Clank! Catacombs: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock to the D I'm doing a discussion over Clank catacombs this is the relatively newest edition of Clank there has been many many versions of this at this point there was Clank deck building game the very first one then there was Clank in space and then there was Clank Legacy and now Clank catacombs uh so to open this whole discussion up uh I should mention that I am actually not the biggest fan of Clank in general uh it's kind of one of those games that just I've always been on the outside like the outlier of of the the game itself because I know a lot of people really really like it and it just never clicked for me the very first one that I played I like I was like yeah this this is all right and I wasn't really a fan of kind of like the overall system like with the deck building and then the the stumble or the clink and then get in and get out uh mechanism just didn't really worked for me but then there was clink in space that I think was better because the original clink my biggest issue with it was the fact that you could uh go in get the very first artifact even though it's worth the least amount of points and get out and because you escaped it now speeds up the game and forces people to start I mean they have to go in and
get the a higher value and then also get out and they can just die that way I just didn't really like that system and clink in space made it to where everyone had to go a certain distance to be able to get an artifact and then get out so there was like oh there's no move two spaces get an artifact and leave you actually all had to breach a certain threshold and I thought that was a lot better and then Clank Legacy happened where I thought the writing was fun and the Legacy aspects of it were fun but it still was original Clank and also each game you didn't really know how to win so it was kind of like a crapshoot so we didn't really like clink Legacy that brings us to clink catacombs which I have heard a lot of people really really like and while I think it is better than original Clank I still am not a huge fan of J Clank and I have at this point narrowed down why I don't like it and I think that while it is a deck builder and that inherently adds Randomness I really don't like the cube bag element of it and and because of that it just adds a little bit too much Randomness that for a 45 minute to a 90-minute game it can just be very frustrating but why get this one over any of the other ones and the main thing is there are these now they're in a bag here but there are these catacomb tiles and this I this I do really like like I
will say I I do think this is better than original Clank and hell even better than Clank in space so if you're going to get any Clank I would actually highly recommend this one uh because while you start on the same uh starting spot which is basically these this colorcoded uh tile here uh that's pink or purple and blue and everyone starts on the Crypt and then you go down then you start unraveling these tiles and you just Shuffle these tiles and that's going to give you a sense of exploration out of all of them this game has the most explorative kind of feel now while the tiles aren't like super exciting you never know where you're going to come across and you have freedom and the orientation of how you want it to go so it's not like every tile is going to be kind of different so whenever you you're running around you can put them together so that it's like okay well I could go through like I could go if if I'm in this uh marketti I could put it like this so that I have to go down and I can actually get a miner secret and then use a lockpick to get a tomb uh or hey I found one that actually takes us to the first artifact but it costs three has three monsters I don't have any swords do I risk going through that for three damage to get the artifact it just it did have a bigger sense of exploration and you actually kind of build out the catacombs in this case um without really
having to just kind of see the same board over and over because I mean that's the thing is like it it is like the the other games are basically the same thing and what's really cool about having these individual tiles is there are cards very few there's not a whole lot but there are cards that kind of actually mess with that there's uh when monsters come out it causes the tiles to turn 180° so they kind of rotate so you're not quite sure which direction you're going I like the sense of you just have minor and major Secrets just out and you just if you come across something you just pick one up it it felt like you were actually exploring something and that was neat so that's the major gimmick of Clank catacombs other than that it's actually basically kind of the same thing you're doing deck building you have your stumbles and your things that cause noise you put your noise in there whenever you refresh the market if there's the dragon symbol you do a dragon draw and I just really don't like that in fact the last game of this that I played and I mean you could attribute it to well you took cards specifically that made noise it's like yeah but I also took a lot of cards that didn't make noise uh or I took cards that specifically removed Clank and removed noise from it but it's still just kind of annoying that the throughout the entire game someone had way more cubes
in the bag than other players and then but it was always their cubes that were still getting drawn it's like this isn't even like fun like yes theoretically in statistically your Cube should be getting drawn more but yet it always happens to be me so I'm always close to dying more than anyone else and you're the one that's been making all the noise why am I getting punished for that I just find that Cube bag to be completely random and it puts arbitrary stress on a player that's like specifically trying to avoid making noise but it's like oh you took a card that makes me put cubes out there uh you I mean everyone has stumbles in their deck so it's like I you almost always will be putting cubes unless you find ways to remove in trash cards it's like why am I being punished for your shitty gameplay uh and why do I have to go out of my way to try and heal whenever I'm getting damaged for just bad bad Cube poles because there's no way to really mitigate the bag because the Clank removal isn't from the bag it's from the Clank board so cubes that are out there that are ready to be put in it's like okay you can take away stuff from that but once they're in the bag they're in the bag and it's like that's always just a frustrating part for me in this in this game and all of the games really uh it's also it's also way longer than I'd like for a for a game of this type like
it feels like it should be like a fun jaunt into the catacombs and exploring but then it's like all right like we're not really coming across any artifact tiles so none of the artifacts are getting pulled out except for the five I guess I'll grab it and just try and make it out and that is kind of a downside of the tile placement is that cuz in the original games it was just a board so the board you would be like okay the five's right here the Seven's over here and all the way down at the bottom is the 20 or whatever it is okay so I know exactly where I need to go to try and get it but in the catacombs one the stack isn't seated it's you just Shuffle the The Depths which are the blue tiles you Shuffle those and then they come they come out so you might have games where it's like no one is really getting artifacts and then it's like oh it happened to be me that found the first one so I guess I'll Pi pick it up and head on out and then get my extra 20 points and no one else could everyone else now has to try and find it because in the whenever it comes around to my turn I'm just drawing cubes and then also if the if the bag runs out of cubes then it's like okay well now everyone loses so I guess I'm not a huge fan of that with where the tiles can just randomly never have artifacts in a timely manner so it could just be completely random on who happens to get lucky and that could be kind of annoying uh or if you're
