Task Force Impressions & Review | Vuca Simulations Sims | Wargame Board Game | World War 2
Transcript
hi everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome I'm extremely excited tonight to have Grant from pushing cardboard on the channel to talk about a recent Adventure we had at San Diego hison where we both played the game task force so in this video we're going to be talking about that but I do want to mention too that Grant has the fabulous podcast and YouTube channel pushing cardboard and if you haven't listened to it I should also mention that Grant your biggest fan that I know of is actually our dog because our dog has separation anxiety and when we go out I always say Hey Google Play pushing cardboard so our dog has probably heard you about 30 or 40 hours so thanks for joining I'm glad to be here and I'm um I I hope to meet your dog someday I imagine it will'll recognize my voice I think he will I know he's heard your voice for at least 50 or 60 hours now so but shall we jump in and chat about task force yeah we played this game at in San Diego and uh we neither of us had played it opposed before so it was our both of our first time to play it opposed on I had a terrific time I thought it was super fun yeah I I I had uh I read the rules on I had started the rules a while ago and i' done kind of like a first look video on it and then I read the rules on the plane on the way to San Diego um but I know you had played some of the like the learning scenarios before that we played the Midway scenario just to clarify too which is I think like the first or second full carrier scenario some of the earlier scenarios are kind of learning scenarios that they kind of limit the
mechanics and stuff right yeah this was the first the first or second one that has Capital ships and carriers and the whole the whole nine yards I think it's yeah I think it's the second one that has everything and it did have kind of everything yeah and I think I mean one of things you mentioned too I the biggest thought I had it was a blast I it was it was really fun that that game that we played I I I was I I had a great time yeah I think it I think what made it so fun is it it it gave that thing that you always want from a World War II naval game which is the cat and mouse of trying to find the other guy like that's like if you don't have that then you don't really have a game but right the the search and the search and then launch thing worked really well and we were both uh super tense every time we had a had a search check go against us yeah and I think the way when it started out you said because the Japanese have four carriers in the Battle of Midway um two larger ones and two kind of medium-sized ones and the US has Hornet Yorktown in the Enterprise three big powerful carriers yeah and I think you hit my akagi and sank it and then irreparably damaged the kaga so I couldn't launch so I had to and that was the morning of the first day right so I came in I was heading towards Midway I launched and I hit Midway with that air raid that you have to conduct as the Japanese player and then you had found out exactly where my carriers were and
you sent think you had two carriers in range right you had the Yorktown and the hornet in range and the Enterprise was off doing its own thing in the other side of Midway right it was out of range I think which which kind of reflect that actually saved me because I think if you had hit me with all three carriers you probably would have taken down another one of my carriers and I would have been dead in the water yeah as it was it didn't turn out that way right right because you think sorry go ahead yeah yeah no it's just you I sank one and crippled one of yours and then I'm feeling really good and then I think you sunk The Hornet and crippled the Yorkton Yorktown or vice versa it was like oh okay turnabout's fair play here right right right I think actually there was we we did that there was the one little goofy thing where we actually caught the was it the the second carrier in surface combat and hit it and damag and was able to follow up with the strike and take it down that's right yeah and then all good military battles the two commanders were were really hungry because we had skipped lunch and so we decided to to call an armist and head off to dinner leaving the mystery of what would have happen because it's a two-day scenario and we played the first day and we essentially Had Each knocked out two carriers of the other side you had a fully loaded Enterprise left and I had a depleted hear you and sawu the other two medium carriers so I think you had probably more at least as many planes and overnight we would would have lost contact with each other because you
throw out all the dummy task force yeah we we'd have to do the whole search search thing again but like the Enterprise is definitely uh the most fearsome ship left but those those zero Fighters with the there's a there's that the that rule that lets you split the zeros into two two half squadrons and like that lets you cover more territory so you can cover you can search or not search more but you can more in cap more in in your strikes it's uh yes unless you yeah it's it's really frustrating to see those those counters splitting two right right so I could I could really I felt like I had a good I mean the cap I had to still recycle it below decks but getting the cap up uh was easier because I could divide those up and chop up planes as they came in pretty easily too so yeah two counters equals four just like that yeah yeah and the other thing I liked about the game too that the the mechanic for um PL loaded and armed armed and fueled planes on the deck because if your carriers get hit when that's the situation and I think that happened a couple times in our I think you like the one that you sank it it almost sank like seven times because you blew up every literally everything that was on yeah you everything was ready on the deck and yeah so there was all this consecu consecutive damage or whatever whatever the rule is it it was like those planes just started going up yeah I think it was roll a die and it was a 50% chance they blew up and if they blew up that carrier was was essentially gone
