A Message from the Stars: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games at Lunch and we're doing a discussion over A Message from the Stars, one of the newest games by All Play, which we just got done reviewing QE. Mhm. Um So, I actually heard about it I heard about it from you, but then I basically completely forgot that you had mentioned it and then I watched the video of The Dice Tower comparing this one to uh Decrypto. Mhm. Kind of like which one does it better and which one um Chris and Wendy liked better. Right. And I was like, well, I love word association games and then I bought it. I'm like, "Hey, have you heard of Message from the Stars?" Yeah, I have. I bought it. Yes, you did. Um So, what do you guys think of A Message from the Stars?
Excellent. Excellent. Great game. Fantastic. I I agree. I would say it takes uh a lot of the fun and clever guessing game portion that I really enjoy in Codenames. Yeah. Yeah. Um and combines it with math, which, you know, always a great time for everyone. No one no one has a bad time with math. If you're in the board game hobby, you probably might enjoy math. know quick maths at least or only play story telling games. Or difficult math, but No, no, it's not. Um It's Yeah. It's it's so unique. Now, one thing I will say is I think everyone's at least in my case, the first game the rules make so make sense. Like what you do in the game makes sense. Where I got hung up was the strategy.
Yes. Like I'm like, what what am I giving you? Like what what clues am I am I supposed to provide besides just a random word? Yeah. What do the values mean here? Right. Uh but you play I mean by the end of that very first game I was like, I'm I'm seeing why why we're given words back and forth now. Right. A- And again, this game is going to work well for people who are pattern recognition type of individuals. Yeah. They're going to see patterns and they're going to be able to decrypt it fast. So like the first time I played this, I play I was the one who did the letter recognition. Okay. Someone else did the clue side of the game to help the other team. Like And played really well with that that basically they were like, "Hey, you just solve the math side of this and we will solve getting him the words."
Yes. And I am really glad they added that extra layer of three words because I feel like if it was just us you know, figuring out the six six letters, it would get stale. Yeah. Um but the the different columns one had a fun element to it. But that's the Codenames aspect that kind of guide everyone. They're like, "Well, what kind of clue should we give? Well, it should contain this letter in it." Mhm. But it should also tie them to you know, this column. So how do we do that? And it's just it's so unique but yet familiar. Yes. Um cuz there's games like So I I mean I will compare this to a bunch of other ones but this isn't really like any of those. But you mentioned Codenames and the other one I would it's like a mashup of Codenames and Turing Machine.
Yeah. But Turing Machine like I feel like that one would check people out almost immediately. It's literally just logic. Like Yeah. It's like, "Is this fun? Do you like logic? No? Well, then no. It's not going to be fun." It's not just logic, it's straight-up computer logic. Which is different than what I call like social logic. Yeah, that that is true. Um so it's not a social deduction game. Like Turing Machine is purely abstract. Like if you And that's the thing, it's like if cuz in Turing Machine you're just picking a random value of three numbers, but you have to apply it to every single rule to get your value. And here, it's kind of the same thing, you're picking a random word, but it's like you still have some categories to put that word with.
Um and it's not a race, either. It's not like who can do this faster, which means who's kind of the smartest one in the room. And that could be very And Turing Machine is definitely that. Yeah, exactly. This Right. And this is not that. This is I'm I want to cuz you're it's cooperative. It's not like I'm trying versus you guys. Um and what's also great is I like this game on both sides. I have now played both the alien and the humans, and it was fun for completely different reasons. Like cuz for me, I actually like the humans more than being the alien, which is usually not the case. I usually like being the one. Yeah. But I think it's cuz this is probably my only negative is cuz in the humans I was playing the game the whole time.
Yeah. The alien is kind of like, here's my word, there's the value. See, and and that was my concern about being an alien, actually, was the opposite. Was I'm going to spend like 20 minutes trying to come up with the perfect word every time. And I almost did. But I had plenty to think about while I was doing that. And the whole time I was just going, what's what's what's a word for What's a word for fabric that has A Z LIKE THAT WORD IS ACTUALLY actually kind of perfect for it because like the humans are puzzling things out, so it gives the aliens enough time to think up, okay, they're struggling with this. I need to get a word that's associated with this, one of these three, and realistically, I need to target this one. Yeah.
