Legends of Andor: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the legends of andor uh this is after we completed all five legends uh went through the campaign and uh this was okay so i mean you're 10 years since the last time you did i was so excited to redo this because i had remembered i had fond memories of it maybe that's why it's kind of like hey tell me your heroes don't just let let nostalgia be nostalgia don't take the rose-colored glasses off yeah yeah whenever whenever you're wearing looking at a game with rose-colored glasses all the red flags just look like flags and uh and boy oh boy okay so that's not entirely fair we are reviewing mostly we're we're reviewing this game like in the year of 2021 when these kinds of games are rampant in the in the industry yeah and at the time that this game came out it was definitely like the first of its kind a very euro-y kind of dungeon crawl you never really you you didn't really see a lot of like games like this yeah with the story and theme behind it yeah and it wasn't all about you know oh do i beat this monster no well actually it does kind of come down to that but uh with five individual legends that came in a in a box with a person who
this is i believe this is his own artwork um a lot of people of course always bring the fact that the tokens the standees have a front and back uh which i will still give them a break yeah i'll still give them praise for uh the double-sided board is nice um so these are always hard to do because you either review them as if it was you know 2012 or you review them in today's day and age or you try to do both um because i don't think this game holds up in any semblance of really anything and it's extremely frustrating so ah yeah it it feels like a great idea and it feels like it's got a lot of interesting possibilities because it's there's a puzzle element to it and you can pre the predictable movements so you can figure out strategize what needs to be done you can see the time element and how it ticks down yeah but it it all becomes kind of you know the interesting puzzle aspect basically goes away whenever the game revolves around rng and it's like oh okay how we have these monster tokens oh all right the whole board is swarmed if we can't kill them because that's going to advance this which is going to give us these cards that will um you know uh
like that will affect and negatively affect us yeah and we don't really get anything at the beginning of the um like of the legend yeah so it becomes a survival horror game yeah i mean a little bit it's it's incredibly difficult and i think i mentioned it during a run through one time was or one of the legends that this feels like an old nes game where it's like hey the game's an hour long but it's super super hard so no one's gonna beat it therefore it'll take them a long time to play it and it's replayable that way and it's replayable that way here it's the exact same way and i feel like the puzzle element really shines in the first two legends yeah and then you're just learning yeah and then it comes down to oh okay well we have to try and defend the castle legend the days of resistance legend three is so hard because your fates are random the way the monsters show up are random um that it's like okay well we're gonna probably gonna fail this all the time so that's that gives this game some legs cat what do you think yeah i like the thought of this game um i was excited to replay it again but i'm pretty much on board with with it's just the first few games are good and then it just sort of keeps going and going and going and it doesn't need to yeah right the last couple of them felt like the end goal when we finally found out what the end goal was it was just a slow grind yeah and then okay let's go over
here where there's another grind yeah yeah yeah we're just adding numbers and it's not exciting it doesn't feel like a finale yeah with the dragon and it's like all the legends whenever you're expecting i guess a campaign which campaign is a very loose term to use for this because it's basically each individual legend is separate it's actually one long game yeah that has reset points pretty much yeah you each legend it's just like oh okay uh all the strength you work to get in that legend in the previous one all that's gone you always for some reason started off super weak yeah it's like why did i it's nothing in it is thematic it's all mechanical like we've even had got some events where i was just like there was no point to that one in terms of theme it was just purely euro yeah and for a game like this i just i don't find that fun i can't be like i can't excuse it thematically i have to just be like oh that's just to knock us down to make the game difficult it's hard for the sake of being hard it's not that there are difficult aspects of it it's that oh well i mean randomness is hard so we'll just have that i even forgot that these two cards existed uh yeah because basically i guess i mean i wouldn't say spoilers but there's no story beats that are spoilers i mean there are only five legends in the game um knowing a little bit about it not
