Terraria: The Board Game Review: The Long and the Long of It
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassal today we're taking a look at Terraria the board game. So this is based on a video game, a video game that I have enjoyed so much like almost 10 years ago now that I played the video game that I I went through and actually beat the video game. Terraria is basically a two-dimensional version of many of the different building games out there most famous being Minecraft of course, but it's not just building in this game. You build houses and and places, but you're also Terraria is all about exploration. You go through different biomes through a jungle biome, a sand biome. You're finding weird and strange enemies. It's very mystical. You'll find some fabulous equipment and upgrade and eventually digging down deep into the earth to fight the evil wall of flesh. So I like that. In fact, this board game coming out made me tell my son about it and so I got him the the video game for the switch and he's playing through it now. Although he's complaining that it's too hard.
Little does he know. So this is a cooperative board game for one to four players that is attempting to take that video game and bring it to life. Video games are often brought to life with a lot of success. Let's see how this one does. I'm going to show you some bits and pieces about how the game works hopefully enough to give you an idea about it and we'll be back. I want to start out by showing everything that's in the box. You have a lot of different trays in the box. These are different materials that you can harvest along with tunnels that will cover up the caverns. There's a lot of dice in here, specific dice for the players and then dice used for attack and defense. Then all the different monsters that you run across. When you run across a monster, you'll find that monster in a certain terrain type and a certain level and then you'll be pulling from here. There's also a box for each of the bosses. There are six bosses.
Um there is two card boxes that are full of cards. And we'll talk more about that as time goes by. And then this one here has the terrain tiles for the game. And then we have a book, and this is a pretty important book for the game in which whenever you craft things, this will tell you what it costs to craft them and what they do. And then on the flip side, you can see different monsters and what defense and attack these will do to you when you run into them. You also have player boards. You have this board. You have an objective board. You have this NPC board. And you have these very unnecessary line of sight uh things that you can play with. This is the way the board looks like when you begin. You're starting in a biome, and this biome is the forest biome. So you have these three tiles, and then one tile underneath. The tile underneath the biomes is sort of all the same. As you move your characters around on this board, you'll be drawing new things. At the beginning of the game, you'll put some tokens here to show what random biomes. There are five different biomes.
You'll use three in every game. And then two biomes, the shadow and the brimstone biome. These will be used You'll use one. Basically, think of it as the bad guy biome. Whenever you move to a spot, you will then go to this biome. You'll find the the one that matches that type. So, let's say for example, I move to this spot, I'm going to find a level two. All level twos does are the same. Doesn't matter what biome. So I'd pull one of those out. I'd look at the next biome and oh, it's desert. So I'd go to desert and grab a random top biome spot and put that there. And this can be There's going to be three in each biome. So it's going to be three across, and then six more on each side. So a total of [snorts] 15 across, and then it can go five deep. Although, once you get to the bottom, you will always pull from the very bottom biome, which is lava.
Now, a couple of things about this. First of all, this is going to make your board just massive in general. It's going to be a huge board. And secondly, you use everything. So, these three forests are always going to be the top three forests. If I want to If I'm looking for the desert, these three desert pieces will always be the top three pieces. They'll come out in a different order, but those are always going to be the same. This is going to keep track of your game. And what's going to happen over the course of this game is players are going to get a turn, and then you're going to move this marker, and the bad guys will move and attack you if there's any bad guys on the board. Um and sometimes new bad guys will spawn, and sometimes the threat token will get moved. That's what these mean. The threat token gets moved one unless a boss is showing, then it gets moved two at a time. Which could end the game very quickly, but there are a lot of ways sometimes rewards that you get for killing monsters and bosses might be move it back one.
But you're just going to be walking this through, and that's how players turns. There's two turns that are night. That matters because different monsters come out at night. These spots here are for gravestones. Whenever you die, you will respawn and stuff, but you'll put a gravestone here. And when there's two per player, you lose. Or if this token gets to the end, you lose. Otherwise, how do you win? There is a pile of objective cards. And so, there will be 10 of these objective cards. There are 10 in the game along with some alternative ones if you want to change things up. And this is for one to two players. You just flip the deck and rearrange it to get the one the three to four player. And these objective cards are here. Whenever you do them, so the first time you dig a block, the first time you defeat an enemy, the first time you discover two biome tiles in one and first time you chop a tree. Whenever you do one of them, you will get the reward on that card and remove it. And then it gets here. I need to make wood armor.