Okay, they're struggling, they need a Z. Okay, what words are with Z? Um Yeah, I think the alien job gets easier if the humans are doing well, like Ryan. Um I mean, it's kind of like it has that element of like Mysterium or Mysterio, where it's like they're Man, that that person is really hung up on this. I need to get him away from that. Like like the first game we played when I was you were like, okay, like at one point I think you crossed off you as like a trust and I was like Right. How did the uh And then you're like, oh wait, no, never mind. And then you're like, G can't be an amplifier. I'm like How did you get that? Yeah. Okay. But one of the things I will say that is probably is helpful, the alien's first clue is probably super important.
Yeah. And so far when we played this game, like I played it now fair number of times, Mhm. that clue's always been very good. And I my gut reaction is that the alien didn't play as good of a first clue problem solve, this game would be way more difficult. Yeah, yeah, my very first game I was just getting trying to get them to guess the six letters. Because again, we were trying to figure out how the math worked and why each letter mattered. Right, right. Um and then it wasn't until the very end that I was like, hey, I finally got a clue that matches the words here. Uh but since then, I've kind of done it the way you've said it. First word has kind of been like, what's the best word I can think of off the top of my head that gets you to this. Yes. And then each subsequent card is for is a clue for each word.
Yeah. Um which again, if this game is too easy with four clues, then you can just move it to three clues. move it to three. That's the only variant they have uh as a hard mode. I would say in in like the games that we've played, the fourth one hasn't really mattered. I guess it did for you to get us to to get the the words. Yes. Um but in terms I don't think you would have gotten at all without my fourth clue. It was I mean you used smog. Yeah. That's right, cuz I got us to pollution. None of None of those other words would have gotten us to pollution. No. So, maybe that's why See, if Ben I was thinking with pollution, but we would have agreed with several others. So, what do you So, what do you guys think? Do you think Well, like where is the majority of the game here? Is the majority of the game getting the six letters, or is the majority of the game trying to guess the clues for the words?
Because to me the majority of the game is figuring out the value of the letters. That's where I That's the logic part. Um, and then the the word part is just kind of like a afterthought almost. It fits. I like it. But, I think for me that's almost where I focus almost exclusively, cuz this portion of the game I'm good at. And so, I can help the team more here than figuring out what the clues are to give to you. And that's the And that's And that's what I think And that's why it's really nice to me that the score is evenly weighted. All right. Oh, yeah. Two sixes. Six. You're right. So, people who are really good at algebra can be puzzling this stuff out, and people who are really good at word association, or know the other person well enough Yeah. Right. What associations would they make? Right. That That I mean, you can play it on separate levels.
It does Yeah, it does fit um, kind of both sides pretty well. Yeah. And I think I mean, I've only ever played this at three. Uh Yeah, initially started at four, but one guy was like, "No." That's me. Yeah. You can walk away. He's like, "You guys have fun." Um See, you know, I would also say that the same thought process coming up with a good clue word as Letter Jam. Yeah. Yeah? Because I have to put myself in the mindset of when you see these letters Mhm. what's going to What are you going to think of? Yeah. [ __ ] that was a bad word. I can't use that word. We need a better word. Yeah. Yeah, cuz I'm also I set It It It It It It's It has so many levels of complexity without being difficult.
Yeah, I mean again it's all play so is there is there actual mission statement two-page rule books? Uh Or is that just something that's been a coincidence? No, I know it's one of their goals is to have I think that's like a requirement for when they take a game on. Zero printing cost. Yeah, I mean and Well, I think it's supposed to be for the simplicity. If your game can't be explained on basically the four pages Somehow it's not Somehow like QE Mhm. Um This one Kabuto Sumo which probably their simplest game. Right. Um Somehow they've they've made simple games to play that have a ton of depth to it. Like even if we like we the game we just got we got a perfect score. Yeah. And a lot of times it feels like oh I got a perfect score the game we figured it out.