which is historically what happened cuz the US planes caught the Japanese planes all on the decks with armed and fueled and just absolutely you know red havoc on the Japanese carriers there and that's another big part of the game um you know for anybody who hasn't played it you you you have to decide how many of your Fighters and your bombers uh you're going to have ready ready to launch then you can either you know put a few fighters in cap but you have to decide how many you're going to take uh on any kind of a strike mission youd go but when they're done the mission then they they come back and they have to go into reserve and then to ready so there's this cycle where you can catch the other guy with his Planes all in reserve as well where he's like you found him and he can't he can't launch back right right yeah yeah I know there was one time too where I was going I wanted to launch but I I didn't I had he had them all in reserve I didn't want to put them on ready because I knew you were going to hit me and it would it was like okay and you still caught me in one because I think it was your first strike was the fighters to kind of check out where I was and then your second strike went for for money and just caught me fully loaded on decks with planes and stuff so but I think that that whole like that that's I think one of the things that really that I felt like they executed well in the game was that whole like you kind of mentioned that sense of Naval Combat but what about your thoughts on the search the hunt and search the search and find metric and like the The Fog of War and the element there yeah that's kind of the that's kind of the key thing in a in a carrier
battle game right is like because once once you're found that if you can find the other guy before he finds you that then you can strike before he can strike and it can be game over so in this game you you put all your ships in task forces and each task force has a counter but you also get a whack of dummy counters right and then when you have to to find the other guy you have to launch searches from your planes and you there's a a cup full of um a chip pull me mechanism where the person who's being searched pulls a chit and it'll say if he has to say that it's been detected or not found or there's a third possibility where it's been detected but misidentified and that can happen as well so so there like it's not ju it's not an automatic thing you know where that that chit is on the that counter is on the board but you still have to go through this whole search procedure to find out if it's a dummy or if it's a carrier Fleet or if it's a capital ship Fleet right and we both did the I thought it was funny we both did the exact same deception mechanic which was to take two destroyers so we made a surface Fleet but yours absolutely fo fooled mine right so because I thought for sure the way the search detection went that okay this was actually a carrier Fleet I launched everything there and there were two destroyers yeah those those destroyers went down quick but they they did their job they did their
job the end of those destroyers yeah there was just planes everywhere I I I play I've been playing another game called from uh against the odds magazine called Clash of carriers and they they sort of they have a similar thing where you you know there's there there's dummy task forces out there you don't know which counters are real or not but rather than a chip pull they just H the person who's um being searched rolls on a table secretly and and again it says you have to say if you're if there's no detection or or there's like a um a kind of a precise detection but there's a few steps in between where you have to tell them but you can raise or lower the number of ships by two or four or whatever you can right so but it's it's a similar sort of thing where it's like you're you're searching hex's to try and identify where the where the real task forces are before you launch your launch your plans and I know when you set it up too you put the game boxes so you have the task force boards where you have all your ships and things and you put the we put the game boxes in between those so that we couldn't see each others and I felt like that was really helpful too yeah enh the gameplay rules suggest that but but it's not it's like it's one of those optional rules but it I mean I think it it really added some spice because like you said we both had that little mini ter little mini Destroyer force that right that tricked the other guy so that would have been more obvious