even the best creatures are gonna move there's a slight spoiler sure but actually you're not gonna make it that far yeah there's not even five there's technically four and a tutorial yes which i mean i guess you could i would say you can praise that because there's something to be said about board games where it's just like hey take this deck and just go top you know read each card and it teaches you the game and it does uh the game is incredibly simple to learn because the tutorials very well done but for the content of the game you actually lose out of the five one of them doesn't really count true so and with the with the you see there's only like four monsters in the game like with the the gores the scrawls the trolls and then the dog things like camera with wardrax or something like that sounds right like so you see them the entire time they do they don't do anything special they're just tougher monsters to fight uh and they're all pretty much just going towards one spot on the map what do you guys think of the characters like the character abilities sorry this is an exciting game yeah i like the fact that there's two sides i think that's neat um neither of them the two sides are just male female yeah i was like they don't do anything which is so cool like and how many are there in the in the box
in the in the base game because there's uh say maybe there is four yeah because i think the wizard that's the fourth one i have expansions so you can get hero expansions okay i was thinking if they were like you know eight or ten or something no there were the four because that would give the illusion of replayability right yeah there's four because the story tells you kind of oh if you're the wizard you start here if you're the dwarf star here it's scripted yeah which yeah makes sense um i like the characters i like that they are double-sided to give you an option um but i like that we all have our different ranks that way we can sort of start differently every once in a while it didn't really happen very often but um i i liked my character personally i don't know how you guys felt about yours but i think i've only ever played the archer yeah i've played uh the the warrior and the and the wizard the wizard only has one die but he rolls it and he can flip it that's um so he always gets he always gets that five or six yeah pretty much um but i mean it's still just one die and if he has no strength he's useless yeah uh like wizards are yeah that's true yeah um i i don't know like i felt like we had a good synergy yeah like i had the willpower that could constantly tank it and the dwarf always had high strength i built up to the stream you were pretty much like you you had the the die options yeah yeah and i was adjacent yeah so it's pretty good character like synergy but the ranks mean absolutely
nothing and if you're in the middle with ranks you get nothing it's always oh highest rank gets something lowest rank you went first one time didn't you yeah okay but i mean that's it who cares going first means nothing right uh yeah like you always got card effects or cat always got card effects and it's just like i'm here granted i never needed anything yeah and the card effects were just oh you go as a group lose willpower okay well i'm at 20 so i'll lose the willpower because i just roll you just roll the dice and it's like oh yeah i got a four okay that's what i get and i mean he's really good with the helmet because he adds like numbers together so if i roll you know two sixes then he becomes useful right the equipment board i mean that's also a nice touch the fact that you actually do have an inventory that you have to manage the the double-sided stuff is pretty neat you know the hawk is really cool the bow is the same but the shield you know protects you from damage and then protects you one more time yeah and then it's gone yeah water skin loses its water uh which is which is pretty cool and the witch's brew you know empties or goes half empty uh so all the art is incredibly well done like i just the story is i mean at this point so cliche and so weak uh it and it's not even a congruent story it's just like oh heroes show up king's
sick yeah what was the third one oh this is actually going to be doing this the days of resistance you're exploring the mines yep go get go get german go get gems all right dragon shows up this is like when you were in the moment you have like [ __ ] whiplash from just the way the story is just going yeah and none of them are none of them are great yeah because they don't they don't change really the puzzle right so you play the same game really five times yeah and for getting progressively harder yeah that's pretty much it and so so so what do you guys think of the dragon fight it was pretty lame i mean considering he's the big bad boss like but there was never any overtone that the dragon was there like there was never any stuff mentioning like oh hey you know there's a dragon that might show up this game if it like it would be fun if it if it had like an overarching narrative yeah a storybook to go along with something like that or a lore book or something something that connects the five legends that whenever the dragon shows up you're like this is what we've been what we've been preparing for now the sentence where it's like what are we waiting for let's get him so it seems like this game probably pioneered a bunch of ideas some of which were turned into better games and some of which they figured out just isn't working well like they obviously specifically avoided a rule book
