just got better players or you made a bet on the race before you started this game and it's just how much it pays out I don't know but basically the highest trick gets to move that many spaces around the board
it coaches up to the gate now the person who got the lowest trick gets to trigger the special ability of the card itself and these card effects like you get more points allow you to put more banners out allowing you to move the boats they do essentially what you're already doing normally but it's a pretty useful ability and sometimes these can be quite powerful we're whoever's in the middle gets to put one of their Banner flag tokens out on the quadrant using the drawbridge and going across until they find one that's relevant if there's a bonus you get it if not then fine but once they're taken they're taken except for the central ones which cover multiple quadrants the reason you're doing this is because at the end of the round you have a interim scoring phase where you see who's got the majority of these tokens in the various quadrants and your score points accordingly but what dictates High middle and low well the quadrant you're in would you whichever quadrant you're in there is a hierarchy of the colors so at this quadrant purple is the best value then orange then yellow then blue so with the cards I've just played down here the nine purple is clearly the best trick here but then even though this is a free and these two are the cards are eight and nine the yellow three outranks the two blue cards because of this hierarchy so the yellow gets second place the eight um sorry the nine gets you know third place and then this 8 despite being an 8 is the lowest trick in that so this one gets to trigger its ability this person gets to like move their speed boat and these two get to put out Banner tokens and this quadrant is
dictated by the player whose turn it is at the Active turn so every time it moves and a new trick is done you've got to kind of look in and go hmm which what am I trying to do here High middle or low and play your cards accordingly on the side there is also fruit that you can get which are these really cool little sort of yellow almost gummy candy looking pieces is really nice would you care for a Jelly Baby occasionally there will be a pile of fruit in the middle and then people will take fruit at various times when it drains you see who's got the most fruit they get points everybody else gets half you know and then it rinse and repeats throughout the game the game continues for three rounds in this fashion you drain out your whole hand you have the scoring phase with the various Banner tokens you then collect most of them back you do another couple of rounds of the cards and the banner tokens and at the end there's a little bit of final scoring total up all your profit and of course the one with the most profit of course to Manifesto is as you can see a pretty minimalistic design maybe a little bit too minimalistic in some respects I mean this is the Box okay so this is a normal ticket ride sized box in a sense so maybe a little bit thinner but still it's a normal size box okay there's not a lot on the table as you can see this is all that's in the Box I mean there's I've bagged up player components so you've got your few cards you've got your banner tokens and the reference Aid and then fruit goes in the bag and that's kind of it oh and a bag for Point tokens and the bag for these cards that's it this box is way too big the only reason this box is that big is because of this rulebook yep because even this folds down into fours so the
Box could have been smaller to even accommodate this but yeah it's it's I feel like maybe the Box could have been a little bit smaller and this could have been packaged accordingly because you do end up with quite a lot of wasted space purely because of this not the best on the sustainability front but that's a minor blemish it's just wouldn't be nice if it took up a little bit less space but component wise other than that oh this is nice I mean this is a very beautiful game yes thematically whatever you're playing a trick taking game the fact that it's tidal blade Universe means nothing to me because I never played tidal blades all all it does is means that you get this gorgeous artwork on here which I do love I do particularly love this sort of artwork and you know it's all over the cards the pieces are good I mean you've got some very nice you know chunky wooden counters for your banners you've got proper you know cardboard chips for you know site decent size for the victory Point markers a very good reference Aid that is useful to have in the game you've got the gummy fruit that I almost just want to eat and chew on because they look so juicy and yummy on top of that you've got a cool gate marker and these cards I mean the card is decent amount of stock although I would definitely recommend sleeving these because people are going to have them in their hand they're going to be playing them face down flipping them over and discarding them you're going to want to sleeve this deck but it's not that big a deck I mean you've only got four suits and you've effectively got zero to nine in all of them so it's not like you'll need that many sleeves I definitely recommend sleeving it just to be on the safe side