But with this I don't feel that it's just like No. going to have so I mean it's technically infinite replayability. Right. Yeah. No, I I like this a lot for it. Um There's a lot of all play games that are good. They have a lot of trick taking card games that are pretty solid. Um And so again their goal is two-page rule books. Um and this one is just Okay, are they based out of where they based out of? Uh somewhere in Missouri. Okay, I thought it was Missouri. Yeah. Or Kansas Overland Park. I thought it was Kansas City. But greater Kansas City. Yeah, greater Kansas City. they're in Johnson County. That's pretty cool. Yeah. Um What I will say I think This is just like if I want to play a game where I really have to think then I want to play this.
Or like Turing Machine that's a game where I like oh I want to sit down and think. it's like cuz I own Turing Machine and a friend has it too and he felt a little bit like this one as he did with Turing Machine where he he really likes it but it takes a little bit to kind of make the cuz you're not constantly thinking like that all the time. So you have to kind of like flip that switch in your brain to be like, "Okay, I'm going to be on the spectrum today. Let's see what I can do." Right. Which is exhausting, honestly. It can be. Um but this it it's it's light. It's like it's still here. You still have to think about the the the logic of it, but you're not like And you know, six may be a terrible score, but it's like, "Hey, we got six." Yeah. Yeah, and you're also You're relying on other people where like Turing Machine, it's just you. So it's even more work where you're like, "Oh, what's the best number?" It's like, "Oh, I could do easy and prove something one, but I'm wasting an entire round without the other two just to prove one answer."
very true cuz there's you get no other information in Turing Machine, right? Except what you get. Yeah. Cuz you don't get to see what everybody else does. That's right. It's literally it's a solo game that you're racing against other people. Yeah. So I guess the one thing I'm also trying to figure out, I guess like why does the alien have a board? I don't know. I think it's because there's team and co-op options. That's right. Okay, yeah. Which I haven't played team. Yeah, I haven't played teams. Um that makes sense cuz I think for setup it's like give the alien a board and then it's purple Oh, it's for the purple team. I'm like, "Why is it purple for the alien?" Um have you guys played Decrypto? Yes. Yeah. Okay. A long time ago. So I'm uh and I actually I played Decrypto and this in the same night. Um why do you think they would compare those two? Cuz after playing all this I I like I don't know why you would Leather Jam makes more sense, Codenames makes more sense than Turing Machine, but Decrypto I just don't remember Decrypto well enough.
Decrypto was basically you had um you had three words or you had four words, sorry, and then you're given a code as like two, three, and four. So you have to give your teammate clues that are good enough for them to guess, but not good enough for the other team cuz you tell the team the clues and they have to try and guess your code. Well, then I guess I would see that as a similar mindset of what's a good clue um without giving too much away. Yeah, so the word association I guess so. That's why but Maybe because it's hard to find comparisons cuz this is really a radically different spin on a theme. Uh yeah, like Yeah, on two themes actually. But to me it's it's combining two things. So it's combining the whole um the planet um uh search planet search planet X and um code names. It's realistically to me it's combining those two.
Yeah. But the thing is we're playing co-op. Neither one of us is against the other players. We're all trying to work on the same thing. So realistically, you're giving us four clues because of yours, but it's not just this. You're also trying to help us solve this which you have that information. Which yeah, which is fascinating because yeah, it's not like both parties are doing like you don't have six letters you're trying to it's like you're against you. Yeah, that the entire time the humans their words are to basically double down or get more information from the alien. It's like, "Right, well, what do you mean?" Like, "Okay, we think Z is the letter." There was no reason if when you made the joke of being like, "Oh, well, if you have Z for us to put zoo." And be like, "Here you go." It didn't matter like cuz you have four rounds like you don't have to do the one good word and then three rounds of each column if you can find a good word that combines both.
Right. And it's like, "Oh, yeah, we kind of have a throwaway card, but we don't really know what the amplifiers are." Right. Um yeah, I just think the variety is awesome. The amount of information that the humans have is also great like the color coordination is fantastic. If it was all just like the same color but like it's like, "Oh, we we pretty much know it's A." That means it cannot be E I L M n you know because all those are gone. Um So I think this is a really good gateway game into well, I don't know if I like logic puzzles. Okay, well, it's cooperative. So if you're on the humans, we can help you understand why things are. It's also a word game, so And it's a word game. Right. If you like that aspect better, you can focus on it and start picking up on the algebra.