if we could have seen each other's displays I think yes yeah and also knowing like where the what planes were ready and what condition they were in and what was moving around and what we were trying to do I felt like if I had been able to see what your carriers were doing I would have had a better idea where they were and what they were and that two of them were there and one of them wasn't so I really liked having the Box up in front I do like I did like the hidden mechanic within the game too because I feel like when you have that big double blind system sometimes it can get it can get easy for mistakes to happen if that Mak sense like I was thinking on also who like I I'm lucky enough to have one opponent let alone have a third person who's gonna umpire some kind of a double blind situation right yeah like I really like the chase of the bismar and that but that has you know you've got two big full screens so you have no idea what's going on and in some of those mean are a little bit complex so you kind of both need to make sure you understand the rules really well there's also I mean an element of trust goes without saying you've got trust that the other person is telling you the truth and all do and not trying I I reckon that like anybody I trust everybody I play with that's I I'm not really you know yeah scratch them off later if I if they do something funky but that's right yeah yeah yeah know I'm in the same way I was actually just reading a book book about gameplay and the guy was talking about how you play to win but you don't really care if you win you know so and that's
kind of the way I am it's like I'm trying to win exactly how I I I feel like it's my duty to try to win to give the other person a good game yeah but it really doesn't like whether I win or lose I'm I sometimes I don't even remember like it's just right right exactly it's the bigger thing is is the story we make and exactly and I felt like that wasal games right it's like the narrative with we spin out of them and that's the thing that I felt like task force did really well was I mean we had a story at the end you know it really spun a really good narrative the gameplay I I had high expectations for the gameplay and it met them um and even I think exceeded them I was curious about how the whole hunt and search mechanic would work but I felt like that was uh very manageable um what about the game complexity too um well you know it's a big box and it feels like there's a ton of stuff in there and it feels like oh my God it's going to a heavy game but I don't think it's all that complex at all and uh like I'd only rate it maybe a five out of 10 I think this is this is a this is a way lighter game than Mark Herman's uh Pacific War or something like that this is this is like half half the complexity of that plus it gives you the those learning scenarios that kind of Step you up so that by the time you're at scenario four and five and you're getting your first carriers you're like oh well I already know how movement works I know how I know how uh the erir the uh air attacks work like you've you've got yourself in a spot to play in a kind of I guess it's kind of
program instruction when they said yeah and I just I skipped the whole thing right because I just read the brills on the plane jumped in but I had it my impression that it was a complex game it was going to take a long time to learn sometimes I think you can look at a book that a game that has programmed instruction and you assume oh I kind of need to work through all these steps to learn how to play so it must be very complex yeah but it it was really easy just to jump into the Midway scenario I think some of the mechanics are kind of Novel too you know with the the search mechanics aren't something that you see I think in a lot of different games done exactly that way the carrier rotation the ship battles there you know there's some unique rules there but the way hits happen is is I haven't seen that done where it's like yeah if a if a if a ship has can take say seven hit points if I do six hits against it nothing really happens if I do seven hits it gets this light damage marker but if I do more than the seven then it flips onto its damage side and we go through the whole thing again to eventually sync it yeah so it's it's almost like it it's almost like it gives it four steps in a way uh it's not exactly that but it it is uh I wasn't sure how that was going to work and it turned out that it worked great yeah this kind of you're trying to get to that threshold damage and you know you need that threshold damage otherwise it just didn't enough to to impact the functionality of the ship which yeah I felt like all that worked really really well it also had a I thought also thought the
um the way that the anti the ship anti-aircraft worked when you know you you're bringing in your strike and the ship anti-aircraft doesn't knock out your planes but the the better your anti-aircraft manages to do it gives the a bigger and bigger dice roll modifier to the attacking planes and yeah and higher and a higher number is is worse they want a they want a lower number so if if uh if your if your AA works really well I still attack with my full force but I get this you know plus eight or something and it's like oh yeah yeah you can see like scattering of the planes as they're coming in it was so effective I think there was a little there was an element of damage and dyro modifier and it could vary depending upon how you rolled but yeah yeah that whole like the the working through cap and that anti-aircraft and then strikes that felt really organic and and authentic to me in terms of how the game modeled it yeah yeah and that's exactly how the Clash of carriers games that I'm playing does it as well it's like I guess it makes sense you know you gota you have you do the cap you see who gets through then you got to go against the AA and see who gets through and if there's anybody less yeah you do the strike and that you know that's pretty much how it really happened I suppose yeah this one was actually just as an as side it was really fun for me to play because the first game I ever played my first war game was midway Avalon Hills Midway and I played that until it fell apart so I played probably 50 60 games of that and
