Il Vecchio Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
Hey everybody, and welcome to Chairman of the Board. Today I'm talking about Il Vecchio, which is a two-to-four player board game by Rüdiger Dorn. Uh the game takes about an hour to play, and it's a Euro style game, so uh there's still quite a niche in the market for an hour-long Euro game, and um this one does that. Um Rüdiger Dorn is a designer I've generally really enjoyed his games, um games like Istanbul, um Caruba, Runestone, so he just makes really solid games that I tend to enjoy. So, um that was kind of my main, you know, peak of my interest in this game. Um it's a pretty dry game in terms of its theme, you know, you're basically these different noble families in the kind of Medici era Italy trying to um you know, overtake the different cities to gain power. Um the game is broken down into um five very simple actions, and each of your player turns is just going to consist of one of those five actions, and players just going to continue until there's a certain number of spots claimed by players um which is going to trigger the game to end of the game depending on the different player counts.
Um obviously the objective is to gain as many as you can, and you do that by moving your workers into these different cities and claiming these different spots. So, the five different actions are pretty simple, um and you're going to start the game with um a number of your meeples um already on the board. Um and you are going to either use one of these action spots, which basically lets you take in um you know, resources such as followers or different tokens that can give you benefits. Um and but the interesting thing about this is there is a number of um these middlemen um tokens or or pawns laid out on the board. And although there's a lot of spots matching those middlemen, only the one with the token on it is kind of um you know, active at the moment. And once a player uses it, then they are going to exhaust their worker by lying it down, which means it can't be used again um until you take another action. And then the middlemen token is going to move to the clockwise to the next spot of that matching um of that matching symbol, so you can't just keep spamming a certain spot because the the actual resource that's available from it is always going to move around the board. And because of that, you kind of have a bit of foresight in the game, you know, you know where the middlemen are going to go next, which means you can line up a few moves at a time, um which can be quite profitable.
The the second action to take is to actually cash in the resources you're going to gain. Um you you've got a uh three different types of followers. You've got the kind of religious followers, you've got the military followers, and you've got the assassins as well. Um and they are all assigned to a different one of these um kind of minor cities on the corners of the board. And if you have one of your meeple's on those cities, then you can take this second action, which is to um basically move those meeple's into the board into the or into that region um by cashing in those tokens and also by cashing in um a certain amount of money. And that money is going to scale up as the game goes on, so you're going to get kind of you're going to be rewarded for going quicker because it's going to be cheaper to get into those cities. And not only that, you're going to get more points in return for doing doing things quicker as well. Also, when you actually use one of those um those province actions to actually get your people into those cities, then you are going to um take a bonus tile as well, which can do lots of really cool things such as, you know, forfeiting the cost of moving into those cities or um you know, taking more followers um and stuff like that. So, there's lots of different kind of play you can use and you can trigger those when you like to have really kind of powerful turns.
There's also a main city in the middle of the board um Florence, um which works pretty much like the um like the other cities. Except in this one, you're cashing in scrolls, which is another resource, and then you're going to place them on the track um and there's two two sides of the track. There's like a council track and I think there's like a noble track. One of them is going to give you permanent that or permanent powers when you take certain actions in the game such as, you know, when you when you take um a certain follower, for example, you might get like a bonus or maybe get to take another one and stuff like that. So, it's it's it's got a little bit of um you know, unique ability in there, a little bit of engine building as you gain more and more powers that nobody else can have. The second part of Florence is um basically where you're going to collect different um end game scoring tokens. So, um you know, it kind of gives you a bit of direction and lets you squeeze more points out of the game by doing so.
So, um that's pretty much the you know, the focus of the game how you're going to get your points either you know, collecting resources and cashing them in in the different provinces. Um another action you can take is to basically roll a couple of dice and then put a new um a new worker onto the board. And when you put them onto the board um you're going to be kind of restricted to the number that you've rolled because they've got different kind of sections on the board. And there's I think there's three cities connected to each section which obviously depends on what what different rewards you can take um from those sections. Um if you roll a seven, you can also go anywhere on the board which is um which is gives you a lot of freedom and gives you a lot of um you know, a a bit more mitigation to do what you want to do. Uh another action is to simply stand up all your exhausted workers. So, obviously as you um you know, as you take more and more actions, your workers are going to become exhausted and um you're going to want to use them again so you can forfeit a whole action to stand them all up um ready for use again and you also get a little bit of money that way as well.