Now I need to make a sword. And you're going to keep going through this, and if you ever make it to the bottom of one of these, so here I need to obtain a guide voodoo doll consumable by defeating a voodoo demon enemy in the underworld. When you get to the end of one of these decks, you win the game. Now, that's on normal mode. If you want to play difficult mode, then you have to get to the bottom of two of the decks. And the decks are very specific. These are about fighting, these are about digging, this is about exploring, and this is about building. And while they start off easy, it's easy to chop a tree, at the end, you need to have crafted all seven houses. You have to build seven different houses in the world. So, this is how you win. There's also one of the bosses is called the Wall of Flesh. And if you make the Wall of Flesh appear, it's a very difficult final boss, and you beat this final boss, you win the game automatically. But, you do not have to beat him to win the game.
You can simply just need to complete one or two of these, depending on how hard you want the game to be. Each player will get a player board, and they're going to start with a character of their choice in it. So, you can go through, there's a bunch of different characters that you can pick, and you can play with one of these characters. That character shows you what your defense is, and how many cards you will draw per turn. You also start with some weapons, so the starting sword, copper short sword, a copper axe, and a copper pickaxe. And then you also have a starting deck of cards. Each of the players go, you're playing basically simultaneous cuz it's a co-op game. You'll draw four of these action cards, and you will play them. As you can see, these are pretty much all the same. There's explore, explore, explore, and explore more. These all give you action points, so I have five action points I can spend on this turn. And sometimes they give you other things, like this gives you money, and players are going to be keeping track of money on a little card here that they'll be able to use to buy things. Some of them give you ways to add to your attack and or defense, and others let you pick another player to draw a card.
Now, as the game progresses, you are going to have the opportunity to buy more of these cards. You might meet different NPCs, and hey, now I can buy more explore more and put in my deck, or second winds, or somersault, and you might even find cards. Sometimes when you're going through, you'll just find a loot card, which might be a really cool card that you get to stick in your deck. So, maybe this is in your ready slot, where you can keep a card that you don't use from turn to turn, I get it, too. Um here I can decrease the threat level by one, but I lose four hearts to do it. Here, I get two, plus I get to draw a card from my deck or discard pile, and here it's one, but I get to draw three cards. So, players are going to be taking turns playing these cards to do various actions. Most of the actions that you're going to do are going to revolve around these three things here, the sword, the axe, and the pickaxe. When you move around the board, it's one dot is one movement, so you can move, and you can there's fall damage, you can even as the game goes by, there's chances to build platforms, so it's a way that you can jump up and move, you can jump up one spot. So, movement's pretty basic. The Another thing you do is with your axe, you can chop down trees.
Uh this will show you for each dot you spend, for example, I get one wood, but you still will roll a die and see how much wood from that tree that you will chop down. This tree, for example, has two, and when it is finished, you'll put basically a lock token on it just to show that that tree has or you There's acorn tokens, I'm sorry. Lock tokens go on treasure chests. Acorn tokens will go there. Although, at at the beginning of each day, this stuff will respawn and you can do it again. So, the axes are chopped down trees. Pickaxes will allow you to dig. Now, when you dig, you can dig downwards in other spots. Each of them is going to The pickaxe will allow you, again, to spend a dot to dig a certain amount. So, this let me I could dig two, although I would dig one at a time and then fall down here at the bottom, which would give me a spider web token.
But, some spots when you dig them are going to give you resources. Now, the game allows you with your starting thing here, you have these resources put on here. So, I have wood, stone, webs, and this. Whenever I get one, I would just make the die go up by one. If I get a resource that's not on there, let's say I got this, I can stick it here, or I could even take another slot. If you're playing three or four, all these slots are not even unlocked. You have to spend gold to unlock all your slots. But, these would keep track of different resources that you have to you'll be able to craft things. So, digging is a good way to help you find your stone, but you will be able to find metal throughout the game. And then the final thing is attacking. And attacking you're going to be doing against an enemy. They'll also be attacking you, and it's done kind of the same way. Attacking works thusly. Your weapon's going to give you a certain amount of dice or die to attack, whether an enemy will have defensive dice. And if they're attacking you, it's the same thing. You will roll these dice. If you have any cards that allow you to, you can increase the defensive roll by that amount, or you can use these to add to an offensive roll. So, in this case, let's say the enemy is the purple one, so they had two of these four-sided dice. So, their highest die is a three.