how does that compare to this yeah it's it's a very it's a simpler game um and you have it's completely double blind so you've got boards up and basically it's almost like a battleship type of thing where you're calling out kind of grids where the enemy ships and then you're sending your strikes there but very much it's that same kind of thing it's who hits first and who hits hardest is win I if I remember right there you didn't have a lot of room for like second and third strikes like a lot of planes would get shot down so you almost had like one but I'm it's just so long I kind of probably misremembering it but to me it always played out like whoever hit first one right yeah yeah yeah and and that was the which is real in its own way as well but it's it's it's fun to have a little bit more uh nuanced approach to that right right to to I mean but to be fair like the battle of the Midway was almost almost like exactly like different degrees but you know the the US hit the Japanese fleets with some incredible damage I like it left one carrier functional and that carrier came back and I think was a crippled the Yorktown I want to say at Midway so there was that you know we had the same ebb and flow just of different degrees going and and you know had you hit a third carrier I might have not been able to take out another one you had hit one carryer I might have taken out to I thought it did a really good job of kind of modeling the history of how it went too yeah yeah it it it felt it felt like the real like like we were it felt like
we were simulating something yes yeah exactly yeah speaking of that I did have a question I saw some conversation because one of the things that the game does um that you can only have one carrier in a fleet which I think yeah a task force yeah yeah so yeah that's that's especially like the Japanese used to put two Carri like they put the they would pair their carriers I think and same with the us but you know I when I first got the game that was the first thing that struck me was like well why can't I put three carriers in a task force and Crown you know with a bunch of capital ships in support but then um you can sort of do that in that if I make task force a has the York town and C task force B has the hornet I can put them in the same hex yeah and uh you know basically have the same thing right because I think i' had read some stuff there was I forget where I read it but someone said you know that didn't feel authentic but to me it didn't feel like it impacted the quality of play at all it's fine I could do what I wanted to I could keep them together I could move them apart and so yeah I felt like it worked out really really well um what about the uh like can we talk a little bit about solitire in the game so the solitary rating on the back of the box is a seven I don't like I love vuka I'm a big supporter I love every game I've played of theirs but I I'm I'm gonna quibble with that rating I I can't see a seven
out of 10 being a a real rating for solitire for this game given that given the the hidden Movement Like if you just want to play um capital ship on capital ship um sure the it's great for solid there but um for carriers I agree too and it's a little decep not de I know decep sounds like there's some lack of int there's something there there are solitire scenarios but they're the ones that have the limited mechanics you know like the Pearl Harbor scenario where basically you're you're learning dive bombing and torpedo bombing mechanics with your planes against stationary targets so it's a it is a solitary scenario but to me the the glow and the shine of the game comes when you get the carriers in yeah and that's I think where you really need that hidden mechanic and that's not going to work really well so yeah I I played I played one or two scenarios with the full carrier experience solo and the best I could do was like I I would put out all the task forces for the enemy and then when I searched one if I if if it was like real contact and I had to reveal it then i' I just I'd roll to see if if something was there or not so but I like I made my own my own solitary system it's not like this game like the the cat Mouse between the hiding and the finding that's the that's the heart of the game yeah yeah how about um replayability I think it's huge I think this game could be played over and over