playing a big multiplayer game and only two people find artifacts and it's like okay well I guess the other two people can just kind of like [ __ ] off uh or they really have to try and find one because you can't escape unless you have an artifact um and even if you get knocked out in like the safety area cuz every game has like a safety spot you can try and get to you won't get the bonus points but you can still score uh it's like you have to have have found an artifact and if the tiles are random and not every tile obviously has an artifact on it you might just get lucky and be like okay well you found one and now you're on your way out because you don't want to find another one you're just trying to rush the end game uh so I have to keep scrambling and hope I don't take any damage from the draw bag and and so you just kind of are top decking your top and then also the randomness of your deck if you're not drawing any movement like you're like I really need to move for some reason I can't because I apparently I'm an idiot Explorer or dungeon Delver uh my entire hand is all byy cards okay that's another round of that I have to try and survive and then okay I got some movement I only got one but that gets me to the next tile and there's no artifact here so I can't leave uh again I don't think this these games are bad I just think that for me in a game of this style it's too random there's too many
elements of Randomness now like I'm fine with the deck being random because it's not like my issue with Randomness if you watch a lot of like uh like games with dice or or deck building games like if you watch my discussions or run throughs for those my issues with Randomness stem from I'm fine with Randomness being uh upfront and then I determine what I can do with what I have versus Randomness dictating if I succeed or not so that's the two elements like in a deck builder which I love I love being because I don't have a predetermined like I don't have it in my head yet that I can do something so I haven't convinced myself or I haven't been like o i really want to do this so it's like okay like discard my hand next turn here's my hand to five okay [ __ ] I really want the movement I didn't get one what can I do with my hand Now versus the opposite where it's like I'd really like to move let's hope this die lets me you know tells me if I can or not and it can't so now I'm frustrated that's my difference here so I can handle the deck being random because that's also a byproduct of my deck building it's like okay I actively didn't pick cards that let me draw or I didn't pick cards that have a lot of movement um and to be fair like the the time where you can't get a move or something is very rare there are a lot of cards with movement but in the latest example of where I need I was like two spaces away from the exit uh and I had like literally this was the last game I
played of this uh I was two spaces away from the exit trying to because the other players had left already so I was trying to get out I was in the safe zone so I knew I was going to be able to still score but it's like all right well they all got the 20 points I don't know if my deck is going to be good enough to compete against that and I was two spaces away and my hand had zero movement at all it was actually it was the worst hand I probably had drawn since the beginning of the game it was just happened to be just super shitty any other game it's like yeah that kind of sucks but because there's a pressure on it now I can't do anything I'm like okay I've healed up a little bit yeah I can still die here but maybe I'll get lucky and then I went to the next player's turn they drew from the bag one black and three red which I was the red player and I had three health and I died and it's like that's just shitty like that's just so anticlimactic and frustrating to be like not only did I get hosed off the bag draw I got hosted off of my own deck and I got and I think yeah we yeah it was it was still like okay I didn't even really get that good of an artifact I kind of had to grab one and then really rush out um but but I mean I was still in the safe zone so I was able to get rescued and score my score was actually still really high surprisingly CU I happen to have a lot of high value cards but it's it was still like I don't really care because it's like the the theme of the game is to get in get an artifact and get out and I died because it's just it feels just so deflating um but yeah still out of all
of that everything that I'm saying about this uh I'm I mean I'm not keeping this like I don't I this isn't like for me it wasn't like oh I really hate Clank and Clank in space but this game completely fixes it it's still Clank so if you love Clank and like if but if you're tired of the staleness of the first one and the expansions you've played of Clank in space uh I would give Clank catacombs a shot it does do enough to kind of flip it on his head with the the extra elements there's lock picks that you have to that's another resource you can manage to uh get to very ious locations to make it easier to get to spots but you unlock it for other people to unlock rescue prisoners to get open chest to get secrets and and money and stuff like that the sense of the tiles is still fun and and gimmicky it it is fresh and this has a lot more replayability than I would even say Clank and Clank and space have uh technically has all of those have more replayability than Clank Legacy because that's a legacy game uh and I believe in the rule book it mentions yeah the party and the catacomb so the Clank and venturing party uh There are rules that allow you to mix that I've never had the adventuring party but you can mix that in here um so that's a thing yeah to mix Clan catacombs with the with the adventuring party expansion uh I think that's the only
expansion you can mix with this um set up the fixed game board to Clank is replaced with tiles okay never mind it I I thought they have these little spots in the rule book I thought it was talking about how you can mix the original Clank with this but it doesn't look like it leave the board behind with Clank catacombs a standalone deck building Adventure so yeah that's that's pretty much it um on a scale of 1 to 10 I'm going to give Clank
catacombs I'm feeling I'm feeling between a six and a seven cuz in my scale which is a Bas is the only correct scale five is average uh so six is slightly above average seven is good eight uh great nine like excellent 10 perfect um um I think I'm gonna give it I'm gonna be generous I'm gonna give it a seven like even if it has all the randomness I still like the tiles um the deck building is still solid like I like I whenever it was my turn I wasn't never like can this be over like it it never had that feeling I wasn't Dre it wasn't until the very end that I was like that's why I don't like this game so this did have the exploration I was still kind of excited to play it but yeah whenever came to the end and I was like that's right I forgot that the bag is very annoying but because of the new tiles and the freshness and like it has the replayability with the deck building and the replayability with the tiles this has a lot more to it I think they could support this with expansions to even make it even more fresh more so than the other ones so I'm going to be a little bit nicer and I'm going to give this a seven out of 10 uh which is good uh but yeah so that's my thoughts on catacombs
let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you