Each of my dice that is equal or higher to the highest enemy defensive dice. Their highest is a three, so I would do three damage here. Now, realizing if the enemy has or you have a a let's say I have an eight-sided die, and I roll and they rolled a seven, then none of my dice would do damage. But, that's basically how combat works. You're going to just roll your your attack dice against the enemy defensive dice. As a free action, you're going to be able to upgrade and build better things. There are new sets of armor, there are new sets of various weapons that you can get or axes. You know, for example, the better pickaxe will allow you when you spend one dot to dig four times. Many of these need a forge to build or maybe a hell forge to build as you get down to the harder things and they require different resources. Then you'll have these bows which do less damage but they have a ranged attack. And so you're going to be able to build these things using the resources that you have gathered over the course of the game.
Players will need to build houses and the game comes with various houses that you can build that you don't need to be in or anything. You just need to have these built to be able to put these weapons together. And as the game goes by, you might be able to get armor which you put on top of this which will change your defensive dice and maybe even change other things. For example, this silver armor, if I put this on gives me four cards I draw but I always have one dot as an action and it gives me two six-sided and an eight-sided as defense to build. And that's going to be the same way with weapons and things that you will draw. There's all kinds of cool things you can get. I might find, for example, a gold broadsword. So this when I spend a dot is going to do three six-sided dice as an attack, which sounds pretty awesome. But maybe later on I get the light's bane which costs two but it gives me a six and two eight-sided and I draw a card. Or I get this volcano sword which spends three but it's two eight-sided and a 12-sided and the enemy doesn't retaliate because if when you attack an enemy don't kill them, they're going to hit you back. So you're going to want to improve everything. You want to improve this so you can dig better, this so you can chop better, and this so you can fight enemies better, and of course your armor so that you don't get killed on the enemy's turn. Characters will also be keeping track of their health. You have a maximum amount of health that you can have. It can go down but it can't go past it. Although there are ways to increase your maximum health and you also have this mana that you can spend which doesn't take actions and can be used to shoot off some different magical weapons and things that you find. There are different enemies, boss enemies. The
first one you'll probably run into is King Slime, but it could be another one. Each enemy has something very specific. So, for example, King Slime says, "Every time you defeat a slime enemy, and they show up around your camp at the very beginning, you'll advance as when it reaches five, you'll flip the card." And when you flip the card, it will then tell you how to bring out the King Slime. So, these are all big giant bosses that you're going to fight. Although, like for example, when you defeat King Slime, you'll then take his crown off and in his second form, you then fight a smaller King Slime to beat him. And many of the bosses are like that. And each of the bosses is different depending on how many players are playing the game. And so, you'll have the boss out here, and it will show you their defenses up. But, there's chances that more defense can be added to it, or more can be added to their attack as the game goes by depending on how long it takes you to beat them. And each of the bosses will have different specific rules that you play. And there's six of these different bosses that are in the game, and they'll all play slightly different. And you won't come across all of them in the course of the game, but you could come across a lot of them. You'll definitely come across two or three. And as I said, there's a whole book here. There's a book that even tell In this book, it tells you all the bosses and how they come about, but it also shows you all the enemies, their attack, their defense, the gold that you get for defeating them, or other things.
Sometimes when you kill an enemy, you'll get some loot. If you find treasure chests around the board, you will also get loot. And there's also NPCs that can show up. Many of these NPCs, they're on a board here, and each of these will show up like this one says, "When all six Forest Cavern tiles are discovered, and a house is available, then this person comes out." And some of them will let you buy more cards. So, for example, the Guide NPC who uh he's he's available at the very beginning. But, this person who gives you random consumables doesn't come until a merchant and the merchant has spawned, and any player has three different level three consumables and a house available, then this person will show up. So, you're building houses for these guys to come into and they'll give you different benefits. There is a lot in this game. I've showed you just a smidgen of everything and it's going to take me a long time just to put the stuff I showed you away. When we cleaned up our game, it took almost 30 minutes to put everything back into the box. It might have even taken longer than that, but we were working pretty fast.
