Skip to main content
Loading video...

White Castle Duel - We Just Played It!

Transcript 21:32

White Castle Duel just hit our table. I've got the rule book right here, which is something I want to talk about in a second. Uh, this is the second time Ryan had played it. Correct.

I've played it, yeah, twice.

First time for me. So, we wanted to give you our first impressions. You know, not not a full-blown review, but I think a pretty good sense for what this game is doing and whether it might be for you or not. Um, if you watch our channel much, you saw that we did a review of White Castle Once Upon a Time. Both of us like White Castle quite

It was one of my game of the years. Yeah, it was in your top 10. Top 10 games of

the year. Not in mine. Mainly because games like that, I like games that offer just a windfall of stuff. I like feeling very smart a lot of the time. And White Castle is one of those games that makes you feel like, oh, how can I do what I'm going to do?

But when you do it, you do feel really smart.

That's what I love about White Castle. Let me say this.

But what if you never do it? Like,

well, that's the thing is like just like I'll say your first impressions of these games. White Castle. My first impression was like you you're not getting anything done. Now when I play White Castle, I can look at the board and it's like that computer in your brain that analyzes what are these cards that are out like what are what are the gardener abilities? Like what what are the training yard abilities? Look at those things. Look at the cards that are available and you'll see and your brain can click and go okay here's a path. It it takes a few plays to do that. That feeling I think has been captured incredibly well in White Castle Duel because it's the same way. And I'll say the number one thing about this game, just like White Castle, is variability. I said this when we reviewed White Castle and I'm saying it when we review White Castle Duel. This is a game where your game experience, the number of points you have, your ability to get things done is going to be hugely dependent on what this board setup looks like, what the cards that are faced up on these decks look like, where all these tokens are placed. There's different tiles over here, different tokens for the garden, different tokens down here for this new shipping track.

All of this is variable. Even like the crawling up the uh the courters in the castle. so variable that I think every time you play this game, you're going to look at it and think, "Okay, I need to play this from a completely different angle than I did last game." Which again, if you want a White Castle duel styled game, I think that is the thing that you want to carry over from White Castle.

Yeah. Uh before we describe the game too, I want to say a couple things as well. I would underscore everything Ryan just said. I think the variability shows itself a little more in some places than in other places. I think you'll feel the variability of different tiles being used here a lot in this game, which I think was also the case in White Castle for sure. These tiles in particular.

Uh the other interesting thing here is these little action tiles. They're not very you're using effectively the same ones every game, but they're in a different position and those will actually change position as you're playing as well, which is a big part of the puzzle. But yeah, this game takes the dual approach to White Castle and I think nails it. So if a game company is going to set out and say, "Let's do a dual version of this game," some games have done that really really well. And I think White Castle joins their ranks.

Well, and they did it in such a way that the gameplay is different. It It feels very different while also kind of feeling the same. And I'll explain what I mean by that in a second. But people will probably ask, "Well, do I really need this? I can just play White Castle at 2." This is a different experience. I think of this more as a companion. If I'm playing at two players, there's still room to play White Castle at two players. This is a different experience, but it's a great companion piece. It's the kind of game where you're like, play them back to back. Play them, you know, in the same game day. Like, they are different enough that there's a reason to own both, but this is probably the obviously the better, more tuned game for a two-player experience.

Yeah, I think it is more tuned. And I would say unlike Ryan, I would say this one would probably be my preference at two for sure. And one reason in particular, that thing I was referring to earlier, that feeling of suffocation and restraint where you're like, "Oh, how can I get what I need to get done?"

I'm more at ease with that feeling when it's just one v one. When you're sitting at a table full of people, that is a a heightened level of tension where and I don't know if it boils down to this, but like when when you're feeling that way and you see multiple other people doing better, it's more stressful, right?

Sure.

Whereas in a two-player game, it's like a cat and mount. It's like a chess match, right? Like it's like you're sitting down and you can invest some time into this to play with one person and like, "Okay, I think we got my my head wrapped around it. Let's play again." You're not always going to do that with a game like White Castle with four players. You're not going to say, "Okay, let's play again."

Well, this one you would.

This this one you could for sure. It's very fast. It is only two rounds. And I guess let's take that as a segue to talk about what you're doing in this game. It is structured over two rounds. And the core mechanic here is you're going to use these pieces. You're going to have two of each color piece.

Yeah, these lanterns. And then you take the lantern on your turn, whatever color you want, and you place it out on one of these spaces that also have effectively the lantern colors. You don't have to match the color. In fact, you specifically cannot match the color. So this one's orange or red. I couldn't put one of my red tokens there. I'd have to put a black or a white there. Then if someone wanted to go there again, if I went there with a white, you'd have to go with a red or a black. And you can stack what? Up to three.