um you can probably decide not to sleeve your starter cards the ones that you flip over for the event events if you've got spare sleeves do it if not it's not the end of the world but yeah this is a very nice package and not that expensive to buy from my knowledge but you know it wasn't that expensive at Essen but it's just nicely produced yes you don't get that much in a box but what you do get in the box is all tap quality now this game goes from two to five players and the player scaling isn't as good as it could be now you're probably expecting me to say five is horrible and there's like five is right out you know as the meme goes and uh five was just put on the box to sell more copies five is right out we are half right I see I do sort of believe that it was done in that fashion but mainly the reason I think this game works better with less players than it does more is a couple of things firstly time length yes you're flipping card simultaneously but it's multiple people resolving stuff and so the game will naturally take longer and probably outstay it's welcome when you go four or five players particularly five five I just think drags this game on a bit long not to mention the chaos factor is a lot higher because you're trying to think right well okay I need to have the highest trick or the lowest trick or the ones in the middle when you've got five of you playing in a trick it's quite tricky to get the highest and the lowest card it's very easy to end up in the middle but to be high and low that's a tool order when you've got four or five of you playing you know sometimes you just end up doing it by complete for Luke two and three players is definitely The Sweet Spot though because in two and three the game is super fast it says 30
minutes on the box that's pushing it even with two players but 60 minutes should be the cap of time a game should take with two or three players four if you know what you're doing could finish in 60 minutes chances are it'll be closer to 75. it could go longer if you have five players it just takes a bit longer to do that many cards not to mention that the biggest problem I have is the fact that ah four to five players not only is it a bit more chaotic with the cards but these Banner tokens become ridiculous this is just having one of my like player banners on the board and you can see there's a fair amount now try four players combined try five players combined and see if you can find out who scores what for majorities and end up in a situation avoiding the one time where inevitably ah ah yes um it becomes unwieldy with these banners it gets ridiculous you start running out of them pretty quickly it's just too much fiddliness with four or five players with these banners two to three is a lot more manageable so two to three best played at four and five four is decent five I don't recommend and sorry no solo mode deal with it there'll be plenty of time to discuss your objections when and if you return but as trick taking games go and I like trick taking games in general this is not your standard trick taking game I mean you play it face down you flip it face up and then you see what happens in terms of the trick so there are some differences to a typical trick taking game again that's good because it means
this has a unique place but I found this quite an interesting little quirky game actually because I like that decision making that depending where this gate is changing the color hierarchy of your hand you might think oh I've got a brilliant hand it's all yellows and they're all really high yeah that's great if yellows worth anything you go to a quadrant where yellow isn't worth Jack then suddenly your high value means nothing and so you're kind of thinking well hang on a minute uh which one of these could I play in order to get the ability on the bottom would that be better then or should I wait until we get to a point where yellows are powerful and then play my yellow cards in order to make the most of their High values that decision process is just a really cool thing it's partially push your luck but it's also just a cool tactical decision that you gotta make and this thing can go up to four spaces so it can cross a couple of quadrons at a time and even that's filled with a bit of tension because you'll think right please put it in the purple please put it in the purple please put in the purple purple no when someone puts it into orange and it like now you've got to think oh it's that card no good anymore so maybe I should play this one and you'll also be aiming for certain things like I really want to put Banner tokens out but then I need to finish in the middle right so don't play anything too good but then also don't play anything too low it's almost like the Dixit current mechanic but then if I really want to move my speedboat around because my speed boat is for example you know here and the gate is here I go all the way around the map if I go the speedboat right well what's the best card I can play at the moment as well highest card I've got is eight yellow oh yellow is not worth anything so my
highest suit is a four oh if four are gonna be good enough I don't know what has been played because not all cards are in the game and you know it's a fixed happening players you'll look at what's being discarded so you can kind of gauge like four oranges pretty high at this point oh give it a go for orange it is and then you succeed and it's all really cool it's just a really cool tactical choice that you make with these the one thing I'm not a fan of though with these is these abilities these abilities are pretty generic I mean most of them are like Advanced your watercraft one space per Banner place a banner at the Region's Tower again a fruit and Advance your watercraft uh place two Banners at this Region's Tower Place a banner in the nearest place getting a fruit the only ones that are slightly different I think on the nines where you essentially get to place it in your scoring pile take it out of the game and it's worth Five Points those are pretty cool if you can play it and get it for its ability because obviously nine is not an easy card to get as the lowest card in the game but the other is a pretty generic abilities and they're basically just clones of the higher and the lower front I would have liked maybe some more interesting abilities to be on these cards and there's a lot of rinse repeat so certainly you know it's not a deal breaker I just wish that maybe there was just something a little bit more interesting on these abilities because they don't feel quite as cool as they could have been but as I say they can still be useful they can still be pretty handy to get two banners out at once and gaining fruit gaining fruit is useful I mean you'll get it from the banner spaces but you can score a decent amount of points on a regular basis if you can collect say five or six of this fruit and have the majority when the festival happens