So, that's going to be basically the the flow of the game, you know, by taking those different actions in order to collect this resource and get them into those cities. Um but alternatively, you are not kind of restricted or you're not cemented to these different spots you've already put your workers on because before you actually activate your turn or your action, you can spend one money to move one of your um um one of your pawns or your meeples um you know, a coin for each road you travel or each city to a city point you travel. So, you've got a bit of freedom there so you know, if you're you know, a a a few spaces away from the token you want, you can actually just pay a couple of coins and um get to that city and then use that action um which is quite nice. You've also got um a few bonus tiles you can use as well. So, you've got um wagon wheels, all these different cart tokens which means you don't have to pay the fee to travel the road. You can just simply teleport to anywhere on the board, which again gives you lots of freedom and can really you know get things done a lot quicker and cheaper. And also you've got these bishop tokens, which means that you can um take an action even if the middleman is not there, but also um you can use it to basically not exhaust your worker as well. So if you use that if you take an action and expend a bishop token, you actually don't have to lay your worker down again, which gives you a lot more mileage out of your out of your workers and it means that you don't have to waste a whole turn standing them back up. Um it also means you don't actually move the middleman, so you can actually kind of spam it a couple of times to get the rewards you need. So uh that's basically the flow of the game. Um there's a great kind of um I love the idea of the way the different
middlemen move around the board. Not only to line up yourself, but you've also got to bear in mind what you're giving your your opponents as well because if I use this action and my opponent is stood in the next closest spot, then I know he can take that action next turn without having to kind of travel to do so. So kind of doing things in the right order can be you know it can be uh or can reap rewards and kind of give you the edge over your opponent. So I do like that. Um you know you can't just willingly willy-nilly just keep just doing things in your own bubble because you've got to be careful about what you're going to kind of lay on the lap of your opponent, which is always a nice touch. Um the balance of the game is quite nice in terms of um the different cities need different resources um and you know the harder ones to get give you more rewards. Um you know for example you need in one of the cities you need two tokens of one type and one of another, where in the other city you need simply just to expend one assassin token. Um and obviously that's going to be a lot easier to get than the um than the you know the three tokens. So um and points do kind of reward that. Um you also get kind of different incentives as well. You know you get additional five points if you get in each of the cities in each of the two Florence tracks. So, there's just a lot of different things to focus on. You know, you're always kind of money itself is quite a tight resource and you know, and you're going to need need it to get into the cities, but you're also going to need it to actually travel around the board as well. And also so something to bear in mind is when you actually move into the cities, you're actually taking a meeple off the board itself. So, again, you're limiting
yourself in what you can do in your future turns. So, having that constant flow of meeples on the board as well as expanding them is is very important. So, mechanically very smooth. Just take one of those simple actions and I like the way that the game is not broken down into you know, strict rounds. It's just simply a free-flowing game until a certain number of those spots are claimed. And once a Medici spot is claimed, then something bad is going to happen to all the players such as expending money or expending one of your tokens. Um so, something to bear in mind there. Um but it's not crippling, but something that can just throw a bit of a spanner in the works. Um so, the the time investment I think it is great in this one. Only takes about an hour to play, which as I said in the intro, it's a it's a bit of a niche still for Eurogames and in that respect, there's not a lot of competition for uh you know, hour-long semi-light Eurogames. I mean, this one I would give it a kind of a uh a medium light weighting. It's not light light, but it's certainly not your kind of traditional medium weight Eurogame. It's um slightly easier to jump on than a lot of those other games.
Um up time as well is excellent in this one because again, the actions are snappy. Um you can do a lot of your actions without having to bear in mind the other people or keep the other players waiting. Um such as when you claim a city token, you know, you get claim a city, you take a bunch of tokens, and you can kind of choose which token you want while the other players are cracking on. So, there's not a lot of down time to bear in mind, so the game does flow um pretty good. Um replayability-wise, um um, so-so on this one. I mean, it's nice the fact that it's it's got that niche in terms of being an hour, so it's quite easy to get to the table. Um, but also, you know, there's not a ton of tokens. And when you go to these cities, um, you know, you're always going to be using the same tokens and you can pretty much choose any of them. When you go to Florence, you can choose, um, I think you draw the top five and pick one of the the tiles you want. So, there's quite a lot of freedom there and you're not going to get completely shafted by, you know, only having to draw two and keep one. You know, you've got quite a lot of freedom to choose a a tile catering to your current strategy or or what you need at that time.