Three. I wanted each color on it,

which we got into a couple times in our game, leaving some of the spaces empty because

the combinations of actions you're going to take are dictated by where you place. The first thing you do is when you place, you're going to

fire off all of the lanterns. And this is going to like bring back some memories from White Castle, although this happens quite a bit more.

Well, it happens every time. In White Castle, remember, if you took the lowest die, uh you would get to fire off your single lantern. In this game, you have three lanterns you're building. And you'll see up here on the board, you can add to your lanterns in a little bit different of a way, but you're and I think that's kind of the theme of this game. You're doing pretty much all the same stuff that you do in White Castle in a little bit different way. We put that asterisk on everything,

but you're firing off those different lanterns and you're not placing the dice anymore. So, there is no lowest die to take that. The number doesn't matter, but the color still matters maybe even more so

because of that restriction and because like when you're putting your first piece out, you're looking at these printed bonuses. You're going to start with a little tiny lantern and it's going to grow over the course of the game. A big part of the game is maximizing that is like how do I trigger off my biggest lantern the most number of times.

Yeah. And then which is very satisfying. I will say it this does offer I think more frequently more satisfying and rewarding turns which is something I like than White Castle might. I know White Castle has the capability of doing that if you're good. This one dangles that carrot and allows players to do it every single time because you're firing off those lanterns. You're basically just getting all the things on your lantern cards of that color that you covered. Then you're going to look at the two spaces around it. Now, the board is set up. So, there's different types of spaces. You have these action spaces, and a lot of the actions are basically all the different things that you can interact with on the main board and do various things, placing pieces out in the different scoring areas. But some of the areas like this action space has an action, but also this stack of cards.

And you'll see this one connects to this stack as does this space. And then this one down here. These cards are a big part of scoring because when I go here, I could take this action and take this card. Now, when you take these cards, you have to pay for it. When you take it, you're going to place it over here on the left hand side of your board and take the action or the bonus that is on that card. But on the flip side of these are a bunch of different icons that are associated with scoring. Scoring that's going to naturally happen, but also a lot of scoring that's tied to the different sections of the board as well.

Yeah, they did a good job still with the scoring kind of making it feel like White Castle, but again different because if you remember in White Castle it was all about where you put different people. Some a lot of it was just like put a guy in the garden and get points. Yeah. Put a guy in the in the castle, climb the castle, you get points based on the level. Your warriors just got points. whatever you multiplied all these different things together. You're still multiplying things together, but each one of the types of different clans people that are out on the board are going to multiply based on some of the symbols that you have on those cards. So, when you're taking the cards, when you're choosing your actions, you need to be cognizant of how you're going to score at the end of the game. Now, little bit of a spoiler alert. David actually crushed me in this game because he did a fantastic job of recognizing what he was scoring. He was putting a bunch of clan people out into the training ground. And these are going to score particular icons, the uh the katanas and the kabuto, which are like the swords and the the helmets. He saw that he was going to score a bunch of points here. So, he dedicated his gameplay out here to gathering as many of those cards as he wanted or as he could. I think he would have wanted to have more.

Yeah,

as many as he could. And you scored like what, 40 points just from that one row.

40 points just on that one type of scoring. But again, I just kind of wound myself up whenever I'm playing a game like this, particularly with Ryan. I don't I I've come to the conclusion that I I'm just going to do what I do. I'm not going to overthink. I'm just going to So I like, okay, I see those points. I'm going to go for those points. I might lose just doing that, which I thought I was for a long time. Uh but the other interesting thing that this game does which also happens in White Castle but this one even more so because it's two players you can look at the other player and go oh

you are going after that hardcore. So you know for instance Ryan could have looked at this now

I should have honestly I probably should have

but it also depends on the board state too whether you can like take things away from someone but Ryan had this interesting one of the scoring are these blue origami multiplied by your white origami. Now, the blue origami, you can get a lot of those. They're all over these cards. Some of the cards have a ton of them. So, he was getting blue origami, blue origami, and a ton of them. And you have to flip these cards in order to score them, which is a whole another action.

But, he needed white origami. So, I was like, so there's one area where I could get this token that had two of them because that's a that would have been huge points for you because it would have been probably like 16 extra points or something.

It would have been 16 more points, which could have made the difference. Yep. So I jumped on that. But then throughout the course of the game is able to pick up more. So this does, like I said, I referenced chess earlier. It does. And it's mainly because it's two players. You're able to in this game look and go, okay, mathematically, it's probably better for me to take this even though it's not going to score me any points, but it's going to keep you from scoring 16 points than it would be. So we're in a three or four player game of White Castle.