right by instead teaching the mechanics and teaching the the strategies through cards which is interesting it's fun sure novel yeah but you're right it leaves out so much theme that could have been there yeah i'm i'm curious to know if uh because i mean don't no one talks about this game like no one references it it's not like oh man you know arkham horror paved the way for ameritrash games or whatever like you no one's sitting here thinking oh because the legends of andor i made my game with a tutorial system it's i mean they might have and it i just haven't heard about it yeah but or it inspired like the d um uh board games yeah the wrath of barcelona tomb of annihilation and things like that and those those are ass i do not like those um but i've never heard of it before you brought it up yeah and what's funny is there's three parts yeah two to the whole you know legends of andor trilogy and it's like i'm pretty sure they're all individual games it probably is similar to this where it's just okay oh i know the second one has a ship like it's it's on like oceans and then the third one is just i i just i have no idea if anyone if yeah more of the same planting huh planting crops yeah rebuilding the fact that we lost yeah um i mean it is neat that at the end of each legend it tells you hey you know
good or bad yeah you know yeah uh nothing stops you from just continuing on because there's nothing stopping you from opening the game be like ooh let's see what the minds are you know just skipping the legend four true um there's i just with games like these what i look for is continuity and being like oh okay we've we're growing as characters yeah because in the first one in the first legend it mentions the arrival of the heroes and you you're meant to think this is the hero that i picked this is the one that shows up but it's just like ah [ __ ] thorn i'm gonna play the wizard now you know you you are allowed to do that sure because nothing changes so it's just showing that other heroes are there and it doesn't have to be like a linear story right but then it's almost like what's the point of the five legends just make them scenarios oh no that definitely stands yeah um yeah the order doesn't matter after the first two i mean yeah the first one's the tutorial even the second one makes you know you don't need to know well it introduces a couple more mechanics that weren't in the first ah the prince the prince shows up yeah yeah maybe the tougher enemies oh trolls yeah i mean it does i guess really that's the point of playing them one to five is it does slowly add in you know mechanisms but but after the first two but i mean there is a there is a reference manual so it's just like
if you need to know what things do you just you just read this and then be like okay yeah we'll just do four we'll or we'll just do the finale i guess yeah i didn't much care for the the battle at all as you can see in my in our run-through because it does nothing it does nothing like his his stupid movement is he just hops around it's like oh if he gets to zero he loses or we lose and it's like so he doesn't i i understand that him obviously not moving one space at a time because there's no reason for there's no track for him on that yeah like i i would understand cards that you flip and he's like oh he moves to 68 okay then 65. then any and he flies towards them but didn't do that it just kind of had him bounce back and forth and i guess we had to kill him before i mean that thing moved down yeah which yeah it was like okay so yeah 44 so we pretty much had all the time in the world to be like okay we'll kill a scroll get some money basically go for the the trolls because it only goes up once and we get a lot of money i mean we've maxed you out in strength and cat got high up there i even got the highest i went all game and it's like okay let's all fight him in fact already i'll read these now uh there were actually these two cards so whenever the prince um was rescued this would have happened each hero would have gotten a strength point um and
whenever the narrator reaches the letter k the dragon is placed on the same space as prince thorold and then you roll a die um move the dragon to the space where prince sorel is standing set the prince aside he will no longer be used to add four strength points to the heroes total but that wouldn't have happened because it was k was covered up anyway well he would have to rescue more farmers which would have taken more time yeah we would have lost in otherwise yeah but all this does is help once there's still hope we roll a die one of the heroes gets your shield each hero raises his willpower points to 14 or you remove the top card a five or two six you remove the top card of the battle deck so he doesn't have four strength but we get something out of it but that's that we still have the shield dwarves it's just [ __ ] lame which is a shame i uh your childhood memories are destroyed well it was the first game i played on the channel uh so it was kind of like ooh keep that old video up that one's definitely going away uh gonna keep connect i've changed i've i'm a changed man
i just i don't i don't know you would think that the other two parts would increase in like streamline probably more narrative because this was his first game that i would i would get i mean this is a good game to play if you i mean this is probably one of the best gateway dungeony fantasy story games yeah um because there's very little rules and yeah i mean it's a fun i guess it could be a good family weight game where if you're into fantasy but you don't want to deal with really because sometimes those fantasy games like the ones it's like oh god i don't want to learn another world right you know every [ __ ] fantasy board game has their own world and lore that's just renames of [ __ ] that's already been made before and that all started with legends of and it all started with no lord of the rings yes but they're just like oh instead of orcs we have gores you know uh but this doesn't have any of that it doesn't bog you down with minutiae just here's our novel before you can play our game you gotta really understand it's just like nope get in instead of just constantly rolling dice you want to be smart about what you kill um and at the end of the day it's what is your task that's that's what you do at all costs and it's always two got to do two things was it always two things i think so at least from three on