Um, interaction is good in this one. I really do like the interaction. As I said, just knowing what to what actions to take, um, because of the way the the middle men move. Um, you know, I love the way that, you know, you take an action and a player loves it because it moves them straight to the on on their plate, which is great. Um, also, the ramping up the up of the money as well is really cool. Um, again, incentivizing you to get into these cities quicker. Um, so, there's that tension of being thing getting things earlier because it gets kind of get more and more expensive. And, um, you know, knowing when to activate these different tokens you require is really cool as well because you can if you use them, um, you know, at its most efficient point, then you can really, um, get a leg up on your opponent. Um, component quality is is good in this game. I mean, it's you know, no complaints whatsoever. It's all good quality. Um, it's got that kind of traditional Euro style look. You know, it's pretty dry to look at, but I think it works well. Um, iconography is is really good on this one. You know, there's not a lot to, um, to memorize or know what's going on. So, um, it there's just it's just a it's just a nice level and nice kind of jumping on point without too much to overwhelm you.
Um, the theme wise, very dry. It's a Euro game. Um, but, you know, it it works absolutely fine. Um, our setup and teardown time as well is is really good. I mean, you got the number of different tokens or all of the different tiles in the different cities to set up, but you know, if you keep if you bag them all up individually, it's no real issue. And it's simply just allocating your workers onto the board and you're you're pretty much good to go. Um the ramping up of the game is quite nice because obviously there's as the game progresses, there's going to be more and more there's Medici spots taken on. So, the the tension to get into these cities does ramp up, but also the cost ramps up as well. If you acquire more and more of those engine building tiles, then you're going to be taking a lot more powerful turns than you are at the start of the game.
So, that's quite nice. Something I should have mentioned as well is at the start of the game you actually do get allocated one of those tiles for free. So, from the get-go you're going to have a unique power to you that nobody else has. And they're all very well balanced as well. Um and scalability-wise, really good. I mean, it's two to four players and it works well at each of those player counts. You know, game is not going to suffer from from playing at a certain player count. You know, good at good at every one of those levels. You know, two, three, two, three, or four players. Um and yeah, that's pretty much sums up Il Vecchio. It's a really pleasant game. You know, it's Don't get me wrong, it's not it's not revolutionary. It doesn't do anything completely new, but it just feels very enjoyable. Again, particularly love the way that the minute men move around the board. Um you know, decisions in the game aren't meaningless. You know, you are really thinking about how to get these resources quickly as you can to get into the cities. Um knowing when to use your cart tokens, knowing when to use your bishop tokens.
Because they are pretty you know, they're quite a luxury thing to have. Um and you know, if you have a certain player power, you really got to learn how to exploit that in order to get the most out of your turns. But yeah, a really nice game. It's um I said a nice entry-level Euro game. I mean, I made a a top 10 entry-level Euro games list not so long ago, and I think this one could have crept onto that top 10. So, um I do think a lot of this one. I think Rüdiger Dorn is a really solid designer, and I do look forward to any game he puts out because he just makes really good games. And uh this is another one of those. Um it's it's good in every way. I mean, there's nothing really I I didn't enjoy about the game. Um and yeah, so it's it's a more tactical experience than it is um strategic, but you can line up a few turns to um you know, to get to get stuff out of your or to to be as good as you can be, which is nice.
So, if you want an hour-long game that's fun, still has a bit of thought going on behind it, got a bit of player attention, and um it's also quite dynamic dynamic as well. So, um Il Vecchio is a solid choice if that kind of um intrigues you. So, um that concludes my thoughts on Il Vecchio, a really nice entry-level Euro game that's um you know, it's going to hit my table a few times to come. So, um it gets a good verdict from me um and well warranted as well. Just missing out on that very good verdict, but who knows, with more plays it could creep up um because I I did really enjoy it. So, uh that is Il Vecchio by Rüdiger Dorn. Um I hope you've enjoyed this review. If you have, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. Uh you can also support me by following me on following me on Instagram or backing me on Patreon. Um I'll leave the links below for those. Uh for everything else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.