Red Rising, Fantasy Realms & other similar games: deep dive into an undersung card drafting genre!
Transcript
now if you've watched this channel before you'll know that i'm a fan of stonemeyer games i love wingspan and scythe i enjoy charterstone and viticulture and my little side is just adorable so whenever jamie stegmar announces a new project i'm always interested maybe even excited but i don't really like licensed games i don't really have much time for games based on films or tv series or anything like that and in this case red rising is based on a book series that i've never heard of now i get offered review copies from time to time and i pretty much always turn them down nothing wrong with a free game i love a free game but that requirement to review takes all the pleasure out of playing the games and yet when stonemaier games contacted me to offer me a promotional copy of red rising then i jumped at the chance so why was that well mainly because of the art i really like the art i don't know this series but i like the fact it looks like a graphic novel and actually each card has a different character on it and the characters the personalities are so beautifully conveyed by the artists and then once you get into the card abilities they really give you ideas about the the personalities the priorities the the goals of these individuals so it creates a world this game belongs to that ill-defined thematic genre role selection now this isn't really a mechanism it loosely describes games which have whole host of different characters in them and every character has a different card ability so when you play that character the
ability activates and we know that i mean jamie stegmar has said that part of the inspiration for red rising came from the game libitalia which he loves this is a pirate game i adore with loads and loads of different characters in it someone's got to reprint this game and give us an expansion now that combination of stonemaier games and role selection and evocative art really got me on board and before i wade in too deep into this deep dive i ought to say that i've got the collector's edition of red rising here okay so we've got upgraded components metal components card holders you get this from stonemeyer games directly you're not going to be able to buy it in stores and it's going to be a little bit more expensive than the retail version now recently i've been designing a new set collection game very simple one for children and it's got a card draft at its core and i was scouring through my collection looking for different examples of card drafting systems i didn't want to use the ubiquitous pick and pass system that you see in seven wonders even though i was going for a similar simplicity to sushi go and there are a few drafting mechanisms that achieve a similar ease of play to sushi go but there's one game that stands out in that regard the central mechanism in fantasy realms is delightfully easy to explain but it offers up a really challenging decision on every turn the game revolves around improving your hand of cards you start with seven you end with seven but you want to make those seven cards combo in the most effective way possible to maximize your scoring on your turn you must draw a card either randomly from the top of the deck or face up from the table and to end
your turn you must discard a card to the table where it becomes available to the other players there are 10 suits and each card has a criteria which you need to fulfill by the end of the game in order to score points or it might have a penalty criteria that you need to avoid in order to avoid losing points or both for example a card in your hand might award you points if you have other cards of the same suit or it might lose you points if you have certain cards alongside it or its scoring might be blanked out totally when in the presence of a certain card or card suit and when 10 cards are face up on the table the game ends and the players total their points from the cards now in the rulebook for red rising the co-designers both acknowledged that it was whilst playing bruce glasgow's fantasy realms that the spark of inspiration for red rising came to them the fantasy realms dna is not hard to spot when you're playing this game in red rising players are trying to amass victory points by collecting the best set of cards into their hand there are 14 different suits each represented by a colour and each card you hold in your hand scores points at the end of the game if certain criteria are fulfilled for example a card may require you to hold other cards of the same colour or a different colour or perhaps even a specific card in order to score points and on your turn you're generally required to play a card then draw a card and maintain the same number of cards in your hand throughout the game although there are ways to get
additional cards using card abilities but the main emphasis is on maximizing your scoring so when you play a card you place it on the board face up for all other players to see and you get to use its deployability which is unique for each card it might move pieces or cards around the board or it might score you additional points by moving tokens on different tracks and then you pick up a new card to replace the one you've discarded now this can either be a face up card from the board or it could be a card drawn blind from the top of the deck but either way you gain a bonus depending on the column that the new card came from and this is generally going to score your points in some way it might activate a special ability when certain criteria are met then the game ends and all players total their points from the cards they have in their hand the tokens they've gathered and the tracks on the board now starting with a hand of cards and swapping them out to achieve a better combination of cards but ultimately ending up with a similarly sized hand and then scoring it is a neat intuitive concept it's the basis of five card draw which is the simplest form of poker i think or at least it's certainly the form that i first learned when i was a a gambling teenager in five card draw each player holds a hand of five playing cards and players are attempting to have the best combination of different cards the best poker hand after the initial deal of the cards is usually a round of betting and then once all players bets have been matched or players are folded then each player may discard any number of cards from their hand
and replace them with random cards dealt from the top of the deck another betting round follows and then any players who have not folded reveal their cards the best poker hand wins the pot now this is not dissimilar to yahtzee okay in the artsy we got five dice and we manipulate those five dice to get the best possible results by re-rolling them then re-rolling them again but essentially we're still going to end up with five dice and we're going to score the combination of results the combination of numbers that we get on those five dice now this is also the basis for poker dice which is essentially yahtzee but with betting gambling rounds in the middle similar to our poker game that we've already described but in red rising and fantasy realms we have a lot more control over what cards go into our hand we can draw blindly from the top of the deck but we don't have to we can instead draw from the face up cards that are on the table and this is reminiscent to the traditional card game golf in golf players have a number of playing cards commonly six in front of them on the table in two rows and two of these cards are turned face up throughout the game the players are trying to get the lowest numbered cards into their selection and on your turn you either take a card from the top of the deck or you take the top card from the face up discard pile if you draw from the deck you have the option of discarding the card if you don't want it or you can use it to replace one of the cards in your display leaving new card face up and discarding