oh i guess so the first one was you had to find the the herb so you had to find the witch and then you have to get she tells you where the herb is um so while defending the castle while defending the castle yeah from onslaught yeah it was kind of three i'll even give three a pass because that does have actual replayability the first two do not uh three i guess three four and five do have some replayability and some and some randomness and some variety you really enjoy being frustrated yeah and it scales well i would say i think three it doesn't really matter three four or five or three two three or four two three four yep players yeah would be would be fine okay because also i like the freedom of actions because the way i initially was trying to remember this game was we okay it's my turn all right i move one that's one time your turn but it wasn't it's just you get there that's how much time it takes um which itself is an interesting variation because then someone has to decide okay do i end my day or do i wait around because i could be very important to you guys catching up with me exactly yeah that part i like there's been other games that are kind of like that where hey this takes a certain amount of time move up on a time track but they they changed it in most games where okay if i do an action that takes four time you the next person is one on the bottom so if it's me at the top and a cat in the middle then you you go and then until you surpass someone it
just kind of that's how the action turn goes right which isn't the case here it is still in a turn order but it's uh it's not bad that the time mechanism is is fine i think it this game it is a tight game yeah like you and they he so once again revolutionary he did give you ways if you're like man we are really struggling like you can swap out cards for easier like um for like hey instead of like in the mine ones of 42 i think it was 36 value we had to get right uh and i think in the third one was the only one where the objective was truly impossible to do if certain things happened right um even in the fourth one it was just like oh okay they're taking a lot of gems but it's gems and gold so we just need to start killing them instead right which is nice in seven and there's no real end-all be-all to oh you either immediately lose um see you're gonna work for it yeah but other than that yeah it's um it's it's a game that i wouldn't play again but i think i would recommend it to people it depends if they're if yeah certain people if someone's coming to me and they're like hey we want a fantasy game we love descent i'd be like
this is not this is not for you but if you're if they are kind of wanting if they're euro gamers this is a pretty good mix i think a hybrid hybrid game between the two okay they came out almost 10 years ago or if they're historian yeah if they're like man i want to know what games were like and those in the days of old archaeologists ah legends of andor here you go so you guys got anything else any pros cons the art is phenomenal quality pieces yeah like once again yeah 3d pieces that um i don't remember a lot of games having at the time yeah i i do understand why the numbers of the on the board are scattered around uh it is frustrating trying to find the one yes but in fact there was one on them on the mine side we could not find 66 i think we were like we finally did did we find it yeah it was stuck away from something oh i didn't see i don't remember oh no you're right we rolled yeah i was like okay re-roll because i can't find it you're right yeah so that is kind of that's probably one of the the biggest annoyances it's just like oh god okay it's not without purpose but when you have to find a specific spot yeah it's just a time yeah i will say though with five legends four i mean i i do not remember how much this game is i want to know if it's gone up in price if it's way down in price i have no idea but probably at the time it wasn't super expensive
and the the art you get the 3d terrain pieces the the difficulty of the legends um i think it's worth the money uh and uh what was i gonna say i can't remember but yeah seems like something you appreciate rather than enjoy yeah that's that's that's about right so um scale of one to ten everyone wants to jump and jump in first i'll give it um a four just because of how heavily it shows its age okay right i'll go five just because i'm split between some things are good and some things are just not yeah it's interesting because it's like it's by the time we were we were done with five legends i was like i'm i'm over it i'm i'm done playing it but it's not a bad game it yeah like cat said it does show its age um but yeah uh i think i'll give it a five as well so yeah that's our thoughts on legends of andor let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new
content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you