because one point per fruit nothing to be sneezed at I mean half a point for a fruit is not too bad but one point for a fruit and you thought the most of them five or six points can make a decent amount of difference so there's a lot of interesting little tactical choices to make but none of it's brain burning you shouldn't necessarily be a pain in this game to a great extent other than possibly the choice of your card and even then that's mainly when you've got a full hand maybe in the first couple of turns of a round as the round goes on though your hand and choices dwindle you'll be able to quickly decide which card you want to play and everything resolves pretty quickly yeah there's a few interim scoring phases and you've got to stop when the fruit dries out but they don't take too long it's mainly just the banner majorities that kind of grind the game to a halt briefly but again that's not as big a deal if you play with two or three players I just found it to be a bit too much of a grinding halt with four or five Savannah Festival was an interesting little surprise for me I wasn't expecting much from this at all I mean I never heard of this game before I went to Essen practically I think it appeared on the the pre-speed or listen and I saw it I thought well it looks pretty but you know whatever I don't care about tidal blades and this is going to mislead people the fact that they think it's an expansion why do it in the tidal blade Universe yes it looked gorgeous as all get out not gonna fold it for that but the fact that it's fooling people into thinking this is an expansion is going to hurt your sales you should have known this going in but yeah I didn't even know it was a trick taker people had to tell me it's like now Luke get Banner Festival a try it's a trick taker you'll
probably like it it was like okay it's broke my interest a bit more grabbed it and it's like huh is actually pretty cool it's a neat game as much as I have a problem with the four and five player account of this two and three do work spectacularly well and four is not a deal breaker I'll still play this with four because let's face it three player still has the same amount of cards out it just cuts the length down a bit and makes it a bit less fiddly with the banners and that is a bit of an annoyance but I can Overlook that to some extent I'll never play this with five of the course but there's a lot of good things in this game the Tactical choices of the cards I really enjoy the artwork in this is beautiful yes it doesn't have much of a table presence in terms of stuff I mean I mean it really doesn't I mean this is it this board and your individual cards that's it you can put Point tokens a little tray and that's it it takes up next to no space on the table which is a really good plus Point compared to a lot of other games I've played lately but then you've got a really easy to follow rulebook with a reference guide and a summary at the back you know I didn't have a problem understanding this game at all the component quality is really good back it up by player account the setups really quick the teach is quick it's it's got a lot going for it and I do feel yes It suffers at four and five players and yes I probably won't get this to the table that often with two but if I can I will but if I've got three of us this is definitely one of the best trick taker games I've played and I want to bring this out in a can so it does depend on player account but overall I'm gonna
give this a solid 9 out of ten I'm gonna give this a distinction level actually because I think it's got it does a lot of things right and the blemishes drop it from a 10 to a nine and certainly if you look at my player scaling rating I think this is a nine when played with two or three and then eight when played with four or five so this is definitely gonna depend on your player count for this game if you're used to having large groups then maybe this isn't the best one to get but it will still be pretty good I mean eight is still a great score but it is going to be a little bit unwieldy but if you're playing this main leave with two or three players you cannot go wrong with this game just remember not related to Tidal blades Publishers stop doing this place so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people I'm Luke Hector and if you like what you see then please do something for me please thumb up the video and especially thumb up the video on Board Game Geek when the video goes up because it's great to see it appear in the hotness reviews but that only happens if enough people thumb it up on Board Game Geek otherwise you can always check out the patreon you can subscribe to the channel but most of all I'd like to get your comments down below what do you think of this game were you fooled like me thinking that this was an expansion and it turns out it wasn't do you like trick taking games you got any others you can recommend or have you tried this one yet and does this one catch your eye or catch your interest in terms how it plays and works until next time though check out more content on the channel including the recent review I did for flamecraft and also the review I did for Starship captains both also fairly lightish games so take care and remember as always regardless of how fast your speedboat is it's still only a game bye
for now fruit do look yummy do you like a Jelly Baby shut up