Tidal Blades: Banner Festival Deep Dive
What the Community Thinks About Tidal Blades: Banner Festival
Reviewers broadly agree that Tidal Blades: Banner Festival is a light, colorful trick-taking game set in the Tidal Blades universe. It was designed by JB Howell and Michael Mihilsick, and it is published by Lucky Duck Games with Druid City Games. Several channels stress that it is a standalone spin-off rather than an expansion to the original Tidal Blades, which is a point that The Broken Meeple, hosted by Luke Hector, considers important enough to lead with. Hector argues that placing the game under the Tidal Blades name risks misleading buyers, even though the artwork and setting are shared.
The consensus on player count is more divided. Maple University and The Broken Meeple both favor three or four players, while describing five-player games as chaotic and slow. Brains On Games reports a strong two-player experience, though it notes that the competition for majorities feels more meaningful with four. Gaming with Edo describes the game as quick once a table has learned it, and Allies or Enemies places it on their top 22 list of 2022 releases, calling it a standout for groups of four or five. Across these reviews, the shared view is that the game plays well at most counts but that its scoring rewards careful attention to who is playing.
Core Mechanics That Define Tidal Blades: Banner Festival
Trick-Taking
Each bout, every player secretly chooses one of their merchandise cards, and all cards are revealed at once. Rather than winning a trick outright, the cards are ranked against each other. The color hierarchy depends on which quadrant the trade gate currently occupies, so the strongest and weakest suits shift as the gate moves around the board. The highest-ranked card moves a racing watercraft toward the gate, the lowest-ranked card triggers its printed ability, and the cards in the middle place banners. Maple University calls this shifting ranking "excellent" because it "really resolves the good draw, bad draw side of the game." Brains On Games describes the approach as a trick-taking system that does not behave like a traditional one, because players cannot see the other cards before committing, which produces "a different feeling, a different flavor from other trick taking games." Allies or Enemies goes further and calls it a trick-playing game, since players often want to lose a trick in order to use a card's ability.
Area Majority
The second major system is majority control of the board. Banners go onto quadrant spaces that match the odd, even, or color conditions printed on the played card, and the towers at the center of each half of the board hold banners permanently. At the end of each day, the player with the most banners in each half earns six profit, the second place player earns three, and third place earns one in four and five player games. Maple University finds banner placement less interesting at five players, where the banner tokens matter less than the other scoring, while The Broken Meeple warns that at four and five players the banners "become ridiculous" and the majority scoring grinds the game to a halt. Edo, of Gaming with Edo, summarizes the design as a game where "area control or majority" in a region earns the profit tokens, and the central fruit supply adds a second scoring track on top of it.
The Tidal Blades: Banner Festival Experience
Colorful and Vibrant
Almost every reviewer comments on the palette and art before discussing rules. Maple University highlights the teal and orange color scheme and argues that bright colors make cards easier to read than the pale or beige tones common in many Euro games. Brains On Games says the color palette is one the reviewer really likes and associates with the Tidal Blades look. The Broken Meeple adds that the color coding comes with iconography to help colorblind players, although it notes that the icons around the central ring are weaker than the rest. The gummy fruit pieces receive frequent praise, with Allies or Enemies describing the fruit as "almost dangerously tasty looking" and The Broken Meeple calling them something they "almost just want to eat and chew on."
Quick and Snappy
The game is advertised at around thirty minutes, and reviewers largely accept that claim for two and three players. Brains On Games describes games that take about half an hour, and Edo says it "plays pretty quick" once a table knows the rules. The Broken Meeple is more cautious, arguing that thirty minutes is pushing it even with two players, that a sixty-minute cap is more realistic with two or three, and that four or five player games stretch well beyond the box claim. Reviewers agree that the play rhythm changes sharply with larger groups, because the banner scoring and the fruit feasts add pauses between bouts that smaller tables never experience.
What Makes Tidal Blades: Banner Festival Stand Out
A Shifting Color Hierarchy
The most frequently praised feature is the rotating trade gate. Because a played card's strength depends on the quadrant the gate occupies, a strong hand can become useless after the gate moves, and that uncertainty drives the decisions. Maple University praises the constant change in which card is highest and which is lowest. The Broken Meeple calls the resulting choice "partially push your luck" but also "a cool tactical decision," because a card that is strong in one quadrant can be worthless after the gate moves. The gate also adds a bluffing layer: The Broken Meeple notes that when the lead player moves the gate, opponents must guess whether that choice signals a high play, a bluff, or a plan for the lowest card.
Artwork and Components
Reviewers repeatedly single out the production. The Broken Meeple describes the box as containing only a few cards, wooden banners, cardboard chips, and gummy fruit, and it still calls the package "very beautiful" and "not that expensive." Allies or Enemies notes that the Tidal Blades Heroes of the Reef characters appear on the value nine cards, which helps tie the game to the wider universe. The consistent message from reviewers is that the components look far larger than the game's table footprint suggests, and that this is a deliberate strength for a small, portable title.
Potential Drawbacks
Scaling at Four and Five Players
The most common criticism is that the game plays differently at each player count, and not always in a good way. Maple University notes that five players make it harder to be both the highest and the lowest card, so the middle position becomes the most common outcome. Maple University adds that the game will naturally take longer with more players and "probably outstay its welcome" at five. The Broken Meeple goes further, arguing that at five players the banner majorities become unwieldy and that the game is not worth playing at that count. Reviewers who prefer the game at three or four still think it works, but they are clear that five players is a poor fit for the design. Gaming with Edo, for its part, suggests that the game would take considerable effort to shape into a social or party experience.
Generic Card Abilities
Several reviewers say the card abilities feel repetitive. The Broken Meeple describes most of them as variations on advancing the watercraft, placing banners at a region's tower, or gaining fruit, and argues that the only standout abilities are on the nine cards, which can score five profit when played as the lowest card. Reviewers still find the abilities useful, but many would have liked more distinctive effects on the cards that are triggered by losing a trick.
If You Enjoy Tidal Blades: Banner Festival
Players who enjoy Tidal Blades: Banner Festival's trick-taking system will find similar satisfaction in Libertalia. Maple University explicitly compares the two, describing Banner Festival as having a very Libertalia feel, while noting that it is simpler and has fewer individual powers. Allies or Enemies cautions that it is not an obvious replacement for Libertalia, since the two games offer different experiences. Players who appreciate the way the game uses hidden information and simultaneous reveals may also enjoy Dixit, which The Broken Meeple names when describing the bluffing and guesswork of choosing a card that is neither too strong nor too weak. For players who want to stay in the same universe, Tidal Blades: Heroes of the Reef shares the artwork and setting, and Allies or Enemies notes that the Guardians from that game appear on the nine cards in Banner Festival.
What Reviewers Are Saying
"This whole thing here where it's constantly changing which card is highest and which card is lowest is excellent. It really resolves the good draw, bad draw side of the game."
— Maple University
"As much as I have a problem with the four and five player account of this, two and three do work spectacularly well, and four is not a deal breaker."
— Luke Hector, The Broken Meeple
"Face down, simultaneous card reveals are very different, and it gives the game a different feeling, a different flavor from other trick taking games."
— Dr Brian McDonald, Brains On Games