Maya - First Play Review
Transcript
Hi there. I'm Jonathan with Getting Games, and this is my first play review for Maya. In this video, I'll be giving you a brief overview about how the game plays, and I'll be talking about what this game was like to play and my opinions on it once it was done. Now, what you're going to see here is a segment that was recorded for the Patreon supporters of the channel, and you can learn more about joining that by going to gettinggames.com/support. Now, if you have thoughts on this game, perhaps you've played it in the past, then I'd love to see that as a comment down below. Also, if you enjoy the video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons down there. Okay, let's talk about the game. This game came out in 2019, and I did not hear about it. Uh it looks like the kind of game that I would actually know about, but I just completely missed it until very recently when a bunch of my friends seemed to be wanting to play this game suddenly online. So, this game was designed by Trevor Benjamin and Brett Gilbert, and it's quite straightforward, but I don't mean that negatively. I I really thought this game was fascinating. And let's talk at a high level about how this game plays.
So, here we have a photo of what the game looks like when it's pretty much done. The board's pretty full here. And the way it works is everybody has their own supply of tiles in their own color. So, these are the blue player's tiles, these are the green player's tiles, and within those there are subsets of uh resources, like we have chili peppers and we have corn, etc. And you're going to be drawing a hand of these um like six or something like that at the start of the game. And when it's your turn, you do one of two different options. The first option is you can take as many tiles as you want from your hand that are the same type, and you can put them down onto the board. Every tile that you place has to be adjacent to a previously placed tile, and all the tiles that you place on this turn have to be contiguous in like a cluster. Then you're going to score them. Uh for example, let's say the blue player put down two more potatoes, and they put them like here and here. Uh then they're going to score for all of the potatoes on the tiles they placed and all of the potatoes of their color that are also touching. So, that means you have 1 2 potatoes plus 3 4 5 6. But if instead they'd put the potatoes over here, they would just score the two. So, that means if you add your tokens down next to your previous tokens uh that match the resource, you could score those tiles multiple times, and this is one of the ways to get a whole bunch of points in this game.
The other thing that you could do on your turn is you can expand a temple and then draw tiles. This is the only way that you do draw tiles. So, you're going to be putting tiles down, and then at a certain point you need to draw tiles back up, which means you're going to be taking one of your tiles, you're going to put it face down next to one of these temple areas that has already been growing, and that will just make it bigger. So, you are spending one of your tiles, and it will be gone. Like if it was a potato, that potato is gone. You don't have access to it anymore, but you've made that temple area bigger, and then congrats, you get to draw three more tiles. So, you need to decide what tiles you maybe don't care about so that you could draw more tiles that you perhaps do care about in that moment. Now, whenever a temple area is completely surrounded, you are going to score it, and you're going to count up the number of the uh resources, doesn't matter which resources they are, that are directly adjacent to that temple.
The person with the most of these is going to get the most points, second most gets less points, etc. And the number of points that you get depends on the size of the temple. You can see this little chart over here. If the temple has just one space on it, then nobody gets any points. If it has two spots on it, then the first place player gets six points, then three. And if you remember, in order to draw tiles, you have to put one tile face down in order to expand a temple. So, that means as you are drawing new tiles, you are increasing the victory point amount for the temples that are on the board already. And obviously, it probably makes sense for you to try and make the temples that you think you are going to win bigger, but by making them bigger, you're making it harder to score them because they get larger, so you have more tiles have to be placed to actually enclose it. So, that means maybe you don't want to do that. Maybe you're about to have one of yours enclosed, and it's a done deal. Maybe you just leave it small so that you could complete that and get those points versus making it bigger, opening up more opportunities for people, your opponents, to put their tiles down and actually swing that back towards you.
