Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Truth About Stonemaier Games? - The Mill

Transcript 19:14

the camera doesn't had ten pounds and it's 45 I'm actually 6 foot tall and a buck oh five yeah I like to start with a joke hello and welcome to the mill I am your host dusty crane and this week I wanted to talk about well I mean let's just cut to the chase if ever there was evidence of the fact that Jamie well some of our games does sponsor the show they don't have any direct say over what I cover on the show it might be this week because this week I want to talk about what a lot of people are talking about as it relates to Stone mire games and that is we'll call it the truth about stun Meyer games or the truth about stone wire games if you are paying attention to certain forums and and public feedback and the truth is that I don't necessarily have a 100 percent side that I that I 100 percent relate to I kind of see both sides and I just kind of want to talk it out I know I'll get some some comments and maybe help me further kind of flush out that opinion and that's kind of what I wanted to go for this week if you have not read jamie's blog post on stoneware games i will link to it in the comments but i'm sorry in the in the show notes but i

kind of wanted to talk about what he posted there there's been some criticism lately all over the board of stone meyer games everything from map pricing which is like minimal advertised price to who they're making copies for where they're directly selling to all of this stuff and you know i just i kind of wanted to talk about at least one piece in particular because there's a part of it that for me i kinda understand kind of don't understand it let's just go ahead and get to it there's one part of the argument that that i have the most difficulty with and that is the one that is stomer games sells to Amazon now I've done a video about this before but there's been more stuff that's come out there's been more conversation and frankly I've had more time to think so Jamie has stated many many times stomer games does not sell to retailers they sell to distributors and so in that regard Jamie doesn't sell the Amazon Jamie doesn't sell to your friendly local game store either and that's another piece of the puzzle here because a lot of people are saying that because these gates because Jamie sells to the distributor flat river group I said flat River group now I don't know if it's flat rock group let's just assume that I'm saying the right name

for the sake of argument shall we because Jamie sells to that distributor and that distributor directly sells to amazon.com Walmart comm target comm one day my voice will be the same again because he directly sells to this distributor that he has then in terms selling to those places and I understand the case to be made for that but I also don't understand if I don't know whether or not there are any other industries where people say hey you need to do it to a manufacturer mind you that they say you need to sell to a mom-and-pop shop and and prioritize them over the big retailers the big-box retailers now before I get into this because I know this is murky waters itself I don't have a friendly local game store that I that I frequent but I do regularly buy games from either stone Meijer website or from I just bought the recently bought the directly from portal games the expansion for 51st state so I tend to kind of either by directly from companies that I enjoy or I like that I want to support them directly because there's a more money for them to be made that way or from Amazon if it's a you know one of

those big-box companies themselves like an Asmoday or something like that part of the argument that has come up is by Jamie selling directly to flat River group that he isn't it's not fair for him to say I don't sell the Amazon and so as I was kind of talking about this with my wife and I was asking her is it fair for people to say since he's knowingly selling to a distributor that sells directly to them that you know that he can say I don't sell the Amazon and my wife is big into the beauty industry like she loves watching the the beauty youtubers and it seems like at least once a month there's some new drama that she's gonna fill me in on and I don't know any of the players involved but I've heard their names enough that I'm I'm kinda in the loop you know I could tell you a little bit about what's going on with Tati and James Charles and and what any of that means I don't know but she mentioned that recently there has been a big cosmetic company called wet-and-wild or I don't know that's their product line or whatever but they claim to be cruelty free and that if you're unfamiliar is that they don't test their products on animals and I don't know where they make their products but apparently if you say if you make a product outside of China and you sell to China then China will test the product on animals and so the

question becomes wet and wild as made a made a point to use the hashtag cruelty free in their social media it's something they brag on they don't personally test on animals however if they're selling to China either directly or through a distributor they are indirectly endorsing it I guess since they know that part of the the chain of how things have to happen is that they get tested on animals so is it fair to use that tag I guess that kind of to me that kind of went around too is it fair for stone wire games to say that they're their friendly local game store friendly if they are selling to a distributor that is then selling to Amazon or Target calm or walmart calm and man it is just as foggy and murky as ever because I see when I when I look at it from like that makeup perspective I mean that makes so much more sense to me than is it friendly late local as FL GS friendly and because an animal is potentially being hurt I think maybe there is more morally wrong with selling to China versus the fact that nobody is physically or nothing is physically getting hurt by Jaime selling to flat River than themselves to Amazon however

I know that we're also talking about Mon pop shop that store owner their livelihood and that these small stores tend to do more for communities than these big stores so it's all very gray not for me personally I don't think Jamie's wrong for saying he's F LGS friendly because he wants them to survive and he has newsletters for them but at the same time this this practice of selling to flat flat River group also impacts the Mon pop shop so that's that's hard for me to kind of wrap my mind around but at the same time like then if I if I think about it from Stone wire Games the company not it's too easy to personalize this and say this is Jamie's doing Jamie is the sole person behind this because he's not he is certainly the face man he's certainly the majority owner and I think if you ask anybody that they would say the same thing stomer Games is Jamie Jamie is stone layer games but he does have partners he does have shareholders and he's beholden to them just like any big box company is beholden to their shareholders now I don't want to I don't want to get into that argument either because there's so much bad I guess bad intention with some of these big-box retailers and the things that they'll do to provide for