And all of those scoring like it it takes the three things you were doing in in regular White Castle and kind of abstracts them a little bit. Like you're still doing the three main things. You're moving your people up the castle, but it's represented by these tiles. You're putting, we already talked about putting the people in the training yard. You're putting the gardeners out here to get some one time and some bonuses and some symbols at the end of the game. But then there's a fourth new thing that kind of represents the theme, I guess, which we haven't really talked about in White Castle Duel. It takes place a little bit after White Castle when the Portuguese have come in and started trading and you're kind of maintaining the trade agreements between them. So that's what these cards represent is like these different trade agreements. And then you can like take what the new action, the shipping action to like actually trade for some of those tiles that could give you some significant icons. And it's all about that. Like I climbed to the top of the tower, which makes all my flags times three. I just didn't get a ton of flags. I probably should have gotten more flags.

Meanwhile, David went all in on this and got a lot of the swords and masks. I kind of did a little bit of everything, which is maybe I I enjoyed it, but it didn't ultimately lead to scoring. And part of that and and part of the reason that you can get halfway through the game and realize that you're in trouble or that your strategy is not valid anymore because there is a huge twist in the game. And we're going to describe that now. And we talked about how you put these out early. The first round of the game is basically just stacking these out there and taking the actions. Once one player or both players have put out all of their tokens, it's the end of the game or the end of the first round, sorry. Then the second round is played the same way, but you're taking them back off.

Yeah,

this is really hard to wrap your head around to understand that all of this the decisions you're making in the first round are going to hugely affect your ability to get things done in the second round, like this space right here where maybe we only put one. And if David goes first in the second round and grabs this, he has taken the only lantern on the board that can access that shipping tile. Which means if you were going huge into that shipping and you were planning on a big shipping action for the next turn, you're kind of in trouble. Unless you grab these like swap tokens which let you swap some of the actions around the board. In the second round, I think especially it's almost like mandatory to at least get one.

Oh yeah.

Because you're going to find situations like that where you just can't access an action anymore because both the lanterns on that action are gone.

Yeah. And you don't get these willy-nilly. I I actually hard to get uh you draft some cards at the beginning that give you starting resources. I took one that gave me one of these. Um but there is a well action similar to uh White Castle where if you don't want to take or cannot take one of your two actions that you're taking when you place, you can take one of the well actions, one of which is to get one of these swap tokens. You can only hold two of those. It should also be noted your player board is where you hold those. It's where you're going to hold your coins in your daimo. Is it

dio seals? Yeah. Uh, and you can only you're limited to 10 total coins and or daimo. These are the resources you're going to be spending largely to acquire these cards. They come into play a couple other ways, but mostly just to acquire these cards. But yeah, so that twist like it's kind of mind-blowing when you get to that second route and you realize,

oh, I was in trouble because I really built out my black lantern and I used my black lanterns first. So, they're buried. So, I have to hope that you are going to maybe take some of these out or I'm taking actions I don't want to take just to finally get my Black Lantern back to trigger my Black Lantern cards. And it means that in future plays, and this is my second time playing, so I was maybe a little more cognizant of this, but when you're playing it in the future, you're really thinking about, okay, the first lantern that I put out could be the last lantern that you're taking in the second round. And if nobody's using those tokens to move things around and you really know like you have to think ahead. I want to end the game with a cordier action or I want to end the game with a gardener action and really like you have to think hard about it. But then that's how it might not still be there by the end of the game, but it could be.

Yeah. And if you do have one of those swap tokens, you can always get one of those actions. If you end the game on your last turn and you need to take two specific actions, you might be in trouble because the thing gets just more and more restrictive feeling. The first round it's like you're in control. The second round you're like, "Oh, this is what it is. We have to navigate this. It feels more like a the second round, which is largely similar except you're taking back, feels way more like a puzzle than the first round because you're like, "Oh, if I take this one, it it and it brings to mind other dual games, right?" Because a lot of what you're doing in this game often telegraphs what you're going after towards the end. And then that middle point, you're like, "Okay, oh well, you've got a ton of black lantern cards. I'm taking the black pieces whenever I get a chance.

I'm taking the black pieces because whenever he takes one, he's going to be able to fire that off naturally. So, I want to keep him from doing that because you can sort of have a nice balance of lantern cards or you can go heavy on one and abuse it, which I did with these light ones a little bit even though I only had two. Um, but yeah, it becomes a really interesting game where you're like, "Okay, I could do this." And I will say this, it does get a little thinky in a not AP sort of way, but you if you wanted to towards the end of the game could truly sit there and go, "Okay."

Yeah.

Well, if I do this with that, like, especially if it's down to like the last two pieces,

like if I take this one, you'll take this one, that might leave me with this one. But if you take this one, then that leaves me with that one.