Now, I've mentioned this on the channel before, but this is a pretty big deal and this needs to be stated very clearly. The side of the box says 45 minutes per player. Now, the fact of the matter is board game companies always stretch this and they make it shorter than it really is. They'll say, "This game's an hour." And you're like, "That was definitely 90 minutes or 2 hours." This game is not 45 minutes per player and it's not even close. My son and I, when we played through this, it took us 9 hours to go through it. This was over the course of several nights. It took us 9 hours to go through it and that was with me as fast as I could expediting things and working really fast to make the game go smoothly and quickly as possible. It took that long to go through.
And that was with two players. Now, technically, you could play simultaneously and as quickly as you can and ignoring what other players do and I think the game would go faster, but I cannot see a situation where this game is shorter than 4 hours. Now, long games aren't necessarily a bad thing per se, but what makes Terraria pretty bad in this respect is there is no save state. The first time we played this, I was like, "Oh, man, we played for 3 hours." And I feel like we just started. And so, we took pictures of everything and packed it up and then realized later on that we have a game table, so we could leave it set out. And that's what we did for the remainder of the times we played it. But not everyone has that. And very few people have 9 hours to play a board game. It's kind of inconceivable to me that they did not have a save state in here.
Another negative thing about it is it's so fiddly. There's so much going on. I mentioned it took us a while to clean up, but during the course of the game I I do this and cover this with this token and do this and then search through this deck of cards and pull this and go here and fight this and find a monster and put that there. Now we killed the monster and I put that monster back and Wow, there's so many pieces. It's all over the table. The box is not particularly huge, but there is so much in there and so much going on that you need someone in your group who's going to be consistently be like da da da da da da da da da da. And keeping things on point. Now, the components themselves are very well done. I like the player boards. Um I like the the different the the dice are beautiful. The the card art is good. The putting the clear card over your character. I enjoy all of that stuff.
So let's talk about gameplay. Gameplay, it is a deck builder. It is a deck builder. You're playing a certain amount of cards per turn. You play these cards and you move around and do things. There are some issues I think with the game itself. The actions that you have, move action is incredibly slow. Once you get spider web, you can build a rope that lowers yourself down, but if you go down in the depths, it takes a while for you to come back up. You can build these little points that let you warp, which will help definitely, but if someone's like, "I'm over here." Especially if you're playing multiplayer, "Come help me." It can be a bit of a trick to get over there and get back to that spot. And I So that is an issue. Also, the three main abilities, mining, chopping, and fighting. We really were struggling to figure out why we wanted to build an axe of, you know, these major axes to chop more wood at the end because who cares? Wood's mostly used.
Yeah, it feels like a chore. We need to build another house. All right, go to the top, get some wood. There are some spots where there's wood below ground, but it's mostly at the top. Well, digging feels so much I mean that the mining feels so much more enjoyable cuz you're get I got some gold, I got this, I got that, and and I'm building these cool weapons and armor and things like that. Combat is interesting, but it's a complete luck fest. It really is. Yes, having higher dice matters, but they're still higher dice. And I I find that a little crazy about the game that I'm rolling three eights out of dice against maybe something that rolls a single four-sided die, and I might roll a one, two, and three, and it rolls a four, and I have missed completely. And that's fine to some degree, but when the enemy hits you and it just it it it it feels a little unsatisfying cuz it just feels crazy lucky.
But another issue with the game is that once you beat a couple of the first bosses, specifically if you find the bee boss and beat the bee boss, as the game progresses, you feel pretty powerful. It's pretty easy to take out everything in the game with the exception of the bosses which are tricky. And bosses also kind of bring the game slowing to a crawl. It's like, all right, let's put the boss out. What are the rules for bosses? How do they work? They move around, they're pushing us. How does this dude things? As opposed to when you're playing the video game, you get in there like, "Oh, I'll fight the boss." And you're you know, you just you just enter into that mode. The bosses are cool looking in the in the pieces for them are fantastic. And I love like you saw that slime where I pulled the crown out, put it in, and there's the the heart of Cthulhu which or the brain of Cthulhu which you open up and there's a heart inside. Man, that stuff's really neat, but this fighting in this this combat system feels a little unsatisfying.