like I think we could we could sit down uh tonight and play the mid Midway scenario again and it would be completely different than last time because we both we both try new things and the way we found each other or didn't is going to be completely different from the first time played yeah and the way you organ and I think even Midway to me felt like a little bit of uh I don't want to say a learning scenario but a little bit of because the Japanese have some very particular constraints to moving towards Midway that I mean you knew where I was right so it was I it was hard for me to disguise where things were all your searches were effective I suppose that could have been different but I think as you get into those later scenarios with with fleets with task forces in different directions that whole cat- and mouse and ambiguity is going to really kind of escalate and make it really really interesting to see where things are and I think they I think they rate the Midway scenario as a a beginner or an intermediate scenario you know like oh right it is like it's an early scenario in terms of the um or the carrier battles yeah they just get more involved after that as you go along and there's a lot I don't remember the exact number but there's a lot of scenarios in like I think there's like a dozen or something there's there's there's a lot and I mean they all have their own mounted Maps it's like bua just goes the whole nine yards in terms of components all I have it here I was so glad that you were driving because I was thinking I'm gonna take this in my luggage it weighs a ton yeah you would have had to pay uh you had would had to pay extra an extra
luggage fee on the airline because that thing feels like it weighs 10 pounds on its own yeah and the production qualities all the ships have their own counters other than the Destroyers so you know even even battleships were sunk at Pearl Harbor and only turn up in that introductory scenario right they've got their own counter right it's like just and and those are and pre-round you know they're they're just punch counters there's there's no counter clipping it's a yeah you know it's typical vuka like deluxe Deluxe components all the way setting the bar for us they're setting the but yeah I'm surpris you know I I think so I guess kind of like sliding over into some final thoughts on this um I I I I am really high on the gameplay for this one I thought it was really really good I think I would recommend to this anyone who's got a a good partner they can play two-player games with in likes World War II especially Pacific Naval Combat I think this is a real winner that people are going I probably wouldn't recommend it just as you I probably wouldn't recommend it for the soliter experience I think you're kind of playing with crutches you know and like it's it's it's it's a I I don't think it would Shine for me in that role but I absolutely love the way that we played it and I felt like it spun great narrative the decisions are good um learning how your opponent's thinking you know there's that whole what are you thinking what are you trying to do here you well and you know when you were reading the rubic you thought oh maybe this is a bit complicated you know
whatever and then you play it and you go well it's really it's like a three tables that you roll on when you you you've got the you got the intercepting cap you've got the AA and then you got the strike and and those those each of those tables they're not filled with dice roll modifiers or anything there there's not a lot of like it's just a lot of straight rolling other than you know your your AA is going to give you a DRM for the the strike but other than that there's like there's one or two drms on each table so it's really really straightforward and I think I don't know if it was the way the rule book was organized that made it hard for me to wrap my head around it a little bit because as I I know I went through the rule book a while ago and as I was going through it I feel like I wasn't quite getting it like I said oh wow this is kind of complicated I'm not sure if it was just the way it was carrying information but around but once we started playing it was crystal clear and I said oh this is way this is so much easier than I thought it was going to be it's one of those cases where you read it in the rules and you're you're kind of grocking it but it once you look at the chart it's like oh oh okay yeah yeah like the explanation is more confusing than the actual numbers and the columns it's like oh yeah obviously what Happ I see what happens here yeah cuz I think even though it was our first game to play AOS and I hadn't played even one of the learning scenarios I felt like for the most part we were mistake free I think we had we had missed like one little rule about how if a carrier gets significant damage from minor damage you have to roll twice on the potential
disabling role we just missed the might have given us another hit or two or something yeah and maybe I think you might have missed the recycling of cap planes on the might been able to recycle a cap one move quicker yes than I actually did once or twice because the cap Works differently the recycling the US cap recycling is more effective than the Japanese yeah absolutely yeah but that was really the only funny stuff it's it's like it's not like it's a beer and pretzels game but it's but it's only just above that it just it just looks so beautiful but it's totally approachable yeah exactly totally approachable total play totally be accessible and and if all of the other scenarios are like the ones that we had I think uh I I think more people would more people should get this more people should learn about it more people will really enjoy playing it it was a yeah one of the it certainly one of the great experiences we had in San Diego but it was really fun playing well yeah I think the proof was in the pudding the fact that we so closely recreated Midway on the first day it was just like holy smokes this is this is how it works right right right yeah and there was that little like there's that strategy guide at the back I think I we talked about it a little bit before we started where you know as the Japanese player it's like you're going to get hit but you're probably going to have something left to hit back with don't miss you got and then when I hit your Destroyers I was like oh it was toast but I think the soru on that second attack that you had just survived