Yeah. Which I love. Like I love word games or word association games. Yeah, to me this one's fantastic. Um do you guys have any negatives? Um want to do mention the app. Yes, thank you. I should have opened with that. God, get the [ __ ] app. It's free. It's free. It's all play games like uh it's going to be the companion section on that. This is the only game on it, but oh my god is it like a must. It's not a must. Like the game is playable without it, but but it's good. All you do you put in what you do is you put in your trust amplifying suspicions and you type in the word and it gives you your value. One it it eliminates double guessing where it's like there were many times where I just I had like an L in a word and I just kept checking. I'm like, where's the L? And you just weirdly the word the letters blend together for no reason.
It's like Okay, here you go. I hope Well, it it it perfects your math, so you don't have to worry about math. Yeah. Which is critical. But to me the better thing is like at least from again, whether you want to consider cheating or not, you can put in values and start figuring out those words and start figuring out values like, oh like for ban, like oh, yes, it's simple enough to do the math, but hey, I need to get the amplifiers, but here's how to do it. yeah, like one of my words was student. I couldn't find one, so I think I did I did degree. That was a zero and I'm like that's not good cuz it had the amplifier, but no trust in it, so it's two times zero. Um and I don't think that's cheating because you could do that by hand. You could do it by hand. It would be cumbersome, but you could do that or in your head. If you make a mistake, it would kill the game.
That is true. If you Yeah, if you like forget like Oh, that was supposed to be negative. Whoops. Last round that was supposed to be negative. Yeah, it's just And honestly, it makes the game go by way quicker because it allows you as both sides Well, technically, maybe the alien for the most, but like I was able to whip up like the next clue. Here's Here's one I just gave you. Before you even give me one back, I already have one. Yeah, think about four or five different choices. Yeah. And they pick the best one each turn. Yeah, so highly, highly recommend the app. Yeah, cuz I mean, you could have a notepad over here starting like four clues based on what the conversation is. Cuz again, it's co-op. It's like, "Oh, I already know this value is this. I need to get them to an odd number, odd negative number because they've kind of figured out the amplify, but they don't get trust."
Yeah, exactly. So, let's eliminate that problem. Well, on the other hand, I'm going to say why don't the humans have an app? I guess they could. I mean, what would they have an app for? They would be able to do the same thing, but also keep track of your guesses and assumptions. And so, it comes up with a score based on what your guesses and assumptions are. That'd be really complicated for the app. I also feel like that kind of ruins the game for the humans. That takes out the the entire reason why the humans are playing. Yeah, think about how many trust values we had and what that possible number of conclusions would be. Well, no, I I it would not be that difficult to write. It may be difficult to interpret. Yeah, yeah, so that's what I mean by I mean, like writing apps would not be hard for that.
But But But keeping things organized on a screen instead of on a dry erase board, which worked perfectly well. Yeah. But I mean, the same thing could be done in an app. Yeah, you could do it in an app instead of having a dry erase board. But I don't know that that would help you all that much. on a screen that small. I guess at least for me as the alien, I don't mind having an app because all the math is on really on the aliens portion and for the humans, they're the ones doing all the logic for it. So, if you had the app kind of do that for you, you kind of ruin Well, I think No, it wouldn't it wouldn't draw conclusions just to keep track. thing would be like Well, when I assigned A as a one and then that we make that assumption, right? So, I I did on paper, right? So, I how I did was I put pluses above letters that I did and then I see. I see. I see.