That's the main crux of the game right there. Um is just trying to score points for the tiles that you place down while also seeding the point value areas and vying for these majorities. And it's fascinating. I played this game just once. Um I really like to play this one more. For what it's worth, it's um getting re-inflated uh as a new game called Seagrass. I think they're changing some of the rules, they're adding some more stuff. It's coming from Bitewing Games, and I think it's going to be going up on Kickstarter soon. Actually, probably by the time you're seeing this, or if you're seeing it in the future, then it's long gone. But uh this one is getting new attention with a new theme of uh sea turtles and underwater, that sort of thing. And I'm I'm pretty intrigued by the look of that one as well. Um but coming back just to Maya, I I'm surprised I haven't heard about this more. Maybe people thought that the theme was too generic. I I don't really know, but this is my wheelhouse kind of game, and I really like it. I mean, one game that uh pops to mind uh pretty quickly, if you're familiar with it, is Babylonia, designed by Reiner Knizia, 2018-ish, 17, something like that. I think a little bit before Maya. And that is also a game where you have a hand of tiles, and you have the ability to put multiple tiles onto the board, and so you're trying to figure out when you're going to put a whole bunch down for that big moment. Um there's a lot of other differences going on. There's some majority stuff in uh Babylonia as well.
You can see some comparisons, but this one feels like its own thing for sure, especially considering Babylonia almost has route building kind of vibes to it, and Maya not so much. Um this one you're just, you know, trying to get the surrounding on those temples as much as you can while also, you know, getting your way through your deck. I mean, that's also part of it is that um I at one point was like, "Wait a minute, I've got a whole bunch of potatoes in my hand. I'm going to put a potato down and then score, and then put another potato down to score the previous ones, and then put another one down to score the previous ones." And so I'm just like re-scoring these tiles over and over again while opponents were just like throwing tiles at the board essentially, and the game ends once somebody places all of their tiles. So, that meant that I was not in a position at all to trigger the end of the game because I was going so slowly piecing these things down. Ultimately, I did not win. I came in second place, although I could have.
And that was one kind of funny thing about this game was the mental state that I had and how I was not flexible enough. In the beginning parts of the game, one of my opponents uh made a pretty big temple, and then he just put so many of their tokens around it. And I was like, "Well, that's just done. Like, let's just not help them complete that temple, so they'll have to do all the work and get those points." As the game went on, you do things are happening, that temple got a little bit bigger, and a moment came where that opponent completed that temple, and they let out a huge sigh of relief. And I was like, "Oh yeah, you scored it. Like, you were in the lead." And he was like, "No. Like, I was, but barely. All you needed to do was put three tokens down, and there are double tokens, as you can see out here on the board. He's like, "All you needed to do was put three resources down, and you would have taken that from me." And I was like, "Oh my gosh."
Like, mentally, I'd written it off. Like, I was like, "Oh well, you know, that's just way beyond what I could even do." And then based off of other things that were happening, the game state changed, and because I wasn't flexible, I lost out on on taking that. I totally could have, and I just didn't even think about it, and I probably would have won the game. Honestly, it was a huge temple by the time it actually scored. So, that was a significant loss for me just kind of focusing on other things. Um there were a couple other moments with other temples, nothing that's hard to parse, but just moments where I thought it was like X, and it ended up being like Y for one reason or another uh because I wasn't just being flexible enough with my my thinking things through. And it was my first time playing. So, I think that makes complete sense. So, yeah, I I don't have too much else to say about Maya beyond I'm really enjoyed it. I actually want to play it again. Uh I think odds are pretty good that I'll be uh really looking into that new version uh with the Seagrass. I think it's going to look beautiful, and they're adding some new things, and I'm not really sure about all of them, but at the same time, I think not all of them you actually need to play with. And uh the new version is also designed by the same designers of this game. So, perhaps they learned a thing or two after this game was put out. They saw how people really played it, and they're, you know, maybe going to tweak things in a way that hopefully makes the game even better. So, yeah, Maya, it's it's a big two thumbs up for me. I'm looking forward to playing this one more. It's absolutely in my wheelhouse.