Skip to main content
Loading video...

...and now for a negative review: Applejack

Transcript 18:09

hello today we're going to take a look at a game that I don't like and uh in this review we'll also talk about maybe the value of negative reviews because um I've been I've been publishing a lot of excellent recommendations lately and I don't publish very many uh bad board game reviews because uh for a few reasons actually first reason being that the games that I have the games that I review I like to keep and I like to keep and review and promote games that I really enjoy now I could just take every game that gets offered to me without any discretion in just you know review them all but the value that I typically see is I want to be able to provide families with recommendations for games that they're going to enjoy playing with their kids and yet it makes me wonder uh you know do people do people watch this Channel and think well gosh does he just does he just like everything so it seemed like it was time for a negative review we could talk about what about a game I don't really appreciate so so there's that also how I do things on this channel uh this is a pretty small Channel I'm getting very close to 5 000 subscribers which is excellent yet in the world of board game

reviewers this is still a pretty small Channel so uh typically what I'll do to to get the games on this channel is I will either buy them so I'm spending money on them or I will write the Publishers directly and I will request a game and usually when I do that it's because it's already on my radar for some reason so occasionally somebody will email me and they'll say hey we're publishing this game do you want to review it and if I am looking at a game that I've never heard anything about before the first thing that I do and I respond to people in emails and I and I ask for the rule book and I read through the rule book and I try to get a sense is this something I would even be interested in buying in the first place and sometimes I just decline thank you for your offer I don't really think this is a game for my Channel or for my for my audience um other times I just play games on board game arena which is what we're watching in the background here this is a board game arena game that's in progress for Applejack and so today I pulled one up this is by uve Rosenberg the game Applejack and uh it came out in 2022 and this is a tile placing game now there are elements of Applejack that remind me a lot of Patchwork if you're familiar with Patchwork and by the way uve Rosenberg is the designer he comes out with games every year he's brilliant he has made some of the classics Agricola and the harv and you know many others

um a lot of people love Feast for Odin that's why I'm not a big fan of but anyway let's take a look at what's going on in Applejack so in this game you are trying to collect honey and uh the the winner is going to be the person who has the most honey at the end of the game so we can see on this player's board they they're placing honey or they're placing tiles and immediately whenever you place a tile on the board you're going to get the honey if the beehive touches another beehive you'll get the honey of the Lesser value so if you're looking at these two tiles beehive is touching a beehive so in this case this player would have received four honey not six honey four because four is less than six and in this case they would not have received any honey because it's not bordering a beehive but if we look over here seven and six these beehives are bordering so they would get six honey so you're placing a tile trying to get honey from that that's that's the first thing you've got going on over here is the market where you're going to be picking up your tiles and there is a die this little die is called the Apple Jack and so it's moving around this spiral shaped track much like Patchwork and when it lands on the space the player whose turn it is can choose uh if they want to buy a tile from the left or the

right so since the die is right here this player can buy the tiles over here or they can buy the tiles over here and the price they pay is the price written on the honey so this tile costs to this tile cost six this Kyle toss cost six as well ah now right off the bat when I saw this I thought this was weird because the price is printed in multiple places on here so you know it's printed three times over here and two times over here and so what's the purpose that doesn't really matter actually they could have put in the price the price has to match the honey I the the pricing and the income thing I found it so strange I was already kind of kinking my head like what why don't they why do they have to put it on the beehives anyway so there's more on these tiles aside from the honey cost which is also equal to the honey income and then of course you got the location of the honey around these excessive ground sides but then you've got the types of apples so you're placing apples on this board over here this is the player's board and it's creating different areas so you they've got an area here for green apples uh these three tiles here here and here and then they've got another larger area of these Brown apples brown brown brown brown so there's four tiles in the brown area three tiles in the red area uh two tiles in this purple area so you're counting up the number of apples that

are adjacent to each other those are an area now why do you want apples to go together because every time Applejack moves along this track like it's about to move over the purple and the orange apple as soon as it moves over the purple and the orange Apple uh players are going to collect income for the areas that are together now that means that when this crosses over this player is going to score their purple areas so three apples over here and then they've got Orange let's see they've got two oranges so you so they're scoring this they're scoring this but then then for each area you subtract the number on Applejack so Applejack is subtracting two are you following me now is this sounding a little tedious yet so you got to count all your areas then for each area you're going to subtract Applejack so in this area we have three purple apples but we subtract two so that means one honey and then over here you've oh it's actually see first I thought it was two orange apples but it's actually three because this one kind of looks yellow to me which is also similar to the color of the Beehive but no matter this is an area of three oranges so we have three oranges minus two for the Applejack value means one so that player would have gotten two apples on that turn you're doing this every single turn counting the apples in different areas now why does it matter the apples are together the apples that should be together because if they're together you only subtract Applejack once for each area

so if you have three areas with purple apples then you're going to have to subtract Applejack three times so it's better to just put them all together into one area that way you subtract less often that's the whole thing it sounds like a counting nightmare it's like a counting game where every turn everybody just gets to count all their colored things whether or not they camouflage in with the beehives wait that's not all if you haven't had enough counting yet let's go into the next level so uh every time apple juice so Applejack's got this shape right he's going round and round and round every time Applejack crosses this wait is the bridge oh shoot it's the every time Applejack crosses this flower we're going to do the flower income what we already have apple income why do we have flower income let's take a look at flower income you're going to count all of your flowers so get ready for this how many flowers on the board if you're looking at this board like I'm looking at this board you're going oh there's numbers there's apples there's what the oh flowers there's flower okay flowers uh one two three did I miss any no look at I take so much effort four five six seven eight oh eight that means I get eight no no no that's not what you get you get eight multiplied by Applejack so Applejack's value was two at that time so you would get 16.