And then it could track all of the words and recalculate the score when you make different assumptions. Yeah. Yeah. And verify I see what you're saying. Yeah. So, so all it's doing is it's still doing the math. It's basically instead of me doing my pluses and then figuring out that math over here, it's doing the same thing you're doing. I put A, C, and L and then I put my basically I can type in the words like I hope that math doesn't Yeah. I mean, to be fair, like just with the app that we're guy I was like, this could be an app game. Yeah. Yeah. This could be an app game. The whole thing could be just computer game. Most logic games are That's true. I mean, I mean, That's what computers were meant to begin with. In essence, it's an advanced I don't want to do this anymore. In essence, it's an advanced version of Wordle. Yeah. In a lot of ways. Yeah, I guess so. A little bit. Um Combined with combined with the guessing the clues, time to words. Um So, yeah, any negatives?
Again, my my only one is like and it it it it's probably the outlier, but if the humans are really good or I mean, if the alien gives like a really good clue, then it's kind of like it gets easier. Yeah, but the game that ends quickly and you just move on to the next one and you play again. So, and if and if your group is all MIT level physicists anyway or whatever You'll never get through one round. What whatever it like you know They'll play Turing machine. Yeah. Yeah, go do the extra hard app. Then this game's not going to be for you, but realistically that the odds that you're going to have geniuses in the room anyways. Yeah, they don't play games. Yeah. Too busy getting that sweet snizz. Right? Geniuses get a lot of sex? Is that Do I have that right?
Uh not with hookers, so. Um That's what I read. So, yeah, cuz it's like what you put this in the lump of all the games that we've mentioned and it still stands out. Cuz like if you think about word association games, it's like Yeah, I I can play all these in a row and have a great time. I can play Codenames, Letter Jam, uh Subtext, which is more drawing but still has word association. Okay. And then this one and it's like, yeah, I'm having a great time. Uh Decrypto. Yeah. Brett, did you have any negatives? Uh what's the player limit? Uh six. Why that grab is that Nope, nope, that's not this. Eight plus. It says eight plus cuz of teams. You can do teams. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Cuz basically you're still playing co-op on one side and the other side is So, more than three or four humans and it's going to get cumbersome.
Um yeah, well, for me it was like I feel like if you are hitting four, you should probably do teams. I think if you're not doing teams, three was good. In fact, at one point I was like, this probably really good at two. See, I haven't played that That's what I'm wondering if it actually plays well at two. Cuz Depends on the Depends on the human, really. Yeah. Cuz they're doing the math. Yeah, like for example, there were times if like if I gave a word and one person's doing all the math and the other person is just kind of sitting there. It's like, oh yeah, now you figure it out. Like No, I didn't feel that way when I was letting you take over. Yeah, honestly the times I've played where like I take cuz again I take over the map. I'm I'm just constantly thinking of good clue words Yeah. that also have some of these letters but not too many of these letters or in the right combination. that's cuz for me a lot of the game is the math part, so I'm just like, well, you Yeah, I agree with you.
If you have lots of people who are math people and not the word association people, then maybe you'll have a problem. Um Or else get six. Yeah. Yeah? Six or seven. But again, I don't see any reason why two would not work. Yeah. No, it should. Um I think it should. Yeah. Uh other than that, Brett, didn't you say at the very beginning you're like, I already see a problem with the game? Yes, I did. Okay, well, what was that problem? Um not a flaw in the game. Oh. A flaw in the way that I'm probably going to play. Yeah. Which is and and I'll bring it up as a possibility is the possibility of analysis paralysis. Yeah. Especially for the alien. Because they have the responsibility of Well, if they happen to do the math Mhm. that just almost doubles the workload. Yeah. The way I've done it with these letters. Not too many of these letters.
Mhm. And fabric. How do I It's yeah. It's got to be a Z and it's got to have fabric. Yeah. I think for me, if anyone is having that issue playing this, um the way I've done it is I've tried to come up with a word and not care about the value. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz whatever the value is to me is still information that's given. So, it's like, okay. early part. Yeah. And so should be almost just exclusively playing for clues. Yeah, it's like, here's a word and it has its value 12. That's high. Um okay, here you go. Um but then you could be have people who are looking at the thing saying, you put subjugate. It's like, no, that's not what that wasn't Right. But maybe that actually is can be a positive. So, again, if you have people who are heavy on the map side and you have the one person who's good at word association. You have the word association player as the alien and the map people on the other side.