the old one if you draw from the discard pile then you must use it to replace a card in your display and when one player has all of their six cards face up then the game ends each card scores its face value except for twos which score minus two points jackson queens which score 10 points and kings which scores zero and a pair of equal cards in the same column also scores zero regardless of the card value the lowest scoring player wins now if you enjoy this mechanism in golf then you might enjoy red rising or fantasy realms the central mechanism of draw one discard one is present in all of these games you have the option of drawing from the the top of the deck or drawing from the face up discards and you have special powers when you utilize certain cards in red rising and fantasy realms you have loads and loads and loads of these powers now once you start to explore games based around golf you find that it's actually a pretty rich design space and as with the myriad of different trick taking variants out there one minor change to the rules of golf completely changes the feel of the game and this mechanism hasn't yet been dissected as rigorously as trick taking but we're on the way lots of games have come onto the market with slight variations on the core gameplay of the original game golf papino is one of these games papagino is a pocket game from helvetique themed around the opera of the magic flute the gameplay is similar to golf with a few special powers when you place the papagino card into your display you can immediately swap
one of your other face up cards with one belonging to an opponent and when you place the magic flute card into your display then the card that it displaces gets passed to the player on your left and they have to put it in the same slot in their display that it occupied in your display that player then passes their displaced card onto the left and so on around the table the game scored when one player has all of their cards face up and each card scores its face value eggs take on the value of the card either to their left or their right and two matching cards in the same column score zero the lowest scorer wins the round and the first player to win two rounds wins the game rat attack cat is a simplified version of the card game golf but it's played with only four cards players are attempting to have the lowest score on the four cards in front of them and at the start of the game each player looks at their two outermost cards then returns them face down onto the table on your turn you can draw a card from the deck look at it and either use it to replace one of your face down cards or discard it or you can draw the top card of the discard pile and use that to replace one of your face down cards if you draw a card from the deck with a special ability you use it immediately this might allow you to peek at one of your face down cards swap one of your cards with a card in front of an opponent or take two turns in quick succession if you think you have the lowest score you knock on the table and say rat attack cat and all other players have one more turn and then everybody reveals their cards any power cards are replaced with randomly drawn cards from the deck
players scores are recorded and after several rounds the lowest scoring player wins bezier games is i don't know whether it's pronounced cabo or carbo but essentially it's the same game as rat attack cat with some minor changes so in this version when you exchange a card from the deck with one from your display you can also discard other cards from your display if they match but if you reveal one incorrectly then you have to keep all the cards which is going to increase the number of cards in front of you there's also a shoot the moon option where you're trying to get all the highest valued cards in front of you in order to score zero points very hard to achieve and silver also by bezier games re-implements all the same systems but adds a special ability onto every single card so peeking at cards stealing cards swapping cards searching through the discard pile all manner of other options and there are four different versions of this game that you can combine together in lots and lots of different ways to to make a unique mix of different powers for each individual game an omerta from helvetique also features a bunch of special powers so in this game when a player places a card onto the discard pile one other player can quickly reveal a matching card from their own display and discard that one too so this adds a really fun exciting speed reaction element to the game and if you make a mistake you take an additional card as a penalty when i designed the trick taking game picoco i took the trick taking genre and i pushed it in lots of different directions at the same time the game had a lot going on so you had
additional features that weren't there in traditional trick taking games most notably you had card holders holding cards so that you couldn't see your own hand of cards but you also had two different layers of bidding that you did before you went into a round of gameplay you had cards that had multiple different suits on the same card the card holders necessitated a bigger box and a higher price point than most people were used to with trick taking games so how far can you stretch a mechanism before it breaks well picoco was highly praised by many people for its ingenuity its originality and for its table presence but it was also disliked by a lot of other people for straying too far from traditional trick-taking games and red rising is going to be equally divisive now i recently made a video about streamlining games and i used side as an example particularly its transition into my little scythe this was stone mire games taking a fairly complex strategy game and stripping it back to its very core well with red rising stonemaier have done precisely the opposite they've taken a really simple card game that works really well and they've added bells and whistles and for many people that added complexity and the ingenuity of the new mechanisms and the beautiful presentation will be a huge attraction but for others it's going to be seen as unnecessary chrome well personally i'm having fun with it i i mean it hasn't replaced fantasy realms for me i still have a place for that i love fantasy realms it hasn't replaced
rat attack cat for that matter each of those is going to have its own group of players i'm going to bring it out with but i am really enjoying watching this undersung genre of card drafting games having its moment in the sun