And you have this token that lets you swap. Could I use a token to swap and screw you up? Oh, no. You have a token so you can switch it right back. And like if I use my token now, if I'm gonna be stuck taking three of these, I might use the token to swap and think I'm gonna do the extra twice, [clears throat] but you might swap. So yeah, there is a lot more. Now you when you say that, when you say that that it's the second round that feels like that, I think if we were better at the game, if we were more skilled at the game, the first round could also feel like that because you go to place when you go, "Oh, well, I don't actually I don't want this. I want to take this action early next round. So, I need to wait and I need to do this later so that it's on top so that when it's my turn in the second round, I can do it first. Like, the game opens itself to that level. I think

if if you could get to that level.

We're not at that level.

I can tell you I will never be at that level. Uh, I've only played the game once, but I can assure you that as I'm placing in the first round in this game with any future plays, I don't think I'll be thinking about the second round because again, it all depends on who takes what in that second round because you might take the first one and go and then it makes me have to rethink completely. Oh, so you took that one first. Now I have to like really kind of think what you're going doing. So, it it does kind of almost feel enough different between the two rounds that I don't I don't know if you're going to feel a connection between the two significantly. I don't think you'll play the second round and go, "Oh, if only I'd placed my oranges first."

I mean, you might. I mean, well, maybe because what happens is some of the actions, if you don't use those switch tokens, some of the actions that maybe don't feel as important in the first round, like we talked about, there's a an action that you have to flip these cards over. If you don't flip a lot of cards in the first round, the action to flip cards becomes incredibly valuable to you. But if you only took that action once in the first round,

that means there's only one lantern. You're taking that action once in the second round, unless you use your swap tokens to move it to somewhere a little more lucrative.

Yeah. And that's what generally happens is someone will use that swap token to get an action that you want to abuse next to a big stack of tokens. For sure. Uh yeah, the game overall I think it's for me a better experience than White Castle. And I think

at two players at least at two players. Well, but even for me

I think overall you just like this better than

I like this better than White Castle. It has nothing to do with the fact that I happen to beat Ryan in my job.

I don't know that it will ever happen again, but I do think I enjoy what this game does on a turntoturn basis more than White Castle. And in a weird way, and it might be because of my familiarity with White Castle,

the different areas are much more easily digested right on the on the first teach them quite a bit.

Yeah, Ryan taught me very quickly and I'm like, "Okay, I see the actions. I know exactly what they do." Whereas I think with less experienced gamers, when you teach them White Castle, you'll have a lot throughout their first game where you're like, "What's this one do again?" this one. And again, it was probably from my familiarity with White Castle, but it was very easy to go, "Oh, there's this, there's this, there's this, there's this." That's

They did a good job. I mean, your familiarity with White Castle, you're right. We're both very familiar with White Castle. And I think that if you and I I taught it to my friend Dan, uh, who's also, he and I play White Castle quite a bit. It's very easy to be like, "Remember the the the cordier track? Okay, it's just a little different. Remember the the training track? It's just these spaces now." You know, it it's just different. But because it's two players, they were able to do some things that you couldn't do in the first game. Like for example, tighten this up so that there can only be a certain number of clans people on each one of these. And in the garden, like you took both of these spots in in White Castle, there's actually a little bit more freedom to take those spots. The tracks that go up the castle, there's two tracks, one on each side. As soon as one person chooses one track, the other player has to go up the the second track. So there's actually I think there's a little bit more tightness, but maybe it doesn't feel that way because you're only competing with one other player for these spots.

Yeah. Some of the actions you do take dictate what the other player has to do or what then you have to do going forward. So it does take some of the decision space out of that in a good way in sort of a streamlined sort of way.

We almost filled up this training yard completely while we almost completely ignored the gardens.

Yeah. I I I and I don't know if that will always be the case with me. I always do see those training yards as something I like to do. So I just like, okay, I'm going to get as much iron as I can and abuse that scoring. Well, and again, this is the last thing I'll say about the variability. It matters because when you sat down to do this, you saw, okay, well, this lets you get these cards, and this will not always be the tile that's here, but getting these lantern cards is really good. And you were like, okay, well, there was a lot of opportunity. There were some some uh sword cards that were out available to buy. There was like you can see that you can look and say, okay, I'm going to grab all three of these and get a bunch of points and then I'm just going to go heavy on that.

But next game, you're right, that the abilities that are up here, you might not like them. the way the cards come out. I mean, there's a lot of variables that are going to make this feel like a different experience every time you play it. But that is White Castle Duel. Uh, I think if we're giving this a rating, it would be pretty high. This is going to be a a seven to nine. Probably eight.

Oh, for sure. I would say nine for me after two plays. It might change.

I'm going to try to get this played with my wife, too. Uh, she's never played White Castle, so it'll be fun to see from somebody that's never played White Castle.

I'd be very interested to see how that goes. But if you have any questions, please make them in the comments below. We'll get down there and answer whatever we can. Until next time, make sure everyone has front at the table and we'll see you then.

Progress saved