Yeah. And then, realistically, cuz those are the two games and realistically, the alien really shouldn't be caring about the map other than some strategy with trying to get certain thing like once you start playing It wasn't It was For me, it wasn't about the math. It was just about how do I fit these letters Right. but not like pizzazz. What a great No. Cuz that's going to be so ambiguous. I know, cuz it's time to whenever I was like, okay, they're really not getting G as the amplifier. Okay. Degree, that's value zero. Great, that's not going to help them get the amplifier. Cuz I guess there's no there's literally I think they heard me slap that. That's there's no rules on the words you can give as long as it's none of the 18. Yeah. So, it could be I mean, you could literally just be like go. Yeah, there you go.
so like we had temperature for one of ours and we did Celsius. Yeah. Like again, to me it was like I want you to guess temperature. I'll put Fahrenheit or Celsius and I really don't at that point still a lot of letters so I can get information and I have some ideas. So, this one's familiar yet unique. And yeah, it's it's a blast. So, on a scale of 1 to 10, what are you guys giving a message from the stars? I would say 10. 10? That's 10 for me. 10? I'm slightly I'm a little bit lower at a four. No, I'm just kidding. I [ __ ] hate this game. 9.6. I am at a nine and the only reason it's not a 10 for me is because I do and this could be just because of the group that we like the games we just played. I wanted it to be a little bit harder.
Yeah. Um that's why I like Codenames so much cuz I suck ass at it. And that's fun for me cuz I'm just like it's funny for me to be like hippo seven. It's like, how? Okay, let me explain at the end of the game when you get none of these. Uh cuz that's just fun. It was round, it was wet. Well, it's funny. I think I gave Last time I played that featured a hippo in 57. There was a I played Codenames Duet and I think I got Hogwarts five. And uh what I did as my clue was the Hogwarts was for one clue and then that and then I linked all the other words to to that one clue. He's like, "You're linking cards." And I'm like, "Right." It's like none of the other ones have anything really to do with with the first But if you get the first one right, the rest are easy.
Yep. Yep. So, yeah. I am I am not good at these games, but they are just so much fun. But yeah, I I kind of like I it's like I see what you're saying. Cuz it's kind of like So Clover. Have you guys played So Clover or Just One? Just One, yes. You haven't You haven't played Just One? I don't think so. The one where you like one person is blindly picks a number of a word, and everyone has to come up with one word. Mhm. Oh [ __ ] And then yeah, two people sh- if people share the same word, they erase it. No. Oh [ __ ] Well, that's another very very good party escort game. Um, but those kind of give like oh, how many did we get right? Seven? Okay, this is your score. It goes up to 20. I wish this game kind of did that instead of just being like 12 is your goal. Oh, well, we hit 12. Right. All right. So, so yeah. It feels good to be like, yeah, we did it. But then I'm like, I want it to be a little a little bit harder. But I guess it could be just Three rounds.
Huh? Three rounds. That's true. Yeah, three rounds. And I think that's just not All Play is more of a entry-level gaming company. Kind of the entry to mid. And so, you're not going to get Turning Machine. No, and I don't want to I have Turning Machine, and I have Or Search for Planet X. You're not going to get that level of oh, we have to really think about that. Yeah. I think really I just would like like there to be like a score matrix kind of just say, "Hey, how well are we doing?" Oh, we didn't get the best score. Or hey, this time we did. That's awesome. And well, I guess that is what we did here, but the first time we got 10. I think that was our first game. Um, I don't know. It's still fantastic. I mean, 10 was the lowest I've gone in this game so far. Really? I think very And but that's the other thing, my very first game with uh all all of us as new players got nine.
Yeah. And it's like, I mean, that's almost 12. That's pretty good. So, but that's that's literally it. The game is fantastic otherwise and I'm glad it can just be lumped in with all those other I mean cuz this is I mean a good party S game. Yeah, that's that's the way I see Like could you imagine being that guy at the party? Everyone's drinking, you pull out Turing Machine, you're not being invited back. Depends the party. That's true. Yeah, the genius sex party we were talking about. Those are all the time. Uh anyway, so that's our thoughts on A Message from the Stars. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.