now after the income Applejack increases to three he increases each time so now Applejack is three the next time you go around count all the flowers multiply by aquable Jack again so you are adding and subtracting by Applejack or you're adding and you're multiplying by Applejack and you're doing this every single time that goes around and then and then you've got the hexagons that have the beehives in different locations so when you're buying the tile you have to like crank it different like you know you put it here it's gonna okay like here let's look at this example they want one that's going to touch these two because of the income oh but they placed it so that they didn't get an income that's interesting I I would have thought they would have placed that so that the 4 Touches the six and get the four income but I don't know maybe they're doing something else or maybe they're playing for the first time anyway um oh you so much so much to think about and explaining these rules the only reason I wanted to explain all of these rules is so that you could hear how ludicrous it all sounds counting and matching and colors and Apple Jacks and multiplying and dividing or minusing no no dividing okay but wait hold on a second so at the end what do you think happens at the end so you end the game and then that's it right like Whoever has the most nope then you do Apple scoring one more time and then you don't wait oh man wait hold

on a second I got the rules over here you do Applejack scoring one more time this is real this is the rule book oh wait yeah you can see it okay so and then you subtract Applejack again for all the different areas so here you go apples apples apples apples subtract subtract subtract subtract and then you double it you multiply it by two every single time and then you do wait where's the flowers and then you do flowers one more time oh here it is at the end then you do flowers one more time and then you look at how many different apples you have and you add up the bonus so if you have all seven different types you get 35 or you can get 21 or 11 or four so this is like some serious points out with hundreds and hundreds of points but just so much counting for like what's the payoff what is the what is the fun in this game okay let me talk about my thoughts on this game and and you know I'm not saying the game doesn't have any value I can see the payoff I'll talk about that too and I'll talk about why I don't like it so first of all thematically when I have a game that has this much going on I want the payoff to happen in the theme I want something to be meaningful about this game to be exciting about this game this is an extremely dry game there's not there's no vision in here you're not making an orchard you're just it's just abstract symbols there's it's a very abstract payout and for a game it's that abstract I don't want to have this element of luck I mean oh we didn't see this but

um when you can't pay for the apples you flip it upside down and there's sheep on the other side so you can actually just play it upside down take the sheep and the sheep gives you two uh honey but you know clearly as you can see this person playing um you don't want to uh you don't want to do that if you can avoid it you will so thematically there's just very little payoff mechanics if you're going to like this game you're going to like this game because of let's this game's about to end so let's jump over and just open up another one okay um if you're gonna play this game you're going to want to play because the mechanics that's all the game has going for it but explaining this game and understanding how these mechanics go it's like silly the the picture of the thumbnail of this video me just going like oh my God you've got to be kidding me this is so dumb I would say that this is a mechanics focused game but the mechanics just are not interesting to me at all so I would give mechanics a three I can see why somebody would give a higher score for mechanics if they you know got really into this game but it is very focused on mechanics it's just really dumb I can't grade components I don't even have a hard copy see once again I'm not going to review this game or request it because I'm not going to want to go through the materials strategy

clearly there's some some thinking about this game and actually this is where the game is pretty interesting there's some pretty thoughtful planning about how you put the apples on your board and when you get and the timing for the income but I the thing that kind of bugs me is that this is this is a randomized income but it's still really balanced you're gonna get the income eventually there's there's two teal apples there's two green apples where's the other one oh where's the other green apple I thought there was two of every type purple purple orange orange oh there's the green green green red red so there's two every type so you're gonna get the income eventually but what you can't control is when the the locations of these apples changes so I think maybe strategically what you'd want to do is try to get it so that you have brown apples on your board first because that income is going to be coming first and then much later in the game much much later there's an opportunity to get orange income and yellow income so maybe what you want to do is you know make sure your game is fueled by income from these apples first and then you benefit from those later so there's could be some income planning on that you're definitely looking at the moves you don't control where this die goes though so on the next turn this player makes a decision it's gonna land here and the next player has to decide between here or here now what's interesting is because you can decide on the next

hexagon or the previous hexagon you can actually throw off your opponent so if the player now had taken one of these two tiles thinking oh well clearly this is what my opponent wants I'm going to take it from them before they get the chance to take it that's pretty interesting I think this would be an excellent uh two-player game and probably not a very good three and four player game um but you know you can either plan to interfere with your opponent or you can take these other tiles that your opponent will not be able to access if they're better for you the tiles are replenished whenever all of the locations have less than two tiles on them it's another thing um and then complexity for a game this simple and this is what I don't like and you probably could already tell from the way I was describing it for a game this simplistic that mechanically simplistic the complexity is ridiculous this is like a seven on complexity it shouldn't be this hard the game is rated for eight and up and while I know a child could understand what's happening here like oh you place this here and because you place this here you get this many uh Honeys like they can understand it but then all of the factors that go into it all of the things that you're having to think about

honey flowers apples timing opponents moves but it's not intuitive I love complexity that is based off of a simple rule set really simple rules and there's all of this depth I love that this feels artificial to me that's the word boom that's the word this is artificial strategic depth they made it more strategic or he made it more strategic by adding more rules and the rules don't add to the game experience the rules just create mechanisms that that weigh into the decision making this is artificial complexity that's what I'm calling it not a game I'm interested in and that is how I do a negative board game review so what value is this did if you watch this entire thing I mean what you could tell from the thumbnail that I I was going to tell you this game isn't very interesting to me I guess now you know why but what do you think of negative reviews would you like to hear more of them do is this was this fun for you I don't know but it's been a while so there you go that's what I've got I'm gonna end this stream where's the button see you guys later bye-bye

Progress saved