because it had planes on the deck ready to go before nightfall because you got to get them up in the air before night otherwise you're not going to be able to retrieve and you can't launch and I had to roll that one that 50% chance they would have all blown up and they didn't which meant that the soru was still functional so I could get enough planes up in the air to hit the The Hornet I think it was or the other one the York toown and put that one away and so it was like it was so close it could have gone either way on that battle so and my Destroyer Fleet didn't fool yours at all you just like that's the Destroyers it's not you kind of completely trashed my carriers well I think it was just lucky I I was probably giving you my game face there you certain you certainly didn't send your entire Strike Force from all your barers to SN two Destroyers I was giving you my best spruance look or something yeah well I think um that I think we've covered a lot of ground on this one is there anything else that comes to mind that you think people would like to hear about the game or know about no I think we kind of covered it all it's um I I there's there's other older Pacific War games out there that I haven't played that I um you know like um flat pop and things like that I I I just just I just got a used copy of that I think from uh from our good friends at Noble KN I played it yet and uh I also have the forementioned mark Herman's giant um Pacific War but I mean every time I look at that it just uh I don't know I get I go it's gonna take a lot
it's gonna take a lot I don't know gonna take a lot I've heard really I've heard people talk about two-player experiences with that one though you know like weekend experiences playing one of the the operations and having a lot of fun with it too I think people I think it's G to be a great game once I finally play it but um this one was just like you'd read the rule book I'd played it a bit I I felt like we set up and were playing in under half an hour it was like and it took us correct me if I'm wrong I'd say about two hours yeah to play the first day yeah that's right think that's and that was we we were learning it too so I felt like we could have C that time and half Once We Were Once We Were fluent with the charts and everything yeah yeah I think if we started this scario from scratch now after having playing that learning we could probably play the whole thing in maybe two two and a half hours or so yeah yeah three at the most I think for sure yeah it was it's quick to get to the table and and play it there's no like it quick to teach you know like it felt like um it wasn't exactly like I was teaching but I was sort of like reinforcing what you'd read so it was like we're going to do this and this and this and then we were playing yeah yeah and you had it all set up up it was it was it was very accessible that that again that was a thing that I for whatever reason I'm not sure I had it in my head it was going to be harder to learn harder to play uh more fiddly but it was it was none of those things it was like wow this is fast and streamlined it's got and a great just a great straightforward sequence of play that you just chunk
chunk chunk through and it's like oh that makes sense yeah yeah yeah I think it helps because the guy I mean you understand people understand what Naval Combat was like you know you and the game recreates it so you get into it's like oh okay it fits with kind of your idea of what should be going on the systems work in that regard so that makes it even easier you're you're like you have you're having those decisions about like how much of my how much of how many of of my Fighters am I put a gonna put up in cap but I'm Gonna Keep On Deck and hope hope that this search works yeah because you gotta that cap decision before you know the results of your searches and all that and yeah so yeah I think you're you're you're having some of the same kind of um heart palpitations that the yeah Admirals had yeah yeah well thank you again for uh for playing I it was one of the highlights of San Diego for me was to get a chance to play that game with you in addition to our breakfast too those were great as well I'm giv the breakfast equal billing but I love the breakfast so that means I love this yeah but thanks to for joining tonight and and for having this uh I thought we would go for about 15 minutes about it but I I think we went quite a bit longer so this probably every everything you want to know about task force but um I really had it blast playing and it was just uh it was it was really a fun game uh well thanks for having me I'm I'm I'm always watching your channel and uh now that I know your dog is listening to my Channel or my podcast it's like I feel like we have this symbiotic thing going that's uh that I'm really happy about
yes likewise likewise so we'll have to we'll have to do more thank you everybody for watching and and have a great night good night