their shareholders and again that's a personal opinion that's not I don't think I can monetize that or prove it but I think Jamie also has to do I think stoneware games also have to see I'm already doing it these things are looking to change when they shouldn't be or maybe they should I don't know but he has to do what's right for himself for his partner for the shareholders is it right by them to go ahead and say hey we're not gonna sell to a flat River group because that is going to cut into what he's obligated to do for them and for himself in in certainly everybody knows that Jamie is like a hundred percent available in around for us so asking him to do something to harm his own well-being seems strange and counterintuitive to you know what I mean it seems weird to me to also say hey small company Jamie because he is a small company just like the mom-and-pop shops say hey hurt your company to help another small company that seems wrong to me - and so like I don't know why like this whole I mean I guess drama just by nature is kind of you kind of

look towards it right I mean you drive by an accident you don't want to see anybody hurt but you still want to see if somebody's hurt and it's it's such a strange part of human nature I don't know if there's like some kind of biological imperative there or there's something there's some explanation but I've been fascinated by by the I guess the accusations levied and the responses to and I sometimes find myself somewhere in-between which i think is is healthy I mean I don't think anyone wants to watch me who's commentating on Sohn Meyer stuffy and who is your sponsored by stone Meyer for me to just you know break out the whole like white knight thing and and Jamie is blameless and perfect in the eyes of the people and I don't think you want that for me I it certainly would not be natural for me I am perfectly okay with the people that I admire or the companies I admire being flawed and you know I know nobody's perfect and I think if there was some easy answer that Jamie could be fair to the people he's beholden to and could also be fair to the the friendly local game stores if there was some ideal way because I've seen some of that criticism level two in terms of you know something about demo copies and again we're personalizing

this and we're saying Jamie doesn't do this Jamie doesn't do that when it's stoneware games handle something a certain way you know maybe that was Jamie's direction but at the end of the day it's it's a company making a business decision it is not Jamie a person making a personal decision but I can also see the argument that it is you can see why this is so difficult to to discuss and kind of kind of come to a black-and-white answer where it's like no this is how it is you know you can put your I don't know you draw your line in the sand and say I can see the arguments for both I like I said I don't have a friendly local game store that I that I go into I go to Amazon in many cases so I want those games to be available on Amazon you know but I also understand the friendly local game star saying hey it's so easy to buy online it's almost a bigger inconvenience for people to come into our stores there needs to be some incentive and I know part of that incentive is you have personal sir and you have people that are very knowledgeable and very passionate about that particular subject that are right there available to you so if I you know if I want to know about cameras I can walk into Best Buy and some guys memorize the the card that says you know these are the the frame link I don't know anything about cameras you know these are the details about the camera

and they've just remembered memorize bullet points you can go on Best Buy that come and see if those bullet points are if you go into a camera shop you have some guy who's gonna tell you everything ISO white balance all this stuff I know a little bit more than I thought but you know it's it's so hard but it's something that it's so hard to kind of find a side to come down on because this matters to me in that I am associating myself with a brand and so I don't want them to be doing anything particularly heinous because that kind of reflects on me even though nobody's like hey how does how does this affect dusty nobody not even me really but you know ultimately where I come down on the side that I come down on I think and this has changed from day to day actually is that I don't think there's any wrongdoing or ill-will or evil intent on stone wire games behalf I don't think that they are looking to screw the friendly local game store nor do I think that they are nor do I think that they are doing anything to necessarily really provide something

that's going to drive you to a friendly local game store I think it's all kind of neutral and I know there's this whole demo copy thing I don't know the answer because there's there's cost involved in doing game store only promos but that almost makes me think like what if that was kind of a a a leaf or what a fig leaf like what kind of leaf is like a nice gesture I don't know that you know if that was like kind of like hand extended to say listen we're gonna make this particular promo or this particular item that's only available to friendly local game stores I don't know if that makes business sense if that would ultimately hurt more than it helps but then again we've seen like cool mint or cool mini no not cool mini cool stuff Inc we've seen them print their own little here's a promo code from for charter stone and you know so there's ways to that the the people themselves can go ahead and differentiate but again cool stuff is a larger company than most mod pop shops so I guess I'm really no closer to having the the solution then then probably any of the rest of us are but I kind of want to share my thoughts because I kind of want to hear what you guys are thinking is well I'm not looking to drag anyone through the mud

or anything like that so if you feel super and negatively about the individual Jamie we don't need that in the comments I mean I can't stop you but it's one of those things where it's like let's try and keep this about the company and the company practices or you know if you can kind of see it both ways because it is a difficult if you're trying to be fair if you're trying to be fair and you're not like super biased in one direction or the other if you're superstone why you're fanboy or you're super f LGS fanboy and and you have had a hard time get ahold of one game or another you know if you're trying to come down in the middle somewhere you're trying to be fair I think you can see both sides of the coin and you know I just I would I would like to hear kind of like your thoughts on it your your opinions if anything related to pardon me anything that I say a said sayed said in this video and that's really all I have for you this week yeah it'd be good to one another I have said it the last few weeks and I just want to I just want to keep saying it be good to each other you know this is a rough ride sometimes this thing we call life and there is certainly no shortage of criticism and critique if there is somebody that you enjoy what they're doing make sure you tell them let them

know build them up we need more people building people up out there I think so thank you so much for watching if you have by chance heard my dog snoring throughout this entire video because to her I am the most boring person that lives or at least the topics I talk about our if you've heard her snoring I'm so sorry hopefully she's not doing it next week but I'm not gonna kick her off the couch either all right so thanks so much for watching I'll talk to you guys later take care of each other take care of yourselves bye Olive Branch yes I met extend the olive branch okay you know this is gonna be like one of those little clips at the end

Progress saved