My favorite part about Terraria, the video game, was the exploration. And that's here a little, but again, you can see every tile, you go these different directions, and it just doesn't have quite the same ring to it. Unfortunately, at the end of the day, Re-Logic here, or Paper Fort Games, sorry, not Re-Logic, Paper Fort Games, Re-Logic made the video game, decided that they were going to try to copy Terraria as much as they possibly can. And I think that almost does a disservice because I can play Terraria. I can even play Terraria with other people. And so, for me to play this board game, what is this board game going to give me over the video game? So, a good example this would be Slay the Spire, which recently came out a few years ago, where I'm like, why would we need a video game of Slay the Spire? Because the video game had such cool cooperative things that were part of it. This tries to do so, where there's a lot of cards that are like, let other people draw cards.
But that's it. And I guess we can fight monsters together, but it feels like a lot of work to do all that. Well, I've just played the video game, it's a lot simpler and easier. And what So, what is the board game giving me above and beyond that? Uh the the There's the the combat, there's all the different things going on, and like I said, the pieces moving around the board, you're going to forget what pieces are where. The cards that you buy for your deck as the game goes by that eventually let you start culling cards from your deck. But there's also a lot of cards in there that they sound cool in theory, but I think as the game goes by, you kind of stop caring about cards. You upgrade to the best weapon that you can, you upgrade to the best armor, and then you're just going to run down and try to finish your goals. To that end, I want to say a good thing.
I like the objective decks a lot in Terraria. I like the objective going through them and trying to accomplish them. I find that to be interesting, they give you rewards. I like the things that you can do with money and buy extra cards, and eventually cull cards from your deck. There's a lot of cool stuff that I think that this game is pretty good. But at the end of the day, after having played this, I don't want to play it again. I got to give it a negative rating. I got to give it a five out of 10 because if you ask me to play this, I think I would say no. Now, the number one culprit for sure is the fiddliness of setup and teardown mixed with the length. That is just a bear to get over, but I would get over it, and I have gotten over for other games like Awaken Realms and stuff, because the gameplay is so immersive and fun. Here, sometimes I'm just like, my turn was just me crawling across the ground and going, or I went somewhere and a monster spawned, and I just spent time fighting this monster and got a little bit of gold, and it just didn't feel worth it.
I've I said this before, and I mean it. I think when you are sitting back on the couch and playing a video game by yourself, grinding, which is just playing the video game to get more stuff, is fine. You just mind mind mind mind mind. You kind of turn your brain off and you do that. You might be watching TV show at the same time, but there's it's it's just something that people do in video games. I don't think that translates to a board game. I want a board game to have more steps, to be more interactive, and Terraria feels like a grand experiment. I don't necessarily want to blame Paper for it. I think they did a really good job, a much better job than I expected. I expected this to be some sort of just trash pile, and it's not, but I also can't say it's great, either. I I I just can't. I I I feel like the lack of a save space for state for a game that's long is going to keep most people from ever playing it.
And I'm telling you this now, anybody There's going to be This always happens in the comments. Someone will come be like, "Well, it only took us three hours." You are speed running this at the speed of light. I'm sorry, it is just not For me and my son, we are fast as we played this, and it took us a really long time, and for the vast majority of people, it's going to be that long. But, the deck building part of it, and you have this little deck, and getting stuff, that feels good. It gives you those little jolts, and then there's a long, really boring time as you sit there and go, "Oh, the next objective is objective chain is to build another house." I didn't want to build a house, but I guess we got to climb up to the surface and get some wood, and then we got to go explore and we find things and sometimes you find amazing stuff in treasure chests and then it feels like the game's broken cuz you're just walking through and doing really well, and other times you're scrambling to find anything. It's a mixed bag.
I think there's going to be some people out there who enjoy it. I really do. But I don't think I'm on that on that ship. I I I I think I have to pass this one up because it just it has the potential. And they did interesting things. And I'll say this, it does not feel like a cash grab at all. It feels like they really tried. I just don't think it works. I think it I think it's a failed experiment. I'd love to see some of this stuff maybe in other games and I like to see it done. And I honestly [clears throat] want to go back and play Terraria now with my son. We're going to sit there and play that together as a video game and yay, we we found something good from this. Uh but for now I just I just can't recommend it. I I I think there's a lot of issues with it, but hey, maybe you feel differently. Let me know in the comments what your thoughts are on Terraria the board game. But there you go. I'm Tom Vasel. We'll see you next time on the Dice Tower.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you liked this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.